[Serious] The rise of pseudo-doctors and the bastardization of patient safety: A timeline

Serious

Nurse Practitioner timeline: The first Nurse Practitioner (NP) program appeared in 1965 at the University of Colorado. In1979, there were an estimated 15,000 NPs in the United States. 20 years later, there were approximately 68,300 NPs in the US. In 2009, 10 years later, the number doubled again to 130,000. In 2019, 54 years after the first school was established, the number of nurse practitioners reached 270,000. Over this same time period from 1965 to 2019 (54 years), the number of NP schools exploded to over 400 institutions. It is difficult to ascertain how many programs there truly are depending on which accrediting organization you query. For example, one search of the American Association of Colleges of Nursing returned over 1,000+ nurse practitioner programs. Of these programs, over 200 are offered entirely online in the form of 18-month programs with no prior nursing experience. Each of these programs have nebulous graduation requirements. At the minimum, 500 clinical hours are required to graduate. At this point, NPs are expected to practice independently according to several aggressive efforts by the American Association of Nurse Practitioners (AANP).

Physician timeline: In 1765 (200 years before the first NP school was formed), the University of Pennsylvania was established as the first medical school in the United States. 255 years later, there are 136 US MD schools in the US accredited by the LCME. In 1892, A.T. Still University was established as the first US osteopathic medical school. 128 years later, there are 36 US DO schools in the US accredited by COCA. Throughout this period, the rigors of medical school and standards have increased. In 1972, the LCGME (currently known as the ACGME), which oversees post-graduate residency training, was formed to guarantee the standardization of residency training programs. A rigorous 4-part licensing examination was introduced to both the MD and DO professions, including a clinical skills portion with standardized patients. In an effort to further standardize education, the American Osteopathic Association (AOA) and the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) merged the residency training programs for MDs and DOs. In order to become “board-certified” in a particular specialty, a minimum of 3-years of post-graduate residency training is required. Some specialties require up to 7-years of post-graduate training. After completion of this training program, individuals must pass a specialty board examination before they can call themselves “board-certified.” Most recently, California introduced a law requiring a minimum of 3-years post-graduate training in an ACGME residency program before allowing individuals to practice independently.

Over the past 200+ years, physicians (MD and DO) have continued to raise the bar on their standards to practice medicine in the United States. Consistently, the training requirements have increased, the number of hours has increased, the number of tests has increased, the amount of continuing medical education has increased, and the expectations have increased. Patient safety was used to justify these ballooning requirements. In 1/4 of the time (50+ years), the number of Nurse Practitioner schools has eclipsed the number of medical schools in the US. However, the requirements to become an NP have actually gone down, their authority to practice has gone up, and now they are pushing for the same practice rights (and compensation) as physicians.

Is patient safety no longer a priority?

That being said, I OPPOSE HB 607 being proposed in Florida to increase practice authority of Nurse Practitioners. Please contact your local senators and congressman. Please financially support your local political action committees (PACs) to fight scope of practice laws. Next, we must lobby politicians to introduce bills that standardize NP education and that limits the scope of NPs in states that have already passed full practice authority laws.

Posted Feb 29, 2020, 12:19 AM UTC

58047
misters0l0d0l0•

Honestly fuck it.

Let's keep trying to fight for physician only independent practice rights but if the government is that stupid and let's people with 500 clinical hours practice independently we tried our best.

When the abysmal outcomes pile up, the NPs will want to come back to dependent practice and get sued under our licenses rather than there's and we will decline as we don't want that risk. We will keep our PA best friends at our sides.

If they end up not destroying healthcare and everything is okay and cheaper with them maybe that means our path was inefficient.

I think option A will be the case but fuck it. We tried our best and these morons will have let it happen.

202
1badls2goat_v2M-4•

Sorry but a defeatist attitude is not appropriate, given that lives are on the line, and people we all know and love may be affected or harmed by this when they go for healthcare visits and end up seeing midlevels who may miss diagnoses or misdiagnose them and mistreat their conditions. As a med student I have had the privilege of being listened to when I've fought on several occasions to see only the physician and not his/her NP or PA. I have even argued with the whore physicians who hire these people for their private practices (yes, that's right, not just in hospitals, this scourge is in private offices across the nation now) and actually let them independently see patients, telling them I flat out refuse to see anyone but them (the doctor) and if that's a problem I'll find someone else.

