Quality scientific material to support the health aspects of eating meat - an objective debate

⚠︎ No reply from OP

I would like to see the best evidence to support the idea that eating meat is unhealthy. As it stands, I have gone through a massive link dump to find out exactly how data is cherry picked to reaffirm the notion that eating meat is unhealthy. The most common points I always see brought up are:

  • Not controlling for consumption of carbs
  • Citing of epidemiological studies
  • Asserting the idea that lower ldl is a health benefit instead of focusing on valid markers like blood results and medication reduction
  • Industry funded studies being referenced
  • Non scientific materials being referenced

So I come here and ask for the most objective responses possible. Because as it stands, nutrition is the only objective debate within the scope of eating/not eating meat. It doesn't matter how you justify your actions if your actions lead to your own demise.

Posted Aug 16, 2019, 9:31 PM UTC

374
howlin•

Meat is way too generic a term. Mammal meat, avian meat, nitrate cured meat, smoked/charred meat, large fish, small fish, freshwater fish, and various sorts of non-fish seafood all have different health pros and cons.

10
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

Not really

-5
howlin•

Fatty fish is probably healthy on net. So is lean, non-charred, non-contaminated poultry. So is many if not most "shellfish".

Mammal meat, cured meat and poultry fat are the best cases of unhealthy meat.

0†
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

Mercury, plastic, and pesticide use is quickly making seafood toxic

6
NotBruce_omnivore•

Mercury, plastic, and pesticide use is quickly making seafood toxic

As opposed to herbicides, pesticides and insecticides not making fruits and vegetables toxic?

1
howlin•

Most of those are only dangerous when they bioaccumulate, so things with a lower trophic level will have less contamination. But moreover, it would be nice to have a link to some research that assesses the real health risk from these contaminants in various animal products.

-1
dirty-vegan•

I'm vegan for ethical reasons. If meat were perfectly healthy, I'd still be vegan, because veganism is also perfectly healthy.

I see no reason to harm animals when I can easily be healthy without it

9
texasrigger•

As a pure hypothetical with no wrong (to me) answer - if an omnivore diet was objectively healthier than a vegan one would you still be vegan? In otherwords, would the self sacrifice be worth it to you personally?

2
dirty-vegan•

There's still no sacrifice since veganism is perfectly healthy, regardless of how healthy meat eating may be.

Unless what you're trying to say is, what if veganism was unhealthy. In which case, yes, it's still worth the sacrifice. 56 billion land animals a year are being bred into abhorrent lives of pain and fear then slaughtered. The resources and waste is causing mass species extinction, which will soon include us.

Now, the reality is, the Standard American Diet is incredibly unhealthy. So, somehow, health is widely agreed to be a fair sacrifice for the sake of taste of food. So why not a worth sacrifice for the animals and the planet? I see no benefit to not being vegan.

5
texasrigger•

Unless what you're trying to say is, what if veganism was unhealthy. In which case, yes, it's still worth the sacrifice.

Yeah, that was my hypothetical and that's a perfectly reasonable answer. There was no wrong answer, I was just curious to hear your thoughts.

2
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

Here's another question:

if an WFPB diet was objectively healthier than a omni one would you still be omni? In other words, would the subjective justifications be worth it to you personally?

1
texasrigger•

Mine is a different deal since my lifestyle is significantly different than the average modern western omnivore. My diet and lifestyle are locked arm in arm and no I wouldn't sacrifice it all for slightly better health. Were I more typical I may have a different answer. I don't ascribe to the ethics behind veganism but I certainly don't object to the idea of it as a diet. I'm not like my father who wants a big chunk of meat for every meal.

1
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

And most useless comment award goes to.... u/dirty-vegan !.

No one asked why you were vegan, this guy is asking for some material to fight common rebuttal against a reason someone should consider going Vegan or cutting out meat.

-5†
dirty-vegan•

Not pointless at all.

Veganism is an ethical stance. The healthfulness of meat is irrelevant, because veganism is still perfectly healthy and causes little harm to the planet and the animals.

