Are TrackPoints normally wildely different between ThinkPads?

Discussion / Information

I just got a W541 to upgrade from my E485. The TrackPoint on my W541 is god tier and responds exactly where I want it to. When I was on my E485 I absolutely could not use the TrackPoint at all and thought I just wasn't the TrackPoint person even after messing with the sensitivity in Lenovo Vantage. It just doesn't respond the way it does in the W541.

Could this be why so many people absolutely despise TrackPoints and why others swear by them? And is this much difference between TrackPoints normal or did I just get a bad TrackPoint on my E485?

Posted Jan 8, 2020, 5:48 PM UTC

26
ieureP1G2, X230, T25, lots more•

Yes. Just like with every other thing, there are multiple manufacturers and the quality varies wildly.

3

Well there are the trackpoint-cap sizes like normal, low-profile, super-low-profile etc. and they can have different materials.

For me the low-profile trackpoints on the T480, T470, T460 and earlier T***s as well as X-2** up to the x270 fare much better than the super-low-profile trackpoints (all newer models).

As with the keyboards, Lenovo is constantly compromising ergonomics to reach slimmer form factors.

3
waltibaba•

My T420 is god-tier like your W541, but the X270 I got for some travels is terrible - jerky, imprecise, gets stuck etc. My company-issued L380 Yoga is pretty good, quite usable, not perfect but I managed to calibrate it to my needs.

2
vostmarhkX1E2, T420, T43•

My T420's trackpoint is also god-tier and feels identical to the T43. The X1E2 though is not as good, but is still decent with right settings.

2
RomanLegateOPW541•

Obligatory comment to make post public

1
archoverX220 X230 T440p T450s T570•

I notice minor trackpoint differences but luckily I'm able to adapt to them on each use. My T450s trackpoint seems really good.

1