r/btc•
Metallaxis

"What's the difference between BTC and BCH? Why is BCH so much cheaper?" - Help me find an effective way to educate newcomers.

This in not an actual question on my part. It is a question I have been asked a few times by people in local.bitcoin, and I was struggling to come up with as short an answer as possible, but at the same time informative and comprehensive for new people (After all, one of the reasons I am in there is to try to educate new people).

The last time I was asked, here's what I came up with. I know its long and rough, so I'd like your help to streamline a standard response. Please contribute. What would you omit / add / rephrase to educate a person that seems to have no idea but is interested enough to ask?

OK, that’s a long story, but if you bear with me, I’ll do my best to explain. Whenever I state personal opinion rather than facts, I will enclose it in - - so treat it with skepticism.

At the beginning, there was bitcoin. Because bitcoin is open source code, anyone could duplicate its code (not the actual coins mind you), change it and create a new cryptocurrency from scratch.

Of course, not all cryptocurrencies that were created had any value, some were just for fun. But some that had good and desirable features (like anonymity, ability for smart contracts or better speed) were valued by people at different prices...

The way each coin gets its price is exactly the same as national currencies like USD and Euro get their exchange rates:

By the free market, through supply and demand. In exchanges, people can buy/sell currencies for other currencies. If a particular one is more bought than sold in comparison to another one, its price rises.

In cryptocurrency space, bitcoin was always the one that was valued the most -because its first mover advantage, which gave it a substantially larger user base-. Also, most of the infrastructure like payment processors, wallets, online exchanges etc were built primarily around it. -Another reason might be that, people that are new to this, only know about the name bitcoin and nothing more, so that's where they invest.-

At some point in 2017, the bitcoin community was divided over the course that bitcoin was taking: Given technical details, bitcoin was limited to processing a maximum of 7 transactions per second worldwide.

Some people thought that this was desirable and that the capacity should not be increased, although the transactions were steadily increasing and the limit was being reached. In that case, they argued, a fee market should naturally arise, where the transactions that paid the larger fees would be the ones that would get processed first. This was the "few transactions, high fees" camp.

Other people thought that the capacity should be increased to account for the increased demand, believing that high fees for transacting would stifle the adoption that was needed for bitcoin to succeed. This was the "Many transactions, low fees camp"

There is more technical detail in these views, this is just short history briefing. If you want, I can provide you with links to people articulating their reasons and opinions for each side.

Anyway, because there was a standstill, the original bitcoin was split in two, and people of different philosophies followed their favorite version.

The "few transactions, high fees" camp is the BTC camp.

The "many transactions, low fees" camp is the BCH camp.

Through exchanges, these two coins got their respective values of today.

One important note: For the capacity to be increased, there had to be a change in the software. So many thought that the "unchanged" software was the original bitcoin, while the "changed software" was not bitcoin. Add to that the fact that most infrastructure, especially online exchanges did not change their software, so the coin that kept being traded and used in them was the unchanged one.

-That's why most people kept treating BTC as the original bitcoin.-

-This, in my opinion, it is the only thing that currently supports the high price of BTC, the fact that it is treated as "the only bitcoin", and people new to this do not know any better.-

-If you want my perspective, there is no "real bitcoin", in the same way that when a highway splits towards two different destinations, two new roads are created, none of which is "the real highway"-

The fact remains that both coins share the same history up to the split, so whichever (if any) is "the real bitcoin" is up to your interpretation.

-It is my opinion that BCH is a far superior bitcoin, and when more people realize it and start using it, this should be reflected in its price.-

For instance, the fees in BTC are such right now, that making a transaction like we just did (of $40) -does not make much sense-, because: To send you $40 in BTC I have to pay approx. $2 in fees, so you will receive $38. But if you want to use them, you will have to pay the fees also, making your BTC worth $36, and it goes on like this...