So, the conversation would go, if meat were to be healthy:

Omnivore: meat is healthy!

Vegan: Veganism is also healthy. Since there is no personal sacrifice to health either way, let me tell you about the ethical and environmental reasons I chose veganism ....

I could understand this argument if veganism wasn't healthy, but it is. A balanced omnivorous diet can be healthy, and a balanced vegan diet is also healthy. No debate.

3
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

I didn't say pointless, also it is relevant if it convinced someone to go vegan

1
dirty-vegan•

So, how can we convince you to go vegan? Vegetarianism is a step in the right direction, although nearly as bad for the animals as omnivorous.

2
Creditfigarovegan•

I'd like to make a point that u/pointlessarguments3 will hate:

All forms of meat are least healthy for the sentient being from whom it came.

If the health argument for eating meat considers this aspect, it's a no brainier.

Luckily a WFPB diet is just fine, and is, in fact, the only diet that has ever successfully reversed heart disease.

Lmk if you find an animal products focused diet that accomplishes anything like that.

5
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

Why would I hate this

1
Creditfigarovegan•

Honestly you said something in another comment that I was tying this to, but can't remember what it was.

Oh well.

1
pointlessarguments3vegetarian•

I mean the only thing I don't like is you didn't link any scientific material in your original comment so OP won't be able to provide the fact that WFPB has reversed CVD, but it's good points

0
Creditfigarovegan•

If OP doesn't agree, I can link the study, but as long as we are all in agreement (because it is an established medical fact), then we are good to go.

0
howlin•

Citing of epidemiological studies

I'm not sure what's wrong with these. They're probably the most effective indicators of factors that affect "real world" health results, assuming confounding factors are properly controlled.

Here's an ok one: https://www.bmj.com/content/357/bmj.j1957

It shows that red meat consumption, heme consumption, and nitrate cured meat consumption are all linked to higher all cause mortality. White meat consumption is not.

5
Antin0devegan•

They're probably the most effective indicators of factors that affect "real world" health results

That's why the anti-vegan reality denialists hate them so much. It's like climate-change denialists saying that ice-core samples, or temperature records don't prove anything.

They don't have any epidemiological studies of their own to cite to support their "meat isn't unhealthy" hypothesis, so they have to discredit the myriad studies showing how the more plant-based a population eats, the healthier they are.

1
GreatMiddle•

Too bad I don't care about my health.

3
ScoopDat•

Over the months there have been some legendary compilations of hundreds of articles, commentaries, and studies of the health aspects.

Why have none of these been stickied or preseved?

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for your submission! Some topics come up a lot in this subreddit, so we would like to remind everyone to use the search function and to check out the wiki before creating a new post. We also encourage becoming familiar with our rules so users can understand what is expected of them.


When participating in a discussion, try to be as charitable as possible when replying to arguments. If an argument sounds ridiculous to you, consider that you may have misinterpreted what the author was trying to say. Ask clarifying questions if necessary. Do not attack the person you're talking to, concentrate on the argument. When possible, cite sources for your claims.

There's nothing wrong with taking a break and coming back later if you feel you are getting frustrated. That said, please do participate in threads you create. People put a lot of effort into their comments, so it would be appreciated if you return the favor.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
Antin0devegan•

I see no good evidence that eating known carcinogens is unhealthy. I know better than the IARC what constitutes "good" evidence.

-OP

1
[deleted]•

I think that the debate on whether or not meat is healthy is too heated.

If we may accept generalities, fruits and vegetables have been demonstrated to be healthy dietary additions. If you eat more fruits and vegetables, you will be healthier.

Thus, if we can't agree about any health claims of meat, we shouldn't eat it. Imagine that a new food that seems to be edible is introduced into the market. I'll label this "the stuff," like in the similarly named movie. No one knows anything about it, whether it's good for you or not, etc.. I wouldn't eat it, even if the evidence confused laymen like ourselves.

Vegetables are proven sources of every necessary nutrient. No deficiency can be proven even on extremely restrictive rice diets. The way I see, people have lived long and vigorous lives only eating plants. If meat's health benefits are unclear, do what's right for your health and don't take risks.

