Terrible Music Theory Advice for EDM

Resource

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gh_nWtW43Yk

Everyone else sees how blatantly unhelpful and just flat out wrong this video is right? It's really discouraging for beginners to think it's as easy as just adding notes and have them try it themselves just to flop on their face, or for them to use the four chords and feel bad because this guy told them to stop. This video actually angered me.

Posted Dec 19, 2019, 10:17 AM UTC

473292
ferniecanto•

I happened to watch that video a while ago and, yes, I was horrified. It's terrible advice with a terrible attitude. Also, the "third level" of chords sounds awful, like the author doesn't know what they're doing at all.

216
Chiasse•

Same here. When I saw this video I instantly hated it.

The information became a business, and people want to teach things on the internet at any cost, even when they don't know a shit about what they talk about. They know there's an audience for it.

76
hwlgrmmr•

This kind of shit is rampant on the edm production sub, and it’s welcomed because of the number of people who want to make hits without bothering to study even the very basics of music. I’ve occasionally offered advice as a trained musician, not in an elitist or condescending manner, and I’ve received hostility. I should say there are also some cool people and some great information to be found there; it’s just rare.

On another note, I often see “Vocal coach reacts to x” videos among my suggested and each time I’ve gone and found a video of the “coach” singing, they’re mediocre at best and often demonstrably lacking in formal education.

6
RushAgenda•

The problem with his third level chords, is that he don’t know his leading tones, nor does he know the function of the chordsleading up to the root chords. He hit some of the good chords, but I strongly suspect this to be luck.

12
Munzu•

Yeah, I actually liked that one secondary dominant, that one had purpose. The other ones sounded were so random though.

2
Carbon_Coffee•

Surprisingly, the first step to writing interesting harmony is not to pick a series of random notes and then add random extentions, unless of course you are John Cage

3
AndyCupcakes•

Lol the third level does not sound awful. It sounds like you’ve never listened to Jazz before. Or any genre besides pop, rap, and rock for that matter.

I agree, however, that those types of chords are not relevant to beginner-intermediate Trap/EDM producers.

-86
Type31•

Don't forget that jazz needs to have good voice leading also, which is something that the chords in this video are heavily lacking.

58
ferniecanto•

Your comment is an insult to jazz. No self-respecting jazz musician would get even close to such horrendous harmony. It's the kind of "complexity" made by someone who has utterly no grasp of traditional functional harmony.

Also, it's funny that you insult rap music. Did you know the 2018 Pulitzer Prize for Music was given to a rap album?

52
AndyCupcakes•

At what point in that comment did I insult rap music? My favorite genre, the one I produce

-26
AssaultedCracker•

I agree, you didn't insult rap. You definitely did insult jazz though. In order to play jazz you have to have a decent understanding of jazz theory. This guy does not, and this video does not teach it. The third level doesn't sound jazzy. It sounds bad.

21
[deleted]•

It was given to rap as a sympathy gift.

-41
AndyCupcakes•

YEAH a rap album that was based around JAZZ samples not FL studio LOL god learn what you are talking about before commenting please

-43
ferniecanto•

I think you may be a little confused buddy: "DAMN." doesn't really use jazz samples. You may be thinking of "To Pimp a Butterfly", and, in that case, you do know that jazz musicians played in that album, right? Folks like Thundercat, Kamasi Washington, Terrace Martin and Robert Glasper. I think, with that attitude, you'll never have the chance to produce one of those guys...

19

jazz

You know, jazz.

An effete white boy whisper singing over computer chords

Jazz.

29
Carbon_Coffee•

As a jazz musician, I agree. Generally when I write my process is to throw darts at a wall of random extended chords and play them all consectively in root position

3
[deleted]•

Finally. someone with standards.

-27
AssaultedCracker•

You think the guy defending a video that spells an Fm7 chord as F G# C D# is the guy with standards?

23

truthfully that is what's going to be most beneficial to the vast majority of young producers using DAWs- where note names do not change with their keys, and sheet music is not used primarily

-9
AndyCupcakes•

Thank you. So much nonesense in these comment threads

-15
[deleted]•

👍🏻

-11
musicianscookbook•

Yeah that was terrible. Riddled with misinformation, doesn't even spell chords right and makes it seem so easy with the "no shit sherlock" meme thrown in there.

One of the top comments reads "this guy is upgrading the whole edm industry with one video". I had a good chuckle from that.

173
Jongtr•

Lends a whole new meaning to the word "upgrading"...

45
ikesrapii•

Just like Windows updates

26
HashPram•

DO NOT TURN OFF YOUR COMPUTER.