Keep in mind, the $2 in fees is just an estimation based on current usage and that fees are independent of the value transferred, they are not a percentage. They actually depend on the size in bytes of the broadcasted transaction. The numbers I am giving you are for minimum sized (in bytes) transactions. Depending on usage and how much money people are willing to pay for their transaction to be processed, fees can be arbitrarily high. Back in December of 2017, they were as high as $40.

Posted Sep 16, 2019, 2:21 PM UTC

2468
MobTwo•

Better Security – BTC has a vulnerability called RBF which increases the risk of double spending. Bitcoin Cash developers aim to make 0-confirmation transactions safe again so that anyone accepting Bitcoin Cash is much safer accepting payments without having to wait for multiple confirmations.

Improved Scalability – BTC is limited to 1MB block size and even with Segwit activated, the capacity increase is only around 1.7x whereas the upgraded Bitcoin Cash blocks capacity is currently at 32x with no limitations. This means Bitcoin Cash can handle PayPal transactions volume today and be global money after a few more upgrades.

Supply Scarcity – During the fork from Bitcoin, some Bitcoin Cash supply were removed from active circulation due to users unable to claim their Bitcoin Cash from unsupported exchanges and wallets among other reasons. This means each Bitcoin Cash is actually more scarce than BTC.

Improved Confirmation Times – Due to the limited block size of BTC, some users were made to wait days for their transactions to be confirmed. Contrast this to Bitcoin Cash where transactions may be accepted immediately with less risk and you can see why it makes sense to use Bitcoin Cash. In other words, if you are a shop owner and you just sold a cup of coffee and some sandwiches, and you accept the old BTC, you may have to wait hours for the transaction to be confirmed because the customer may use RBF to void the original payment. With Bitcoin Cash, your risk is minimized.

Low Fees – One of the advantages of using cryptocurrencies over traditional payment methods is the low fees. Due to the limited block size of BTC, fees have exceeded over $70/transaction during peak period. On the other hand, I have never paid more than 1 penny/transaction during my entire time in using Bitcoin Cash. This makes using Bitcoin Cash ideal for merchants, businesses, companies and everyday usage. The industries that may be disrupted such as Remittances, Payment Gateways, etc are worth trillions of dollars and Bitcoin Cash is well positioned for use cases in these industries.

Tokens - Bitcoin Cash has tokens to start taking some marketshare from Ethereum. You can get some free tokens by joining the discord chat at 1BCH.com

Better Privacy - Bitcoin Cash has better privacy than BTC thanks to CashShuffle. You can enable it through the setting in the Electron Cash wallet and it's completely optional. If you don't want others to know how you spent your money, it is better to use Bitcoin Cash over BTC.

Better Risk/Reward - If BTC gains another 250 billion marketcap, it only 2x in price. But that same 250 billion will 40x your Bitcoin Cash investments. It is such a smarter option.

At the moment, the old BTC has network effects advantages just like how Friendster used to dominate the social networking space. Since Bitcoin Cash was only out for 2 years, it would remain to be seen how much time would be needed to play catch up. It took Facebook years to catch up to Friendster’s dominance back then and it may take Bitcoin Cash just as long to achieve the same.

20
MetallaxisOP•

Thank you for your input. Some of your points are good additions. The problem in my view regarding some other of your points is that newcomers have no idea what a "block" is, or what a "confirmation" means, let alone "RBF" and "0-conf"!

Most newcomers imagine cryptocurrencies like digital money, like gold and silver in an RPG game server, nothing more. Plus, it takes a while for someone to understand that to have crypto, you don't have to create an "account" in the "official bitcoin website".

After some trades, when I see they are complete noobs, I take my time to explain that if they lose their keys, nobody can help them regain them, because if someone could, that would mean that this someone had custodial control of their money and not them. So we are talking basic stuff here...