If you want, I'll cite, but I feel that most of these axioms are well established enough.

1
chris_insertcoinvegan•

Eating meat is unhealthy for the ones who need to die in order to get it. That's reason for me enough. Also it destroys our environment. Humankind cannot stay healthy without a functional environment.

1
acmelx•

Which measurable parameter your choose to determine if diet is healthy or not?

I choose all-cause mortality, then all-cause mortality between vegan, vegetarians and omnivores isn't statistically different ( https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10408398.2016.1138447?journalCode=bfsn20 article beyond paywall):

With regard to prospective cohort studies, the analysis showed a significant reduced risk of incidence and/or mortality from ischemic heart disease (RR 0.75; 95% CI, 0.68 to 0.82) and incidence of total cancer (RR 0.92; 95% CI 0.87 to 0.98) but not of total cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases, all-cause mortality and mortality from cancer.

So eating meat isn't unhealthy, according to my chosen parameter.

1

Some international institutions on the health benefits of plant-based diets:

American Dietetic Association It is the position of the American Dietetic Association that appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases. Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes.

Dietitians of Canada A healthy vegan diet can meet all your nutrient needs at any stage of life including when you are pregnant, breastfeeding or for older adults.

British Dietetic Association Well planned vegetarian diets (see context) can be nutritious and healthy. They are associated with lower risks of heart disease, high blood pressure, Type 2 diabetes, obesity, certain cancers and lower cholesterol levels. [...] Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for all stages of life and have many benefits.

The British National Health Service With good planning and an understanding of what makes up a healthy, balanced vegan diet, you can get all the nutrients your body needs.

The British Nutrition Foundation A well-planned, balanced vegetarian or vegan diet can be nutritionally adequate ... Studies of UK vegetarian and vegan children have revealed that their growth and development are within the normal range.

American Academy of Pediatrics Well-planned vegetarian and vegan diets with appropriate attention to specific nutrient components can provide a healthy alternative lifestyle at all stages of fetal, infant, child and adolescent growth.

—

Some recent population-based cohorts, published in top tier medical journals:

Journal of the American Heart Association, 2019 Plant‐Based Diets Are Associated With a Lower Risk of Incident Cardiovascular Disease, Cardiovascular Disease Mortality, and All‐Cause Mortality in a General Population of Middle‐Aged Adults:

Diets higher in plant foods and lower in animal foods were associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality in a general population.

In all indexes, higher intakes of animal foods received lower scores. Results from Cox proportional hazards models showed that participants in the highest versus lowest quintile for adherence to overall plant‐based diet index or provegetarian diet had a 16%, 31% to 32%, and 18% to 25% lower risk of cardiovascular disease, cardiovascular disease mortality, and all‐cause mortality, respectively, after adjusting for important confounders (all P<0.05 for trend). Higher adherence to a healthy plant‐based diet index was associated with a 19% and 11% lower risk of cardiovascular disease mortality and all‐cause mortality, respectively, but not incident cardiovascular disease (P<0.05 for trend). “

JAMA Internal Medicine, 2019 Association Between Plant-Based Dietary Patterns and Risk of Type 2 Diabetes A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis:

Plant-based dietary patterns, especially when they are enriched with healthful plant-based foods, may be beneficial for the primary prevention of type 2 diabetes.

JAMA Internal Medicine, 2017 Animal and plant protein intake and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: results from two prospective US cohort studies:

Higher animal protein intake was positively, whereas plant protein was inversely, associated with mortality, especially among individuals with at least one lifestyle risk factors. Substitution of plant protein for animal protein, especially from processed red meat, was associated with lower mortality, suggesting the importance of protein source.

European Heart Journal, 2019 Lower carbohydrate diets and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: a population-based cohort study and pooling of prospective studies:

Our study suggests a potentially unfavourable association of LCD [low-carb diets] with overall and cause-specific mortality, based on both new analyses of an established cohort and by pooling previous cohort studies.

