We hear a lot about ancient tribes, but what were they?
Germanic tribes, Gallic tribes, Illyrian tribes. What was a tribe? Was its structure formal or informal? How were the actions of the tribe, such as migrations and military actions, coordinated? What sort of importance did people place on their tribal affiliation? If the people in the next village over were a different tribe, how would that affect someone's view of them? Did these tribes have anything to do with the ruling structures that emerged, like kingships?
I know that's a lot to answer. I would be most appreciative even of a book recommendation.
Posted Sep 14, 2019, 2:27 PM UTC
That's rather a good question, especially as the term seems to appears regularily in question about Barbarian "tribes", in opposition to Greeks or Romans.
The first thing that must be stressed is that the name doesn't come from ancient sources : while Greeks or Romans can mention Barbarian peoples with different names, sometimes making a point to differenciate social frames (as with Caesar about Gauls), when they have to name peoples in a broad sense, they often resort to "natio" or "ethnè". Thing, is, these words can be used to name a small people or an entire "race" such as Germans or Gauls; both being defined by common ancestry, the size varying a lot; and without any real implication on the social sophistication : Aedui with their sophisticated state and Veneti living on the fringes of the known world could both be labelled as such.
Does that means that the word tribe didn't existed in Antiquity? It did and was used by Romans, to talk about their own social organisation, tribes being considered a traditional tripartite (tri-bus) subdivision of the original Roman people : Tites/Ramnes/Luceres extended during the royal period and early Republic, to 35 different tribes. While the original ones were often taken as coming from the three founding peoples (Latins, Sabins, Etruscans), a tribe was mostly defined trough civic lines, on which curia one belonged (tribes being divided in smaller ensembles) and participation (at least, possible participation) to assemblies.It's not clear at all if it was based on perceived genealogical ties, and it might rather be understood as a political identity.Athenian phylai (sometimes translated as tribes) seems to have been close enough from this, with the same blurry origin and without clear evidence it was associated to a genos, a group unified by ancestry.
We don't really know how ancient Barbarians named their own social organisation : thanks to Caesar, we know the main institutional frame was the "people" (civitas) made of pagi. Pagi were traditionally considered being the assembly of a tribe, but nowadays specialists rather argues that they include too many people and too great of a territory for that, Stefan Fichtl in particular proposing that Caesar's description of "fractions of pagi" might be a more accurate description of Gaulish tribes.Incidentally, thanks to Gallo-Etruscan and Gallo-Greek epigraphy and comparison with Old Irish, we might know the Gaulish word for tribe : *touta or *toouta, as in Toutatis "the tribal [god]". At least in some aspects, it seems that *tooutios/*toutios was based around a city, itself possibly defined by a common sanctuary : as such it is often translated as citizen.As in Rome, the tribal identity in Gaul seems to have played an important part into the making of a personal and local identity, but little in the political identity of Gauls as far as we can tell, the civitas (being understood as a political gathering of men in late Republican Latin, and not a city at least not in this context) became the main political institution, gathering pagi that themselves gathered fractions of pagi, these being possibly tribes. (Les Peuples Gaulois du IIIème au Iè siècle, Stefan Fichtl, 2005)
It's really unclear for early Germans. but what Caesar describe as the pagi of Ariovistos' confederation might be closer to be defined tribally : while Helvetii gather 5 pagi, Ariovist can count on more than one hundred. It's probably not due to an "ethnic" difference between Gauls and Germans (Germans of this period being often Celts, Celticized or partly made up of Celtic or Celticized peoples) than an institutional difference, Gaulish petty-states having possibly a separate and longer tradition of political build-up.
Still, an interesting set of inscrptions in Northern Britain might enlighten us a bit on the definition of a tribe for a Romanized German in the IInd century, especially what was found on the old Roman fort of Housesteads (RIB 1593 and RIB 1594)
Tihuanti being generally considered as a latinized Germanic name for the people around modern Twente, and the same known as Tubantes; we'd have a same consideration for citizenship/tribality, maybe around the idea of assembly (under the auspices of Mars of the assembly). The important part there would be the personal localized identity, and not necessarily the Frisian label that might be more Roman than Barbarian.
