Aren't eidolons spawned by primordials too weak?

Come on, Valve. Buff these guys a bit, or they act just like charging mana for enemy. Also brawnies are gratified to see that.

Posted Oct 7, 2019, 6:56 AM UTC

9829
Tann1k•

I think their whole deal is to buy you a little more time early in the game with mages, don't think they are supposed to really do much. Could use a buff for sure though.

39
DaiWales•

Primordial distribution is 1, 1, 2, 4, 5.

If you can only complete the second tier with high-end units, that second tier should be stronger imo.

35
Eire_Ramza•

This. Razor is just overall a very lack luster unit that falls off quick (albeit that can be said about a lot of 1 cost units), even in mage comps razor is fairly weak. Tiny is excellent but has much more usefulness outside of committing to primordial. Same goes with morph, in a primordial mage build he can do very well especially at 2 stars but if not going into assassins I again feel he brings little to the table and gets sold off fast. So basically early primordials are fairly bad units outside of their own main alliance/effectiveness. Which basically means early to mid game primordial feels weak, and with the majority of the units falling into the 1 and 2 cost range that do better in other comps it feels wack. Enigma and arc warden are excellent units but later in the game I doubt anyone picks them up for their primordial alliance as at that stage in the game primordial doesn't seem relevant.

As it stands primordial feels like an alliance you never really want to go into purposely, early game I'd much rather savages or druids or warriors etc, and later in the game primordial just feels useless. So to me it's in a weird position. I'm sure there are some strong primordial builds using mages and assassins etc but I doubt the main power comes from the primordial alliance, and unless the shop is throwing nothing but primordial at me I am never going into that alliance on purpose.

10
lllkill•

Razor is literally the worst 3 star. A big mana trashcan that can never get pas 1k dmg.

14
TwinkleTwinkleBaby•

Ehhh but on the other hand the 4 and 5 are very strong units. You can plug and play them into almost any comp, especially arc warden. Also as a bonus their secondary alliances match each other.

1
Soph1993ita•

with summoning stone gone they could use a buff. not every alliance need to be strong enough to base a team around it, and primordials would be quite awkward since they do their thing on death.

So far they seem to be decent at making you gain a bit more time when you use them as a frontline and provide some early game for assasins and mages build.Could definitely get buffed a little

22
Dirst•

Units take a moment to find new targets, so the eidolons actually tank more than you might think. Especially noticeable with a stacked Slark. Still not great though. I hope they get a rework in the big update, cuz eidolons are sort of boring.

Idea, what if all primordials were really shit, and eidolons were mega shit, but when a primordial dies, it spawns again as a 1 star lower variant of itself 1/2 times. So you kill Tiny3 and a Tiny2 pops out. And just balance their numbers to not be broken.

20
Soph1993ita•

spawning a lower star version of yourself is just too hilarious to not ask it to be in the game.i like your idea so much.

it's gonna be a bit hard to balance however: normal units double their health when upgraded, but even if you make tiny 2 stars have the same health pool as tiny 1 star the primordial spawn is already making you fight through 2x its hp.i am sure there is gonna be a way to make it work, such as the primordial alliance level determining the health of the spawned unit.

19
DetourDunnDee•

3* Arc Warden would give everyone PTSD.

14
Xavori•

roflmao

So you start with 2 3* Arcs. The clone dies which leads to 2 3* Arcs plus 2 2* Arcs. Another 3* clone dies along with a 2*. You now have 2 3*, 2 2*, and 2 1* Arcs.

Pretty sure even a 3* Luna with MoM isn't chewing through just that one unit...

6
BigSpicyMeatball•

[flashbacks to pre-rework refresher+CM Arc Warden]

Actually, on second thought, that makes me want this more

2
photofluid•

Maybe an effective lower star copy rather than a lower star copy.

With 2 alliance it is a quarter of health and attack, with 4 it is a half.

2
Haydezzz•

theyre probably trying to balance the game in relation to the new patch. i dont think we can comprehend those changes yet

7
get_ketoned•

I agree. Especially after seeing the change to Savages, it seems clear that there are a few new heroes/alliances about to be released that they feel the need to balance around. The unfortunate result is that the number of dead alliances is at an all time high.

3
zody0•

Definitely, currently they just food for beastmaster

Whenever I am going hunter brawny and I see dem primordials I am just like bon appetit

6
DrakeRowanGay for Axe•

Primordials are great for cheesing a potential draw into a win.


Your active Primordial unit, your last unit, is killed at the same time as the last unit of the opponent's (a non-Primordial, unit of course). Congratulations, your little guy spawns, and the opponent is without a unit. You win.

3
blade_angleOP•

Yes, but this mechanism is actually not good during the first 10 rounds, since your opponents will have a free roll, as well as not lose their health points.

4
Eire_Ramza•

Primordial does feel like a fairly useless alliance to be honest, the ability is just very lack luster and I feel like they should expand on it more. "Spawn a little dude when your dead" is just such a shitty ability imo. There are times where the eidolons might hedge you out a lucky win here and there but think of all the times on the contrary that the eidolons just amount to basically nothing.

2
JWBSS•

They're literally useless.

2
joaocozinha•

As units, they are weak, but in fact, i lost the count of times they won a round for me, so I have nothing to complain about.

1
GodLikeKillerX•

Maybe they should explode on death dealing a ministun or slow and maybe around 100/200 magic damage.

1
Stack_ManModerator•

I find that 1* eidolons are weak, but 2* eidolons are a power spike like no other.

The fall off again during the late game though.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
papakahn94•

Honestly i think primordials need a revamp period

1
_tpyo•

FWIW helm is pretty baller on primordials because even if you draw, you win as the eidolon pops out at the end and gives you the win.

0
Catobleppa•

As far as i know helm units count as alive for deciding the winner, the only way to drow is if your helm expires as the attack is going out. they just don't count towards round damage

2
lightgray03•

Won't it be great if primordial dies and their items carry over to their eidolons? I think it would give them some edge by mid-late game

0
zlandar•

WTB SS.

-1
InfiniteTooth•

Eidolons should revive unit when not killed within x seconds

-1†