Newbie searching split keyboard

I'm a total noob when it comes to mechanical keyboards.

I own Corsair k70, Microsoft Surface keyboard and Apple magic wireless 2

So, I'm searching for split keyboard, preferably, either low profile, or regular keys with shorter travel. Could put the switches, caps and so on together. However, do not want all in DIY-kit.

Help a newbie out

Posted Oct 19, 2019, 11:36 AM UTC

324
Schemik•

It depends what form factor and layout you want.

  • Fixed-split, or two separate halves.
  • Standard asymmetrical row-staggered layout, or proper columnar layout, or something else.
  • If you need a physical function row, arrow keys, number row etc.
  • ...

Also your budget.

2
fancyfruitOP•
  • Separate halves
  • I'm used to asymmetrical row-staggered layout, I suppose. How hard is it to accustom a symmetrical layout?
  • Ok, so an example; look at ErgoDox. The keys on the thumbs, I would like to have programmable, where i could press a key with one thumb to make, say [I,J,K,L] act as arrow keys, much like VIM.
  • Number row would be nice to have, because I often type special characters, like, ", /, %, etc.
  • Function keys would be appreciated as well
1
Schemik•

You can just go and buy a Kinesis Freestyle Pro.

It's on the cheaper end (under $200), works out of the box, has a more or less standard layout but split, and the SmartSet firmware allows quite user-friendly remapping&macros.

Mistel Barocco is very similar, except with a more limited firmware. The original is 60% (after Pok3r), but a 75% version is coming out now (MD770).

Other options will have a steeper learning curve (columnar layout), higher cost (usually $200-500) or require some assembly.

Here go some recommendations:

There's a list of readily available keyboards in the wiki.

Here's what I think about ErgoDox and why I don't recommend it anymore. (another comment in the thread documents Dactyl-Manuform)

This post covers various ergonomic aspects of keyboards.

3
fancyfruitOP•

The kinesis freestyle pro looks good, but I'm looking for more options at hand for the thumbs, not having to reach for the enter key, backspace and more.

Are there maybe non DIY keyboards or is it a must if you're looking for that, key for the thumbs, that is.

1
Schemik•

If you want a standard layout, but with more thumb keys,

  • the cheap SmartYao/Koolertron listed in the wiki exists (but has some technical issues like latency);
  • VE.A can be considered an improvement over Freestyle Pro (it's a very expensive custom, but there are cheaper Chinese clone kits, such as YMDK's on AliExpress);
  • Quefrency is another affordable DIY kit;
  • Matias Ergo Pro has a very interesting bottom row and other features (they've had quality problems, though);
  • UHK exists (although it's very expensive and has some questionable properties).

If you're fine with learning a columnar layout, see my linked posts, but notably:

  • Keyboardio M01 is fantastic and has a well-researched layout (expensive, though);
  • Dactyl-ManuForm is also fantastic and can be fully customized being a 3D printed DIY design (you can get it as a kit, or even assembled, but then it gets expensive);
  • Redox and ErgoDash are both quite decent improvements over ErgoDox and available as kits or assembled as well (e.g., from FalbaTech);
  • there are plenty of other mostly DIY kits, especially ones with very minimalist layouts.
1
StupidHumanSuitIris | UT47 | Launchpad x2•

The Ergodox and nearly every other split is fully programmable. Fn keys are worthless when any key can be an Fn key. QMK is amazing and allows you to do nearly anything you want with your keymap.

Ortholinear or columnal staggered boards are a revelation. No more finger contortions. It will take a bit to get back up to your normal typing speed, but the benefits far outweigh the effort required.

Stop being afraid of soldering. Hotswap is cool, but it adds cost and narrows down your options. You can find several open-source PCB files and have them printed yourself. The lily58 is, for me, a nearly perfect layout. There are several others like it.

2
fancyfruitOP•

It would be fun to try a column staggered board. Have a feeling I would appreciate it. The lily58 layout looks interesting. These layouts are just to get through DIY?

1
StupidHumanSuitIris | UT47 | Launchpad x2•

The lily58 is sold as a kit from a few different places that seem to be perpetually sold out, but they all require complete assembly by you, including soldering.

But don't let that deter you! I'd never soldered anything before I got into this hobby and now I've built half a dozen boards/macropads. It's fun!

1
PM_ME_A_SHOWER_BEERSplit Keeb Life•
1
Schemik•

That's not ultimate. It hasn't been updated for almost a year and doesn't provide any information about features/pricing/availability/..., it's just a pile of images with links.

Meanwhile, there's a curated list in the wiki with links to other resources, including the one you mention.

1
PM_ME_A_SHOWER_BEERSplit Keeb Life•

The wiki list is far less comprehensive, but sure

1
Schemik•

The wiki

  • doesn't list keyboards that you can't buy anywhere and deliberately excludes several bad products;
  • has been updated several times to include actually available products (e.g., compared to that github repo, it includes ErgoDash, newer Mistel Barocco versions);
  • provides some guidance and information about pricing/vendors, not just a list of random keyboards (many of which are one-off prototypes).

Xah Lee's website is much better than that list at github, even though I disagree with the author on many things.

1
fancyfruitOP•

I've looked at this list, but I'm still left with many questions.

1
ijauradunbi•

You can ask r/ErgoMechKeyboards.

But you can check gergo ready on zealpc.ca or kyria on splitkb.com / mkultra.click if you're in conus.

1