Sour Gas Condenser (pre-space material, 1kg/s methane out @ ~110C)

Build

This is the second post in a series of builds starting with this build for a sour gas boiler. As stated, the idea is to start putting out ideas for pre-space sour gas boilers so there are some basic concepts that folks can be moving on with. These builds are all works in progress and suggestions are welcome.

This post concerns a condenser capable of condensing 1.5kg/s of sour gas at 125C to achieve 1kg/s of methane out. This build uses both liquid methane and ethanol. I would suggest getting liquid methane from a source of natural gas through the use of an AETN. I have ideas on this that I'll post later. I feel that ethanol is fair in this build on the premise that getting enough ethanol to get things going requires only a single arbor acorn from the printer pod and some pH2O on any map. If this is simply something that's not happening, hydrogen run at the same temperature should be doable with three thermo regulators.

Sour Gas Condenser

https://preview.redd.it/m0lb7id66jk41.png?width=330&format=png&auto=webp&s=4d32a532f211fed22593dbbac8cedd84e2e1f920

This build is sized to be near the height of the boiler so they can be lined up side by side. I have found that the counterflow performs better with higher thermal capacity materials, so I would suggest using iron, steel, aluminum, or diamond. Of the four, I've found that diamond works best, but the difference once the counterflow is established is only a matter of a few degrees. This height of counterflow achieves an average of around -93C sour gas at the bottom and around 110C natural gas at the top and there don't appear to be significant improvements for a taller counterflow. The minimum height for this counterflow would seem to be 7 rows of heat exchange material to achieve a minimum viable cooling of the incoming sour gas. The conductive gas pipes are made of steel.

Cooling chamber

https://preview.redd.it/sbkt9cc78jk41.png?width=530&format=png&auto=webp&s=f4e89f361db0d3f42836924bdadd84411d79beda

The actual cooling chamber is a bi-coolant cooling system that I had developed a while ago with an attached condensing chamber with three stages of baffles. The condensed liquid is then piped up to a vaporization chamber that is in contact with the last stage of the heat exchanger. The condensing and vaporization chambers should start as vacuum. The turbine chamber should be filled with a conductive gas such as hydrogen or ethanol (as convenient). The aquatuner chamber is filled with 200kg of oil and 5t of water (to assist in absorbing a startup spike, this may not be necessary due to current automation). The reservoirs are in vacuum. There is a pipe valve included in the vacuumed area to assist in startup which I'll cover in the summary at the bottom.

The baffles and radiant pipes passing through them are all steel. Aluminum also works, but means that the methane baffles must be built in two stages to prevent the methane from boiling in the priming process. Diamond also seems to work for the baffles.

Cooling chamber Piping

https://preview.redd.it/td8o8l7t8jk41.png?width=1060&format=png&auto=webp&s=4daac8eacccbe3679f25fd74080329f47377142c

On the left is the fluid piping with four distinct lines.

In the middle left, the first line comes from the turbine and empties into the oil in the aquatuner room. This line is used to self-cool the turbine.

Below that is a second line of ethanol. This second line of ethanol comes from the reservoir that was turned off and primed with 5t of ethanol, goes left past a liquid pipe thermo sensor set to "Above -103.1C", goes up and around the aquatuner room to flow through radiant pipes that cool the top baffles, returns to flow to the aquatuner, and flows back to the reservoir through two bridges that are arranged to allow the cooled liquid to take priority over the bypass. The aquatuner automation will be explained below.

To the right of the second line is a third line of methane. This line is similar to the ethanol loop except that there is a liquid valve after the liquid pipe thermal sensor, and the fluid flows through the lower baffle before flowing through the upper baffle. The liquid pipe thermal sensor is set to "Above -171.6C". The valve is set to 1000g/s to pre-cool the baffles and pipes only. Once the baffles and pipes are cooled to within the liquid temperature of methane, the valve is set to 10,000g/s and could be removed entirely.

The right most line is a fourth line that moves the condensed methane to the vaporization chamber.

On the right is the gas piping. The natural gas from the vaporization chamber is combined into a single pipe to flow up the middle of the heat exchanger while a line of 1kg/packet sour gas flows down the left gas pipe and a line of 0.5kg/packet sour gas flows down the right gas pipe. The gas is dumped into the condensing chamber by high pressure vents.

Cooling chamber Power and Automation

https://preview.redd.it/fs2bpms2cjk41.png?width=1060&format=png&auto=webp&s=c90c73600c77d971132fa06d6e1a64789aa47449

The power connections are on the left. This is fed by a single 2kW wire. Not shown here is that the 2kW wire was fed by 2 small transformers feeding from main power into a smart battery (smart battery set to 25/75 to allow room for turbine power). I found that the automation handover between aquatuners stalled when no battery was included on this line, so it is necessary to include a battery on this line. Don't worry about overloads; the automation takes care of that.