Of course, contact with Rome had certainly a great influence in Barbarian self-identity, not just materially but as well politically, and by the IIIrd century onward, Barbarians would refer to themselves trough a more broad identity, rather than tribal in this sense, as found in Pannonia.
For ancient sources, tribal simply doesn't have a relation to a degree of social sophistication, it is rather a matter of personal identity, shared with a small group and maybe less defined by blood than by assembly (or, rather, jointly with assembly), which would be made clear by the "adoption" of provincials citizens into Rome tribes.
It might have been, compared to broader assemblies and identities, an immediate and regular participation to the organisation of everyday life, maybe popular or partly democratic depending on the circumstances : how to manage sanctuaries, harvests, buildings, basically commune management decision, how to delegate but as well how to know and execute decisions taken at upper levels.
The usual meaning of tribe, in the modern sense, owes a lot to an extremely Eurocentric ethnology, issued from the Age of Discoveries and Colonial era; contacted peoples being considered as closer to barbarity than Europeans, as were Barbarian peoples to Romans. Using the word tribe, passed trough medieval Latin to call scattered Hebrew peoples in the Bible, it gave us the obnoxious "tribe".I won't dwell too much into a question that would probably, given its complexity and nature, have a better place and answer in r/AskAnthropology about a contemporary understanding of the concept, especially on an evolutionary model (although I find the rough state model proposed by Colin Renfrew interesting with an understanding of tribes as a relatively acephalic ensemble, Maurice Goudelier and Alain Testart being good reads on the general question too)
It is not that the whole tribal concept is a waste of time, that said, for Barbarians and Antiquity, even beyond the political/regional understanding of the word as we very briefly seen. But just as ethny had been replaced with a broader sense of ethnicity, tribal could benefit from a broader sense cut from a straight evolutionary model.
I mostly think there of the "Tribal Zone" model as a factor into identity and popular ethnogenesis, which Peter Wells defines as such in Beyond Celts, Germans and Scythians (2001)
"Tribal" societies (although the term could rather cover what Colin Renfrew or Richard Hodges would consider as chiefdoms) would be defined by a fluid indentity based on territory, genealogical relations, and political boundaries with a unstable and relatively weak leadership. Complex societies would provide with the means of prestige display, wealth as capital meaning possible hoarding and social investment, and possible increase of capacities of mobilisation and creation of an oligarchic elite and "Early State Module"
In the case that interest us, lasting contact between Barbarians and "Primary state"-like cultures such as classical Greeks and Romans, notably trough trade and access of prestigious goods (for instance, wine for Gauls) and the material cultural influence it represents would impact on local self-identity (either embracing the changes as the aristocratisation of Gaulish societies in the IInd to Ist centuries BCE, either refusing it as in Ist century AD Bavaria) and its political frames : the switch over a "Sicambri" identity to a broader "Frankish" one in the IIIrd to IVth centuries being due to the success of the Frankish coalition and its centrality in relation between tribes and Romans.
Great answer. Perhaps one of the most muddying aspects of accepting the Graeco-Roman term "tribe" as a concrete expression of self-identity is that we don't really know on which basis these people defined their group identity, as you pointed out.
Etymological analysis of ethnonyms is quite helpful in this regard as we can at least get a glimpse into the core of "tribal" self-identity; early Irish population groups for instance seem to have been formed solely around cult identity (a people united by their devotion to a primary deity or cult figure) with names like the Osraige, the Bibraige and Artraige ("people of the ox/beaver/bear" respectively) before the development of a strictly hierarchical society dominated by a warrior aristocracy, which in turn gave rise to group identities based on one's supposed lineage to an ancestral figure with famous groups like the Ui Niaill and Ui Briain.