In order to give them an idea of what's going on, one must speak in much simpler terms, and also try not to sound one sided, cause even if everything you say might be true, remember that the person has no idea, and thus has little ability to confirm what you are saying. So it's a matter of building trust. They must first feel that you are not pushing them towards your opinion, but you are just by their side trying to explain.

5
MobTwo•

I agree with you on making things simple to understand. When I meet people and tell them about Bitcoin Cash, I just explain to them some examples of what cryptocurrencies can do which traditional fiat monetary system had problems with (eg. hyperinflation, inflation, micropayments, tokens, dividends, etc)

That way they have a reference point from which to understand.

3
Odbdb•

This is when the discussion needs to be steered towards things like trustless transactions, anti censorship, and solving the Byzantine Generals Dilemma. These were things often discussed in r/bitcoin long before blockstream.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Obscure_BuffaloRedditor for less than 6 months•

I use RBF on BCH, you just need a Gameshark

1
jgun83•

Only an insane person would describe BCH as more secure than BTC. By what objective metric?

-4
phillipsjk•

Improved 0-conf.

The lighting network is a rube-Goldberg contraption with many security pitfalls that have led to lost funds.

7
jgun83•

Yes, the only lost funds in BCH are those that you're holding.

-7
phillipsjk•

Good thing it can be used for things other than Hodling then, isn't it?

8
phillipsjk•

Just the fact the users know there was a split is a victory, given the amount of censorship in the space.

My short version may be:

BCH split from BTC in 2017 because BTC was unable to scale to meet demand.

...Unfortunately, that does not explain why BTC has a higher price than BCH today.

18

Sometimes people just want some things to be more expensive to make it seem like it's "better"

You can do it with anything that has brand power

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5†
mars128Redditor for less than 60 days•

Tether.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
nighthawk24•

Might need further investigation as the volume includes BCH folks selling for USDT to invest in other tokens.

3
[deleted]•

No, it isnt fair to say based on a single biased datapoint from one exchange with no time frame.

3
[deleted]•

Yeah...ultimately there just isn't really a "short version". Bitcoin's history is long and twisted, parts of that history don't make sense without the rest for context. I've been paying eager attention to this space for over 5 years and still barely feel like I know what the hell is going on half the time.

In this instance, it isn't because BTC couldn't scale to meet demand, BCH split because a hostile group took over and blocked that scaling in place of their own bizarre roadmap no one agreed with but the Blockstreamers.

4
nevermark•

BTC/“Bitcoin” is more valuable because it retained the names with the best branding after the split.

The more scalable branch was refounded with the new names BCH/“Bitcoin Cash”. This reflected new development arrangements, even though the new branch retained a more traditional vision of the tech.

It is common in tech and commerce, and especially in things considered valuable, that branding means more than many objective features.

It is economically rational for (most) everyone to want the thing that (most) everyone else wants, to be assured that they will get a good return when they resell it.

Branding is an important, albeit self-fulfilling, feature.

3
500239 •

Simple really.

This is meant for regular Joes who don't know what a blockchain is, what Lightning or Segwit are and who Blockstream is:

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

Bitcoin got popular and there was as disagreement in the Bitcoin development team on how to scale. 2 paths were taken. 5 years later Bitcoin has high fees due to sticking with it's unproven and untested wild approach, and Bitcoin Cash has low fees because it's scaling approach was straight forward and simple.

However since Bitcoin Cash only has existed for 2 years, it's value is lower as Bitcoin retained the original name and ticker.

Even better I would explain the 2 Bitcoin chains using some real world example where a team had irreconcilable differences that caused a split. Don't know a mainstream one off the top off my head, but I would look at common Joe topics like sports or cars as that will connect better.

9
lubokkanev•

The BCH brand exists since 2017, the BCH chain exists since 2009.

13
500239 •

true, that's even simpler.

I would however mention the reason why BCH exists and mention today's fee costs on both chains. A real example works better than any explanation.

3
capistor•

I think it's more about rent-seeking than a disagreement. an attempt to manipulate and add fees to a permissionless network.

