Terrible Music Theory Advice for EDM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gh_nWtW43Yk
Everyone else sees how blatantly unhelpful and just flat out wrong this video is right? It's really discouraging for beginners to think it's as easy as just adding notes and have them try it themselves just to flop on their face, or for them to use the four chords and feel bad because this guy told them to stop. This video actually angered me.
Posted Dec 19, 2019, 10:17 AM UTC
I happened to watch that video a while ago and, yes, I was horrified. It's terrible advice with a terrible attitude. Also, the "third level" of chords sounds awful, like the author doesn't know what they're doing at all.
Same here. When I saw this video I instantly hated it.
The information became a business, and people want to teach things on the internet at any cost, even when they don't know a shit about what they talk about. They know there's an audience for it.
This kind of shit is rampant on the edm production sub, and it’s welcomed because of the number of people who want to make hits without bothering to study even the very basics of music. I’ve occasionally offered advice as a trained musician, not in an elitist or condescending manner, and I’ve received hostility. I should say there are also some cool people and some great information to be found there; it’s just rare.
On another note, I often see “Vocal coach reacts to x” videos among my suggested and each time I’ve gone and found a video of the “coach” singing, they’re mediocre at best and often demonstrably lacking in formal education.
The problem with his third level chords, is that he don’t know his leading tones, nor does he know the function of the chordsleading up to the root chords. He hit some of the good chords, but I strongly suspect this to be luck.
Yeah, I actually liked that one secondary dominant, that one had purpose. The other ones sounded were so random though.
Surprisingly, the first step to writing interesting harmony is not to pick a series of random notes and then add random extentions, unless of course you are John Cage
Lol the third level does not sound awful. It sounds like you’ve never listened to Jazz before. Or any genre besides pop, rap, and rock for that matter.
I agree, however, that those types of chords are not relevant to beginner-intermediate Trap/EDM producers.
Don't forget that jazz needs to have good voice leading also, which is something that the chords in this video are heavily lacking.
Your comment is an insult to jazz. No self-respecting jazz musician would get even close to such horrendous harmony. It's the kind of "complexity" made by someone who has utterly no grasp of traditional functional harmony.
Also, it's funny that you insult rap music. Did you know the 2018 Pulitzer Prize for Music was given to a rap album?
At what point in that comment did I insult rap music? My favorite genre, the one I produce
I agree, you didn't insult rap. You definitely did insult jazz though. In order to play jazz you have to have a decent understanding of jazz theory. This guy does not, and this video does not teach it. The third level doesn't sound jazzy. It sounds bad.
It was given to rap as a sympathy gift.
YEAH a rap album that was based around JAZZ samples not FL studio LOL god learn what you are talking about before commenting please
I think you may be a little confused buddy: "DAMN." doesn't really use jazz samples. You may be thinking of "To Pimp a Butterfly", and, in that case, you do know that jazz musicians played in that album, right? Folks like Thundercat, Kamasi Washington, Terrace Martin and Robert Glasper. I think, with that attitude, you'll never have the chance to produce one of those guys...
You know, jazz.
An effete white boy whisper singing over computer chords
Jazz.
As a jazz musician, I agree. Generally when I write my process is to throw darts at a wall of random extended chords and play them all consectively in root position
Finally. someone with standards.
You think the guy defending a video that spells an Fm7 chord as F G# C D# is the guy with standards?
truthfully that is what's going to be most beneficial to the vast majority of young producers using DAWs- where note names do not change with their keys, and sheet music is not used primarily
Thank you. So much nonesense in these comment threads
👍🏻