r/guns•
MacDuff

Just Some Counterpoint for You, Gunnit.

From the Tao Te Ching:

46

When a country is in harmony with the Tao, the factories make trucks and tractors. When a country goes counter to the Tao, warheads are stockpiled outside the cities.

There is no greater illusion than fear, no greater wrong than preparing to defend yourself, no greater misfortune than having an enemy.

Whoever can see through all fear will always be safe.


I know not everyone on here is looking at guns as "if someone breaks into my home i will shoot them with this gun and this bullet while holding it in this such a way and i will aim at them like this and like that and will fire off those shots crisply and when the police come i will be certain to say that i believed he was about to spring across the room and kill me"

But for those who are, the above is for you.

Everyone else: Guns are fun as hell. Let's just be honest about that. Don't get caught up in the "but I'm defending my home/country/conception of liberty" to make that the ends by which the means of enjoying guns gets funneled. Some/most/all of that is appreciable, important, or crucial - but it doesn't have to be the whole thing.

We can just have a good time, share hobby tips or good deals, and innocently and for entertainment purposes plan out hypothetical situations like how to conquer an army of zombies.

But to be truly happy, one must not be on the defense. That "truly happy" is the big one, not the "comfortable for 20 years" kind.

EDIT (UNRELATED) Regarding my potential suit against NJ, The SAF has finally gotten back to me (would update that old post from last week but ... meh, you know how it is ...) and plans on taking some action. No word quite yet. I may have to make some phonecalls if they aren't forthcoming. STILL no word from any NRA at all.

Sorry if that hijacks the above.

EDIT TWO aaaaaaand /thread!

Posted Jul 29, 2010, 2:53 AM UTC · edited

044
born_lever_puller•

"Hokey religions and ancient aphorisms are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid."

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Key_Lime•

Hans Solo, Star Wars.

4
Raw_Shark•

Hans?!

5
[deleted]•

From the German edition.

3
born_lever_puller•

I read it in a fortune cookie.

2
filseyphill•

I'm just blown away that the annonymous author of the Tao knew what trucks and tractors were or were going to be all the way back when he penned it. Does the Tao have lottery numbers in it too?

10
born_lever_puller•

The original Chinese text discussed horses and manure. The truck and tank thing was from a modern "interpretation," (as opposed to translation). Almost a riff on the "sword into plowshares" thing from the New Testament, but not really.

3
MacDuffOP•

There's translator's bias in everything. Ever wonder why the bible talks about snow?

Just my two cents. I never wanted to represent that the tao te ching was the be-all, end-all of human disposition.

0
filseyphill•

Well of course there is but wouldn't you expect a translation to take into consideration the context of time? I understand what we're getting at here, but when I opened the page I wasn't expecting the Tao to be speaking of internal combustion engines and mechanized facvtories. The Tao's I've gandered through have generally been rooted in the idea of historical context. Same goes for The Art of War if we want to just stick with Chinese classics. Certainly this could be put in a modern phrasing, but I've never read a translation taking this liberty.

1
MacDuffOP•

Oh, I always thought of "tractor" as in ... the kind the Amish use. Not what we call a tractor in Big-Farm-USA.

2
[deleted]•

i have three translations of the tao te ching. i really like the stephen mitchell version from whence you've quoted, and it is my favorite. love that he published it with a photo of wood pulp on the book cover - being a book made of paper which is made of wood pulp.

1
[deleted]•

Why the bible talks about snow? Maybe because it can snow in Israel?.

-1
Psychomedic•
A witty saying proves nothing.
    -Voltaire

I'm fine with "just have a good time, share hobby tips or good deals, and innocently and for entertainment purposes plan out hypothetical situations like how to conquer an army of zombies." I don't particularly like seeing the same 'we gonna get raped' posts over and over again, but your quote doesn't really mean anything to anyone here.

8
MacDuffOP•

Fair enough. May the undertow of downvotes do away with this unworthy tangent.

1
StormingPolaris•

I guess I just really wonder how many people with guns actually expect to use them. I have a gunvault next to my bed. At night, before going to sleep, I open it.