1
500239 •

but Blockstream doesn't gain from Bitcoin's high fees. They took control over Bitcoin Core and the high fees keep miners attracted to Bitcoin as a side effect. No miner is going to leave this sweet gig no matter how corrupt Core is.

1
capistor•

idk that blockstream has to turn a profit when they get funded by axa. I think they just have to shove a wrench in the bike spokes.

1
500239 •

basicaly, but if they can also sell their Liquid service then they can do both.

1
Totalsense•

I'm sure this will get downvoted, but my explanation is simpler.

BTC is for day traders and speculators, BCH is for real world use.

6
wtfrelalyRedditor for less than 30 days•

Don't overcomplicate. "BCH is better. It's cheaper because it's newer."

6
BoooksOnBooksOnBooksRedditor for less than 60 days•

The quickest answer I can give is this:

The Bitcoin (btc) GitHub repo was hijacked by Greg Maxwell, Adam Back and their company Blockstream, with the goal of restricting the usefulness of BTC inorder to push their own affiliated products, "Liquid BTC", Lightning "2nd layer" Network and others.

5
E7ernal•

Don't ever answer that question for them. Give them the information and then ask them. If they can't figure it out, then you reveal, "looks to me like it's undervalued and a great investment opportunity."

3
MetallaxisOP•

Good point, thanks. Although, most of the time it not going to be a two way discussion, so I need to say everything that needs to be said in one go :)

3
shazvaz•

BTC is an original piece of artwork, a Mona Lisa. Over time it has been damaged, pieces scuffed, colors faded. Nonetheless it is valuable and sought after - for it's scarcity as well as its history. BCH on the other hand is a high quality print, a perfect copy which has been touched up and color corrected. It is better than the original in every way, and yet it will never be the original. In Bitcoin a majority of hashpower determines which chain is legitimate, which chain represents true digital scarcity, which chain is Bitcoin. Without majority pow a blockchain isn't Bitcoin but simply an altcoin, a copy of a digital asset which is inherently uncopiable. Many people look at the two pieces of art and can't understand why the authentic version commands such a high price, while the objectively better print is sold for pennies on the dollar. These people are sure that eventually the world will recognize that the technically superior print should be worth more, so they buy more and more. They laugh at the real collectors bidding at auction on the originals. This is the nature of every debate between Bitcoin and altcoins.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tl121•

This argument holds no water. The changes from pre split bitcoin to the present BCH are much less than the changes from pre split bitcoin to the present BTC. BTC has different design goals than the pre split bitcoin and a fundamentally different protocol, namely Segwit, which no longer follows the design outlined in the white paper. There is no question about different design goals, as the developers of BTC call it a "store of value" while BCH continues as an electronic cash system as per the title of the whitepaper.

1
[deleted]•

"To send you $40 in BTC I have to pay approx. $2 in fees,"

What on God's earth are you using? It's more like $0.19 for a transaction.

https://bitcoinfees.net/

2†
MetallaxisOP•

Today, not when I made the particular trade. When I made the trade it was approx. $1.6 for next block if I remember correctly.

7
Rishodi•

My most recent BTC transaction cost me the equivalent of $0.03 in transaction fees.

-2†
Alexpander•

Mine was 30$

4
Rishodi•

Get a different wallet or manually set the fee, because unless you were sending a transaction with hundreds of inputs your wallet overestimated the fee for you.

2
phillipsjk•

"Most recent" could have been 2017.

2
Alexpander•

did you edit your first comment?

1
Odbdb•

If someone is buying bitcoin and asks “what’s the deal with two (or more) bitcoins” they need to be told to do more research in their investments before they execute.

2
nighthawk24•

BCH also has multiple implementations that avoid a bitcoin-core style take over of the project by 3 Blockstream and 3 Chaincode Labs developers.

