Question as a person transitioning to vegan - why no honey?
[deleted]
Posted Jun 13, 2019, 3:15 PM UTC
[deleted]
Posted Jun 13, 2019, 3:15 PM UTC
Hi! Here are some explanations about why and how honey production hurts bees:
they can come and go as they please.
Bees cannot really leave the hive; they depend on it for survival, and the queens often cannot come and go as they please (relocating a hive isn't an everyday occurrence, but it is possible).
Finally, in terms of the "support the industry or else the bees will die/won't exist/will suffer more" argument (which you may already know falls flat when it comes to all other animal agriculture industries as well), there are many ways to support bees (including wild bee populations, not just commercial ones) and fight Colony Collapse Disorder, purchasing honey is not the only one; in fact, purchasing honey can actually make CCD worse, as the links get into (just like purchasing any animal product can increase the negative environmental externalities of animal agriculture).
Personally I do not buy honey because insects have shown in some cases to feel pain for example.
That being said, if someone buys me something that has honey or if I accidentally buy something that has honey, I will still eat it. I just don't go out of my way to buy it.
That seems like a good way to go about it. Thanks :)
It's not really though :/
If you deem something as not in line with your moral/ethical values why would you waver on it?
Accepting it from someone else normalises it as a food and should we not be trying to move away from that, and remain strong on our beliefs not to use animals as products, rather than stipulate it with "well if I didn't realise at the time then I guess the immoral act becomes moral"?
There is a lot of manipulation and cruel things going on. Among them beheading of certain queen bees. Moving the bees from one place to another in big trucks for hours on end, which stresses them out severely. Not to mention using smoke to calm them down. And many more things. I didn't know any of it (but didn't eat honey, I always disliked the taste), but a documentary on Netflix was quite informative. It certainly isn't the romantic picture the people in the honey industry make it out to be.
No sensible bee farmer is beheading queens. They use those to either start new hives or to replace the queen. There aren't many of em
Most are marked with a red dot with bee pen. So the beekeeper can actually identify the queen and check on her.
Worker bees have a shitty ass life tho.
They also only take the excess. Else the bees die. Sometimes replace it with cheaper sugar.
I've helped out at a beehive when I was a child. (Did volunteer work across the road). As long as you don't hit at the bees you're fine.
Besides that. If you are in the US, and the product is cheap especially. Most likely it doesn't contain actual honey anyways. Just other sugars.
[deleted]
I feel like this comes down to the individual. I personally don't have a problem with honey but a lot of people do and I respect that
Honey doesn’t come from wild bees. An entire industry exists to breed queens and ship them all over the world.
Bees produce honey as their food. Bee farmers take the honey away, feed the bees artificial honey substitutes (which aren’t healthy for the bees), and usually kill the queen bee to manipulate the colony into continually producing more honey than they normally would. There is lots of info about it online. It may not seem as brutal and cruel as dairy and other forms of animal agriculture, but it is still exploitation and it is not good for the bees, only humans.
I’ll look more into that, I didn’t know about the altered feeding practices and all of that. Thanks for the info!