18
chastity-spider•

Why would I? It's the one thing that continues to be turned on around me.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ILikeasianpeople•

I love how they spelled the Fm7 chord as “F, G#, C, D#”. Like, Jesus Christ bro. I called out a similar video a while ago. The creator responded, and agreed with me, but ultimately left the video up. EDM Prod YouTubers make straight trash music theory videos. I remember when I was starting to make music and watched a ton of these things. I was so confused for such a long time and was really irritated+enraged when I finally picked up a textbook, realizing I had picked up so much bad information and basically had to unlearn a bunch of stuff.

117
mage2k•

Any time I see a "Music Theory for EDM" article or video I instantly cringe and move on.

18
halb7•

I mean Fm7 is f,#g,c,d# its not the hyper correct way but it is Not wrong

-35
ferniecanto•

Yes, it's fundamentally wrong. Triads are built by stacking thirds. That's not a matter of debate.

30
halb7•

They are the correct thirds, f to g# is a m3, g# to c is a M3 and lastly c to eb is a minor third so so it is fm7, i assume you are a piano player ?

-24
ferniecanto•

Are you trying to troll, or are you just really THAT arrogant? I have to sound rude, but I have good reasons to believe you're just trying to waste my time.

13
Perc_Dealer•

f to g# is an augmented second, not a minor third.

They sound the same because they’re enharmonic, but in terms of theory, it’s not correct.

10
wood_and_rock•

F to G# is an augmented second, which sounds the same as F to Ab, a minor third. They are different in name only, but it is important to the underlying theory.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
EternallyWarped•

I love how they spelled the Fm7 chord as “F, G#, C, D#”.

You have to realize that he's using FL Studio which doesn't have any flats at all. It only has sharps. That chord in FL Studio is Fm7, and just based on the actual frequencies that *is* Fm7.

As one who uses FL Studio, anytime someone might say that Fm7 is F, Ab, C, Eb (not F, G#, C, D#), I look at my FL Studio MIDI grid and I think... What's the difference? In my DAW, they're the same damned thing! I saw a guy called Composing Gloves going into the frustration the lack of flats causes him in FL Studio and I'm scratching my head because I've never had a problem with it at all because they're the same frequencies.

Additionally, FL Studio has "chord stamps". YOu can select a minor seventh chord, plop it down, and that's exactly what you come up with: F, G#, C, D#.

I still don't see what the big deal is.

-36
MaggaraMarine•

I still don't see what the big deal is.

Understanding enharmonic spelling is important if you want to understand music theory. Just makes understanding stuff like intervals and functions a lot easier. It doesn't matter if you personally don't care about the difference between Eb and D#, but it's not a mistake you should make in an educational video.

Interval naming will never make sense if you don't understand correct enharmonic spelling. Like, why is it called a third? That's because it's three note names: F G A. F to A is a major third and F to Ab is a minor third. F to G# is not a third, it's an augmented second. That's because it's two note names (F G). Interval names come from the note names, and why something is called a third or a fifth doesn't make sense unless you use correct enharmonic spelling.

Again, if it works for you, fine, but don't make educational videos about music theory where you make that mistake. It's kind of like if you made an educational video about language, but said stuff like "allot" (instead of "a lot"), "would of" (instead of "would have"/"would've") or used "then" and "than" or "to" and "too" incorrectly. Everybody is going to understand what you mean, but those are not mistakes that you want to make in an educational video about language. I mean, I probably make mistakes all the time because English is not my first language and I'm not some kind of a language expert, but that's also why I'm not going to make educational videos on how to speak/write English. If I did, my videos would probably be full of mistakes and I would just spread misinformation.

Also, the chord progression he used in the video was "Ab Fm Cm A#". Like, why would you use A# and Ab in the same progression? That's just going to look very confusing. Call it Bb. It also helps with understanding functions. If it's in the key of Eb major, it's a IV ii vi V progression. Again, look at note names. The V chord is built on the fifth note of the scale that is E F G A B, i.e., some kind of a B. Now, in the key of Eb, the B also gets a flat, but it's still some kind of a B, because you count five notes from E.

Using the correct enharmonic spelling also helps you with understanding scales. In diatonic scales, you always use all of the seven letters - all diatonic scales are A B C D E F G with added sharps or flats. Eb major is not D# F G Ab A# C D, it is Eb F G Ab Bb C D. Notice how each note name appears once in the scale, and it's a lot easier to comprehend than something like "D# F G Ab A# C D" that mixes sharps and flats and includes two D's and A's in it and no E's or B's, and that also looks like some kind of a weird chromatic scale when actually it's just going to sound like the major scale.

