I feel like the future of MMORPGs is in loot shooters and survival games

I think that new genres are evolving to take the elements of MMORPGs that we knew and love without all the nonsense baggage that comes with being a full on MMO. A lot of MMO issues are fundamental core design flaws and a lot of people both fans and haters have innumerable expectations upon hearing a game will be an MMORPG.

The solution in my opinion is not the mostly hopeless upcoming mmos (exceptions: blue protocol, project BBQ, lost ark and maybe new world) but rather new genres becoming popular and taking our favorite elements from MMOs

Loot shooters like Destiny and the Division have brought raids and mmo-styled gear treadmills from MMOs. Online survival games have brought the persistent player driven open worlds full of players from MMOs. There's a growing number of games that let you join your friends for a monster hunt or a dungeon crawl. We've got games like path of exile and warframe for MMO styled economies where you can get rich by taking notes in your econ 101 class or reading Adam Smith.

The point here is that I think the true successor to the MMOs of old that we used to love will likely not be on kickstarter or from one of the greedy major publishers or whatever, but rather we'll find them in Destiny 3 (division 3, anthem 2, etc.) or Ark Survival 2 (Conan 2, Rust 2, etc.) When those franchises evolve to have 100+ players in an area and seamless group content without tab targetting or p2w.

What does r/MMORPG think?

Posted Jan 8, 2020, 9:37 PM UTC

057
JohnnyBGaming•

Nope. The future is multiple directions. Also, people are super confused about survival stuff and it's kinda weird. Collecting stuff to harvest has been in mmos since the beginning. Simply harvesting to build is not "survival".

Mmos will move into pvp turf, virtual reality, aprg styles, and more.

Also, all those potential games you listed... they probably wont be mmos either. They have a particular game style that requires a massive amount of server ticks that would make an mmo too expensive. Mmos are getting better at it, but they arent there yet. Like, look at planetside vs destiny. Planetside does not have the same response and fluidity that destiny does. And that's because destiny isnt an mmo and isnt hosting hundreds of players.

6
devilkingx2OP•

I actually meant that in 2025 or 2030 there won't be any more MMORPGs or nobody will care about them anymore and instead we'll have split off based on our favorite MMO features into various factions.

So my predicted model of the future (do not get too caught up on the specific examples of games or the names I choose to use):

Those who primarily like freedom and sandboxes will be playing "Ark 2" (et al)

Those who primarily care about loot grinds, progression and gear treadmills will be playing "Destiny 3" (et al)

Those who primarily want to hunt bosses and run dungeons with friends or groups of people will be playing stuff like PSO, monster hunter, DDO, the newer soulslikes with more robust co-op options (remnant from the ashes and code vein come to mind), etc.

And finally those who care about economic things like trading and crafting will probably go to POE or Warframe or some other game that has their economic model. People who just need a chatroom for guildies will either also go here due to region chats or use discord on their phones.

People who hate social interaction and other people will finally stop ruining online games with their bullshit (hopefully)

People who love things like tab targetting and the holy trinity... Are fucked? I guess.

0†
DithyrabTibia•

Oh yeah you're 100% right, Anthem 2 is going to be a fackin winner bro. lol

3
devilkingx2OP•

I actually thought about not mentioning that as an example of a looter shooter because the mere idea of that game ever happening would probably inherently turn my post into a troll post lmao.

1
AtisNobDebuffer•

Anthem 3 is where it's at.

0
AtisNobDebuffer•

Loot shooters like Destiny and the Division have brought raids and mmo-styled gear treadmills from MMOs. Online survival games have brought the persistent player driven open worlds full of players from MMOs. There's a growing number of games that let you join your friends for a monster hunt or a dungeon crawl. We've got games like path of exile and warframe for MMO styled economies where you can get rich by taking notes in your econ 101 class or reading Adam Smith.

Neither of them utilized massive multiplayer for anything fun. They use mechanics that are ASSOCIATED with MMOs in some minds but that doesnt make them cousins of MMOs. Just because raids were introduced in MMOs doesnt make raids MMO-specific feature. There was some game that introduced having graphics instead of text and this game falls in some genre, Is having graphics is a feature of this genre?

There is only one MMO-feature - massive multiplayer. If game takes some overwhelming amount of ppl and makes it an integral part of gameplay, its MMO game. With RPG elements its MMORPG. thats it.

Evolving or revolutionizing MMOs by taking massive multiplayer out of them is like advancing games by taking gameplay out of them. Would you like some non-interactive games? Oh wait, we already have names for that: movies, cartoons, comics, books etc.

