r/xmen•
Cosmogenus

The Dark Phoenix movie seems more like a reinvention of Jean's comic origin than an adaptation of the Dark Phoenix Saga...

Jean’s not very villainous in the movie. Even in the “Making of Dark Phoenix” the cast and crew say that Jean is not a villain but traumatized. In many ways it mirrors her comic origin story but with some obvious changes.

In both the comic and the film Jean’s power manifest during a traumatic moment in her life, involving someone close to her dying in a car accident. In the comic its her childhood friend Annie Richardson. Jean was connected to her telepathically while she was dying and feeling all the emotions she felt . A special feature on X-Men: Apocalypse says that happened to Jean with her mother. So the was obviously taking inspiration from that.

In both versions Jean can’t shut off her telepathy due to being traumatized. She can’t stop herself from hearing the thoughts of others and feeling what they feel. She would lash out at people with her telekinesis when it would be too much for her. Just like Jean does throughout the movie, like this scene. Both versions also distance themselves from others.

Also, like in the movie Charles Xavier tries to help Jean with her powers and trauma. Difference is Charles erasing Jean’s memory of her traumatic experience is only suggested by her father and he doesn’t go through with it. Instead he just suppresses her powers like he does in X-Men: The Last Stand and helps her cope with her trauma. Movie Charles doesn’t do that because Wolverine showed him that doing that would cause Jean to become evil and they weren't going to make a movie about Jean going to therapy. So he does the opposite and erase her memory, which he has done in both the comics and films.

Both the comic and the film end with Jean overcoming her trauma and fear thanks to Charles' help.

It seems odd call the movie “Dark Phoenix” when there is no Dark Phoenix. It is really just "What if...Jean Grey became Phoenix when she was traumatized". Then again, they were originally going to call X-Men: Apocalypse "Age of Apocalypse" despite being based on the Horsemen storyline from X-Factor.

Posted Dec 8, 2019, 3:26 PM UTC · edited

95
amator7•

Agreed. Of course there’s an element from the Dark Phoenix, her realizing she’s been manipulated by Xavier and being manipulated currently (Hellfire Club in the comics which has already led to Jean being sexually abused and her attacking her friends and the aliens in the movie), but there’s no big breakdown like in the comics

3
CosmogenusOP•

her realizing she’s been manipulated by Xavier

I honest don't remember that. Which issue was this said?

1
amator7•

This is probably more of a point of view from Jean, but Xavier did block her powers when he was her “therapist” after Jean was traumatized by Annie’s death. Maybe it’s more of a head canon but I would assume that Jean as Dark Phoenix felt that he had been one of those people who did her wrong, and I don’t really think that he “only” blocked her powers.

1
SilentDuesOG•

The films did a kinda weird reverse-engineering of the Phoenix mythos in their adaptations. The Last Stand was basically their take on the Dark Phoenix Saga following the bit of X2 set-up, that was in the original timeline while the literal titled film Dark Phoenix (in spite of this marketing label) in the new timeline was more inspired by the initial Phoenix arc following the bit of Apocalypse set-up, that's how I look at it.

In the films' new timeline Charles' mental barriers for Jean aren't as severe as the original timeline, he only blocked select memories revolving around the accident of her parents and the direct aftermath, but he by no means suppressed her powers with the added effort of altering her broader memories of that. This is in major thanks to the insight from future-Logan and Xavier's own tremendous character growth in the diverging '73 events, he still had a difficult choice to make in "helping" Jean, but this time around it wasn't about blocking off the lionshare of her power and hiding the secrets of that from her (in turn leading to the insane split personality).

The Professor's choice in the new timeline leads to a different life for Jean, she's a naturally far more powerful person even when not tapping into her inner Phoenix potential (I don't view "the Cosmic-Force" in Dark Phoenix as that, simply instead a solar power enhancer that screwed with her mind), also she's still got a bit of that superiority complex her original timeline counterpart had in 1981 when Charles and Erik first met her. She's a much more socially awkward person and she may not even be on the road to becoming a Doctor like the first time 'round, people naturally fear her because of her power (possibly the only "Class-5/Omega-Level" Mutant besides Apocalypse), but at the same time she doesn't have any schizophrenic issues.

But yes in the end it was odd how Fox labeled the films directly focusing on Phoenix adaptations, in my opinion it would've made more sense to call the 2006 film X-Men 3: Dark Phoenix and the 2019 film X-Men: The Last Stand

1
CosmogenusOP•

I don't view "the Cosmic-Force" in Dark Phoenix as that, simply instead a solar power enhancer that screwed with her mind

All it really did was trigger Jean traumatic memories. She already had violent impulses, they were just buried in the back of her mind.

2