92
Tanteline•

You crushed it

16
_sebu_•

Great response. I just wanted to add for other beginner/intermediate readers in case something else clicks, the correct way also matters for notation:

  • A major or minor scale will have notes evenly separated visually on the staff, the result of having one of each letter.
  • You can notate a major scale on the staff and change it to its parallel minor simply by changing the key signature (e.g. F major to F minor = going from one flat to four flats) - this accurately represents the fact that the difference between a major scale and a minor scale is that three of the notes are flatted. If you took the F minor key signature (B♭, E♭, A♭, D♭) and decided that you could just ignore the D♭ and use a C♯ accidental whenever you need to, now it looks like 1) you're sharpening the fifth degree and 2) there is no sixth degree. This is very misleading for someone trying to understand how harmony works.
  • Key signatures on a staff only make sense with the correct naming - think of F♯ major, which has 6 sharps, the last being an E sharp. If you called this note "F" instead, it would mess up the whole system because there's no way to notate that on a key signature - the F line is already taken by F♯. If you dropped the E♯ from the key signature under the assumption that it's the same as F, your key signature would have 5 sharps, which would suggest B major or G♯ minor even though you're in F♯ major, and you'd have to use a natural sign (♮) every time you have the seventh scale degree. Silliness!
11

I'm beginning to delve into this sort of stuff recently and it's helped my understanding a little, thank you

4
yardaper•

Great reply, and also, your English is incredible!

9

Using a righteous rant, you've made a concept that I've been struggling to grasp for a few weeks "click" a little bit for my self-taught ass, ty

3
Alexico91•

Amen

2
norwegianjazzbass•

Theory wise its incorrect. A scale contains only one of each letter. An Fm scale already contains G, so next would be Ab.

So, F - G - Ab - Bb - C - Db - Eb - F.

19
ferniecanto•

That chord in FL Studio is Fm7, and just based on the actual frequencies that *is* Fm7.

Yep, but chords are made of notes, not frequencies. The correspondence between notes and frequencies depends on the tuning system you use, and that's one of the reasons why G♯ and A♭ are not "the same".

And if FL Studio is cheap enough not to have the black keys labelled with both enharmonics (are you sure you can't change that setting somewhere?), that's not an excuse for one to get the note names wrong, especially when they're making a video tutorial. There's no excuse for teaching wrong things.

I still don't see what the big deal is.

You're in a music theory sub, so that's a good start for you to learn exactly what the big deal is. But you're gonna have to change your attitude from "I'm correct and I don't know what the big deal is" to "I'm human and fallible, and I hope to learn what the big deal is". Remember, any artists who stops studying and learning is as good as dead.

15
HashPram•

just based on the actual frequencies that is Fm7.

What?

5
wood_and_rock•

They just mean that, from the physics of music standpoint, an A# and a Bb are the same thing. They are the same sound wave.

This ignores the point of the theory and note names that other users have pointed out far more eloquently than I could.

6
AssaultedCracker•

And the fact that they're only the same sound wave in an even tempered scale.

2
Type31•

The reason it's spelled F Ab C Eb is because the chord is derived directly from the scale. F (natural) minor contains F G Ab Bb C Db Eb. You cannot have a G# in the scale of F minor because G is already in use and you cannot use the same note twice in a scale (with an exception being given to the altered scale which has a sharp 9 and a flat 9). Dont rely on your DAW for music theory advice. Read a book.

3
EternallyWarped•

The only thing all this reveals is the difference between MIDI and staff paper. I remember reading a post from someone in another thread saying that you can't use G and G# or Gb in the same scale because of the notation problems and possible confusion that might arise for someone reading the music. It's just supposedly clearer if you don't drop two different notes on the same line in the staff. That translates to: It makes the music easier to read.

Well, in a DAW, there is no staff paper. There is no notation. All the music is laid out on a grid that looks like a spreadsheet. It's easy to tell the difference between major, minor, suspended, and augmented chords by the distance between each block on the grid. In a minor chord, the second bar is closer to the first bar. In a major chord, the second bar is closer to the third bar. It's the same for SUS2 and SUS4. Once you've learned what different types of chords look like in MIDI, it's easy to just know what you're looking at with a glance. And that leads to knowing what kind of chord progression you're looking at based on the relationship between MIDI data positions on the grid.

As I mentioned before, this is about frequency and movement. No matter how a chord is spelled, it sounds the same. One using a DAW just has a different approach to writing music than one who uses staff paper. Whether a note is G# or Ab isn't going to change where it appears in a MIDI grid. I'm not against FL Studio having both flats and sharps, but it doesn't and I don't feel crippled by that because I don't actually think too much about notes or note spelling. It's all visual for me. I just think about whether I'm in the right key (which is easy when the DAW itself will highlight the bars that are in-key so you can use them or know when you're borrowing notes or chords) and I think about the intervals and relationship between all the different notes being played. It still works. It's just a different approach. That's why I like what that guy Composing Gloves is doing by making "MIDI Music Theory" videos to distinguish it from regular music theory. There's no difference in the use of frequencies, but for me, MIDI is easier to comprehend than sheet music. And since I have no plans to ever compose on sheet music (I have no need to), it wouldn't make much sense for me to learn it.