Multiplayer survivals are just what name implies - survs with many players. Lootershooters are shooters with gear treadmill. MMOs can and should learn from them but not become them because they have different playerbases. Even players who play both, do that for different reasons. If some game will manage to 100% satisfy both crowds - great, but realistically, they better go different ways and only borrow some elements from each other.

3
ScopeLogic•

I really hope not. I can't stand survival games and looter shooters are tipically very shallow.

2
devilkingx2OP•

Why can't you stand survival games?

What do you find shallow about loot shooters?

1
ScopeLogic•

I played a great deal of destiny 1 and 2. Also borderlands. What I found was while I loved the moment to moment fun play, the rpg side just felt very flat. That's not to say all of them would be like this but most studios (anthem excluded) will use destiny as a hallmark for design.

For survival games it comes down to not liking pvp content and or loosing all your equipment. I like pve challenges in mmos like boss mechanics etc etc.

2
devilkingx2OP•

I think borderlands is actually pretty good on the RPG side (once you're high enough level to actually make a build. Thank god borderlands 2 essentially lets you skip the first playthrough now) and so is the division. It was destiny that completely struggled with allowing any ability to build or customize your character/playstyle until recently (shadowkeep).

As for PVE in Survival games I completely 110% agree with you on that front, I can't get into Rust and I hate DayZ. however I think: Ark Survival, Conan Exiles and 7 Days to Die are the ways to go for PVE content. They all have a metric fuckton of things to do without killing a single player.

1
AtisNobDebuffer•

They all have a metric fuckton of things to do without killing a single player.

Like what? Ark: collect dinos, build house, kill bosses. Conan: collect tralls, build house, kill bosses. 7d2d: collect scarce materials, build house, kill weekend hordes.

1
Havesh•

Back around 2003, point & click adventure games turned into action/adventure games, but the fansites that were associated with point & click adventure games didn't evolve into action/adventure fansites for a reason. They died because of it, but there is a point to be made here: The only reason MMORPG-focused sites have tried to 'hang in there' by including other genres of games is because of money, not passion.

Here's another important point: Action/adventure games didn't hang on to the point & click adventure game distinction either.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GravityblastsStar Citizen•

Basically MMORPG's will cease to exist.

2
latin_latinaDebuffer•

Nobody wants a SAO future? VR is still baby right now, but will become king in the mmorpg future.

1
devilkingx2OP•

Even in the SAO universe full dive headsets cost like $10,000. Infinite Dendrogram (anime upcoming) has a similar high price on its full dive VR.

Real life VR costs $1000 for a tiny fraction of the SAO experience.

Basically what I'm saying is that it'll only be the future for rich people if it even happens before 2100

2
latin_latinaDebuffer•

Come to think of it, I don't remember Kirito or his family being particularly that wealthy to be able to afford those easily (but then again there's their dojo and all that).

Here's hoping that VR will keep growing. Though Nostos seemed to have bombed due to it's poor launch, I'm sure games like OrbusVR or even something like Asgard's Wrath will eventually inspire a competent VR mmo in the future.

2
devilkingx2OP•

Well it's an anime so stuff like weird amounts of wealth are common (how many protagonists live alone without needing to work because apparently their parents send them thousands of dollars a month lol)

But considering that a car costs more than that and most families with houses have one, I can imagine that affording one VR headset for their beloved child isn't unreasonable on a credit card... But idk how they afforded two (suguha has one too)

I'm surprised VR came back to life after it died before and as long as it doesn't cause harm I hope it finds the success its fans deserve too! (I doubt full dive is happening though.)

2
AtisNobDebuffer•

I'm sure games like OrbusVR or even something like Asgard's Wrath will eventually inspire a competent VR mmo in the future

How? Adding VR to boring MMO doesnt make it better. VR adds immersion via senses which is important in simulators, adventure games, walkies, porn. MMOs require enjoyable game loop, what can VR do for that?

1
latin_latinaDebuffer•

MMOs require enjoyable game loop, what can VR do for that?

See, this is what's wrong with the current mindset. People want to focus everything on the "gameplay" aspect, forgetting that mmos are supposed to be a perfect mix of socialization and gameplay, which in turn improves the "sense of adventure" and how memorable the experience is. VR allows players to use more senses to control their avatar and world, and this is a huge opportunity for devs to create new kinds of gameplay.

If players just want to focus on the gameplay and nothing else, then they should stick to looter arpgs like Path of Exile to maximize their fun. But that's not how a real mmo is supposed to be.