2
capistor•

banks bought control of bitcoin discussion forums /bitcoin and bitcoin talk, most likely through axa insurance giant who has the most derivitaves on its books and the most to lose if fraud is no longer the status quo in finance. then any discussion of the planned scaling was censored. after a period of time some bitcoiners forked off.

1
mqpickens•

BCH has flawless leadership; it has it will win!

0†
jgun83•

Anything with "leadership" is doomed to fail.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
unitedstatian•

tl;dr ELI12 because the market prices are purely speculative and not based on real demand

0
Xlren•

Why buy btc or bch when you could have btc gold, sv and diamond for much cheaper?

-3
BsvAlertBotRedditor for less than 60 days•

​ ​

u/Xlren's history shows a questionable level of activity in BSV-related subreddits:

BCH %BSV %
Comments50.0%50.0%
Karma50.0%50.0%

​


^(This bot tracks and alerts on users that frequent BCH related subreddits yet show a high level of BSV activity over 90 days/1000 posts. This data is purely informational intended only to raise reader awareness. It is recommended to investigate and verify this user's post history.) ^(Feedback)

1
Mr_Again•

Bots like this show a questionable level of groupthink

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Xlren•

Yeah but its not bitcoin

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
MobTwo•

Can't help it, people tend to ask the same questions. I try to be productive with my time rather than being busy.

13
Alexpander•

But what if it’s true, new redditor?

1
stos313•

Prices are determined on supply and demand. There is less demand for BCH, while their supply is the same.

Go ahead and give noobs your "satoshi's vision rant," and Bilderberg conspiracy theories after that- but any explanation that doesn't start with the simple truths of the economics behind it could potentially be misleading.

-6
MetallaxisOP•

I am guessing you did not read where I literally described supply and demand first thing after explaining open source and altcoins.

So feel free to assume what I say to newcomers, but it's not much work to actually read for yourself before writing your generic "one size fits all" response.

5
stos313•

I am guessing you did not read where I literally described supply and demand first thing after explaining open source and altcoins.

Nah. tl. dr.

-2
MetallaxisOP•

So what the f**k are you commenting about? About what you imagine I said? What a moron...

7
stos313•

Calm down there cowboy. I just commented on your title. If I’m not allowed to do that in this sub, then I’m humbly apologize for disrupting this otherwise amazing circle jerk. (This sub not your post)

-3
Alexpander•

Idiot

1
stos313•

Such a deep and well thought out response!

1
MrRGnome•

Stop lying to new users. What is and isn't bitcoin isn't a matter of interpretation, it is defined by network consensus.

The lengths people in this community will go to casting doubt about what is the "real" bitcoin. Why can't you just promote yourself without trying to pretend you're bitcoin like every other alt? Then we'd have no problem.

-7
[deleted]•

FYI this piece of lying shit is a moderator of /bitcoin who promotes censorship and gaslighting and helped hijack that sub and Bitcoin

tl;dr u/MrRGnome fuck you

10
MetallaxisOP•

I respect your point of view, but at some stage you need to try to understand the opposite point of view also.

I believe it is clear as day that I go out of my way to explain my honest point of view to new users, and also make extra effort not to conflate the facts I present with my opinions, while at the same time giving my opinion, explicitly stated as such.

So no, if anything, I reject your accusation that I'm lying.

If you are honest, you should at least try to do the same, if only for yourself, to put facts in one basket, and your opinions, like that " What is and isn't bitcoin isn't a matter of interpretation, it is defined by network consensus." in another.

Let's run this thought experiment: Say BCH at some point overtakes BTC in cumulative POW. What will be bitcoin then? I am not claiming that it will be BCH, just stating that according to your own definition, to which I do not ascribe, BCH will be bitcoin and BTC not.

In my view, both BTC and BCH are descendants of the same pre-fork coin, and discussing which has a particular label is as non-sensical as discussing which one is the true "dinosaur", the birds or the reptiles.

