So lets theorycraft over/talk about PVE. How can Amazon make it good in light of the PVP changes?

:NW-DISC:Discussion

Personally when I first heard about this game I was hoping for a PVE experience as robust as games like 7 Days to Die, Conan Exiles and Ark Survival Evolved, etc. But now it seems like they're more like PVE Rust, which sounds like a terrible game on both sides.

What do you guys hope for in terms of New World PVE? What does the game need to be good/succeed? We all know that survivals and sandboxs and MMOs can be great without PVP despite all of those being associated with it. But will New World be one of them?

Posted Mar 2, 2020, 12:36 AM UTC

020
TheGladex•

Wouldn't really call any of the games you mention "Robust PvE experiences". Ark and Conan are pretty bad, unimmersive grind with mediocre UIs and repetetive content that mostly boils down to holding left click. Conan is a bit better in that regard but it still doesn't do anything extraordinary that would make the game worth while IMO.

I honestly think New World needs to be delayed. I cannot see the game providing a fun and meaningful PvE experience when their PvE content has only been in the oven for a year.

WoW and FFXIV take 2 years to release big content expansions that are worthwhile for players to explore, and they already have the frameworks needed to support this sort of content. New World however doesn't. At most it will have some open world bosses and collectables to find in the world (and depending on how well those are integrated, this might not even end up worthwhile).

Any video game lives or dies based on it's launch. If a launch is bad, people leave, game doesn't get funded, development ceases. Once the game fails in that regard, you need something big and game changing to bring the game back.

This can go one of few ways:
-They actually managed to pull off a satisfying gameplay loop that can retain players for the first few months while updates roll out.
-They haven't and will release on the date currently planned, game will lose players in the first few months and will likely go free to play within a year
-They will delay the game and add more content before release allowing for a smooth PvE launch

5
devilkingx2OP•

The thing about Ark is that official servers are balanced for a 10 man tribe on a 100 player server. It's more fun at higher rates because you spent more of your time playing with dino and item mechanics than punching trees.

I don't think anything they could possibly do would make New World into the kind of game that the big 4 are. They'd be more likely to turn New World into Diablo on an island than that.

If new world is to save itself they need high mileage content, the kind of stuff with high replay value yet low developer effort.

1
Common-Scientist•

Without going to much into the PvP vs PvE rant, I personally would like to see a level based system that doesn't involve rushing to max level to be competitive.

My rose-colored glasses shine on the days of MUDs and my favorites always had a progression system with a "legend" level (usually around level 30 for those games), with the abilitiy to progress to level 100 or such. The difference was, character stat growth drastically dropped after legend, so that even after you were big enough for end game content, you had a reason to grind. Levels after legend tended to take significantly longer obtain and have maybe 1/10th of what a normal level's growth so that people who spent a lot of time on their character had a numerical advantage over others, but in the context of those games it was never enough to assure victory. Such a system may sound convoluted but it worked extremely well at incorporating new players/characters into endgame content while giving older players something to strive for.

People unfamiliar with the concept may think it sounds unfair or require heavy time investment but it's quite the opposite. It was a great system that let you be competitive early, while still rewarding long hours of play in a way that was never required of you.

2
devilkingx2OP•

Actually I don't think anyone would be unfamiliar with that concept nowadays! Bethesda did it in skyrim and fallout 4 and fallout 76. I like the idea of leveling up forever or at least long past where you need to. I remember when korean MMOs would have a level 200 cap and endgame would start at like 100 or 120. (Maplestory and Cabal Online come to mind)

The issue would be balancing it between feeling like a pointless grind to pad out the game and making an insurmountable grind wall based power gap

2
Common-Scientist•

Glad to hear that concept is still around! Always enjoyed the MUDs but they just don't captivate as well 20 years later.

1
CogitoErgoSumGod•

Yeh, wow does it with pvp scaling too

1
Duhtest101•

The pve is slightly lacking as the only thing you can really do currently is gather/harvest and craft over and over to level up your skill. So really all that’s holding someone back is time to catch up to you.

Now I would of really liked it if they had more pve content aside from crafting only. Wish they had fishing where players stay logged in and just fish on auto or something to give the world life. I say this because there are a lot of rivers and water around the world for this to be a great idea to give the world life.

And then trading, like deliver this item here and there since lots of quests to go far distances. and maybe some mini games added in like bow/gun challenge on who can kill most turkeys/rabbits/elk.

2
tteabag2591:New_World:•

I'm not sure if this is already in the game but it would be sweet if governors of settlements could hand out quests to players or delegate giving of quests to their top crafters or warriors. Would be much better than just getting quests from NPCs and would feel much more important and impactful.

2
AbyssalKultist•

More quests, open world dungeons with harder mobs to make players want to group up and tackle them.

2

PVE experience as robust as games like 7 Days to Die, Conan Exiles and Ark Survival Evolved

Please fucking excuse me? The PVE in ARK/Rust is absolutely horrible unless you're a huge fan of building mostly rectangular boxes cause other than that it's just hitting stones/trees or other braindead trivial tasks which require you to mash one button mostly. Considering the PVE in ARK/Rust "robust" is the same as considering glue to be some serious gourmet shit.