I'd argue that Gaulish population groups seem to have similarly formed their collective identities from a core warrior aristocracy holding the majority population in their thrall than some sort of ritualistic or cultic collective identity; Gaulish ethnonyms are pretty much the closest thing in the ancient world to modern day street gang names. Names are tricky because they often lose their semantic meanings almost immediately after a generation (Canada is derived from an Iroquoian word for "village", but most Canadians are totally unaware of that etymology), but Gaulish ethnonyms are unique for their unambiguous emphasis of warfare and combat: ethnonyms like Catugenatos ("those born in battle"); Orgenomesci ("drunk with massacres"); Aeudi ("the fiery ones") and Roburos ("the very furious") completely outnumber any attested ones that could be established as names derived from cult identity.
This seems to be an indication that by the time Caesar began his conquest of Gaul, the prominent form of communal identity in that region was almost like that of modern military regiments or companies (like the Big Red One; the Black Watch; the French Foreign Legion etc.); an identity formed around a core of warrior aristocrats and their commoner dependents. A former mod on this sub who specialized in Migration-Era Germanic society had a similar theory regarding identities from his particular area of study; he compared identities like the Goths, Langobards, Vandals etc. to corporate branding, where you had a core of warrior aristocrats called the "Goths" around whom a chain of non-noble dependents and servants derived their collective identities from, rather than some blood and soil ethnic identity. This seems to me to have also been the nucleus of group identity in pre-conquest Gaul.
Of course the expansion of the Roman Empire into temperate Europe radically changed how "tribes" self identified, a process which would happen centuries later when Europeans began to colonize other parts of the world and indigenous peoples there formed new identities to better protect themselves and/or negotiate with the new colonial powers. For example, the Marcomanni, a Germanic people who lived just beyond the frontier of the Roman Empire north of the Danube, were a confederation formed in response to Rome's occupation of that region; their name literally means "men of the border", suggesting a collective identity formed out of necessity by Rome's very expansion.
So I guess all in all, the word "tribe" is a terrible catch-all used to group any sort of communal identity in temperate Europe at this time (as it would later be used in Africa and the Americas centuries later) regardless of how those groups actually articulated or formed those identities. I suppose it would be like an academic writer today grouping together North Korea, fans of the Green Bay Packers and Wall Street bankers as "nations" just because they're all collective identities whose underlying formation is incomprehensible to them as an academic (or Graeco-Roman ethnologist...).
First, I agree with most of what you said in this post, and names are a good way to understand how peoples could perceive themselves (even if they somehow "lost" the ability to understand it, which is almost certainly not the case for the ancient Celts, they could always "reinterpret" it).
When it come to Gauls, tough, it's probably better to speak of collective identities, plural form.We know little of the pagi and tribal names in Antiquity, partly because they were submersed by civitates, especially in Central Gaul (only up to a point, tough, hence the survival of the tribal god "Toutatis" and the reference to the "gods of such and such place"). To make the difference between a client and a pagus of the Aedui, for instance, can be really tricky if possible at all.
Now, we know very little of the build-up of Celtic (in the geographic sense) peoples, and almost exclusively rely on archaeology there, at least until the IInd century. But the success of Celtic agglomerations of the second Iron Age in Keltikè tend to be associated with early sanctuaries1 with the structuration of sanctuaries being accompanied of a proto-urbanisation rather than following it (the heroic statuary being quite possibly older than previously thought, maybe VIth or Vth centuries rather than IVth).It's in this sense I said that tribal, local identity (giving the centrality of oppidae and small proto-towns in Gaulish political organisation^(2)) had a cultural origin as much as expression, being understood that warfare was both a religious and civic expression, and being profitable.The annual druidic conference, furthermore, could be understood as a model for the "lay" interregional assemblies (concilium totius Galliae, concilium Galliae, concilium comune Belgorum, maybe as well in Armorica or, speculatively there, Celto-Ligurians) that might have represented the "top-level" of the Gaulish political matrioshka3, and quite possibly the expression of a pan-Gaulish identity comparable to what Olympic Games and Delphic cult were for a pan-Hellenic identity.I agree, tough, that sanctuaries' role in IIIrd to Ist centuries is less clear, maybe due to a decline of druidism as proposed by J-L Brunaux. There's the possibility of the existence of federal sanctuaries, notably set at the confines of various peoples (Ribemont, Mirebeau)
It's not to say that Gaulish civic/religious conceptions, and therefore identity, didn't relied on warfare, far from it. As you said personal name and civic names (although I'm not really sure that it was that dominating in Gaul, and geographical names could be quite well represented too^(4)) highlight its importance and it does have a gang-like aspect as had late ancient Barbarians.There's some differences that deserve to be highlighted, tough : the latter were, to quote Guy Halsall, "peoples of the limes" whom identity and institutions (especially with the IVth century) and could be understood as "extensions" of the Roman state, then more or less fully part of it, and the old Gothic or Frankish identities had to deal with a pervasive Romanisation (both due to living next to a superpower, and having to integrate the lot of enslaved, former slaves, deserters, etc. as part of their people), having to stress a militarized identity
One the other hand, Gaulish entities were more or less stable as far as we can tell since the Vth century : it's quite possible (if not likely) that the Gaulish civitates were formed trough warfare (either conquest or alliance) but after the IIIrd century and the (likely) Danubian groups settling and forming Belgians/Belgicized ensemble, you really have to wait for Cimbri and Teutoni to disturb the political and social frames, and essentially on the Rhineland.
