This argument is primarily based on volume.
I took a look at WRs in the past 4 seasons that earned 150+ targets, and their corresponding finish in PPR:
- 2021: Kupp (WR 1), Diontae (WR8), D. Adams (WR2), Jefferson (WR4), Diggs (WR7), DJ. Moore (WR18), T. Hill (WR6), K. Allen (WR11)
- 2020: Diggs (WR3), Hopkins (WR4), A. Robinson (WR9)
- 2019: M. Thomas (WR1), J. Jones (WR3), A. Robinson (WR8), Edelman (WR7), Hopkins (WR5)
- 2018: J. Jones (WR4), D. Adams (WR2), A. Brown (WR5), Juju (WR8), Hopkins (WR1), Thielen (WR7)
As you can see, other than DJ Moore last season, every single WR in the past 4 seasons with over 150 targets has finished as a WR1.
So can Mooney earn 150+ targets?
Well he