We have a hard-earned privilege of being med students and knowing what kind of damage these people can do. But I shudder when I see all the nice, less-educated folks who work at the hospital or visit the hospital and call me "doctor" even when I don't have my white coat on (they can still see my badge/lanyard, but I'm just doing research right now rather than rotations). Even during M3, nice patients would say "oh you're close enough, I'll call you doctor." This was always sweet but it made me shudder to think of the potentially lethal consequences they may face for being so lax and ignorant in their knowledge of what counts as a real physician and what doesn't.

So, please, let's not give up. We need people to speak loudly and fight the harpies who are trying to complain and whine until they get independent practice rights and equivalent pay. Fuck them. Everybody wanna be a doctor, don't nobody wanna lift no heavy-ass course packs and malpractice insurance.

edit: Oh yeah, one more thing is at risk besides innocent lives: our livelihoods. Doctors already make like half of what they used to make in the late 90s, before adjusting for inflation, and even less than that when adjusted for inflation. No way in hell I'm gonna sit around and accept that these fucks can cut into our already-dwindling paychecks. I'm not part of the crew of med students who keep naively stating "yeah well 200-300k is still good money, so we shouldn't complain." No, it's not, considering where the profession's salaries were just 20 years ago and how med school costs have SKYROCKETED. Fuck. That.

122
[deleted]•

[deleted]

59
1badls2goat_v2M-4•

True. Doctors are also particularly stubborn and, once in practice as attendings, the become super fucking lazy and complacent and just roll with life's punches because they've been trained from day 1 of med school to be spineless. As always it will be up to the few who are willing to be vocal. Good news is that all it takes is a will to do something, and talking to representatives and putting together well-researched arguments should be a top priority for anyone who still remotely resembles a vertebrate.

26
bala7799MD•

The only way to win is the make a statement. Not a written statement but a bold statement based on actions. For example, all physicians at a large medical center in a major city just give their resignation at the same time. Of course, it is unlikely but if you pay their salary for 1-2 years afterwards it may be successful. Just guarantee the surgeons who resign 3-400k per year until they secure another position. Meanwhile, the hospital where they were working is out a surgeon. Multiple surgeons. And once that hospital system is destabilized, move onto the next. You would probably need about a 1- 2 billion dollar fund to make this happen which is probably not hard to do.

3
OMyCoddMD-PGY1•

Look at all the mass shootings in our country. I would call those tragic and we have yet to learn from those so even then we struggle to react in a positive way. I live in Milwaukee so the topic is currently relevant here but I’m sure we will brushed under the rug again by the end of next week until the next shooting happens

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9

Wouldn't you say that health insurance itself is the root of most of these evils? Time to go nuclear and institute a different way of doing things. Always follow the money to see who is to blame.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PhysicianPepperMD-PGY3•

It's not time to throw in the towel. Not just yet. We need you now more than ever, cadet.

Forward unto dawn!

113
Dandy-WalkerM-4•

No. Poor outcomes will occur, and the public will blame the public face of the healthcare system, physicians. It will only worsen the problem.

Even more likely, poor outcomes will happen and biased research will be published that manages to obfuscate those outcomes. Dont underestimate the power of money to overpower truth.

90
stresseat4lyfeM-0•

This.

12
Ceramic-Bowl•

Truth? Your entire post is speculation. Talk about biased

-10
[deleted]•

The public won’t even know or care when their outcomes suffer.

Even if evidence comes out that people are being hurt (if that study even is allowed to be published) there would be an uprising of the nurses union and it would be discredited or at least people wouldn’t know what to believe.

Also, people outside of Medicine have a hard time distinguishing the difference between us and mid levels. And even if they can, if they like their NP, they will just assume they have a “good nurse practitioner.”

People care more about feeling like they are receiving care, than actually receiving the best care. And moreover, they cannot tell the difference.

This is the reality. The truth won’t matter.

