These two have similar plots and even have an very similar scene involving a forest

Posted Feb 28, 2020, 3:31 AM UTC

Posted Feb 28, 2020, 3:31 AM UTC
So they are mutants and travel to the space bc a phone call from a direct line? And aliens with no personality try to kill the girl
It about a red headed girl with psychic powers which she has trouble controlling due to having anger issues(as a result of the trauma of losing a parent) and tries to avoid hurting people.
There are some plot beats I won’t spoil.
You right, it sounds like dark phoenix
It pretty much is. Re-watching Dark Phoenix or re-reading the comic or even re-watching the old X-Men cartoon will give you the same story in a much better form.
Sophia Lillis could probably be a solid Hope Summers.
I can see it.
And they both deviate greatly from the comic, although it isn't a bad thing for "I am not OK with this"
Dark Phoenix is a lot closer to the comics than fans realize. It was based on the build up issues from Uncanny X-Men #100-134 and Jean’s origin story, rather than the actual Dark Phoenix arc. It really just gets the villains wrong.
Yeah I get that but their were so many changes, as there were for the entire film universe. Kind of worked for the film, but the comic storyline is a hundred times better. The Netflix show is better than the Phoenix movie
I noticed that from the trailer. All it did was make me want to re-watch Dark Phoenix again.
So, you're saying that I should avoid this series?
I recently reread Uncanny X-Men #100-138. I don’t understand hate from the fanbase for the movie other than getting the villains wrong.
It's not just about getting the villains wrong. It's about getting the characters and the plot wrong. The dark Phoenix is something that they should have worked up to. It's something that is supposed to be an emotional voyage for the viewer as well as the characters. You're supposed to feel for Scott and Jean, when they're forced to make the hard choices. In the movie you don't feel that connection because you've only spent two movies with them. It's more of a story about Charles, Erik, and Raven, which the original never was.
It also feels like a very small movie. In the comics the X-Men are introduced to a wider world. They're taken to other planets, meet alien races, and have the final battle on the blue area of the moon. By cheaping out and having the majority of the movie take place on Earth, you don't get that same sense of wonder and the resulting emotional impact isn't nearly the same.
Where is what a lot of fans don’t realize about the movie: it was originally titled Phoenix and it’s purpose was to work up to Dark Phoenix. Fox cancelled the sequel and rebranded Dark Phoenix.
Jean in the movie doesn’t act like the Dark Phoenix. She acts like Jean in the comic after she become Phoenix with her being afraid of her own power and slowly becoming aggressive over time.
At the end of the movie where she embraces her power and flies off into space is the moment where she became the Dark Phoenix. That ending parallels Uncanny X-Men #135. Here is a comparison:
https://jimmy-o-face.tumblr.com/post/188601312147/dark-phoenix-40th-anniversary-tribute-comic
I can appreciate where you're coming from and why you enjoyed this movie. However, I actually was aware of this, and it doesn't change the fact that the movie we got was an inferior product. You can only judge the movie by what was released, not what could have been. The fact that it was supposed to be two movies, instead of one, only makes it worse. The things that had to be cut, or stitched together, makes it a less compelling whole.
I also want to address this because that isn’t really true.
Mystique was just a plot device to get Jean grief-stricken. Like how the Jean accidentally caused the “deaths” of the X-Men and her grief lead to her being manipulated by Mastermind in the comic.
Charles’ role in the movie is exactly the same as it was in the original story in that he didn’t help Jean with her grief. That is why she had blamed him for the events of Dark Phoenix.
Magneto doesn’t even show up until half way through the movie and his role is nothing but a subplot to prevent second sag.