Move 'Personal Stats' under 'Stats' instead of 'Leaderboard'

Every time I look for my personal stats I click 'Stats' in the menu at the top of the web page - only to notice that this gets me the global stats. At which point I start poking around, looking for my personal stats.

Eventually, I find it: under 'Leaderboard'.

Wouldn't it be more plausible to have 'Personal Stats' under 'Stats'?

Posted Dec 8, 2019, 1:48 PM UTC

539
eatin_gushers•

Also, for those of us who don't start the puzzle at midnight, can you give us a stat for when we first opened the puzzle -> solved? Probably more difficult than absolute time, but I'd like to see it.

Obviously cheatable, but would be fun to see.

16
tim_vermeulen•

Additionally, I’d love to have this as an additional sorting order on private leaderboards. Some sort people might still cheat it, I guess, but just don’t look at the stat if you don’t trust the people in your private leaderboard.

5
forrestthewoods•

I love this idea.

1
zamansky•

Problem is, as an official measure it can be gamed - read the problem without logging in, do it, then submit (or even test on a secondary account).

2
forrestthewoods•

This would be a private personal stat, not a public leaderboard number. If someone wants to game a stat that only they can see that doesn't hurt anybody.

6
tim_vermeulen•

Well, it does “hurt” them in the sense that other people’s stats become less accurate, but of course nobody has anything to gain from this.

2
[deleted]•

I asked exactly this to him yesterday, this was his reply:

Doing this would generate extra writes to the database when everyone simultaneously loads their puzzle at midnight. (Or, it would require everyone to use the same browser to submit as they first read the puzzle, if I store the time client-side, which is also gross.) It would be trivial to trick either way, so I don't have any plans to support it.

1
daggerdragonMOD•

Pinged your suggestion to u/topaz2078.

4
liviuc•

They are still "Leaderboard Stats", so the placement seems ok. I will agree that it's somewhat annoying to have to do 2 clicks to get there. I just keep a separate tab open for these stats. And, for things not to get out of control, everything AoC stays in its own desktop/workspace.

1