We all know that survivals and sandboxs and MMOs can be great without PVP despite all of those being associated with it. But will New World be one of them?

They can't unless they got explicitly developed with either PVE (like Minecraft building, or Themepark like WoW/ESO etc.) or Survival in mind. In order to succeed as a PVE-sandbox you either have to appeal to your audience's creativity and give them the tools to work that creativity OR if we're talking about survival, you need to make the survival aspect the main aspect of the game, cause otherwise it's just tedious at best distracting people from what they actually want to do.

NW is neither of those - it didn't even get developed with PVE being an actual factor safe for the most basic systems for the longest part of the development time. You will not be able to build nice bases/structures like in Minecraft, nor will survival even be an actual aspect of the game anymore as is confirmed. Since there is also no themepark content worth mentioning in this game (literally can't be due to reality being a thing) you absolutely do need PVP to keep people engaged and that got gutted.

Finally don't use fancy words such as theorycrafting when you already fail at formulating a stringent post (how in the fuck do you even get from "lets theorycraft about what kinda PVE NW needs" to "wIlL neW wOllrD be gUd?") and obviously don't know the meaning of the word in the first place.

1†
devilkingx2OP•

Firstly, calm the fuck down lol.

Secondly, I've played a lot of Ark don't compare it to Rust. Ark and Conan have tons of PVE content to do (a bunch of bosses and dungeons for one thing). I think PVE is actually more popular than official servers on both games.

Thirdly, despite the fact that you came here to war about PVP, the point of the post is what they should do to make the best of what they've got. As in how should they try to make it into a worthwhile PVE game. (Fun fact: I don't support their PVP decision but I made this thread because nobody really talks about the PVE).

I think that their best hope is adding some sort of unique mechanic (7D2D hordes, Ark taming, conan religions, arpg-styled loot, etc.) That gives a ton of mileage without requiring years of dev time.

-2
Atilla_Hun•

It seems pretty obvious that this game will be lacking content and my die out because of it on launch. Hopefully they have a game-loop that can hold people till they add something, but I don't think any amount of money or skilled development team can keep up with the pace of pushing content into a game that will need so much more to do. I think this game was just a test subject for LoTR anyway.

I agree that, given time, work, and money, this game could copy and be a better version of any game on the market with the server tech and engine they have.

2
aaaaaaaack•

The focus of the game can still be PVP without there being open world PKing. The foundation is already there with the Faction system. If anyone here is old enough to remember an mmorts called Shattered Galaxy, that is a model that would fit NW perfectly, all faction battles all the time!

If Factions are always trying to claim as much territory as possible, the borders should be places of eternal conflict, and holding an area, even for a relatively short amount of time, should be useful. Companies would organize coordinated attacks to take territories and for larger battles, multiple Companies would need to band together.

Perhaps outside of a battle, players could gather resources from any territory but if they don't belong to the Faction that controls that territory, they only will gather 25-50% of what they would if their Faction did control it. This would make controlling strategic resources very important to the entire Faction. Since this game is open world without instances, if there was a battle for a territory underway, being inside that area should auto flag you for pvp after 30-60 seconds. This greatly incentivizes a PVE type player to join in on the PVP instead of being forced into it.

This type of Faction vs Faction focus makes the PVP experience much more intentional and strategic, there would be huge opportunity for large scale coordination and strategy, but also opportunity for a small companies or even solo players to join in on large battles or take fringe territory while everyone else is focused on the big wins.

1
TwoFalls•

I got an idea actually, instead of completely flipping a 180 with your game and making it a piece of boring ass content everyone is gonna hate in 5 hours. They could do what they advertised and not fuck the player base over.

1
AlexusN•

They can make it good if they will delay the game for at least couple more years, but they will not so no point in discussing it.

0
devilkingx2OP•

Why would they need to delay the game by multiple years? Do you want them to full on release ESO at launch or do you think what they have now is so bad its like they haven't started yet?

1
AlexusN•

What they have now is just a shell of a game. It has no interesting story, no dungeons, a single world boss, small world, boring crafting and a flawed 50v50 war system. They could change all of this if they would delay the game and add more stuff.

2
devilkingx2OP•

What do you think they should add, like what should be their top priorities?

1
AlexusN•

Everything other games have and then make it better. Start with huge optional zones with forced PvP where PvP players can build custom forts and castles and destroy other player's forts and castles without idiotic "war by schedule" system, these territories can be added to existing safe territory on same island or as new islands. Add dungeons for PvE people who enjoy killing same dumb NPCs over and over (I do not but other people should have a choice to do this). Add a system where you must always depend on crafters, like make all gear fully lootable by other players or NPCs, with a chance of gear to permanently break if you are killed (with this system you are still safe from PvP - nobody can attack you in safe zones unless you enable PvP flag on). Add huge houses, not tiny shacks with single room per floor. Add ability to build ships and basic naval combat. Add large NPC cities for safe zones. Add mounts like horses, add social systems and minigames.

I could list many more stuff but what is the point, none of this will be present when the game launches in 3 months.

6