oojacoboo•

Great decision given the new information. It’s not easy to set aside your baby in light of new information like this, but it’s the right move and shows serious professionalism.

42
Emul0rdLuckyNano.com - Faucet - Casino - Rep :redditgold:•

Better be safe than sorry, good call on delaying the new algorithm.

40
JoohanssonCommunity Manager | :n3:Links•

Phase 2: VXX.X release
So that means it will come with V99.9 as the latest? That's great news =)

Seriously though, agree it was a good call to delay. Thank you John Tromp.

21
NanoYoBusiness•

Great update. I appreciate the way you guys are always transparent and forthcoming. This is why my faith in this team is so strong. They just never stop working, and are constantly grinding. I look forward to the day when Nano gets the respect it deserves from the rest of the crypto community.

31
zergtoshi•

That!
Once more I relish the transparency and professionalism in awe-stricken silence.

Thank you, /u/tromp, for your invaluable feedback!

10
mlgoodynanoyobusiness•

So, it reads like the team is optimistic about solving the concerns posed by Tromp and production the new NanoPOW?

19
mekane84•

Well worse case they can just use one of the existing memory hard PoW mechanisms, which I think would still be an improvement. the idea being that our normal devices (phone / desktop) can compute the PoW with similar efficiently as ASICs.

6
QwahziFreeNanoFaucet.com•

I think that's part of the challenge though. A PoW algorithm that works roughly the same on phones and ASICs doesn't really exist yet. Even the initial Nano PoW implementation didn't help that issue much. GPUs have a significant advantage over CPU, and HBM has a little advantage over consumer memory

5
PlasmaPower•

That was never the goal of Nano PoW AFAIK. The proposed algorithm made the gap between CPUs and GPUs a lot larger, and while I haven't benchmarked it on a phone, I'd expect the gap there to grow even more, due to the low memory on most phones.

My understanding of the goal of Nano PoW is to bring down the maximum performance of a miner (i.e. ASICs), which doesn't necessarily mean making low-end devices like phones perform as well as medium-high end devices like GPUs, and may even widen that gap.

7
QwahziFreeNanoFaucet.com•

Thanks for the clarification!

My philosophical question in that case is, "With no transaction fees to be earned, does anyone actually have a significant financial incentive to develop an ASIC for Nano?" A theoretical bad actor would have to spend millions on ASIC development, only for a chance at disrupting Nano. Particularly since transaction prioritization already exists with dynamic PoW

That being said, since most "commercial" implementations already require a GPU, I'd guess that Nano PoW would be a net positive in most scenarios.

EDIT:

My one other concern is that increasing the PoW costs for service providers will incentivize them to pass the cost on to their users in the form of fees, thereby degrading the user experience

5
shamo42•

Most phones have around 4GB of shared memory. Flagship phones up to 12GB. I'm not sure about speed but the amount shouldn't be a problem.

Personally I don't understand why not more focus is put on phones. If adoption ever happens and most of the POW has to be delegated, the Distributed PoW systems won't be able to keep up anymore.

Or it will simply cost too much for wallet providers like Natrium which means transactions won't be able to stay free anymore.

A solution would be for wallet apps to be able to generate POW in a couple of seconds and only use Distributed PoW systems for slower phones or special circumstances.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

-6†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
[deleted]•

[removed]

4†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1†
sneaky-rabbit•

Thanks Tromp and PlasmaPower! So glad NANO is able to attract so many smart people. Let's us improve the world together!! Go NANO!!

12
bundsslongtime hodler•

Awesome as always guys! Thank you for the info!

4
n1231231231231235•

the fact that the foundation's work attracts such feedback and that they accept it and work it in the manner described - that really shows that Nano has become a vibrant open source project. great trajectory!

4
Paolo6153•

When a new Exchange !?

3†
FantasyGilbert•

Just today!

9
OberstWeltMeister•

POW MIA.. and that's okay for now

3
ThisGoldAintFree•

Great, thank you so much for the update.

2
sgtslaughterTV•

Can anyone give us an ELI5 explanation on what dynamic PoW means? I couldn't find a simplified explanation on Youtube or anywhere else for that matter.

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=what+is+dynamic+proof+of+work%3F

1
DotcomLOP:n1: Guilherme Lawless | Dev | DPoW•

It's a term only used in Nano and there is still a lack of explanatory video content in general. I will try to add an explanation to the docs though.

Dynamic PoW means simply the nodes using a different PoW difficulty threshold (formerly it was always static), in order to prioritize their transactions on the network (PoW prioritization).

So the nodes will spend more resources producing the proof in order to have their block prioritized.

1