But I do this less out of actual consideration that I may have to use it and more out of, "You know, on the off chance some terrible person does break in here at night, I'm going to feel like a complete dick if I have a gun in the house and it is completely inaccessible." The first rule of gunfights is...

The reality for me is, I've never been a victim of a violent crime, I live in a town which has very few (if any) violent crimes, and don't really expect that to change anytime soon. I've spent most of my life in what you might call condition white just because no one ever really fucked with me, and my thermostat was turned down low. Owning a pistol has changed this somewhat, at least to the degree that I find myself more aware in parking lots or walking alone after dark. It isn't the pistol itself so much as all the reading on self-defense I've done. This can only be a net positive in the long run because I do go walking at odd hours in odd places.

One of the dumbest yet most persistent allegations about gun owners is that we're basically paranoid would-be vigilantes, just looking for a reason to shoot someone (the term "trigger happy" comes up all the time when anti-gun people talk about gun owners).

I wonder what goes on in peoples heads. To me, guns have these dimensions:

(a) The right to own them is a direct measure of the state's regard for me, personally. Governments which insist it is their right to be armed, and to leave me defenseless against them, are by definition not governments I would ever consent to live under, were "consent of the governed" an actual concept rather than something people talk about while winking and making air quotes while saying. I guess I'm not a one issue voter in that other things do matter a lot to me, but gun laws are a "canary in the coalmine" for me. A government which insists not only that it has the power to infringe the right of self-defense, but suggests that I simply can't be trusted to be responsible with a firearm, is likely not going to be the kind of government I'm going to be digging in other contexts either.

(b) Craftsmanship. I despise planned obsolescence. I hate cheap mass-produced crap that falls apart. The guns I own are manufactured with the opposite philosophy. They are probably the best manufactured things in my house. I just like having them for this reason (my old Leatherman Supertool would be another example of this). They represent manufacturing philosophies I wish were applied to everything I own. If for some reason I could never shoot a gun again (say, for physical reasons), I'd still own guns because I just like to hold them.

(c) The centering nature of shooting. With the possible exception of shotguns, pistol shooting has nothing to do with releasing any kind of pent up aggression. Shooting calms me. The violence of the recoil and flash and the kind of strange environments (indoor ranges, mostly) allow me to completely immerse myself in the activity. I am easily distracted, but not so with shooting. My pulse slows and I almost always leave in a good mood. "Relaxing" doesn't quite cover it. It is almost meditative to me. There's also something about calmly holding what is basically a small explosion in your hands, and meticulously aiming, squeezing the trigger, and making it hit a target down the range despite all of the ruckus involved that's really good for me.

(d) God dammit, it makes me feel like a fucking American. The enumerated right to own, carry, and shoot a gun as a civilian paints a stark picture of the relationship of the individual to the state here. I believe every person on the planet who intends to own a weapon responsibly - that is, for self defense and/or sport - ought to be able to do so without being interfered with, but I recognize that the way it is enshrined in our Constitutions (federal and state) is unique. I think a lot of people abroad think this has something to do with Americans being inherently violent or somehow we all think we're cowboys, but for me, it is about individual sovereignty: that at most, we lend revocable power to the state, and that the state is not the "fact of life" authority it is elsewhere.

Obviously, the state has grown far beyond what we should ever have allowed, and a pistol isn't going to hold off tyranny by itself, but so long as we have this right and can exercise it, the flame never quite goes out.

It is not violence I am concerned with; nor do I crave any kind of conflict with others. Was never into schoolyard fighting and dislike having enemies, however necessary that occasionally is (I really am more about building bridges than burning them). It is justice I am concerned with: the principle that my life is not negotiable, and that a gun is the best and most practical means of protecting it, should the situation arise, from those who would take it away. It is not the love of the capability of doing this that is important here - it is the love of the vision of a society where no one ever attempts such a thing.

