r/rpghorrorstories•
Mtlguy

It's finally over. But how did it come to this? Bad Player turned Bad DM leaves group.

I had previously written about my problems with the current DM.

This week it all came to an end. Without resorting to personal attacks I focused on and explained how his behaviour was negatively impacting me. I told him that I wouldn't tolerate antagonistic commentary, tantrums and having to walk on eggshells around him. I also told him that if he ceased doing these things then things would get better over time.

He decided to figuratively storm off in a huff but not before making a last ditch effort to paint himself as the victim.

That's how it ended but how did it come to this? Well, let me tell you the story about how a skill check led to such acrimony and animosity.

Way back in the summer of 2017 I embarked on my most ambitious campaign yet, a sweeping high fantasy grand tour of a world of my own design. At first all was going well. In my years of playing D&D I had encountered few actual 'role players' who thrived on the performance aspect. More often I'd have players interested in exploration and combat while reserving RP 'for laughs'. I was fine with that but the person in question... may as well call him 'PIQ'... PIQ was really into the RP. Initially this seemed to me to be a very positive contribution to our table. He'd introduce his character the same way with the same catchphrase to every NPC, he'd act out actions in combat with flair, and was very good with dialogue. When PIQ joined the group he expressed relief that we were more receptive to his play style than the folks on roll20 and LFG who had no patience for his Polyanna 'the creatures in the monster manual are misunderstood and ready to befriend' approach. I wasn't thrilled with this approach but I did try to accommodate him.

The game favoured exploration and combat in desolate, remote locations where PIQ's bard wasn't going to be doing much persuasion. Although PIQ had a tremendous influence on the party's action economy by crowd controlling enemies with Hypnotic Pattern and later Forcecage he was envious of the other party members who weren't playing support classes that would often land more killing blows or inflict massive damage totals.

I tried to adjust PIQ's power levels to offer him more options in combat and I added more social scenarios to sessions, including private adventure sessions where he could go experience all diplomacy had to offer without making the rest of the group sit through hours of him talking.

It just wasn't enough. Nothing was. If he couldn't bring his bear mount into -one- city in the game he'd nag me about it endlessly asking which bureaucrat he needed to get in front of to persuade them to change the law. I tried to explain that I had reasons I didn't want any fantastic or irregular mounts in the capitol-hub. Eventually I relented once the party reached a higher level. It didn't end there. I even put my game on hold for a couple of sessions so he could railroad the party through his character's backstory in a linear adventure. I indulged him thoroughly spending more time trying to accommodate him than the rest of the group combined.

The campaign had a theme of uniting indifferent neighbouring states against a common threat by undertaking quests in the various regions to earn trust and favour. This culminated in a grand mass combat battle between an army of Hobgoblins and an alliance of humans, dwarves, elves, halflings etc. Typical high fantasy stuff. PIQ lives in another city but was going to be in town for a change and it was going to be his first time playing at the table with everyone so I hoped to run the big event with everyone gathered 'round a battle map that I painstakingly set up and poured a lot of time into creating military units, leaders, assigning Battle Ratings and otherwise implementing the UA mass combat rules. On the off chance that someone would want to attempt 'intelligence' or diplomatic activities, I had made two potions of detect thoughts available to the party. Two of them just in case one was used on something irrelevant.

PIQ decided to spend close to 13 hours over two days/sessions using the potions to explore his party member's psyches postponing the event, twice, (necessitating clearing and resetting the board to prevent my dog from snacking on miniatures) then he decided to pitch the idea that he could talk the Hobgoblins out of invading with a persuasion roll. I did my best to hint to him that such an effort wouldn't be likely to succeed.

PIQ had built his character to have double proficiency in Persuasion using the Half-Elf Feat and it being late in the game (8th level spells) he could reach very high results even on low rolls. I didn't put a stop to his mental mystery tour because I encouraged player initiative even if it resulted in something that wasn't necessarily thrilling to me. I wanted players to have as much agency as they could manage without devolving into indecisive circular conversations repeating "ok, so what do we want to do now?"

Three sessions after the big event was supposed to occur, I finally run it. PIQ, back in his hometown wasn't really interested in the battle and tuned out.

Having routed the Hobgoblins worst units, PIQ called for a parlay. PIQ attempts to persuade the Hobgoblins to trust him and make peace by invading somewhere else more convenient, it doesn't succeed, PIQ flips me off over skype and throws a tantrum.

After the game he sends me a message on facebook heavy on character status envy & victim narrative while light on details as to why his plan should have succeeded. He was angry and claimed that 'DM fiat' was holding him back but not other players. I tried to explain that he wouldn't have appreciated it if in his backstory adventure one of us decided to circumvent the adventure with a skill check and that he would have responded the same way, (indeed he would later respond the same way in his campaign, frequently railroading the party through 'cut scenes').

However, PIQ opted to double down on his victim narrative. He spent the subsequent session moping and had his character 'teleport' to a remote location (without rolling for mishap or even running it by me, the DM) to wait for other PCs to give him attention and sympathy.

For the remaining four or so months of my campaign he would sporadically subject me to his toxic negativity and antagonisms. It was a long 18 month campaign and I wanted everyone to reach the epilogue so I put up with it. Then I continued to put up with it during his campaign hoping his time in the DM chair would give him some perspective. It didn't.

After the previously written about events transpired PIQ-DM suggested a week of cooling off. Instead of facing the issues afterwards PIQ stopped communicating beyond agreeing to postpone resuming his campaign until September when two absent players were bound to return, once of which was central to the chapter.

In the interim I started running a substitute game for those still available to play, inviting PIQ to each session only to receive neither a positive or negative reply concerning his attendance. Finding it to be passive aggressive and an ill omen for September I confronted PIQ about his behaviour both current and past.

As shitty as his final parting shot was I feel a tremendous sense of relief at having confronted the primary source of negativity in my social life and having excised it, not by fighting 'fire with fire' but by trying to respond to him as an adult would (and should).

Posted Aug 14, 2019, 1:02 AM UTC

20051
Loading comments…