13
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
omae-wa-mou-•

I’m getting my prereqs done for nursing school to get my RN and eventually get my NP. i’ve done some research but i’m by no means an expert on this. that being said, don’t NPs also go through very vigorous, intensive training after nursing school? correct me if i’m wrong but i thought that was why they have almost as much “authority” (hate that word in this context but for lack of a better word...) as doctors do?

edit: also if NPs and MDs/DOs are required to take the same ceus, classes, etc while keeping their respective scope of responsibilities the same, wouldn’t that more or less “fix” the issue? (also just clarifying, i don’t believe NPs should be able to practice as extensively as doctors do of course, but they are advanced practice nurses and should have considerable authority in the healthcare field).

59
misters0l0d0l0•

I’m getting my prereqs done for nursing school to get my RN and eventually get my NP. i’ve done some research but i’m by no means an expert on this. that being said, don’t NPs also go through very vigorous, intensive training after nursing school? correct me if i’m wrong but i thought that was why they have almost as much “authority” (hate that word in this context but for lack of a better word...) as doctors do?

I hope nobody downvotes you, because you're just asking a question, but here is your answer.

Edit; thanks guys for bringing this person back to neutral <3

No. Their education is less rigorous than a lot of our undergraduate course-work, even. Biochemistry Orgo in college was more rigorous than the pathophysiology courses some NP schools offer.

I have 3 friends in 3 different NP programs and they're inconsistent and all in far far less detail than medical school goes into. They also spend a lot of time on "nursing theory."

PAs go through rigorous education, and we all clearly recognize that. Not so much NPs. They absolutely should be spending their time improving their education, not fighting for independent practice rights.

I recommend you go to PA school instead of NP school. We all hope NP schools bring their education up to PA standards, at least. They certainly are not there yet.

225
omae-wa-mou-•

thanks for clearing this up guys, it really helped to get some perspective! also thanks for not being rude about it either, really appreciate that lol. i’m not 100% set on anything after nursing school, but i’m definitely gonna continue researching! best of luck to all of you :)

54
TheOneTrueNolanoMD-PGY1•

Just keep an open mind and do what you think will bring you the most happiness. Everyone has an opinion.

For instance, my opinion is that nursing is actually a killer backdoor premed major. Med schools love people with clinical background and if you like healthcare, do nursing, and then realize you want to run the show, consider going to Med school. Every MD I’ve met who was an RN first was stronger for it. Honestly in a more rational world I think we’d see tons more nursing become doctors. It seems like a natural progression to me.

Just my 2c.

61
WholeHandTechnique•

I also feel similar about EMT / Paramedicine. I was an EMT for over a decade before medical school and it has helped a lot.

10
oncoconut•

I totally agree. If I were to re-do my pre-med life, I would have definitely gone into nursing before med school. Job security, flexibility, ability to accrue savings prior to med school and even during if you pick up locum shifts.

8
DntTouchMeImSterileM-3•

I’m sorry but I have to disagree with you on the PA school point. Let me start by saying there are many very competitive programs that draw from applicant pools of people with extensive healthcare backgrounds, who get good educations, and will make great contributions to healthcare.

However, the issue remains that the quality of programs varies VASTLY and that’s the main issue we need to focus on in our criticism Mx For example, I have a few friends from undergrad who are currently in/graduated PA school, they have biology degrees (little/no clinical applicability like a nursing degree would provide), they met the absolute minimum requirements of “clinical hours” by getting a CNA certificate and working for a few months on a part time basis, and then go to a two year program with no direct patient care in the first year, and a second clinical year in which half of their “rotations” are just shadowing.

Granted, these are “low-end” programs but the fact remains that these people will be soon graduating with masters degrees and as far as anyone else knows will be PA-Cs.

So these people essentially skate by with very little clinical knowledge and very little clinical experience yet will be out there with a pretty big responsibility to patients. This just cannot happen and we cannot stand for it as healthcare providers. People at all levels of healthcare from nurses, NPs, other PAs, residents and physicians should be outraged by this as its an insult to every one of them.

12
robijeHealth Professional (Non-MD/DO)•

While I somewhat agree that a lot of PA schools are cropping up, please note that the ARC-PA accrediting body is universal for ALL PA programs and holds these programs up to high standards. If a program isn’t meeting standards and doesn’t make detailed changes that meet said standards when ARC PA returns, the program will shut down.