Some potential mechanisms may mediate the unfavourable impact of LCD [low-carb diets] on health, i.e. the reduced intake of fibre and fruits and the increased intake of protein from animal sources, cholesterol, and saturated fat,[37–39] all of which are risk factors for mortality and CVD.[40] [...] Increased cancer risk has also been reported in relation to the intake of animal proteins[14] and the consumption of red and processed meat.[41] Further, it has been proposed that vegetables, fruits, cereals, and legumes, which have been found in several studies to be core components of healthy dietary patterns,[42] many of which contain important sources of fibre, are important sources of carbohydrates, so that reduced intake of these food groups is likely to have adverse effects on CV health. Moreover, several studies have reported that meat consumption or high intake of protein from animal sources may essentially increase the risk of CVD,[14] whereas high fibre diets appear to be associated with better long-term outcomes.[43]”

American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2015 Dairy products, calcium, and prostate cancer risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies:

High intakes of dairy products, milk (1 glass of 200 mL), low-fat milk, cheese (50g/day), and total (400g/day), dietary, and dairy calcium, but not supplemental or nondairy calcium, may increase total prostate cancer risk. The diverging results for types of dairy products and sources of calcium suggest that other components of dairy rather than fat and calcium may increase prostate cancer risk.

JAMA Internal Medicine, 2014 Vegetarian Dietary Patterns and Mortality in Adventist Health Study 2:

Vegetarian diets are associated with lower all-cause mortality and with some reductions in cause-specific mortality. Results appeared to be more robust in males. These favorable associations should be considered carefully by those offering dietary guidance.

The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1999 The Oxford Vegetarian Study: an overview:

Cross-sectional analyses of study data showed that vegans had lower total- and LDL-cholesterol concentrations than did meat eaters; vegetarians and fish eaters had intermediate and similar values. Meat and cheese consumption were positively associated, and dietary fiber intake was inversely associated, with total-cholesterol concentration in both men and women. 

After 12 y of follow-up, all-cause mortality in the whole cohort was roughly half that in the population of England and Wales (standardized mortality ratio, 0.46; 95% CI, 0.42, 0.51). After adjusting for smoking, body mass index, and social class, death rates were lower in non-meat-eaters than in meat eaters for each of the mortality endpoints studied [relative risks and 95% CIs: 0.80 (0. 65, 0.99) for all causes of death, 0.72 (0.47, 1.10) for ischemic heart disease, and 0.61 (0.44, 0.84) for all malignant neoplasms]. Mortality from ischemic heart disease was also positively associated with estimated intakes of total animal fat, saturated animal fat, and dietary cholesterol. 

Thus, the health of vegetarians in this study is generally good and compares favorably with that of the nonvegetarian control subjects.

—

Some other articles from top tier journals:

New England Journal of Medicine, 2012 Intestinal Microbial Metabolism of Phosphatidylcholine and Cardiovascular Risk:

“[…] our data suggest that excessive consumption of dietary phosphatidylcholine and choline should be avoided; a vegetarian or high-fiber diet can reduce total choline intake.” See figure 3.

IARC Carcinogenicity Classification, World Health Organization, 2018. Processed meats, just like tobacco smoking, fall into category Group 1, meaning the evidence is clear: processed meats cause cancer. Red meats fall into category Group 2A, meaning they probably cause cancer.

Nutrients, 2014 Beyond meatless, the health effects of vegan diets: findings from the Adventist cohorts:

Vegetarian diets confer protection against cardiovascular diseases, cardiometabolic risk factors, some cancers and total mortality. Compared to lacto-ovo-vegetarian diets, vegan diets seem to offer additional protection for obesity, hypertension, type-2 diabetes, and cardiovascular mortality.

Journal of Geriatric Cardiology, 2017 A plant-based diet and coronary artery disease: a mandate for effective therapy:

WFPB [whole-foods plant-based diets] can restore the ability of endothelial cells to produce nitric oxide,[28] which can halt and reverse [coronary] disease without morbidity, mortality, or added expense.

1