Quality scientific material to support the health aspects of eating meat - an objective debate
I would like to see the best evidence to support the idea that eating meat is unhealthy. As it stands, I have gone through a massive link dump to find out exactly how data is cherry picked to reaffirm the notion that eating meat is unhealthy. The most common points I always see brought up are:
- Not controlling for consumption of carbs
- Citing of epidemiological studies
- Asserting the idea that lower ldl is a health benefit instead of focusing on valid markers like blood results and medication reduction
- Industry funded studies being referenced
- Non scientific materials being referenced
So I come here and ask for the most objective responses possible. Because as it stands, nutrition is the only objective debate within the scope of eating/not eating meat. It doesn't matter how you justify your actions if your actions lead to your own demise.
Posted Aug 16, 2019, 9:31 PM UTC
Meat is way too generic a term. Mammal meat, avian meat, nitrate cured meat, smoked/charred meat, large fish, small fish, freshwater fish, and various sorts of non-fish seafood all have different health pros and cons.
Not really
Fatty fish is probably healthy on net. So is lean, non-charred, non-contaminated poultry. So is many if not most "shellfish".
Mammal meat, cured meat and poultry fat are the best cases of unhealthy meat.
Mercury, plastic, and pesticide use is quickly making seafood toxic
As opposed to herbicides, pesticides and insecticides not making fruits and vegetables toxic?
Most of those are only dangerous when they bioaccumulate, so things with a lower trophic level will have less contamination. But moreover, it would be nice to have a link to some research that assesses the real health risk from these contaminants in various animal products.