I tried the best I could, which doesn't says much, to make a picture with big brushes of Gaulish political identities there. I didn't covered too much tribes there, because frankly, there's not much to say apart "they probably existed, and might have played an immediate role of delegation and execution in a small group of peoples" and they're seldom mentioned (although decades of fighting off "tribes" to name Gaulish peoples might have ended with an omnipresent "people").
Overall, central Celtic state seem to have the bearing of ancient statecrafts comparable to archaic or classical (if not Hellenistic) Greece, especially when it come to Aedui and their coalition. There's no doubt that warfare kept being an important, if not the most important (aristocratisation of Gaulish society being really apparent from the IInd century onward) factor of social and cultural identity (would it be only because the Gaulish assemblies were assemblies "in arms"), but when Dumnorix, Vercingetorix or Orgoterix raised an armed clientele (soldures) they're not creating peoples or new social identities within Aedui, Arverni or Helvetii, but structure their political faction with private following and clientele (something that wasn't that hugely different in Republican Rome.This factor in the identity, and political identity, giving its form, but as a social phenomenon, might not define what was the Gaulish early state structure (up to a point, we know that Suessions outright killed their senate when they refused to go to war).You're right that pagi, and maybe tribes, were mostly recognizable by the Ist century as forming army groups and units, but it might rather be what remained of their autonomy and identity, and not what defined them entierely as groups in an, largely unattested, original state (although it would certainly stress that warring, even as a reduced and autonomous state, was always particularly important to define them).
Essentially, at least a good part of Gaulish entities seems to have changed from complex chiefdom-like to state-like entities by the time of the conquest), something that ironically hastened their absorption within the Roman state, and their survival (while utterly changed trough romanisation) into modern names. If Parisii were defined mostly trough a warrior aristocratic identity, I'm not sure it would have survived as an identity trough five centuries of heavy romanization. In continental Europe, apart from Franks (and thanks to an illusion of continuity there, and a tireless historiographic work), Barbarian identities didn't had such fortune.
^(1) La Celtique Méditerranéenne. Habitats et sociétés en Languedoc et en Provence VIIIè-IIè siècles avant J.-C.; Dominique Garcia; 2014
^(2) Arguably, not everywhere : some peoples traditionally understood as being Belgians, didn't have a central oppidum before the Augustean period and British people, otherwise quite close from Gauls, didn't underwent the construction of proto-agglomerations before the Ist century AD maybe as a reaction against Roman presence.
^(3) La Politique des Gaulois - Vie politique et institutions en Gaule chevelue (IIè siècle avant notre ère - 70); Emmanuel Arbabe; 2017. He notably compares the assemblies as the expression of a Gaulish equivalent to high-kingship for the whole of Gaul, Belgica, probably Armorica, maybe Celtica.
^(4) Cadurcoi, Petrocorii, Salyes (IMO), Aquitani, Andecavi, Ambiani, Helvetii (sort of), Albigenses, Morini, Menapii, ...