7
MrRGnome•

That nakamoto consensus defines bitcoin isn't an opinion, it's literally a fact of how bitcoin functions. There is a method of deciding which chain is bitcoin built into the protocol. Conflating facts with opinion is the sole reason you feel justified in saying things that are factually untrue and which I have called "lies". That you think these things are opinions when they are in fact simply false statements doesn't make them not lies.

You have a dozen reasons to promote BCH. It's less likely to have a full mempool and has more 0 conf support than peers for example. Trying to suggest it is the "real" bitcoin is so unnecessary and dishonest and leads to genuine victims trying to use BCH with BTC addresses. Please just stick to the facts, your "opinions" are harming people.

-8
MetallaxisOP•

That nakamoto consensus defines bitcoin isn't an opinion, it's literally a fact of how bitcoin functions

FACT: The nakamoto consensus is about deciding between chains that follow the same rule-set, but happened because of two miners mining two valid but mutually exclusive blocks, and other miners randomly building upon one of two said blocks.

FACT: Nakamoto consensus says NOTHING about chains of conflicting rule-sets. Are you sure you are referring to facts and not your opinion?

OPINION: The term "Nakamoto consensus" is kinda made up during the last year or so to sound "like we know what we are talking about, we are referencing something well known" when in fact most often than not is severely misrepresented, like in your comment above

​

Trying to suggest it is the "real" bitcoin

Are you even reading what I am saying? I never claimed that. What I claimed is that the term "the real bitcoin" is non sensical. You are welcome to disagree, but do not read into my statements your preconceptions about this community.

​

Edit addendum: Case in fact about "Nakamoto consensus": People running the core client followed the core rule-set regardless of the POW behind blocks found in the ABC side. Their clients did not check POW, they just rejected the conflicting block. In the same way, exchanges CHOSE to run the core client and thus followed the core chain. This was a political choice, not something dictated by software consensus, it was a choice of which client to use.

10
MrRGnome•

When you create a new conflicting ruleset creating a minority network that's a fork. FACT. BCH is an altcoin fork of Bitcoin. FACT. BCH has a fraction of the accumulated PoW as bitcoin. FACT. Users are regularly harmed by the obscurity you attempt to create between BCH and BTC by calling BCH "Bitcoin". FACT.

Stop lying, stop causing harm to other users. Just stop. If you can't promote BCH based on its own merit and instead need to engage in predatory behavior against potential new Bitcoin users it reflects pretty poorly on both you and this community.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Alexpander•

Who are you to set the condition for what Bitcoin is??? Bitcoin is a p2p electronic cash system, defined by its very creator. What is BTC? It’s a store of value.

1
MrRGnome•

Who are you to set the condition for what Bitcoin is?

I don't, the network does.

Bitcoin is a p2p electronic cash system

Who are you to set the condition for what Bitcoin is?

defined by its very creator

It is defined as the longest accumulative PoW by the creator, which is BTC.

1
Tai9chRedditor for less than 60 days•

Walmart sells several brands of kleenex. Monero is a neat bitcoin with privacy protections.

-3
MrRGnome•

No they don't. There is literally one brand of kleenex by law. No other tissue box will have that word on it in an American walmart, ever.

You just made my exact point for me.

3
Tai9chRedditor for less than 60 days•

Ahh, but in the bitcoin case there's no trademark. Just a spec that no existing coin conforms to.

8
MrRGnome•

In bitcoin there is nakamoto consensus and a BIP process defining bitcoin, which is the spec bitcoin conforms to. Bitcoin isn't the white paper, the white paper was the origin point and nakamoto consensus and the BIP process outline how the network state transforms from the origin.

Bitcoin thus absolutely conforms to the Bitcoin specification, where as BCH does not for failing nakamoto consensus and not being the most PoW chain.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
500239 •

there's no trade mark on Bitcoin. Remember when Matt Corallo cried to the SEC? They don't even care lol

go read up on trademarks idiot before pushing your drivel.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1