Grasshopper pie help
So I'm making a Grasshopper pie. I am on mobile so it's tough finding my exact recipe. Here is an example pretty close to what I'm going for.
I have made it once and came into one issue. I create the pie core by melting marshmallows with half and half. Very slowly. I pour the mixture into a bowl surrounded by an ice bath. After cooling, I then add creme de menthe and creme DE cacao. This is where I ran into problems.
After adding the liqueurs I then tried to fold them into the marshmallow goop. My goop broke into solid pieces instead of retaining it's shape. So I ended up having to whisk it together then fold in the whipped cream. I think because I had to whisk the marshmallow batter the pie lacked peaks one might expect.
Questions:
- should I have let the marshmallow mixture cool further?
This is my first suspicion.
- Did I use too many marshmallows/not enough half and half?
This is my second suspicion. The mixture was too solid to begin with so it was always going to break up.
- Is this simply suppose to happen?
Maybe I'm overthinking this and I am simply meant to destroy the marshmallow form. It turned out fine. Tasted great. Very much a smooth and light pie.
Appreciate and tips and/or insights. I know this is an old recipe so I don't expect much. There are 3 or 4 dozen different ones out there and they all vary in different ways.
Posted Jul 4, 2019, 10:09 PM UTC
I wouldn't cool first. I've never made that kind of pie but I think the liqueurs would combine better with the marshmallow while the marshmallow is liquid and the liqueurs should be at about the same temperature.
I do think your mixture got too solid. Also sometimes if something is warm and melted and you add something cooler to it you make the warm thing cool in those areas and seize up.
[deleted]
Yeah you want it to be cool enough that it doesn't melt the fats in your whipped cream but not so cool that it's solidifying. You want it to be about the same thickness as the cream.
[deleted]
De nada.