First retirement came WAY too late - So I cheated, er, house ruled
I've been playing a 2p campaign with my wife for the last month or so. We absolutely love the game so far and play it whenever possible. Our starting chars were Scoundrel (Wife) and Brute (Me). We really enjoyed our starting classes a lot, but we were about 15 scenarios in before I realized I may have picked one of the worst PQs for my first character.
522 The Thin Places - >!Complete 6 side scenarios!<
We attempted to play Gloomhaven, as it should be, with as few spoilers as possible, but this resulted in my Brute reaching level 9 and 14/15 perks and completing a large portion of the game (25 scenarios in now) before getting half of my objectives completed. I went ahead and researched a minimum path to guarantee completion of my PQ and realized it would require yet another 5 scenarios to reach retirement. Sadly, most of the enjoyment I get from this game has been the progression of our characters. Both my wife's Scoundrel and my Brute had reached our max potential, so many fun mechanisms in the game were no longer relevant (XP gains were pointless, Battle Quests were irrelevant, and we were so OP dungeons were a pushover). We weren't very motivated to continue grinding scenarios just for PQ.
So a new house rule was born. If a character reaches level 9 and full perks before the PQ is complete, the character MAY choose to retire at any time he/she visits Gloomhaven. We'll probably have to add some conditions or other rules so that if we ever hit prosperity 9, we can't instantly reitre after 1 scenario, but we'll leave that for another day.
While my wife and I are strong believers in RAW, we also feel that there are times where tweaks must be made to continue having fun and getting the most out of your time and experience. We rolled new chars last night and were much more careful about choosing our PQ, even pulling 3 cards instead of 2 to choose from and openly discussing them as they affect the whole party.
Thanks for reading and PLEASE share with me if you've done something similar or ran into similar PQ problems. I'd love to hear how others dealt with this challenge.
Posted Jul 18, 2019, 1:50 PM UTC · edited