Meta: Why is it so hard to get meditation worshippers to be honest? Science ways in (again)
Highlights for the lazy:
- "The study, published in the European Journal of Social Psychology, provides preliminary evidence that brief mindfulness exercises can blunt moral reactions to harm."
- Examples of blunted moral reactions can be found in r/zen/wiki/sexpredators, as well as the most recent AMA fail by one of our local religious meditation promoters: essentialsalts
- "In a hypothetical scenario, participants who meditated displayed a weaker tendency toward repairing the damage after causing harm to a friend by losing their bicycle. In addition, meat-eating participants who watched a video depicting the suffering of animals tended to report lower levels of bad conscience when they had meditated, which in turn was related to weaker intentions to reduce their future meat consumption."
- In general, I tend to advance the argument that we get more transparency out of people when the stakes are low. The higher the stakes, the more immoral the conduct. If meditation allows for greater immorality, then it is more likely that people who worship meditation would be far more immoral if the stakes were the credibility of their church or the historical facts about their religion.
- "Mindfulness — without being embedded in an ethical context — may thus have downsides regarding interpersonal and moral behavior that have been so far ignored by researchers and also practitioners,” Schindler told PsyPost."
- I think we can see the genius of AMAs here. The Zen tradition of public accountability demands that people give an explanation, moral, ethical, etc. for their conduct... when they can't, that is largely considered to be a final judgement on their practices, beliefs, and sincerity.
- "And, of course, the findings shouldn’t be interpreted as suggesting that mindfulness meditation always promotes immoral behavior. “Practicing mindfulness can also certainly lead to stronger moral or less immoral reactions, for example, when the otherwise experienced feeling (e.g., feelings of vengeance or anger) would result in harming another person,” the researchers noted in their study."
- It is non-negotiable, then, that people be very clear about the moral/ethical basis of their beliefs. If you practice meditation in a religious context, or practice religious meditation or prayer-meditation, being open about your beliefs and publicly accountable to those beliefs would be... "essential".
I added this study (and link) to the meditation section on my wiki page: https://www.reddit.com/r/zensangha/wiki/ewk
Posted Aug 16, 2019, 8:24 PM UTC · edited
This is the crux of it for me, and why I recommend meditation as a physiological exercise, but I neither recommend nor think it’s Zen to detach from your emotions and ideas
I think Zen “detachment” is about detaching from “this is me! This is how I am!” That is: attaching your identity to something (See Foyan’s ghost story)
My most treasured ZM quote is Yuanwu’s comment on BCR Case 4:
“When one sees ones faults, they should reform. But how many can do this?”
I don’t remember where, but Yuanwu even references the quote in the Analects that I use on a near daily basis in my head:
“To see what is right and not to act is to want in courage”
And I mean, I think of this when it comes to shit like “ah I can put the dish in the dishwasher later - I need to go” all the way to “she loves you and you don’t love her”
I think Baizhang’s Fox, the intentionally excerpted passage from the Diamond Sutra in BCR 97, and others display a concept of forgiving oneself while also confronting one’s emotions and possible disagreement with their actions
The scorn of the those today absolves them of the wicked deeds of their past lives
The doctrine of no-self or however you want to phrase it absolves any responsibility of what I argue is the path to “the good life”: liking yourself upon inspection
Do I think that’s what Zen is? No - I think a Zen is seeing your true nature
Do I think doing that makes it easier to manifest your deeds in a way that makes you like them? Yes I do.
I called myself the Fox King for some time. It’s a hard crown to shake off. There is a distinction between specific shame and complex shame, and sure - meditation can probably help distinguish those
If you look for the source of your shame and can’t find it - well that’s one thing. If you think of your shame and suddenly your drinking comes to mind, that’s another
The practicing Buddhists I’ve met irl (who are emphatically so) are quick to frustration. I think meditation to go beyond the self and say feelings of suffering are an illusion is literally suppressing WHAT YOUR OWN BUDDHA NATURE IS REVEALING TO YOU
Like Jesus Christ
Anyways, that’s enough of a soapbox for now
We gonna rap / DND later?
There is a lot there... but "Buddhist irl" means "has a church"...
Have you met any of those people? What churches?
Yeah. I live less than 10 minutes from NC’s head Soto Zen Center
There’s a handful of other Buddhist temples around the area
So various ones among those
For starters, I don't think that Dogen Buddhists are Buddhists in the Eastern sense. I think they anger easily because they are threatened by more or less every fact, ever.
They are more like early Mormons or Scientologists, who also angered easily.
I may have been unfair about the grouping
The individuals I have in mind were Soto. However, I realized my psychiatrist is a contrary example. But she goes to a Buddhist temple as opposed to a zen center
Really great post NegativeGPA!
An excellent sermon Master GPA!
I am planning on it. Had to bail on DND tonight but I am going to be making a bonfire and chilling with the laptop and some delusion-inducing substances.
We’re going delusion diving woooo!!
Haha but yes: I will be in my back yard, writing poems by a fire on my laptop to my internet friends, later tonight, if that is what you were asking. XD