Prusament troubles

Discussion

After hearing about how great prusament is and waiting months for it to pop back on Amazon, I finally got some last week. However, it has been an utter pain in the ass to print with. I used to get really good bows on benchy with Esun PLA+ and Hatchbox PLA, but now, if the print even finishes without jamming, I get really bad bows. I've tried every 5 degree temp range between 185 and 220 and have not had a benchy come out nearly as good as Esun PLA+. I read that prusament has a bigger issue with heat creep, so I doubled my printing speed @ 220 and started to get a nicer result, but the print jammed when it got to the pillars. I have a lot of faith in, and a huge amount of respect for, Prusa as a company, but this filament is driving me nuts.
Has anyone had similar issues using Prusament and overcome them? I feel like my last resort is to diddle with my retraction settings, but I'm out of ideas after that...

E:I'm using PrusaSlicer as well.

E2: lowering retraction to .4mm did not help the jams.

E3: Simplify3D fixed the bow/overhang. Still jammed though...

Posted May 22, 2019, 10:49 PM UTC · edited

214
Jmakes3DPrusaI3Mk3s, Printrbot Simple Metal tal•

I've used prusament, specifically doing filament comparisons with it and others, and it was one of the best printing filaments I tried.

The issue you are having looks like not having enough cooling on the part. Based on your tag I see you have a printrbot. I also have one and prior to doing a blower fan upgrade basically all of my benchies looked like yours so that might be something to look into if you don't have a fan upgrade already.

2
PewpasaurusOPPrintrbot Simple Metal w/ E3D V6 Volcano & Titan•

I have a blower fan.

1
Jmakes3DPrusaI3Mk3s, Printrbot Simple Metal tal•

Hmm. Might have just been a bad spool?

1
PewpasaurusOPPrintrbot Simple Metal w/ E3D V6 Volcano & Titan•

I guess that's possible, but I'm not sure what they could've goofed to ruin spools. The diameter's fine on it and I don't think someone just threw a bunch of bubble gum into the hopper. Also that'd be concerning because I have 3 more rolls that'd likely be tainted if they're from the same run.

1
Jmakes3DPrusaI3Mk3s, Printrbot Simple Metal tal•

Maybe try to get in touch with their support? Sorry I couldn't help more.

1
bivaterlPrusa i3 Mk3•

Is it an orientation thing? IE is it fixed if you rotate your benchy the other way? If so, it could still be a fan issue (not enough cooling even though you have a part fan).

1
PewpasaurusOPPrintrbot Simple Metal w/ E3D V6 Volcano & Titan•

It's not. I orient benchy facing into the fan. I don't think it's a fan issue. Don't mk3s only use 1 30mm blower fan for part cooling?

1
mobius1ace53D Musketeers - Zcorp 650 - F410 - Taz 6 - i3 - Big Ass D-bot•

It's a 50x15 blower.

1
PewpasaurusOPPrintrbot Simple Metal w/ E3D V6 Volcano & Titan•

Oh wow. I guess I could try out a beefier fan,but that'd only help with the overhangs (which appear to not have be an issue when I slice with S3D) and not really address the jamming

1
mobius1ace53D Musketeers - Zcorp 650 - F410 - Taz 6 - i3 - Big Ass D-bot•

I mean replacing the noctua fan.any people do it. I haven't but mine are okay.

1
mobius1ace53D Musketeers - Zcorp 650 - F410 - Taz 6 - i3 - Big Ass D-bot•

I'm running 0.95mm at 75mm/s on our mk3s's without too much trouble. No issues with heat creep. You can try upping the extruder pressure to try and force the clog through maybe?

1
PewpasaurusOPPrintrbot Simple Metal w/ E3D V6 Volcano & Titan•

I've tried to force the jam through with no luck. I reassembled my E3d V6 last night on the off chance my nozzle wasn't against my heat break, but I won't get to test it until after work.

1
mobius1ace53D Musketeers - Zcorp 650 - F410 - Taz 6 - i3 - Big Ass D-bot•

Put some oil on the filament next time you feed too. Seems to work. The larger bore of the heatbreak can be a pain

1