First Ergo: Build or Buy?

buying

Im ready to make the dive into my first build and hoping for a little insight before I pull the trigger. Two avenues Im considering for an ergonomic/split build

  1. buy the ErgoDox EZ with all the bells and whistles.
  2. buy an (old?) Ergodox PCB and put it together myself. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01CJ4LJ68/ref=psdc_12879431_t1_B07CQ3HHQR

I have seen other split designs and kits, but this line seems to come to the top of the heap in terms of quality and community support. Im a mech engineer so Im not afraid of soldering, or machining/3d printing my own case.

Im really caught between these two options. At the end of the day they appear to be almost the same price however...

  1. Ergo PCB: $31.99
  2. Teensy 2.0 x 2 $45.00
  3. Key Caps $75
  4. Switches $100
  5. Cables/misc $30
  6. case $20?

DIY build cost = $300 ish

Brand New Ergodox with all the shit = $325

what do you think? am I way off here? Im a little iffy about spending this kind of dough on first build.....at least with the EZ i dont have to solder..... Any comparable alternatives??

Posted Aug 19, 2019, 11:36 AM UTC

414
Schemik•

(redacted copy of my earlier comments)

I wish Dox had listened to community feedback back in 2012 and changed the layout a bit (thumb clusters more similar to newer keyboards like Redox and ErgoDash).

On the other hand, its imperfections have stimulated development of keyboards like Keyboardio Model 01.


I've had an ErgoDox for >5 years, but there are better choices these days.

Common criticisms of the ErgoDox layout:

  • column stagger isn't aggressive enough to account for significantly shorter little fingers
  • thumb clusters are located too far out

Technical limitations of the OG ErgoDox:

  • Teensy controller + IO expander (sort of fixed by Infinity w/ ARM or ErgoDone w/ 2x Micro Pro)
  • miniUSB and TRRS connectors (sort of fixed by Infinity)
  • no backlight, if you care about it (partially fixed by EZ and Infinity)

Obvious incremental improvements are ErgoDash and Redox.

But, there are much better-designed options out there too, like Keyboardio M01, Katy K80CS, Dactyl/Manuform and Maltron assembled from parts. Esrille NISSE might be worth a look as well.

Back in the day, it was basically between DIY ErgoDox and factory-made Kinesis Advantage, which had terrible firmware at the time (fixed on Advantage2).


The Split Keyboard: An Ergonomics Success Story

tl;dr [split form factor] fixes inherent health problems with wrists stemming from the standard straight, single-piece layout

The other thing here is that

  • human hands are symmetrical,
  • fingers have varying length,
  • thumbs are opposable.

So, this sort of layout matches human physiology much better than the standard. However, it's also necessary to learn to type on it, because the motions are slightly different than on a standard keyboard.

The ErgoDox was the first very successful open-source keyboard design back in 2012/2013 (EZ is a vendor that makes it in a factory), but the layout wasn't designed properly and suffers from several issues: the thumb clusters are too far out, and there isn't enough column offset to account for much shorter little fingers. [more here]

These issues aren't present on Maltron and Kinesis Advantage keyboards that were made for decades before the ErgoDox. The thing is that these are contoured, while ErgoDox is not in order to be cheaper and easier to make.

Now that 3D printing is easier and more common, it's possible to make your own contoured keyboard: Dactyl, Katy K80CS or Manuform.

Alternatively, the ErgoDox with its imperfect layout inspired the development of Keyboardio Model 01, which is a great product with an evidence-based layout (from Japanese ergonomics research in the 80s).

It also inspired the development of many DIY projects that may not be quite there ergonomically, but people have fun with them.

6
tinyenormous•

u/Schemik I've been thinking about designing a split and you seem to have strong opinions on this, so I'm interested in hearing more about them. I'm all for standing on the shoulders of giants!

Specifically I would love to know more about these two thoughts:

Teensy controller + IO expander (sort of fixed by Infinity w/ ARM or ErgoDone w/ 2x Micro Pro)

Are you saying that 2 micro pros are better? Or that the teensy is expensive? Or that the io expanders are a pain?

miniUSB and TRRS connectors (sort of fixed by Infinity)

Do the trrs cables have a significant downside? I see the infinity uses a usb cable for that same purpose.

1
Schemik•

Want to use only one half of the keyboard at a time? It needs to have a controller.

Every connector has its upsides and downsides; for example, the microUSB connectors used in Infinity often fell off the PCB.

The issue with TRRS is that it's not hotpluggable, it can short the keyboard. I would personally prefer connectors like RJ11 too.

2
tinyenormous•

Thank you! I've always wondered why they used the rj-11 on the dactyl manuform. It's not great aesthetically, but I understand the functionality now.

If the trrs was wired correctly you could make it so that it is hotpluggable from one end, right? ie if power was the tip then I think you could safely unplug the powered end. The opposite action would not be safe, and that does seem like it would be a design to avoid if possible.

1
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

wow the dactyl looks insanely cool.....thanks for the tip.

1
Schemik•

(another redacted copy of my earlier comments)

You can wait for hotswap Dactyl/Manuform.

Between Dactyl and Dactyl-Manuform, this is my recommendation:

Manuform is a better design. I find it technically somewhat nicer, but more importantly from ergonomics perspective,

  • thumb keys form an arc, instead of a rectangular cluster;
  • the angle makes pressing thumb keys more similar to closing a fist.

