Carson v. Lindsay v. Drake (PPR)
I've been having a hard time personally ranking the following three running backs: Carson, Lindsay, Drake. They are generally available at the 4/5 turn in mocks and I'm having hard time figuring out who to select.
Carson: 2018 - RB15 finish, 14.4 ppg (16th rank).
- Pros: SEA runs the ball more than anyone. As a result, plenty of carries to go around. In 2018, Carson had 247 attempts (7th in the league), 82.2 rushing yards per game (4th in the league). Hot finish to the year as only CMC, Henry and Zeke outscored Carson the last 5 games of the season.
- Cons: Injury concerns due to mad man running style (guy refuses to go down). Threat of timeshare with Penny (who is an ex first round pick!), although such threat is mitigated by sheer volume of SEA run game (so plenty for both to eat). And real dinger in PPR, only 20 catches in 14 games in 2018!
Lindsay: 2018 - RB13 finish, 14.9 ppg (13th rank).
- Pros: New OL coach Munchak is one of the best OL coaches in the league (coached Steelers for last 5 seasons). Flacco is a check down king - according to PFF, in the last decade only Brees and Rivers have had a higher target share of their passes go to RBs.
- Cons: Injury concerns due to small frame. Threat of heavy timeshare with Freeman who is the RB the new staff has had a chance to work with while Linsday has been hurt and is an ex 3rd round pick. Below average offense - 24th in scoring in 2018.
Drake: 2018 - RB14 finish, 12.9 ppg (21st rank).
- Pros: Tremendous receiver - 50 plus catches in 2018. Little to no competition in backfield - main comp is Ballage (ex 4th round pick) who is still very raw (rest are low picks/UDFA types) - Gore is gone! Had dominate stretch as lead back at end of 2017 season (24 points three games in a row!). No longer in Gase offense - which was bottom three in pace (plays per game). Durable - has not yet missed a game. Put up good numbers given his reps/opportunity.
- Cons: Can he be a lead back? - has generally been 1b in timeshare. How bad will the Miami offense be? Especially, if Fitz is no longer starting? Additionally, OL concerns - their OL is being ranked towards the bottom of the league.
In all, these three, in my opinion, are studs and pass the eye test, but as noted above all three have their own red flags. How would you rank them? Are they interchangeable or is there a clear pecking order? What are your thoughts?
Note: Analysis for 12 man, PPR league
Posted Jul 17, 2019, 6:37 PM UTC · edited