Never wanted to be a boss, or a master, and sure as hell never wanted to be a slave. And this is true for how I feel about others as well. Guns are part of this equation. Whatever I think about someone's politics or they think of mine, there is always an open channel of communication possible when someone indicates that they would never attempt to rob me of my means of self-defense and personal sovereignty.

It is not even so much what people think about their own guns that tells me a lot about them, but what they make of mine. And in my experience, even people who don't like me, or don't share my politics, but would take a stand for my right to be armed, are people I can live with and constitute a society with.

When I think of guns, they are implements of, and products of, the Enlightenment, emphasis on light. They've got nothing to do with darkness or brooding or obsessing on death.

8
MacDuffOP•

I am so, so so so happy about this response, I'll just keep gushing before I make a substantive answer.

Thank you for letting me know I'm not crazy.

Thank you also for catching what I was saying and not assuming that I was being trollfaced or anything.

1
[deleted]•

That tao thing you quoted is a bunch of drivel. Nonsensical, overly idyllic, garbage. IMO.

7
MacDuffOP•

It's just philosophy. Most is overly idyllic, unless it makes its way into a fortune cookie.

4
kodozoku•

Fortune cookies have a lot to do with rational, realistic discussions about firearms.

5
sewiv•

There is no greater illusion than fear, no greater wrong than preparing to defend yourself, no greater misfortune than having an enemy.

I completely disagree with this statement,but I'll defend to the death your right to say it.

4
MacDuffOP•

And I would do the same for you.

I won't toss out my explanations and my ramblings - not that I claim to understand, at any rate - but I will say this:

I interpret "There is no greater wrong than preparing to defend yourself" to mean that by doing so, you have not risen above the violence and selfishness of the world.

I picture myself buying guns as entertainment, but then figuring what they're "for" when the sport is over and the night has fallen, and know that if someone broke into my home to try to kill me I would certainly count myself lucky to have a gun at the ready.

However...

There's something beyond that, there's something that says, "go ahead, take whatever you want, because having these things doesn't do anything for me really and you taking them is just you suffering from the dillusion i once had."

But yeah, someone comes in to try to - i dunno, kill my housecat? - I would be all about popping a kneecap and taking pictures of the bleeding asshole as the EMT's loaded him up. I'd have the pictures online before I was done with the police report. I wouldn't just be violent, I would be sure to assassinate his character.

I'm not changing lives here, I'm offering counterpoint to Gunnit.

And I thank you for your tolerance. Maybe we can talk on it.

2
kodozoku•

I hope you realize that if you "pop someone in the kneecap" there's a damn good chance that person will bleed to death in under ten minutes. Both the popliteal artery and popliteal vein are in danger of a shot through the knee, and even clipping either one will cause a fatal drop in blood pressure, and, as I've said, probably under ten minutes later (depending, of course, on the cardiovascular health of the person you just shot) the victim will be dead. Sorry to burst your bubble.

TL,DR; The idea of shooting someone in the leg as an alternative to killing them with a central mass shot is a Hollywood myth, you're perpetuating it, and I hope that most people here in gunnit aren't dumb enough to think that you can shoot someone anywhere and have it be a reliably survivable wound.

Also, the TDC quote you used above is extremely out of context, and the way you paint gun owners as either (A) I'LL F**KING KILL YOU IF YOU STEP INSIDE MY HOUSE or (B) I like shooting targets! is polarizing and ridiculous.

Just my two cents. Also, you're not offering a counterpoint to gunnit because there is no true consensus here (although, again, I hope most people here realize that you're completely wrong about being able to "popping a kneecap" and having that person survive long enough to have an EMT show up. Also, you'd be probably tried and convicted of malicious wounding if you DID do something that stupid.)

6
MacDuffOP•

I feel like I've been strangled by irony. Thanks for the edification. Upboat!

1
fucema•

If you're skilled enough to only maim the person in the knee cap (leaving aside the question of whether you were really under threat of life if you only shot to injure) in a high stress condition possibly abruptly woken up and in the dark of the night... you are a true god.

