r/vegan•
gregmzak

Honey?

hallo hallo other vegans,

so i have been having a bit of a question lately about the use of honey as a vegan. From a basic perspective, no, honey would not be vegan as it is a product from bees, meant to sustain them through the seasons where they can not harvest from flowers. It's their food, many bees die of starvation from the honey harvest, etc. With that in mind, of course it isn't vegan, yet my concern with it isn't necessarily there, it is taking a look at the entire population of bees.

​

It is beyond a doubt that bees are highly endangered as a result of climate change, and from that, a very high percentage of bees are those held on bee farms. If enough people stop using this animal product (as we are trying for people to stop using animal products) i fear that bees will lose their economic significance, and thus lose even more numbers in their population. Even more terrifying is that ecologically speaking, bees are what are called a "keystone species." This means that their presence is so ecologically significant that losing them will have a cascade effect on other ecosystems. So although I am morally opposed to the death of bees from a loss of food that keeps the hive going through the non-harvesting seasons, I feel we all should continue to use products from bees to keep them economically significant and thus, ecologically present.

​

I just wanted to put this here to get some of your opinions, and hopefully share some thoughts with you all.

vielen dank!

​

(by the way, im not sure if this is against the "no extensive debate" rule. I didnt mean for it to be a debate, just me giving an opinion and happily welcoming other ones. im really sorry if this is against that rule.)

Posted May 24, 2019, 6:50 PM UTC

05
6480kantiantivegan troll•

Hi--honey bees are not a monolith. A big issue with the bee/honey industry is that they use only one species of bee, which is invasive in many parts of the world. Also, because only one type of bee is used, disease spreads quickly through commercial crops of bees. If you want to prevent bees from dying out, you should stop supporting the large honey industry, and start supporting conservation efforts or beekeepers who raise native bees for the environment and not for profit.

7
gregmzakOP•

I see your point, I do only buy local honey because big-business can go fuck itself, but i do see what you mean, through the extensive use of one species and bringing in invasive species. I do what i can for conservation efforts, mostly through advertising when i can, and i dedicate a decent portion of my class to educating on bees, however as far as money goes, i cant really give much to conservation efforts.

-1
Re_Re_Thinkveganarchist•

Commercial honey bees are not the only types of bee (there are wild bees), and bees overall are not the only pollinator. In some crops they alone are not even responsible for the majority of pollination, and their use is a short term local optimization that does not account for potential negative long term or global optimization effects (which is a feature of all businesses whose behavior is dictated by quarterly profit reports to investors, rather than a longer time frame). "Support commercial bees or they die out" is a false dilemma (please read through this link in particular, as it is especially important to your way of thinking about the topic right now, which is very common) to begin with, and use of commercial honey bee operations can hurt wild populations, like through spreading the varroa mite or by competing for pollen resources. It is not at all an open-and-shut case that supporting commercial operations will ensure a long term population of pollinators or help (all the) bee species.

2
singleplant•

Human don't have to interfere into life cycle of whatever animals and should decrease artificially created populations (including pets').

1
gregmzakOP•

I dont entirely agree with this. I feel we should do our part to maintain species as the anthropocene extinction is truly making the world much more grey through metropolitan development. Through climate change, deforestation, and overall habitat loss of the bees, we have driven a keystone species into endangerment. I feel we need to do what we can to preserve the natural world in every way that we can.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1