I think it’s unfair to say that we get “no clinical experience” our first year either. While it’s true there are no clerkships, I spent my first year doing a lot of sim work, learning and testing out on portions of the physical exam, passing multiple OSCE’s and sat in PBL (problem based learning) courses every single week where you work through patient cases in a small group led by an advisor.

Rotations vary extremely depending on your geographic location, hospital affiliation and preceptors. It also varies by STUDENT based on how much initiative they take as far as asking to see patients on their own and come back with an A/P. I do agree this is the one part of PA school that needs the most work as far as standardization across the country. I had 15 months of rotations, worked my ass off and ended up with close to 5000 clinical hours which is well above average. Just wanted to share that last piece to make people aware there are plenty of students that don’t just “shadow.”

  • new grad PA-C homie sticking up for their profession who supports the heck out of docs for all the time/money/effort/bullshit they go through
13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
bala7799MD•

The nursing backround does not lend itself to disease management, clinical diagnosis and critical thinking.
PAs take advanced science courses with lab applicability which is necessary for the academic rigor necessary to critically think about problems . Nurses follow algorithms and dont learn how to think critically. This is the main problem with advanced practice nursing. They do not have foundation

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-22
RedditName12MBBS-Y5•

"likely worse" lol, try definitely.

8
[deleted]•

In this magical world of yours where we eliminate all doctors and have NPs perform surgery...

Why would AI eliminate the doctors? Wouldn’t we just have less of a need for medical professionals and be able to eliminate the less qualified people (NPs and PAs)?

This of course ignores the fact that AI will take over just about everything before we give it the responsibility of diagnosing patients. We cannot even reliably use AI to read EKGs yet.

8
IridescentOslerMD-PGY1•

I am also a nursing student trying to get NP.

They seriously let people who drive school buses while high (and have zero fucking remorse) and a documented DUI into nursing school these days? Jesus fucking christ...

​

That's about it, I am not anymore. I was a school bus driver (got a DUI about 3 months ago, not convicted yet, but my boss found out and let me go) for a couple years, I am only 23, and I would smoke weed before driving several days per week, for both morning and afternoon routes.

My DUI was in my own car, but it was after I had been smoking while doing a shuttle trip for a fraternity. But I never got caught in a bus, or by my work (cop called all the bus garages, saying they arrested a driver, my work asked if it was me, I said yes), so I basically got away with transporting hundreds of children to and from school while legally impaired.

I have been driving drunk/high/twisted on various drugs for several years. Never any major consequences except the current DUI, which sucks, but is seriously under-representative of my actual criminal behaviors. I regret telling the cop the truth, that I had been smoking, but other than that, I can't say I feel guilty or remorseful.

Obviously I was playing with fire. It obviously caught up with me to some extent. But I have not received punishment commensurate with the amount of criminality I have engaged in. Idk. Hate me if you want. No one got hurt except me and my immediate family from the stress of incarceration.

https://www.reddit.com/r/confession/comments/bt0953/i_drove_a_school_bus_high_for_months/

4
Contemplate321•

Yes. They obviously didn't check my reddit posts.

0
OrneryNervesMD-PGY1•

I worked as an RN for several years before medical school. My spouse is a nurse practitioner. The training isn’t anywhere near the same. Not even close. NP school can be challenging for some but I wouldn’t call it rigorous at all. People work full time while becoming a nurse practitioner. That would not be humanly possible through medical school/residency. I do not mind working with PAs and NPs. I of course have great respect for my spouse. But even she would freely admit the level of knowledge and training are on different playing fields.

80

If it will give you some perspective the “500 clinical hours” needed to graduate nursing school is about 5 weeks on a surgery rotation. So you need about 1 total month of 3rd year of medical school training to graduate.

For starters that’s absolutely insane on general surgery to destroy my will like that, but it gives an idea that medical school is hard and residency is even tougher

68
pleasedontkillanyoneMD-PGY1•

That’s would you would think but, no. They do not go through rigorous training after nursing school.

