Insidious trains bug: broken switch

I'm posting this just to raise awareness as it happened to me multiple times in the few days trains are out and while it's simple to fix, it may pass unnoticed for a while, damaging the performance of your rail network, and may take quite a while to find out where the problem is.

Essentially, when you build a switch, i.e. a rail splitting into two, and then later you rebuild something and remove the common rail, often enough the switch box (with the arrow) will stay in place, and when you put the common rail back, it will only connect to one of the two rails coming to the place of the former switch joint.

The result looks perfectly like a functional switch but it will not work - your trains will never use the "broken leg". But since they're intelligent, they may find a way around and still reach their destinations, just using strange and inefficient routes. Exactly that happened to me, I only noticed this problem after I observed my trains at places where they had no business.

Also, when you replace the common rail, you can't know which of the two rails it connected to - not until you see a train go through that switch.

To fix it, you need to rebuild the whole switch - remove two of the three rails and put them back in correct order. That's usually not hard. But figuring out which switches are broken this way after a while since you did your "maintenance" through observing what trains are doing may be rather time consuming.

A preemptive workaround is, when you need to replace the common rail in a switch, first remove one of the split rails. And then put this split rail back after you're done.

Posted Jul 10, 2019, 11:25 AM UTC

224
phatal80871 SCs/min 50 TMs/min•

The switches are so borked they might as well not even had added them yet.

3
Jcl1986•

that's for sure. I have 5 stations each with a bypass for each direction and each of the 5 freight cars takes a different route causing the train to stop at the station and the freight cars to be in different locations on the map :-(

2
TroZShack•

Ah! That may be what happened to me.

I have a train line with a few stations on it, and I noticed last night that a train going from station 'A' to 'B' actually bypassed station 'B', went to station 'C', turned around there, just to come back to 'B'.

This could be explained by your observation because there is a T junction on either side of station 'B' (providing a bypass of the station, or allowing the train to go around and enter from the correct side), if the direct path from 'A' to 'B' was bugged as you describe, so that the train doesn't think it is valid. Then the only path would be to go further down the line and turn around to come back.

I'll have to rebuild those junctions and make sure I delete the switches properly!

2
[deleted]•

I had this happen just the other night. Because of the set up I had, it just sat there not moving and complaining that there was no way to reach the next station. I ended up deleting both halves of the split and recreating them. I had no idea what had caused it though, so thanks!

You know, I love that this game gives you a 100% refund for deconstruction, redoing things like that would be such a huge pain otherwise

2