Customized Dactyl can be nice too, though, if you use more aggressive angles. Its benefit is that it can keep the thumb keys closer together, but I'm not sure if it matters that much.

See Dactyl-Manuform repository.

It's a 3d-printed contoured split keyboard with thumb keys in an arc. The circuit is usually hand-wired, but it's possible to use one-piece PCBs (Amoeba) or a flexible PCB too.

It's open-source, you can customize and print it for your hand size/shape and use case, but crystalhand sells pre-printed kits and you can buy them even assembled; he's also working on support for hotswapping switches as per post linked earlier.

2
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

Man these are awesome. I'm sold on the hot swapping. Designing and printing one of these would be so much fun

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
wdpk•

Thanks for this extremely detailed response.

Since you seem to have a lot of experience with split keyboards, what is your solution for using a mouse with them?

I’ve been starting to read about mechanical keyboards in general and ergonomic ones in particular but one comment mentioned that using a mouse off to the side becomes uncomfortable and so a trackpad/trackball in between the split was their solution.

What’s your take on this/what do you do for a mouse?

1
Schemik•

It depends if/how you need a pointing device.

There's a lot of tasks that can be done with the keyboard instead (e.g., vi-like controls in web browser, via Vimium or more radical UIs like the Next browser).

Personally, I would like to see pointing devices die off (perhaps with the exception of graphics tablets) and get replaced by motion sensors: eye trackers or gesture-based input like Leap Motion.

If you do need a pointing device, the most ergonomic keyboards tend to be quite compact and symmetrical, thus there isn't much of an issue with regular mousing (or balling), if you have them angled in the middle (like keyboards from the TRON project... or MS Natural/Sculpt), as opposed to having halves separated at shoulder width.

Aggressive tenting or some other unusual form factor can make it awkward to reach for a pointing device positioned much lower, but even then you can, for example, put it on a higher surface (another tray, place a thick book under a mousepad etc.).

Another consideration is having a pointing device in the middle indeed, or alternatively in front of the keyboard. Rollermouse and other stationary devices built into palm rests are somewhat popular. The downside is that those usually interfere with keyboards' thumb clusters or built-in palm rests. Rollermice in particular tend to be quite bulky; the most compact alternative is probably Trackbar Emotion. If you aren't too picky, you can have such a device integrated in the keyboard (Maltron trackball module, KeyMouse Track, trackpoint modules in place of key switches).

On a related note, some people have developed weird ways to use/place their regular mice. A classmate of mine had the mouse sideways in front of the keyboard, while resting his forearm on the desk; some gamers rotate their standard keyboards as much as about 45°; and I've seen someone rotate their mouse 180° and press buttons with their palm.

2
wdpk•

Fantastic info.

I’m definitely leaning toward a fixed-split keyboard. Do you have any examples of that trackpoint module in place of a key switch?

I’m leaning toward a Kinesis Freestyle2 right now (probably as a stopgap to something like building a Dactyl) and my ideal setup would be to have something like Thinkpad’s pointing stick on the right portion of the keyboard but since that isn’t possible, I’m also open to building something like an Iris, so maybe the module you mentioned would work.

Otherwise, that Trackpad Emotion seems like the best bet. Thanks for mentioning it.

1
supermitsuba•

This might be slightly cheaper: https://kono.store/products/ergodox-hotdox?_pos=1&_sid=c2b497281&_ss=r

The diy vs pre built, the only difference i see is hot swappable switches. I like the EZ and hot dox for that. The other thing I would say is tenting the keyboard is important.

I would go with the EZ. The tenting and hot swap is worth it. They all use qmk.

2
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

Yeah tent is a must. Hot swap definitely appeals to me as I assume I will be changing switches alot until I find my sweet spot.

Thanks for the link, significantly cheaper.

1
Schemik•

The downside of prebuilt ErgoDox is that you're stuck with 76 thumb clusters, only FalbaTech and possibly other makers provide 80key configuration, which slightly reduces default-layouts' shortcomings and gives you more keycap options.

Or better, go beyond ErgoDox.

There's this important thread about thumb clusters.

Regarding tenting, regular ErgoDox cases can be used with the Kinesis V3 kit, which is less fragile than EZ' weird "legs". Keyboardio is even better, though, because it has proper built-in tripod mounts for full freedom of adjustment.

3
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

hmm interesting point. i did think those leg things were awkward and dont look very dependable. too bad the keyboardio is so damn ugly!

1
ctrlshiftbahttps://ctrlshiftba.com/•

You don’t need to spend $100 on switches. If you do they will be way better the ones that ship with the ergodox ez.

You can buy Gaterons for like $20 or something premium like silent inks for $80.

2
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

ahhh good point.

I am still sorting out my switches: waiting on a little cherry tester..... I tend to go for whatever everyone says is the best so ive been looking mostly at cherrys. I will definitely look into these you've mentioned.

1
yomimashitaErgodox copper, CRKBD bronze.•

Check out the iris and crkbd.

1
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

Iris looks smashing but can't buy it anywhere....how often do they drop?

1
yomimashitaErgodox copper, CRKBD bronze.•
1
Anticosmic-OverlordOP•

Cool. Ty

1