28
dav1dpuddy•

I have been a RN for a little over 5 years. Little over 2 in the ICU, and I'm currently in an ACNP program. My schooling is a joke. Ultimately I'll have 875 hours of clinicals as a NP through my program, but the only classes of any substance are advanced patho, pharm, and health assessment, which I havent started yet. I wish schooling was better but unfortunately it's only getting worse right now. Maybe one day.

27
jbBUM-4•

What level of training are your professors? ANP, DNP, MD, PhD? Just curious.

5
dav1dpuddy•

So far it's been mostly DNPs. Im curious to know what it will be for pharm and patho

3

An easy way to see for yourself if the training is equal is to take a practice board exam. Every physician is required to pass these exams before being allowed to practice. It's not perfect, but it's a decent yardstick.

19
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
DrDavidGreywolf•

You asked a question so here’s one for you. Why? Why bother doing all of that if you want to practice, why not just become a physician?

3
omae-wa-mou-•

because np school is 1) less expensive, 2) easier, and 3) less time-consuming than med school

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MatrimofRavensM-1•

This almost feels bait.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
omae-wa-mou-•

i clearly stated above that i was looking for answers/clarification bc i know next to nothing about it and yet people like you still want to chalk it up to something it for sure isn’t. get off reddit and study

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dbdank•

Bottom line, physicians need to stick up for themselves before this becomes a bigger problem. A law giving them more autonomy won’t be reversed. By doing nothing you’re enabling them.

41
IRWizardOP•

HB 607 has not been enacted yet. That’s why we have to resist it NOW

13
dbdank•

My program director now refuses to allow midlevels to rotate with us at all. “Advanced care provider” is not a thing. You’re a nurse

17
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
mjshooterM-1•

While I understand there is a massive difference in education and training hours, I have two questions.

  1. With the massive shortage of PCPs, and many of the NPs helping fill this hole, will this bill make a actually affect physicians that significantly? And will it improve the care of underserved populations?

  2. Is there any evidence showing the difference in training results in a tangible detriment to the patients? I've only read one meta-analysis (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK384613/) which basically says there is no significant difference in patient outcomes between NP and MD. Now the studies are small and very inconclusive, but it's all I've seen and I'd be happy if someone could provide other papers.

Tl;dr Yes I'm salty the road I chose is longer and more difficult to reach the same conclusion as the easier NP route, but is there any data to prove the long road is any better for the patients?

-5†
KingPrudienMD-PGY1•

I suggest you comb through that paper you posted. A lot of the evidence is of low quality and inconclusive which the authors acknowledge. Read some of the papers which were included. It does not give any justification for independent practice.

29
mjshooterM-1•

I suggest you comb through the rest of my comment I posted because that's exactly my point. I'm asking if anyone has evidence. That meta showed nothing, and I feel like our defense would be a lot stronger if there was definitive evidence showing MD outcomes were significantly better than NP.

-16
KingPrudienMD-PGY1•

The issue with that is the amount of NPs practicing at the level of a physician. A lot of midlevels get the easier and low complexity cases. I doubt there is a way to get good numbers on that information of consistent comparison of midlevels taking on the same complexity cases.

Also no need to sound condescending with your comment to comb through your post.

14
mjshooterM-1•

And that was mentioned in the one paper, but the point was brought up on ER docs vs NP because there is much more randomness in distribution of cases, but that was a small study and showed insignificant differences. But there has to be data out there or a way to get it, otherwise our case is as good as lost. NP presents that meta to naive politicians and says the MD program is out of date, overpriced, and inefficient, and we have no evidence to refute with. May as well pass it now. Point being, we are an evidence based profession, yet unfortunately I haven't seen a single piece of evidence being used to fight this movement. If it's there and I just didn't see it, please direct me to it.

Was quoting you, try not to be so condescending yourself next time.

-13
IRWizardOP•

All the papers in the meta analysis were published by special interest groups with low quality observational data. No true RCT has been performed. All high quality data shows that mid levels make poorer quality referrals, order more imaging, and do more biopsies.

Intuitively though and through my anecdotal experience, there’s absolutely NO way an NP can provide care at the level of an MD. They can be nicer to patients and convince them that they’ve provided top care but they just don’t know what they don’t know.

We have a saying in radiology: “you see what you look for and you recognize what you know”

They don’t even know what to look for.

13