-4
really_dunno•

Eh... so what?

Western music theory has nothing to do with physics underneath. It‘s flawed, as it‘s expanded 7 note diatonic scale to 12 note chromatic, but still tries to maintain conventions of the diatonic scale.

The only thing that mattes to the listener is the end effect. That isnthe harmony, the interaction of frequencies. Which is the same, regardless how you write it.

So sorry, but imo this is just snobby.

-69
musicianscookbook•

Western music theory has nothing to do with physics underneath. It‘s flawed, as it‘s expanded 7 note diatonic scale to 12 note chromatic, but still tries to maintain conventions of the diatonic scale.

I don't see how this is relevant. The video is giving blatant misinformation to people who are looking to it for guidance.

34
really_dunno•

Well perhaps if you had a greater understanding you could see the relevance.

What is this „blatant misinformation“ he‘s supposedly sharing?

-52
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

Don’t use diatonic chords while using diatonic chords.

22
F_u_c_k_this•

Are you the Creator of this video?

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ferniecanto•

The only thing that mattes to the listener is the end effect.

What nonsense.

If you're a musician, and you don't understand the processes you're using, it's very likely the end effect will be trash anyway. I mean, just listen to the "level 3" example in that video. The harmony and voice leading are horrendous, and, well, that's the kind of stuff you might get when you don't understand diatonic harmony.

I mean, why are you defending people who makes "tutorials" with blatantly incorrect information?

33
Blozi•

If you're a musician, and you don't understand the processes you're using, it's very likely the end effect will be trash anyway.

How can you possibly think this? Are you forgetting that music is art? You think every artist knows the exact mechanism that gives their art affect? You think artists just... don't experiment ever?

Please stop gatekeeping self-expression.

2
ferniecanto•

How can you possibly think this? Are you forgetting that music is art?

... wait, isn't this /r/HeartTransplantSurgery? [looks up] r/musictheory? Sheesh, I must've made a typo when I typed in the URL! They're so similar.

I mean, of course I know this is art. Do you often go around Reddit talking to people assuming they're 8-year-olds? Watch your tone, man. Also, keep in mind of the context here. We're not discussing a video that suggests you to experiment with 12-tone serialism or microtonality to expand your horizons. We're talking about some condescending YouTube "specialist" teaching you how to write chord progressions without understanding how sharps and flats work, and telling you to avoid diatonic triads "at any cost". THAT is what I mean with "not understanding the processes you're using". I'm not talking experimentation, I'm talking setting off to make music in a given idiom and not knowing its most basic fundamentals.

You think every artist knows the exact mechanism that gives their art affect?

No, not every artist. That's why I said it's "most likely" that the result will be trash. Some people are true geniuses and everything they try to do comes out perfectly right off the bat. In most cases, though, every time you try to do something new, you have to fail a bunch of times before something good comes out. There's a name to this process: "learning". I, for one, had to do a lot of learning in my life, and I can't remember one single time when I tried to learn some new skill or idiom and came out with a masterpiece on first try. When I got into free improvisation, it took me months before I started to listen to myself and enjoy what I heard. It took me almost two decades of writing music before I attempted to write vocals songs and managed to write a 10-minute-long song about a Pinkie Pie plushie toy.

Also, when I say "understand the processes you're using", I don't necessarily mean a formal understanding. Some musicians aren't able to tell the names of the chords they play, but they know that if they play chords X, Y and Z in a certain order and with a certain rhythm, it sounds similar to other songs they've heard before, and they're able to sing their own lyrics and come up with new songs. That's an intuitive understanding. It's limited, it's informal, but it's still an understanding nonetheless. The guy in the video doesn't seem to have an understanding on tonal harmony, whether formal or intuitive. Or are you gonna try to argue that a person who tells us to "avoid diatonic chords at any cost" has any place giving music lessons?

I champion all forms of self-expression, I champion experimentation, I champion new forms of doing things, and I champion doing the opposite of what people tell you to do just to see what happens. But I also champion pointing at trash and calling it trash, and I specifically champion the condemnation of bullshit being passed off as knowledge. Self-expression is free for all, but teaching is something else, and if you're teaching shit you don't understand, I reckon I have full right to tell you to bugger off.

... but yeah, it turns out I thought I was in a medical surgery subreddit, so everything I just said is invalid and you can ignore it.

2
really_dunno•

What nonsense. Neural networks are able to create music without any theoretical „knowledge“.

If you were right, music would not be possible wothout having theory first, which is nonsese obviously.

And success of these people clearly shows lots of people enjoy their „trash“.

You guys must feel quite endangered judging by your irational, emotionalnresponses!

-60
ferniecanto•

Neural networks are able to create music without any theoretical „knowledge“.

That's because they obtain that knowledge through the training data they're fed with, buddy. That's why it's called machine learning.