1
Mage_Girl_91_•

full dive VR would either replace the car as everybody's big purchase made in small payments, or go the smartphone route and you'll get the set for free and be under contract and in exchange they get to borrow some of the parts of your brain processing power you're not using to run the network or mine for bitcoin or whatever

2
AtisNobDebuffer•

Nobody wants a SAO future? VR is still baby right now, but will become king in the mmorpg future.

SAO was soooo "cool" that it wasnt possible to make an interesting series about it without turning it into generic isekai. Now look how actually cool stories about EvE sound when you cut non-eventful months of in-between: large battles, coups, clan dramas. The game, that makes you feels regularly like that, would be revolution, while a usual grinder in full-VR will stay a usual grinder.

1
latin_latinaDebuffer•

Well all I can say is that whoever handles SAO has a lot of opportunities to create a (maybe) lucrative mmorpg, there's so many SAO fans out there. Instead, every SAO game is a freaking single player RPG or a limited multiplayer game. It makes no sense whatsoever.

1
AtisNobDebuffer•

SAO has a lot of opportunities to create a (maybe) lucrative mmorpg, there's so many SAO fans out there

Nope. SAO fans mostly dont even aware what they want. They watched/read isekai but think of it as game. Then they get pissy about devs who dont give them new world. But SAO itself didnt work without actual lifes at stake. Try imagining SAO as normal game, without real deaths or "stuck in game" trope. It would be just watching main character farming some mobs, with him in fullVR but without you being in fullVR. Thats exactly what you get in SAO games - killing mobs and watching someone else (not you) using cool VR tech.

Instead, every SAO game is a freaking single player RPG or a limited multiplayer game. It makes no sense whatsoever.

Thats what they can do - normal games with SAO looks.

1
SluttyEnrii•

Now look how actually cool stories about EvE sound when you cut non-eventful months of in-between: large battles, coups, clan dramas. The game, that makes you feels regularly like that, would be revolution, while a usual grinder in full-VR will stay a usual grinder.

Meanwhile, actually playing Eve if you don't already enjoy eve is a complete bore. I love hearing about those big battles as much as the next, but without those big battles and what not.. Eve online would be extremely boring to hear about.

Most people who play eve are either also in big positions what makes corp drama and what not real. Just remember vilerat, dude died in benghazi. And any eve player back then will tell you he was a big name in the eve world.

SAO would've been an interesting anime even without the 'full dive' aspect, Full dive aspect just made it into a more modern .hack... With a stupid 'if you die you die for real'

1
AtisNobDebuffer•

Its not "Meanwhile", thats exactly what I said: revolution would be to cut on timesinks, not on monitors and mice.

Full dive aspect just made it into a more modern .hack... With a stupid 'if you die you die for real'

No, its a more modern isekai i.e. "stuck in different world". With real death and no logoff, nothing significant says "its a game" in SAO. Even second part about new game was centered at one stuck player.

1
ticytictoc•

People like trash mmos which is the problem. If you and your friends rather play a survival game or loot shooter, go ahead you will only help the mmo genre.

1
IsilithTehroth•

Unforunately survival genre while adding needed things like fps combat, sandbox building and pvp anywhere all suffer from raid and rebuild syndrome and any survival game claiming to be a mmorpg is just lying(Atlas and New world).

1
devilkingx2OP•

We don't know what New World is yet because we don't know anything about it. It could be an MMO.

Atlas is a garbage game in general it's not anything.

Playing on a popular Ark Server definitely feels like playing an MMO to me back when I had a good server with 50-70 players on at once all the time.

1
IsilithTehroth•

We do know what New World is ;D and it really keeps the same core principals survival games have, but its going into more of a pve direction, which is a death sentence for survival games.

0
devilkingx2OP•

If you look at the most popular and successful (at least in their time) online survival games:

Ark Survival Evolved (heavy PVE and single player elements)

Conan Exiles (heavy PVE and single player elements)

Rust

DayZ

(Honorable Mentions: 7 Days to Die, Minecraft, H1Z1, Citadel Forged with fire, atlas, dark and light, Fallout 76)

It's actually really really common for them to have a PVE focus and currently the most successful one (Ark) also has the most PVE out of all of them basically. Most people would actually want or enjoy more PVE elements in all of the existing survival games from what I've seen.

So I think New World is stepping in the right direction

1
AtisNobDebuffer•

It's actually really really common for them to have a PVE focus

Collection focus. Most time ppl spend in Ark pve is on getting some rare dino, then another one. Same with named tralls in Conan. Rust is all about PVP, DayZ took off as game about not dying for a mere hours, AFAIR.

