Any theories? Or was it already explicitly explained and I just missed/forgot it?
Cosmogenus
u/Cosmogenus
I recently reread the entire Dark Phoenix saga(all 38 issues) and the only major difference is that they changed the Hellfire Club to those random aliens(they were the Hellfire Club in an earlier version of the script). Otherwise it followed the beats of the original storyline.
Here is a brief comparison:
Comic:
-Jean gets cosmic power in space.
-Jean develops wild and less under control personality.
-Jean accidentally “kills” X-Men and is at her lowest.
-Hellfire Club takes advantage of Jean being at her lowest and manipulates her.
-Jean gets tricked into thinking her allies are her enemies.
-X-Men get captured and have power disabling collars placed on them.
-Jean turns on the



I know this happened in the pre-Claremont era but I can’t remember which issue.
I’ve seen a lot of people say they rushed to make Jean the Dark Phoenix but after recently rereading Uncanny X-Men #100-138 that isn’t really the case.
I’ll start off by saying that I’m sure most people here know that it was planned as a two-parter. But what a lot of people don’t know is that Chris Claremont told Popcorn Talk back in June the title of the films: Phoenix and Dark Phoenix He says first film was to build up Jean’s character and the second film would show her fall from grace.
I think it’s pretty clear that Fox cancelled the sequel and changed the first film’s title from “Phoenix” to “Dark Phoenix”. Because almost everything in that movie i
Dark Phoenix 40th-Anniversary Tribute: Comic Compared To Film (video essay script I want some feedback)
jimmy-o-face.tumblr.com/post/188601312147/dar...Kevin Feige asked Patrick Stewart to come back as Professor X but he said no due to Logan
digitalspy.com/movies/a30526782/x-men-marvel-...It’s frustrating how close we were to getting faithful adaptation to the original story.
It seems like they were trying to bring the plans for X3 on to the screen. Seems like Vuk’s role was originally meant for Emma. I imagine they would also have her and Shinobi try to get revenge on Magneto for killing Shaw.
This would also explain why Selene is in the movie.