You guys must feel quite endangered judging by your irational, emotionalnresponses!

You're the guy who made the video, aren't ya? That's why you're so desperate.

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
wood_and_rock•

The only thing that mattes to the listener is the end effect

I take issue with this from an educational standpoint. If you are a musician that makes music that impacts the listener and you don't know a lick of theory, that's fine. Do your craft and stumble through composition until the next big idea hits you. This works for tons of people. But don't make a theory video about it explaining the theory behind what you've created if you just don't understand.

It's not just being snobby, the video is factually detrimental to the viewers that are trying to improve their grasp of theory to compose better music.

6
AssaultedCracker•

Western music theory has nothing to do with physics underneath.

Lol. Harmonics would like to have a word with you.

4
really_dunno•

Lol, physics would like a word with you.

It doesn’t matter if you call your tones Joe, michelle and Mbassa, the only thing that matters are their relative frequencies.

So again,”proper chord tone names” do not exist in nature, and coearly different names can be used to achieve the same result.

-1
AssaultedCracker•

Exactly, physics! ie. the physics that scale systems are based on (harmonic overtones, etc), and that we altered somewhat to come up with the tuning system that you think is purely based on physics! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament

Part of what I'm getting at here is that an Ab is not necessarily the same frequency as a G#. In case that isn't clear.

3
Blozi•

Agree with you 100%. This sub likes to get all riled up about the dumbest, pettiest shit. You literally have people here arguing you can't write a good song if you don't use proper enharmonic spellings. The elitism of the music theory community knows no bounds.

1
MaggaraMarine•

I think the way the video started was fine (and actually contained some information that can be helpful to beginners), but yeah, I agree, I don't see how this is helpful. I mean, it's good to experiment with stuff, but the video didn't really explain much, and made a lot of mistakes - the enharmonic spelling of the chords was horrible, and some chords were named incorrectly. Also, he called the four-chord pop progression "diatonic triads", and told people to avoid "diatonic triads", which is pretty misleading, since his own progression also used diatonic triads.

And sure, one doesn't need to know theory to be able to write this kind of music, but they probably shouldn't do educational videos if they don't know how to explain those concepts or their explanation contains a lot of misinformation. If the only advice you have is "just play different notes", that's really not going to help anyone.

88
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

I hate peoples harping on four chord songs as if they killed music. Beginners should make tons of four chord songs to understand how to use functional harmony and practice song structure and melody crafting.

Edit: typos

105

Beginners should make tons of four chord songs to ... practice song structure and melody crafting.

This is a very insightful remark, and I have to admit that I never looked at it that way. It's good to be reminded of how it is as a beginner. Thank you for that.

51
bordain_de_putel•

I hate peoples harping on four chord songs as if they killed music.

Imagine how they'll react once they discover punk music

50
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

Or funk lol. Entire songs vamping on one chord

56
[deleted]•

Coming from a techno producer, i typically limit my songs to 4 chords max. Typically ends up being 1 or 2 though. With various effects and such it can feel like a progression though. With guitar based stuff, i tend to only like 5 chords max.

Its worth noting that like funk, hillcountry blues will focus on a looping riff or chord. They call it hypnotic blues because the rhythm is infectious for sure. This calls back to African roots in Blues and Funk which, if im correct, were more groove based.

27
Lepton_Decay•

Drone, stoner metal, doom metal, funeral metal, Avant garde ambient like Ulver's "Teachings in Silence" album. Music is music. If there's an audience for what someone produces, cool. (That Ulver album is sick btw).

2
sansocie•

Nice

1
dat529•

I'd rather listen to a good three chord tune like All Along The Watchtower than any number of pretentious crap tunes that make use of complicated chords. All folk music is basically three or four chords and that's because it was made by people with no formal training. Yet a lot of those tunes from Scarborough Fair and Greensleeves up through numerous songs from the American Blues are way more beloved and, frankly better tunes, than a lot of more complicated jazzier tunes that try too hard. Similarly, a lot of standards by the greats like Rodgers and Hart are actually surprisingly simple progressions when you break them down that can be simplified pretty well into four or five chords (songs like Blue Moon, To Keep My Love Alive, This Nearly Was Mine, It Never Entered My Mind). Sometimes the chords are modified or the bridges get a little more complex, but people really underestimate the power of a good, hummable melody.

20
CloseButNoDice•

Honestly, simple music is great and I've never really heard anyone dispute that who knows anything. But calling complex music pretentious and saying it's trying too hard is the same musical superiority start bullshit you're fighting against. If there's nothing wrong with making music simple to convey emotion there's nothing wrong with trying to make music complex to experiment with new ideas and make something new. In fact there is no won't way to make music and it really gets under my skin when anyone implies that some form of music is better than another.

So more power to you for fighting the dozens of people who don't like simple music but can you do it without pointlessly attacking other music?