If you have a psychic ability to determine that an intruder in your home is only going to steal a few things and is completely uninterested in harming you or your loved ones... you are a true god.

I am not that skilled or gifted, unfortunately.

Sorry if I broke up your masturbatory outpouring.

3
MacDuffOP•

I have to admit I have no idea why it's considered mastabatory outpouring. I was explaining something I thought relevant.

2
kodozoku•

Nobody is skilled enough to only maim someone by shooting them in the kneecap. To do so would require knowledge of your victim's individual cardiovascular layout; i.e., not everyone's veins are in the same place. As I stated above, the idea of "shooting to maim" is a Hollywood myth that has no place in a serious discussion about self defense.

1
[deleted]•

I know lots of people that got attacked that should have been armed.

1
jeffwong•

I appreciate the classics, but I can think of many wrongs worse than self-defense. Was Confucius aware of the kinds of atrocities that people were capable of at the time? Is this advice for a person or a state?

War is the worst possible thing, but advice for states should be different from advice for people, since they are different.

Is his advice really for governments? It would be reasonable to conclude that armed monarchs who start with defense in mind can later turn into aggressors. Is Confucius referring to the paranoia of armed monarchs?

We know now 2000 years later that there are examples of states that can be prepared for defense and don't have an aggressive demeanor.

The state of Zhou was eventually destroyed by Qin Shi Huang. Prior to this, China was in constant states of war.

Well, that's the justification that Qin gave....

3
MacDuffOP•

Wish I could extra-upvote for injecting history and interesting counterpoint to my counterpoint.

As a human being, I think self-defense is practically a virtue.

As a member of the audience of the tao, I try to wrap my head around the idea that thinking of defense is to become a victim to violence.

It's not like violence doesn't exist. It's not like if, say, someone pointed their gun at me, I wouldn't point mine back.

Not saying that at all.

But there's something ... comforting?...about thinking that there's a whole way of life outside what we know, a way that perhaps - maybe by contradistinction if nothing else - lets us question what it is we're really all about.

I didn't buy a gun so I could shoot someone, justifiable shooting or not. I just like guns. I once said I thought a gun was useful for self defense or home defense or something, and now I see that such a justification was entirely needless.

And I wanted to share the idea that there are lots of pro-gun ideas that are not pro-death or pro-violence. I say this even though a gun is often considered "inherently dangerous."

Here I am explaining away again, sorry. Not the intention.

In reply, I think that it's almost impossible to not consider self defense when thinking of the disciplines of a complete person. Whether it be physical or simply knowing how to discern when someone is lying or tricking you, these defense mechanisms are vital. And yet, to actively seek to defend one's self, according to the tao, is to already have lost.

I think it's a beautiful idea. That's pretty much it.

1
jeffwong•

Perhaps your point exhibited by Tao Te Ching passage is that "one is not free of the threat of violence once one is forced to plan defenses against it."

In that case, what's wrong with preparing for defense but not being consumed by fear? Video blogger NutNFancy aptly said , "No gun, no options."

Although I don't personally fear death, I would prefer not to be killed for no good reason and I certainly would prefer the other person be dead because they probably be a lesser person than me. (Hypothetically a criminal)

That's how I feel. Awful, but true? Am I giving up something about being human? Empathy?

Being a gun owner has certainly given me interesting meditations on life, death, and the morality of violence. Would not have happened otherwise.

2
msiley•

Confucius didn't write the I-Ching.

0
jeffwong•

That's fine. We are talking about the Tao Te Ching.

2
MacDuffOP•

The damned comments aren't showing up, so let me try again:

There's a difference in how you see the world if you have a gun because you spend your time expecting to use it against a person and if you just simply have it because you enjoy it. Lots of overlap, but BIG difference.

What the ancients describe as peace does not include a hearty vigilance - this is not error and this is not because of foolhearty idealism - this is because true peace is at once a detachment from the offenses of the world and at the same time an acceptance of it, along with all the good.

I'm not sure how long I've been here, but I've only just had it crystallize that we've got two groups here. One is looking to shoot people and one just likes guns.

