The Wizard's Fireball Missed...Was I wrong?
I ran a one-shot for a new group the other day. When it looked like a social encounter was about to turn sour, the wizard jumped in excitedly and said she cast fireball. I said okay where does the fire ball strike? She designated the area, but before she tolled for damage I told everyone to roll for initiative.
The wizard rolled somewhere in the middle (can't remember the exact number). More than half of the dozen enemies outside the town wall (including the two giants) rolled higher. On their turn they charged the wall, taking them out of the fireball's area of effect. Of those still in the area, a handful made their DEX throw and took half damage.
The player didn't say anything, but I could tell she was pissed. I guess she thought she would get surprise.
I believe hard lessons are effective lessons...but what do you think? A bit harsh?
Posted Jul 11, 2019, 10:56 AM UTC
You’re wrong.
Fireball is an instantaneous cast that takes an action. She should have been able to adjust the blast radius when her turn came up in the initiative order.
What “hard lesson” were you trying to teach the player here?
That shouting "I cast fire ball" before giving other players the chance to disarm the situation doesn't mean you get a surprise attack/free action.
...except it’s an instantaneous cast, so if you declare the action before initiative is rolled then it does exactly that.
If the rogue declared during RP that he was going to hide (also an action), no sane DM would say “hold your horses buddy, everyone roll for initiative first!”
I don't think that's true though. At least not the way that I use and understand the rules. For me, if combat is about to happen, that's an immediate initiative roll. If the enemies are aware of the wizard, and they roll higher on their initiative, then they react before the wizard can cast their spell (like, they were quicker on the draw).
If the enemies were ambushed or otherwise surprised, then the same situation plays out, but the enemies are affected by the surprise condition (so, in effect, the wizard would cast first regardless of initiative rolls).
That's my understanding of how to run a situation like this, and it's worked pretty flawlessly for me to make the mechanics "work" (the wizard doesn't get a "free action" before combat) and sensically as well (just because you say "I attack" before anyone else doesn't mean that everyone automatically just sits there and takes it).
However, either way, it is 100% wrong to make the wizard shoot at their initial target after everyone else has taken their turns. I don't even see the sense in that aside from trying to stick it to your player, which is counter-productive in nearly every way.
Messing with the spell mechanics was a stupid mistake on my part. I admit that was wrong and I have apologized to the player.
But you have worded (much more eloquently than I could) the reason I thought getting a surprise just because she shouted "I cast fireball" didn't seem right.
Having reviewed the Surprise rules in the PHB, I agree with you.
PHB: "If neither side tries to be stealthy, they automatically notice each other. Otherwise, the GM compares the Dexterity (Stealth) checks of anyone Hiding with the passive Wisdom (Perception) score of each creature on the opposing side. Any character or monster that doesn’t notice a threat is surprised at the start of the encounter."
It suggests that surprise only occurs when a character or monster doesn't NOTICE a threat. In my example, the Giants clearly noticed the threat, even if they hadn't acted on it yet. Saying that, one could argue that the giants didn't know it was a threat at the time, but I don't think giants are THAT stupid.
Right on! Declaring a combat action of any type means everyone's going into intiative.
"Shooting first" does not gain the Surprised status on everyone else in the room.
Nope. Seeing someone casting a spell in the middle of a conversation 100% calls for an initiative roll. Everyone would see and get a chance to react.
The guy should've let her actually take a turn and not just say the spell happened but initiative roll was the right call.
Okay that makes a lot of sense. I've clearly got the wrong end of the stick when it comes to surprise/initiative and use of actions before/during encounters. Back to the drawing board. Thanks.
Nope, you definitely had the initiative part right. If a PC takes a combat action, roll initiative for all the combatants.
Now, I would agree that 1) maybe some enemies were surprised and couldn't move and 2) the PC should have been able to move the target location of their fireball, but otherwise you had the right of it.
Really? I would call initiative if things are getting sticky and a player calls a combat action.
"I want to hide been things go poorly"
"Alright, roll initiative everyone. Are you bolting towards cover, or trying to be discreet?"
"Uh, 19, and discreet"
"Cool, well... Roll deception/performance"
"16?"
"Nice, you beat their insight, so they don't think anything is up. They spend their turn talking to X"
"Okay, my turn? I'll hide now."
Initiative doesn't have to be a universal case of "we've rolled it so now everything is combat." If a wizard wants to cast fireball, I'll ask for initiative first, and then play the round before the spell. It just might not be combat until the spell goes off.
Except this is completely nonsensical when you think about it - what happens when the rogue is trying to hide and the hostile NPCs beat them on the initiative order? Do they suddenly initiate attack? That’s fine, but it makes it seem like the DM is overtly trying to squash player creativity and enthusiasm. And if they don’t initiate attack, then what? They use their 6 second round to... keep talking? Prepare a Dodge action?
My rule of thumb is to never roll initiative until the last possible minute to avoid gumming up the entire session in the combat system. You’re free to do otherwise, but it doesn’t make a lot of sense in the context of the game world.
I’m also liberal when it comes to surprise, as if you’re a) in striking range of someone and b) have a potentially harmful action ready and c) they’re not actively defending themselves, you’re going to get the hit off (and then immediately start a fight of course). Anyone who has ever been sucker-punched in a bar will tell you this pretty much conforms to reality - it feels like this one player is getting crapped on just because her sucker punch can reach out long distance and rolls 8d6, but hey, that’s her spell slot for the day.
I've always used the "roll initiative" phrase in a three step maneuver
This way the player's are already aware of what's happening next, which prepares them for whatever events happen next.
No. Taking a combat action does not cause everyone around you to become Surprised. It puts you into combat - and you roll initiative along with everyone else.
What OP probably should have done was told everyone "they see you readying a combat spell - roll for initiative." Casting magic is obvious to anyone paying attention. Given the NPCs rolls, they clearly figured out what was going on before the player could act. (But that doesn't mean she couldn't have changed her plans when it came to her turn in the combat. - OP was arguably too harsh there.)
If you don't get a free action then you also aren't forced to use your action... for an action you haven't taken... and a spell slot.