r/zen•
ewk

If you're one of the people who says, "I study what crossed from India to China, what passed from Huineng to Rinzai and Soto"

Why would you say "what Bodhidharma brought over" if you are a Buddhist?

  • Don't you know Buddhists lynched the 2nd Zen Patriarch?

Why would you say "what Huineng transmitted" if you believe in 4NT and 8FP?

  • Don't you know that Bodhidharma and his followers never taught those religious doctrines?

Why would you say "what Linji and Dongshan teach" if you believe in messiahs like Dogen and Hakuin?

  • Don't you know that Zen Masters reject practices like Dogen's Zazen prayer-meditation?
  • Don't you know that Zen Masters reject Hakuin's ritual question and answer certification?"

Why would you say Caodong or Soto if you've never studied Caodong?

  • Don't you know the teachings of Dongshan the founder, Hongzhi's Poems, and Wansong's book of instruction?

Why would you say Linji or Rinzai if you've never studied the Linji line?

  • Don't you study Huangbo, Linji's teacher, and books of instruction written by Linji's descendants Yuanwu and Wumen?

.

Welcome link; Meet ewk link; Note:

Why not be honest about what texts you chant, what beliefs you hold, and what historians have revealed about the sources of your religions?

Posted Dec 19, 2019, 8:35 AM UTC

325
CaseyAPayne•

What's the source for the lynching of the second patriarch? I've seen that referenced before.

Saving this post for reference. :)

3
ewkOP•

A Zen Master brought it up... I forget atm who...

2
RandomActOKindness•

I heard that while passing through a town, he heard a lecture by a local guru. Criticising the content, he attracted a crowd. The guru was upset enough to accuse him of blasphemy, and when asked for a defence, he offered his neck.

They killed him pretty much the same day, for formenting a political rebellion.

​

Its said about Huineng and Sengcan too.

2
ewkOP•

I've never found it anywhere in Zen texts except in reference to 2P.

2
[deleted]•

Same, I did find this excerpt in the Chinese Buddhist Encyclopedia:

In 579, Huike returned to Yedu and expounded the dharma, drawing large numbers to listen to his teachings and arousing the hostility of other Buddhist teachers, one of whom, Tao-heng, paid money to have Huike killed but Huike converted the would-be assassin.

The Wudeng Huiyan (Compendium of Five Lamps) compiled by Dachuan Lingyin Puji (1179-1253) claims that Huike lived to the age of one hundred seven. He was buried about forty kilometres east northeast of Anyang City in Hebei Province. Later, the Tang Dynasty emperor De Zong gave Huike the honorific name Dazu (“Great Ancestor”) >

Some traditions have it that Huike was executed after complaints about his teachings by influential Buddhist priests. One story says that blood did not flow from his decapitated body, but rather, a white milky substance flowed through his neck.

2
CaseyAPayne•

Ha… just ran into this from a link someone else shared…

Guole explains that this is indeed the place where the Second Ancestor’s remains were interred after his execution. According to the records, his teaching of Bodhidharma’s Zen angered the entrenched Buddhist establishment. They denounced his heresy to the king, and Huike was indicted. Convicted and condemned to death, he thus became not only the Second Ancestor but also the first martyr of Chinese Zen.

https://www.lionsroar.com/searching-for-bodhidharma/

1
skeletalyeast•

Obsession.

Poor Germans ... They don't exist anymore ... Not after Adolf, anyway! Who calls them Germans? They are the G-people.

Hey you! Yes, you, stupid programmer. Studying computer science without physics... Get the hell outta here!

3
ewkOP•

Disagree.

Churches lie and teach lies because the benefits outweigh the costs.

Zen is famous even when there aren't Masters around... the teachings are famous even when people don't understand them...

It isn't obsession... it's profit.

1
skeletalyeast•

Yes! It is profit!

Disagreement is health.

1
robeewankenobee•

Of course it's profit ... capitalism is the norm, all societies adapted to profit gain otherwise they slowly disolve. It is like Nothing else lies beyond profit, pragmatically speaking. If One is not after profit he gets used and discarded because that represents something beyond the social norms ... the "intelligible" ones at least.

1
Blue_Sky_Record•

It's pretty simple. Everyone thinks Zen is cool, including Buddhists. But they don't like when Zen makes fun of Buddhism or takes away all their circlejerking about the Buddha, the sutras, and all the stupid pali and sanskrit terms. So they just take Buddhism and call it Zen. Now they can be cool without any of the dangerous elements in Zen.

Then you get people like Thich Nhat Hanh who call themselves Zen masters and tell people they'll turn into a cloud when they die.

2
Leperkonvict•

I sit shikantaza. A practice born out of the old Zen Masters criticism towards focus based meditation and in which Dogen adopted.

Some people sit with Reality to get to know it. While some people have an obsession with a dead guy named Dogen and a serial killer named Richard Baker and call this "Enlightened behavior".

You do what you gotta do.

2
ewkOP•

Dogen invented Shikantaza. Dogen's manual on it is the earliest known description of that religious practice.

You are a troll and a liar, and you harass people who point out that you violate the Reddiquette to proselytize for your cult:

Leperkonvict: Religious troll with [sex problem](https://www.reddit.com/r/zen/comments/8j0ro5/what_zen_masters_mean_when_they_say_mind/dyy9gjp/ and); here he is promoting cult meditation, contrast with regular non-cult meditation.

Dogen was a Mormon Buddhist, a fraud, and a plagiarist, and the church he started still bears the marks of his moral and spiritual malignance: r/zen/wiki/sexpredators.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
RandomActOKindness•

Nice questions.

I would say i have merely read the dead words of men long passed.

Lineage is retrospective, truth is never welcome in its home town.

​

Coming from the East, landing in the West, still eyebrows meet in the frown.

​

Why DO so many cling to the ghosts that haunt there personal power structure? Why is it so hard to simply meet the dawn like an old begger?

​

I would simply say, having failed to find (lettle lone present) my own mind, i simply wish to pacify my body. This brain is calmer then before, but still its one foot in front of the other.

​

​

good talk, and id like more to answer these very simple and basically fundamental questions, if they are serious at all.

1
dec1phahProfoundSlap•

Showing the truth to dishonest people again? Nice try...

1
royalsaltmerchantSaltyZen•

Hang em high

1
RaindropsDance•

Hey u/ewk, can you post links to some of the sources for stuff like this? It would help clarify and allow us to read up on it more. The comments here are just all over the place. No one effectively addressed your points! It's a shame people come to r/zen just to do petty bickering rather than have productive fact-based discussions.

1
ewkOP•
  1. This is my guide for people starting out: https://www.reddit.com//r/zensangha/wiki/getstarted

  2. This is some Cases that address most the more grotesque modern misperceptions about Zen:

  1. This is what I've written after reading that guide:
  1. This is the wiki page where I try to track some of the longer running r/zen business:

If you want something specific I haven't covered, do tell.

1