Open Source Could Be a Casualty of the Trade War
bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=5590Posted Jun 21, 2019, 1:06 PM UTC
Posted Jun 21, 2019, 1:06 PM UTC
Spot on thank you for posting this. The Huawei ban is a hugely critical issue that too few people are talking about.
Meh. The open source argument could be extended legally to the entire Internet. Reference the weaponization of social media during the 2016 American presidential campaign. This could get ugly real quick.
All media have been weaponized in capitalism since day 1
How is media doing outside capitalism?
Religious texts and wandering theater groups?
the only media I know of that is outside capitalism is the media that belongs to the only people able to survive outside capitalism, the Zapatistas. Their media is https://enlacezapatista.ezln.org.mx
No.
Did you actually read the article?
There's only a side note about open source, and it completely misses the strong point of FLOSS, which is that the individual developers and distributors are largely irrelevant. There's very little short of a total split of the internet that can be done to even just hinder FLOSS distribution.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
More what-about-isms and a cynical outlook. Good luck living under a rock.
Um, open source is a model that embraces forking/splintering when it makes sense to the point of fundamental fragmentation in fact. It's proprietary software that's usually dependent upon a particular developer since by design the original developer holds sole stewardship and so you have to worry what its country of origin does.
Clearly you didn't bother to RTFA. What the article says is that companies like Huawei make huge contributions to open source organizations registered in US such as the Linux Foundation. These contributions could be prevented by the trade war:
The trade war also begs a question about the fate of open source as a whole. For example, according to the 2017 Linux Foundation report, Huawei was a Platinum sponsor of the Linux Foundation – contributing $500,000 to the organization – and they were responsible for 1.5% of the code in the Linux kernel. This is more influence than Facebook, more than Texas Instruments, more than Broadcomm.
Because the administrative action so far against Huawei relies only upon export license restrictions, the Linux Foundation has been able to find shelter under a license exemption for open source software. However, should Huawei be designated as a “foreign adversary” under EO13873, it greatly expands the scope of the ban because it prohibits transactions with entities under the direction or influence of foreign adversaries.
This is my new second-favorite acronym.
After RTFM I hope
Of course. Many, if not most, of the questions asked about Linux programs are answered in TFM.
I read a good chunk of the first paragraph and the first few paragraphs of the "Collateral Damage" section and that's pretty much all I cared to read honestly. The whole thing is a bit melodramatic and for the first bit the author does that annoying reporter thing where instead of just saying what he wants to say he gives this long drawn out and unnecessarily hammy anecdote about ARM.
I understand their point (at least for what I have read which includes your citation) it's just not a realistic concern and wasn't the point I was trying to get across up above. I was saying that one country doesn't have meaningful purview over FOSS as a whole. That's a different discussion than whether the Huawei ban could potentially lead to something unfortunate and in no way is FOSS as a whole at some sort of existential crossroads. Worst case scenario this is just a unforced loss for FOSS.
Obviously, FOSS as a whole isn't going anywhere, but the fat that US can prevent FOSS organizations registered there from collaborating with countries it doesn't like is problematic to say the least. My takeaway from this is that you wouldn't want to register a FOSS organization in the states.
Sounds to me like the Linux Foundation is moving to Europe soon...