r/Cosmere•
Axerin

Prose or Graphic Novel?

SpoilerWhite Sand

I have finished all the books and short stories in the Cosmere except for White Sand.

I was wondering whether I should read the prose version or the graphic novels instead. There's also the GraphicAudio version (which I have used far for all the other books till now), but I don't know how they have made this one, so I am a bit sceptical about it (any information on that would also be appreciated). Hence, I was looking for ideas and opinions.

I recently heard that there are some changes that have been to the prose version (something about the ending being changed. I don't know any details), and I also noticed some differences in the sample chapters of the Graphic Novel and the few early chapters of the prose version

Please help me decide. I would have loved to read both simultaneously and note the differences etc, but unfortunately I don't have the time for thay as of now and would prefer to read only one version.

Also, please don't spoil anything in the comments and use tags. Thanks

Posted Dec 27, 2019, 3:22 PM UTC

521
jofwu:whitesand:•

The graphic novels are canonical. The prose is not, though it served as the source material. The graphic audio is based on the graphic novel (same script writer) but is fleshed out with narration and extra dialog (drawn from the prose).

The main sentiment among hardcore fans is, I think, that the prose is superior because it feels more like Brandon. His strengths are worldbuilding and magic, and the graphic novels simply don't have as much depth on these fronts. (because of the medium, largely) It's also a very political story, and politics aren't particularly entertaining in graphic novel form. (and can't have as much depth, again because of the medium)

The art is also kind of rough, especially in the first volume. Some people like the style, but most don't. And the main issue is that the art has lots of mistakes. Items that don't fit the worldbuilding. Facial expressions that don't fit the tone of dialog. Things happening that contradict the dialog. This gets better in volume 2. It's much better in volume 3, and the art style in 3 is more appealing (in general) as well.

The differences between prose and graphic novels are mostly small. Ais was changed from a man to a woman, but still had the same story. Lots was cut, all around, obviously. The ending of the graphic novels has some notable tweaks though, and is better in a few ways. (in my opinion) More satisfying at least, and includes a brief additional scene that's very interesting.

There are plans for additional graphic novels that continue the story on Taldain, and I think they're going to be valuable cosmere content. I also think the quality will be better, as White Sand Volume 3 was very promising. I think Brandon's team has a better sense of what they're doing with graphic novels now. So, I think all the people out there who don't like graphic novels are going to have to learn to deal with it... or miss out on good content. And those who only read the prose will, at the very least, need to go read a summary of how volume 3 ended.

Brandon mentioned there will be an omnibus version coming... In the next year or two? which will presumably have all 3 volumes combined. Might be worth waiting for that.

12
AxerinOP•

Thanks. That was super insightful and useful.

So, from what I understand, I will have to read the graphic novel as it is the only canon version. And the prose is optional/additional material if someone wants it.

About buying, I generally get the ebooks (for various reasons), so I think I'll just stick with that for now. But thanks for the heads-up anyway, I didn't know there was going to be an omnibus version in the pipe.

4
liatrisinbloomElsecallers•

An omnibus?! Was that in this year's SotS, or maybe 2018's?

2
jofwu:whitesand:•

This year's SotS:

STATUS: Trilogy complete, likely to do a collection of all three in coming years. Sequel series being outlined.

Guess it's just "likely" here, though I want to say it's been mentioned once or twice elsewhere.

3
liatrisinbloomElsecallers•

fffff

Well I guess the only reason to really freak out would be if the compilation had extra material. But having one book is more convenient than three... In any case, the sequels are cause for more excitement since we'd see Darkside this time.

2
sazed813•

The graphic novel just doesn't feel like Sanderson. I mean it's nice, the art (at least of the first 2) is fantastic, but it feels more like a fan made spinoff in graphic novel form. It also greatly bothers me they had to change artists for #3, but that cant be helped.

This isn't to say it's bad, it just lacks that depth Sanderson gives.

4
AxerinOP•

And are there differences in the storyline like in characters or events ? Is one canon and the other isn't or anything of that sort?

2
szmiiit•

Prose version is not cannon. It can not be bought. It was given away to some people some time ago, before graphic novel was a thing, because it didn't met Sanderson's standards. I don't know if it is still being given away, but it stuck on the internet.

2
AxerinOP•

It's still given away to everyone who signs up for his new letter. That's how I got it. The White Sand Prime is definitely non canon, the prose version is different, he wrote it later. From what I know it's the one that serves as the basis for the Graphic Novel, that's why I am not sure if it is completely non canon.

2
purringlion:kaladin: Kaladin•

I would, personally, just read the prose version because it has a lot more depth to it, then brush up on the differences online. More than 90% of the story is the same and the prose is just a lot more engaging. Also, it's free and if you read on a e-reader, it's pretty convenient.

Edit: everyone made great points, I just wanted to add to them.

4
liatrisinbloomElsecallers•

I have the three graphic novels and am currently reading the prose to see what's up. I haven't experienced the Graphic Audio version so can't comment on it, but each of the other two formats has their strengths and weaknesses.

I like the prose more, but if you're only set on choosing one format for now I would say pick the canon-compliant graphic novels. Maybe at a later point you can read the prose. That's what I did/am doing, I'm taking notes as I read the prose, seeing what worldbuilding was added or changed between versions.

3
Fatikis42:felectrum:•

In my opinion the graphic novels are bad. I tried to read the prose, but they aren't great either.
I would skip it. Nothing of Cosmere significance happens.

3
liatrisinbloomElsecallers•

Nothing of Cosmere significance happens yet! :)

1
Fatikis42:felectrum:•

The story is done! Maybe the next graphic novel series about DarkSide will have something important.
The only important thing about White Sand is the White Sand.

1
liatrisinbloomElsecallers•

Ah, I lump the Dayside/Darkside stories together in my head. So if the Darkside half [Cosmere]>!is fully of juicy stuff like Autonomy making some sort of appearance, or seeing the chain of events that leads Khriss and Baon to becoming worldhoppers and/or Autonomy implementing isolation for Taldain!<, I would be one very happy fan.

2
Fatikis42:felectrum:•

I agree. If we see the isolation of Taldain that could be cool. Maybe even the creation of an Avatar.

2
jmcgit•

I bought the Graphic Audio version. If you like GA, I would certainly recommend it. It's a sort of hybrid between the prose and graphic novel versions, reflecting all the canon changes in the comic. The script is written by the writer of the comic, but used Brandon's text when he can.

The graphic novel had a sort of troubled history, with four artists in three volumes. I didn't really love it at first, to be honest, but the last volume was pretty good.

2
marethyu316•

I really didn't care for the Graphic Audio format, but I think it was more the format in general than the particular production. I think I just prefer traditional audiobooks, so I suspect if you generally like GA, then you'll like White Sand.

1
AxerinOP•

Yes, but GA follows the books (I listened to them while simultaneously reading the books). I am not sure about White Sand though. That's the main thing. Given the length of the GA version seems to work with the length of the prose version, so I think they used that as the base and adapted it.

1
LittleMas42:edgedancers: Edgedancers•

I actually haven't read the graphic novel version, but I LOVED the prose version

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
masoomrana94•

I think the prose works better than the comic book, but the Graphic Audio audiobook version is the definitive version so far. I see people try to put the failures of the comic book on the medium, although atleast 30 different weekly titles work better than that comic book does, not to mention the endless list of comic books that just do excellent work with the worldbuilding and art, and I genuinely believe that the medium has little to do with how poorly done it comes off as. If the graphic audio version script is converted into a novel, which will mostly be an editor's job at this point, rather than Brandon's, it would absolutely be the best outcome. That way, it wouldn't affect his schedule.

1