I think I'm going to sue NJ.
Call me impatient, it's been two weeks since McDonald and I haven't heard a peep about changing NJ law. I think I'll go apply for a carry permit, get denied, and pursue legal action.
Few questions for those of a legal slant, those in the know on human nature, and hopefully someone to tell me that I don't deserve a carry permit since I own the "wrong" gun =) ...
First, anyone want to help? Anyone want to "come with" and do the same?
Next, how the hell does one organize something like this, assuming like-situated folks want to do something about being in the same boat? I thought of ACLU-NJ and reddit (done and done). I ask this because I don't want to step on toes: if someone's got the ball rolling, I want to find them and know about it and get the hell out of the way since I'm just 1 guy. On the other hand, if someone is about to do this (and do it "better"), I want to NOT set up a precedent to make it harder for them to succeed down the road.
I honestly believe that with McDonald, there is a fair chance of changing NJ law. It's my hope that we don't stumble and fall all over each other - we need someone to get out there and DO THIS.
I don't have any money, but I have the internet and the Constitution on my side.
Thoughts?
Posted Jul 20, 2010, 2:08 PM UTC · edited
Bad idea. Let the pros handle this. There is potential for a bad ruling if the case is not handled right.
There are people spending a lot of time setting up cases to knock down anti-gun laws. I'm sure CCW is high on their list. You can help by funding them. Is there a NJ-counterpart to Calguns.net?
Well, you hit the nail on the head. IS there? If so, I shall retire to my sofa and begin to scratch myself and perhaps enjoy a turkey sandwich and some grapes.
If not, all the loose ends that are cropping up over here need to be addressed. I like that you're optimistic though. It took just these last 2 weeks for my optimism to fade (WHERE is the murmuring about NJ? WHO is handling this? etc etc).
I'm in CA so my knowledge tends to be limited to what's going on here. Like NJ we've got a lot more laws to break down than most states. I know that there were a number of cases here that were on hold pending a MacDonald verdict. One thing you need to keep in mind is while the SCOTUS ruled on incorporation, the ruling for the actual handgun ban has not been made (the lower court has been ordered to rule again in light of incorporation). This could a couple months I seem to remember.
Anyways, here's why I'm telling you to sit back down on your couch. There was some guy here who went and funded his own lawsuit here, lost, and generated some bad case law in the process. If you're some guy instead of an experience gun rights attorney there is potential you'll do damage to our cause even with the best intention.
One more thing: it tooks years for many other civil rights cases to come to full effect. This won't be an overnight thing. And that's ok.
Well again, that's just it: I don't want to rush out to be part of the front line, fall, and have all comrades trip over my corpse.
The other thing that I think is really crucial is the fact thALL HAIL THE HYPNOTOAD
BUUUZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
Really? Grapes too? Jesus.
Think: Hedonism bot, but with all appendages. And much fatters. And not gold.
My thoughts exactly! This must be some serious shit to be bringing out the grapes!
If all else fails, whether you agree with them or not, send a letter to the NRA. NJ's been on their radar for a while for a completely unrelated matter (Governor ended bear season early a few years ago, even when the wildlife department said it was a bad idea).
There is no murmuring yet, because a test case is required. I'd say no case has hit the courts in the last two weeks that would make a good one for NRA or SAF to back.
I wouldn't say "Let the pros handle this." I would say "Seek out the pros, and volunteer some time."