21
dat529•

I didn't call complex music pretentious. Complex music done right is the highest form of musical achievement to me. The problem is that it's very rarely done right and music students tend to assume that complexity is all that matters and everything needs to be overly complicated. What I said is I'd rather a good three chord song to any number of mediocre complex pieces that are complex just for complexities' sake. That's what the video was saying originally was to complicate everything without using simple chords. People get so sensitive about this stuff, I wasn't attacking anything, just making a point.

3
kisielk•

Depends on the kind of music they are making. Functional harmony is totally irrelevant for a lot of styles. But keeping it simple chord wise is always a good idea.

Going to more chords once you gain experience is easy. Once you know how to set a mood with a couple of chords going to more is basically just shifting between moods.

7
ILikeasianpeople•

What kinds of genres, besides serialism or atonal music, ignore functional harmony? Not trying to be a dick, I’m genuinely curious.

5
kisielk•

A lot of electronic music, particularly techno and especially dub techno has basically no harmonic movement. A track might sit on the same chord for 8+ minutes. Other styles might use chords in a non-functional way, for example just using parallel motion of an m7 chord.

13
kbarron24•

Modal jazz is one

4

late jazz

romantic and later music which uses harmonic ideas that are either without functional explanation or completely random

some chopped and screwed hip hop music

any sort of music that's made by someone without a grasp of functional harmony... so a lot of edm

any music that isn't composed with chords... aka the vast majority of music in history

-1†
catplaps•

it's not that it's non-functional harmony, it's just low functioning harmony.

1
coffeeblack85•

Also 4 chord songs are used in pop and edm songs so much bc it works. Its enough variation to be interesting but repeats itself often enough that its catchy and easy to vibe/sing along too.

6
Scatcycle•

What, you don't like it when you're out here dancing in the bar and the song graces you with its intellectuality through a C6addb2add#13Sus9/B chord?

7
coffeeblack85•

If you can play a chord with 2 hands then it’s not real jazz. Real musicians have their buddy come hit those last 2 notes for them

8
Verifiable_Human•

I feel like at lot of those guys are targeting the audience with the pretentious opinion that "simple music = bad music."

A far better way to look at music is to see different compositional tools as the grammar and syntax to your story. Not every good story is written like a dictionary.

4
ChrundlesRatStick•

And the stories that touch the most people use the clearest language. I feel like a lot of people in the jazz/music theory community hate the idea of music actually being accessible. If other musicians are the only people who like your music, that just means you are writing music that doesn't connect with most people.

6
Verifiable_Human•

It's complicated. I think there's definitely a place for the intricate music that's designed to test boundaries rather, but there's also definitely a place for simplistic music that's written to soothe the soul.

I think all music is valid when looked at with intent - the key is to learn how and why the music was/is created and performed so you can connect with it.

3
Masterkid1230clarinet, jazz, comp•

Tbh, as a non-beginner, some of my favorite tunes I've written use basically two chords on loop. More chords isnt necessarily better. Texture, timbre, melody, rhythm and structure all exist ffs.

3
_sebu_•

PREACH.

2
bloodyell76•

The only issue with four chord songs is simply that they make up so much of the pop landscape these days... things used to be more varied back when bands were either more influenced by jazz, or flat out didn't know what they were doing and came up with weird progressions that simply sounded cool.

These days there seems to be a lot fewer risks being taken in pop music.

1†
Masterkid1230clarinet, jazz, comp•

Then again, you could argue that music back then was timbrically much less interesting. Compare most 60's or even 90's rock/pop bands which featured basically always the same lineup with small variations, to something like Post Malone's great sound design. Something like Psycho may be just a couple chords, but it's synths and general timbre is what makes it awesome. Pop music nowadays relies much more heavily on rhythm, lyrics and timbre, while pop music back then relied much more heavily on harmony and melody to shape its identity, leaving stuff like Timbre and Texture somewhat behind (though obviously there are examples that contradict this for both cases, like The Beatles with their extremely complex arrangements and timbres, or Ariana Grande with simple, dumb stuff).

5

there are plenty of interesting songs with cool chords being written. The main reason you don't hear them as often is that much of popular music is more rhythmically and timbrally rooted. You'll have producers talking about "frequencies" far more often than notes

2
underwaterpizza•

Not to mention all the other elements of music that don't require a super deep harmonic theory knowledge (layering, Dynamics, rhythm, textures). Some of my fav songs are just vamps over one chord!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
aFluffyKogMaw•

Yeah I was confused about that part when he said avoid "diatonic triads" and then proceeds to use it.

3
caleblee01•

Well I think it was a fine video. I think level 2 sounded better than level 3, but level 3 didn’t sound horrible to me.

And one very important thing this video teaches is that it’s ok to have “random” notes if it sounds good to you. Too many “guides” restrict to just diatonic triads.