The automation is on the right. The vaporization chamber includes an atmo sensor set to "Above 5000g" which activates the gas pumps and establishes good pressure in the vaporization chamber on startup. The condensing chamber includes a hydro sensor set to "Above 30kg" which activates the liquid pump and a thermo sensor set to "Below -97C" which activates the flow of input gas.

The reservoir chamber includes a left liquid pipe thermal sensor set to "Above 103.1C" and a right liquid pipe thermal sensor set to "Above -171.6C". The left sensor controls the ethanol aquatuner and the right sensor controls the methane aquatuner. However, the AND and NOT gates are arranged to ensure that the ethanol aquatuner cannot run while the methane aquatuner runs. This prioritizes cooling the methane which is helpful in protecting the pipes against bursting at startup. While this also means that the sour gas isn't as pre-cooled by the ethanol loop, this causes the above mentioned thermo sensor in the condensing chamber to trip and disable gas intake. With gas intake disabled, the entire system pauses and can more easily come back to temperature.

Gas Intake Shutoff

https://preview.redd.it/iybwzs27fjk41.png?width=690&format=png&auto=webp&s=ecda3c79d93cd2115d1cc4c58d6f84d00f936a05

The automation wire from the thermo sensor in the condensing chamber comes straight up to the input of this not gate. The lower shutoff controls the 1kg/packet line and simply turns off when the automation wire goes red.

The upper shutoff and valve control the 0.5kg/packet line. The packets on this line come in via the bridge between the shutoff output and the valve input. The valve is set to 500g/s and passes 500g/s to the shutoff. When the shutoff is disabled, the 500g/s packets flow on to the system. When the shutoff is enabled, the 500g/s packets entirely loop back to the valve input and block the bridge with nothing moving on to the system. Since this arrangement allows flow when the shutoff is disabled and blocks flow when the shutoff is enabled, a NOT gate flips the signal to correctly enable/disable both gas lines at once.

​

Startup concerns

This system was relatively easy to arrange, but difficult to come to a relatively safe startup. Methane loves to burst in pipes if you're not careful, but I have made an effort to make this as safe as possible.

Before the system starts, it is important to cool the metal baffles in the condensing chamber that will be in contact with the methane. My preferred method for this test was to:

  1. turn off the reservoirs and fill the methane reservoir with exactly 5t of methane. This filling process should be as direct to the input of the reservoir as possible. When the tank is filled to 5t, remove the filling pipes so no more than 5t is added to the system.

  2. remove the first radiant pipe in the methane loop and replace it with an insulated pipe that connects upwards to the insulated pipe directly above it rather than the radiant pipe below it.

  3. set the valve to be entirely open and turn on the reservoir. Run the system until the aquatuner naturally stops running to ensure the methane is down to temperature.

  4. Turn off the reservoir.

  5. Set the valve to 1000g/s and the methane temp sensor to "Above -161.6C" (one click of the double arrow to the right). Also remove the insulated pipe installed at step 2 and reinstall the radiant pipe.

  6. Turn on the reservoir and allow the system to run until the insulated pipe leaving the cooling loop has methane that is below -158.5C.

  7. Set the valve to 10,000g/s or remove the valve and connect the insulated pipes.

  8. Wait until 10kg packets are reaching the aquatuner and reset the methane thermo sensor to "Above -171.6C".

These were the steps followed to cool steel or diamond tiles used in the methane cooling loop and installed at 20C. When aluminum tiles installed at 20C were used, this process was performed twice. Once with only 4 aluminum tiles installed at 20C. Then the reservoir was turned off and the last 4 aluminum tiles were installed before performing steps 2 through 8 again. Tiles and pipes were installed at 20C because that's the default build temperature in debug mode. If the tiles or pipes are hotter, more care should be taken.

Alternatively, you could install temporary gas pipes through these metal tiles and cool the tiles with thermo regulators running hydrogen or an AETN on a hydrogen loop if one is nearby. In either case, the tiles must be cooled to below -158.5C to be safe. This may not be sufficient to render the radiant pipes in vacuum safe from bursting, so it may still be desirable to run 1kg/s methane through the system for a brief period in any event.

The ethanol cooling loop is far simpler and carries relatively no risk of bursting. Just turn off the tank to fill to 5t as above, and then turn the tank on when the loading is finished. The loop should safely bring everything to temperature in short order.

​

As a separate issue, the counterflow heat exchanger is a large factor in enabling this design. The thermal mass of the heat exchanger drags the temperature of the sour gas down when the system starts up and that helps assist with the start up. However, when the counterflow is installed at 20C, the sour gas temperature isn't dragged down enough for the system to simply start at full input. This is why the thermo sensor in the condensing room is there, it disables sour gas input so the cooling loops can catch up and work to condense the methane that will work toward getting the counterflow heat exchanger working properly. Once the counter flow heat exchanger has begun working, the system will handle progressively more input until the gas pipes are all running at capacity and the thermo sensor in the condensing room will no longer be tripped.