I would enjoy more PVE in Ark but i'm not sure its realistic. What elements would you add that fit current game?

1
Jahsay•

It's not in looter shooters unless they massively improveme. Games like Destiny just do not feel like a massive meaningful persistent world.

I think the future is in more sandbox type games that are more than just glorified daily quest/dungeon runners theme park MMOs we get these days. MMOs like New World and Ashes of Creation which do things differently are where I see the genre going.

1
devilkingx2OP•

There's this one mission in Destiny 2: Shadowkeep where you're assaulting a fortress, the titular shadowkeep (it's the first mission of that campaign).

The mission automatically matches you with numerous other players throughout the mission so as you're playing it really feels like the guardians are assaulting the moon. As there's constant fighting all around you and other people helping you with the mission

I think all Destiny 2 needs to feel like a full on MMO at this point is larger amounts of players in an area. Let there be 100 people (or at least dozens) on a planet at a time and it'll be as much of an MMO as any other.

1
Jahsay•

The problem is the game just isn't designed that way right now at all for a true MMO feel. The areas are way too small, they're all segmented into so many different zones, very little social interaction, only one real city, no real presence of guilds, etc. The entire time I've played I have never even interacted with anyone or heard or encountered any clans. It just does not have much of an MMO feel at all. It isn't as simple as just putting in a bunch of players in the zones and calling it a day.

2
devilkingx2OP•

You are correct that Destiny still has a few major steps to take to become a full on MMO, it's sooo hard to find a clan or a group to do the non-matchmade activities and why the hell can't you even chat or recruit in game, it's so dumb.

2
Havesh•

If that's the case, then either r/MMORPG should cease to be, and other subreddits dedicated to those genres should take up the mantle, or r/MMORPG should change its name, because at that point it's false advertising.

1
[deleted]•

I have yet to play a good looter shooter.

1
devilkingx2OP•

Every Destiny game becomes good a year after release for the low low cost of $120

All of the borderlands games are pretty solid

The division 1&2 are good if you can get over the lack of sci-fi or fantasy (it's too grounded which makes it hard to get into for me)

1
The_Venomous_Kid•

Red Dead online is way better then any Mmorpg I have ever played. I could care less about loot shooters and survival but Rockstar has put out a nice sandbox with a mix of everything. I'm also looking at New World that is a mix bag but was fun in alpha minus the drop everything on death crap.

1
devilkingx2OP•

Isn't red dead online really bad? I heard it was awful.

0
The_Venomous_Kid•

Has it's bugs but it is a roleplay paradise. Nowhere near the fallout 76 bugs but there are some. People today love to hate anything that is not perfect but I encounter a couple bugs a day and it's not the end of the world for me. It is the most demanding game to date but it's also the best online world ever created in my eyes and they are just getting started.

1
lockmasterg•

I think there is still room for theme park mmos. I would kill for a Harry Potter type mmo. My problem is I hate kickstarters and announcing games years ahead of release. By the time it releases hype is usually gone . I think more games will be like diablo 4 and others where its seems like a solo or co op type game but converge in places with many players all killing big boss types. Small personal encounters is what I like.

0
devilkingx2OP•

I think the problem with kickstarter games is not announcing too early, it's announcing an idea AND THEN starting to work on it. I learned that shit is dumb when I was like 13 and programmed a calculator but needed to constantly cut functions I couldn't understand how to program (like logarithms, exponents and square roots)

I can tell you for a fact that most of those games didn't test their ideas before announcing them:

shout out to chronicles of elyria wanting persistent destructable environments in an open world

and star citizen thinking that people will be okay with easily losing their $10,000 ships (or that free players will be okay with permanently being the underclass to the rich people with invincible $10,000 ships)

1
Noobzilla_Gaming_YTMMORPG•

shout out to chronicles of elyria wanting persistent destructable environments in an open world

Chronicles of Elyria wants a lot of things though. Let's see if they can deliver.

2
devilkingx2OP•

As much as I like that game's ideas, it is literally Star Citizen except not a scam. Elyria is chock full of plans that won't survive contact with the enemy imo.

2
IsilithTehroth•

CoE is definately a scam, they litterally have NOTHING to show. Star citizen, Crowfall, Camelot unchained all have half-assed unfinished terrible messes and overboated scope and more than likely won't release for 5+years, but at least they have terrible games to scam you for your money.

2
AtisNobDebuffer•

If MMO cant fly without novelty hype, was it sustainable MMO to begin with?

1