2
Chiasse•

"Diatonic triads : avoid it at any cost"

Oh jeez, why would someone give such dumb advices to beginners?

39
WhatAGayTwist•

lmao thats the stupidest shit ive seen

13
mrgarborg•

Well, if you just move the inner voice by an octave the triads aren't diatonic anymore dontchaknow.

6
Boris-Holo•

that doesnt even make sense??

2
aleksfadini•

Cos we have been playing diatonic chords for too long? :)

Once you experiment with something different you can always go back to diatonic, but most beginners never go past that. So it seems like an absolute silly advice but it could be for a good cause - no one will abandon diatonic chords all together, there is no worry.

0
baranysos•

Yep, sole reason why i am preparing a music theory tutorial series towards edm producers.

Edm producers mostly expect practical tips and tricks tho.

29
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

It’s mostly because in home edm producers are used to a fast workflow (which is not a bad thing) and music theory is usually best learned with sheet music in front of you writing things down, which can be a tiny bit off putting. It’s very different and hard to adjust to. I recommend trying to cater to that do it yourself vibe if edm producers and encouraging them to trek through the difficult stuff! More musicians being literate of fundamentals leads to more good music!

20
baranysos•

I am planning to use piano roll as a representation means rather than sheet music. I think it will be easier for the average DAW user.

But i am planning to focus on voice leading and writing different parts as separate melodies with less emphasis on strict counterpoint/voice leading rules.

We will see how it goes :)

14
HealthyHotDogs•

Are you going to put it on YouTube? That sounds really interesting

4
baranysos•

Yes i will be. I am currently playing with the routing of softwares, certain problems have occurred and having slow progress due to full time office job.

I will start uploading once i have recorded first few videos.

I am open to any ideas and feedback.

3
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

That’s a really good strategy! I feel like people really respond well to that style of teaching music theory and it helps explain functional harmony so well!!

2
MaggaraMarine•

I don't think there's anything wrong with using piano roll notation per se. It can actually be more effective in teaching some aspects of music theory than standard notation (because you can see the half and whole steps all the time). It makes certain structures/patterns a lot easier to understand than on standard notation. I think piano roll is actually a really good way of visualizing theoretical concepts (it's much more intuitive than standard notation). The problem with the people who use it in their educational videos is that they use incorrect terminology and can't really explain the concepts properly. Piano roll notation has a lot of potential and is probably easier to understand if you are a beginner. But the teacher needs to know what they are talking about.

7
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

I think it helps visualize voice leading incredibly well, but it’s similar to guitar tablature in that it isn’t necessarily as standardized and ingrained in western music as sheet music. Sheet music is also the common language for musicians, not everyone can read piano roll as fast as they can sheet music.

5
MaggaraMarine•

Sheet music is also the common language for musicians, not everyone can read piano roll as fast as they can sheet music.

Sure. But I would still say that for beginners and especially for those who write their music on DAW, piano roll notation is probably much easier to approach. You just need a good teacher to explain the concepts. There's nothing wrong with piano roll. I would also say that it's more visual than tabs because you see which beats the notes fall on, how long they last, how high or low they are compared to one other, and it's easy to visualize half and whole steps.

Would I use piano roll to replace sheet music? Of course not. Sheet music probably works much better for sight reading purposes (it contains more information and takes a lot less space). But piano roll may actually even help people who are familiar with sheet music (especially if used in combination with sheet music), because it's so much easier to visualize certain things on it. And we also need to consider the target audience - people who write music on DAW probably aren't interested in sheet music, so using sheet music to explain these concepts to them may be a turn off.

3
baranysos•

Totally agree with you.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MaggaraMarine•

Sounds interesting. Do you have a link to your Youtube channel?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
hessreindeer•

Gotta love the serious and concerned comments here, but come on. EiNsTeIn EqUaTiOnS

28
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

E=Cm^2

27
gaztelu_leherketa•

Christ the comments

"It would be really hard to write pop music with a blues progression"

Yeah there are no pop songs in histort built on I IV V ...

27
musicianscookbook•

I find it hilarious that when someone pointed out his theory was wrong, people commented saying "this is why producers find people who study music theory annoying, just letting you know"

10
Spad3s3s•

This happens a lot and, as an edm producer it's really frustrating that this is how people see us :/ edm can be really melodically rich and full of interesting music theory

22
ferniecanto•

Definitely. Some of the most inspirational and interesting music I've listened in the past 15 years come from the electronic realm, and I realise there's only so much crap in EDM because that's true for every genre of music.

13
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

I know right!! Even still, I don’t think things need to always be harmonically diverse in order to be moving, or have the most interesting music theory to gain an emotional response that you want. Four chords are sometimes all you need!