That's all I have to say about that. Sorry if I broke up your Gunnit party.

2
Key_Lime•

Philosophy is all fine and dandy as an academic exercise, but in my opinion has little application outside of academia. The philosophy majors I've met are so detached from reality that I'm surprised that they can even function in society. The saying you posted reeks of the same philosophical crap that instructs women to just lie back and accept that she is being raped, rather than defend them self.

3
MacDuffOP•

Well, I'm sorry you see it like that. I won't try to explain any further. Resume normal r/guns debates, discussions, and discount-notices.

1
StormingPolaris•

Philosophy as a formal discipline of studying, understanding, being able to compare and contrast, and track the development of philosophy across the ages is indeed an academic pursuit, however:

All people have philosophy, or at least make the conscious choice not to choose one and I'm getting very close to quoting a Rush lyric so I will stop here.

1
WallPhone•

Have an upvote. Its not fun being misunderstood.

Weapons are instruments of fear; they are not a wise man's tools.
He uses them only when he has no choice.
Peace and quiet are dear to his heart,
And victory no cause for rejoicing.
If you rejoice in victory, then you delight in killing;
If you delight in killing, you cannot fulfill yourself...

Of course, the option to use a weapon is always available, and there is nothing wrong with armed self defense--only when he has no choice.

Congrats on you're SAF progress...

2
MacDuffOP•

Just for the fuck-all of it, if it makes any sense, it was the packet the SAF sent me that I happened to be looking at when I made this post.

The packet contains a sticker with a 1911 on it and some big letters that say "THE OWNER OF THE PREMISES IS ARMED! NOTHING INSIDE IS WORTH LOSING YOUR LIFE OVER!"

That's what prompted this whole thing, I realize now. I guess I was trying to shed the "pro-gun means shooting people in the right circumstances" assumption that can so easily be sniffed out of normal r/gunnit traffic.

And I guess this makes it fair that one of my responses was called a mastabatory outpouring.

It all makes sense now.

/thread!

2
WallPhone•

It all makes sense now.

Sometimes ideas exist in your head but you don't truly understand them until they've been bounced off another person. We've both benefited (and likely others) even if most have apparently completely missed the point, been angered, and dismissed the new perspective entirely.

I don't follow Tao, but every time I see more of it I respect it more. Thank you.

3
fucema•

Too bad the world is not so black and white and easily compartmentalized into your groupings.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

NO U MACDUFF NO U NO U

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kodozoku•

This guy is an obvious troll. We should stop responding to him.

-2
StormingPolaris•

I wouldn't say that. I think when you own a gun, it is important to meditate upon death; upon killing and being killed, and how you feel about that.

Guns for me, like war, when used against other people, should be solemn moments in that they are indicative of failure of civilization, socialization, and all of the things we as a species have done to uplift ourselves from our animal roots. I have always hated, most of all, the flag waving celebration of war in this country. It is not that I am a pacifist and believe violence is always wrong -- only that it is never to be celebrated.

The dirtbag you are forced to kill because he's going to kill you was once a cute toddler, probably with a mother who loved him, and even so in his present state with a lifetime of memories. Maybe he himself is a father and has brought life into the world.

People love the Fight Club bit about, "You are not special. You are not a beautiful or unique snowflake."

Well, people have taken it to heart and we are a shittier civilization because of it. Look at the political debate in this country where the only way most people (it seems) can disagree is be dehumanizing their opponent and reducing them, at least mentally, to vermin, or the casual way in which people get behind and support war and all of the death it brings.

Well, I don't think this way. I think people are unique and life is precious. It is because I regard life this way that I would take another life in defense, but it would be a grim moment, and one which would likely fuck me up for the rest of my life. And you will find few people as radical and consistent on the right of individuals to keep and bear arms as me. My comment history indicates that, I think.

So I really don't think this is a troll at all.

5
kodozoku•

What if your attacker was really ugly as a child?

...sorry. I am no longer convinced that MacDuff is a troll, and I apologize to him for my insinuation.

1