(But yes EDM is great I really love the song Ultimatum by Dislcosure and plunder phonics is a pretty amazing form of electronic music)

9
Spad3s3s•

Yeah, a big mistake of new music makers is doing complex stuff just for the sake of being complex

9
TheRealBillyShakes•

Thank God I learned music before there was Internet.

17
Dickless_50s_Boy•

Yucky yucky yucky. Very discouraging to beginners. He looks like he doesn't know mu ccj either.

16
sickvisionz•

Probably like 75% of "instructional" videos are from people who don't have the knowledge to really make an instructional video and were motivated by another video that was like "I made $10k a month making instructional videos on YouTube and you can too!"

16
Type31•

Absolutely no voice leading technique touched on. The chords jump around like a lamb in spring and sound awful. Not to mention the consistent incorrect spelling of chords. Also, a chord is three notes or more; "two (2)" notes is an interval. This is just the state of music production (not all admittedly) these days. It's a classic example of people wanting to run before they can walk, thinking they can make it big on a buck. Sort of like someone calling themselves a chef when all they know how to make is cheese on fucking toast.

15
aleksfadini•

I disagree. I assumed he didn't use the term voiceleading but that video was all about it. When he "picks cool notes" it's just voice leading in the bass. The economy of motion is quite nice actually. Where do you see jumps in the last Batch of chords (foolishly called Einstein, which is extra silly admittedly)?

-3
[deleted]•

Colund't finish the video, i hate when they do little joke cuts lol.

9
ferniecanto•

[insert "licc" here]

3
natekid•

My biggest gripe is when he generated the lyrics, opened notepad, and then typed the lyrics out instead of copy-paste.

9
hessreindeer•

IT C EQUAL TO THE SQUARE ROOT OF Em THO?

8
HashPram•

I couldn't watch past the first half a minute.

There are many levels of awful in this video of which "the same pizzicato strings that everyone uses at the beginning of their videos to indicate something's happening when I haven't told you anything yet and if I'd only used words I could have got this bit over in half the time and got onto actually teaching you - or, you know what, maybe I'll just cut that bit because it's not really doing anything" is just the beginning.

8
aleksfadini•

But it's not fair to judge if you saw 30 secs.

-2
HashPram•

It's fair to judge the 30 seconds I saw. I saw those 30 seconds, judged them to be a waste of my time and proceeded no further.

1
aleksfadini•

When it comes to music, I try to take my time before judging. There is so much music I have dismissed too hastily and found out was great later.

0
SantaRosaJazz•

If someone serves you an absolutely horrible breakfast, you don’t have to eat the whole thing to know it’s bad.

0
aleksfadini•

The amount of great music that has been judged as bad by rushed ears is astounding.

Ever heard about early Coltrane critics, given your user name?

Music is not like sausage and eggs, it requires dedicated listening to be appreciated. Your comparison doesn't stand.

Also, we should be supportive between musicians, it's a community. Especially for jazz.

1
SantaRosaJazz•

So, your comparing this video to Coltrane. Mmmm, okay. My comment was directed at this video, not music at large.

0
Koringvias•

This looks like pretty much any chord tutorial on youtube, spiced up by some jokes.

I'm curious what you would expect from video like that one tbh.

7
musicianscookbook•

F, G#, C, D#

13
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

Idk I think there’s a lot of great education on YouTube that goes into basic chord function that’s leaps and bounds ahead of this

12
Koringvias•

I would love to see some examples that would be just as easy to understand for a beginner.

0
EmphasisIsImportantOP•
4
Koringvias•

Can't argue against that. Andrew is awesome!

1

In fairness, regardless of how bad the info was, I liked the format/way it was presented.

I can't stand trying to watch a DAW tutorial and listening to some guy with an awful mic take a century to get to the point and i have to set the video to 1.5x speed just so I avoid murdering someone.

*"Okay guys............ So........... welcome back.......... to.... another tutorial................... Now.... before..... we get started............ coughing fit Before we get started........... let's recap.......... what we learnt..... in the last tutorial................"

10
HAMLOL1•

YouTube is full of producerbros trying to teach music theory and when half of them try to explain what a chord in first inversion is, they try to sound smart by using terminology and end up saying that the bass is now playing the second of the chord

6
O1_O1•

Bunch of EDM artists think more lines of notes equal better chords in general, which is only true when you really know about chords and also harmonization. Someone showed me this video a while back after showing me a beat they just made, telling me this video was great for him as he liked music but didn’t know about music theory. Gave him a 15 minute theory class just explaining semi tones, whole notes, notes in general, minor and major scales and how to build triads, guy is a quick learner so after that mini class he made a beat in another 15 to 20 minutes that sounded a lot more clear.

Let’s not discourage people for learning things, whether they’re good or bad it’s a matter of perspective, but if they’re interested in music then give them tools so they can figure out things by themselves.

6