This process can be greatly facilitated by pre-cooling the heat exchanger and I myself would perform this step if I were to build this in survival. What I would do is disconnect the sour gas input lines and the high pressure vents from the sour gas lines going through the heat exchanger and connect a hydrogen cooling system to run cold hydrogen up one sour gas line and down the other until the hydrogen coming out of the system is at most -100C (but no colder than -117C). This should greatly improve the startup and may eliminate the need for the thermo sensor in the condensing chamber.

With all of this pre-cooling performed, it should be good to connect everything up properly and start sour gas flow. The sour gas should initially come in in pulses, but will shortly achieve full flow once the system cools down.

​

Summary and Thoughts

This system is more fiddly to start up, but appears to be stable once started. The system can also be mirrored around the methane return pipe such that a double wide system could be created that should be able to produce 2kg/s of methane output. The system is designed both as a proof of concept condensing system for sour gas as well as a companion to the previous post such that the two systems can be used together and are sized so that the two systems can be integrated into a single block.

For the best integration, previous sour gas boiler should be modified to include an atmo sensor directly below the petroleum cooling loop that's set to "Above 1200g" and connected to turn off the intake of oil. The oil intake of 1500g/s can be turned off with a liquid version of the above gas shutoff arrangement used for the 500g/s line. The thermo sensor from the condensing chamber can also be connected directly to gas pumps in the boiler. If this sort of connection is used, it's best for there to not be as many pipes between the gas pumps and the condensing chamber so as to prevent an excessive amount of sour gas to still be on the way once the system has decided that it's getting overwhelmed.

The aquatuners are automated to run on the same line. This was an initial aspect of my original bi-coolant cooling system to help the system operate on a single 2kw line. This did not work very well initially since the condensing chamber became overwhelmed on startup and the methane ended up bursting the pipes relatively often. I then put each aquatuner on their own line and eliminated the automation. This worked reasonably well, but I was still having some startup issues. I eventually added the thermo sensor in the condensing chamber to turn off gas input and this turned out to be enough to make startup more reliable. Once I made this change, I realized that I no longer needed to run both aquatuners at once to prevent the loops from being overwhelmed on startup and re-implemented the automation.

The thermal inertia of the condensing chamber is critical to an operable startup. For this reason, I suggest using materials with at least the thermal capacity of steel if not better. This restricts the number of material types useful for these tiles, but I believe diamond and steel are plentiful enough that this shouldn't be an issue. Above all, do not use gold. Gold does not have enough thermal capacity to hold off the natural variations on startup.

You may have noticed that I encountered a few problems starting this system in realistic conditions. This is the bad news. The good news is that, once this system is started, it is stable. The initial designs involved reusing a counterflow heat exchanger that was already primed a good number of times and using debug to set the baffles to appropriate temperatures. Once the values were set, the system stably ran for all metal types. This means that the system is significantly more stable once it has started than it is on startup.

With respect to the purpose of the ethanol in this build. This serves two purposes: pre-cooling the sour gas on startup and providing a little boost to the heat exchanger cooling in steady state. The startup benefit is obvious given the above noted concerns. The boost is useful because the sour gas is cooled to an average of -93C when everything is running right while the ethanol can further cool this to closer to -100C. As noted at the start, hydrogen could serve the same purpose. This would use a cooling section at least twice as wide and is suggested to use three thermo regulators. I have not validated such an arrangement.

​

Even with the complicated startup, I'm satisfied that this build is good enough to actually be used in a real play through. This is especially true since every stage of the startup can be performed stably. That is, you can set the system to pre-cool the baffles or something, go off and do something else, and come back later to a system that is ready for the next step. That being said, this is still mostly a proof of concept that one can build a pre-space material condenser that can output 1kg/s of methane. Portions of this concept should be useful for condensers that use space materials as well.

This system was tested using an iterated version of the previous boiler which exhibits superior operation. There was also discussion on the previous thread about an integrated boiler/condenser that uses an open flow design that I want to delve into. I plan on posting a quick overview of the iterated boiler soon and will get to work on an open flow design.

​

Comments and suggestions are welcome.

Posted Mar 4, 2020, 12:24 AM UTC

1813
not_old_redditor•

I might have missed it somewhere, but why two separate cooling liquids when just methane is enough?

Also a note to newbies: in exchange for a hit in power efficiency, you can make the cooling far simpler by just using hydrogen gas and thermo-regulators, rather than liquid cooling.

3
psirrowOP•

There's a slight per benefit to shaving a few degrees off with the ethanol, but the biggest benefit is that it drastically improves the robustness against the start up shock. 10kg of methane at -171.6C can only suck 87.33C out of 1.5 kg of sour gas before it boils. Since the sour gas needs to be cooled to -163.4C to condense (that's what my methane comes out at anyway), the incoming gas needs to be very cold which might not be easy to do.

To get a perspective on this, I turned off the ethanol loop, and removed the tiles and pipes for the loop. Everything ran fine (not surprising). I then vacuumed out the vaporization chamber and the condensing chamber to stimulate a start with a primed counterflow. The thermo sensor very swiftly turned off the input for quite a while and only small groups of packets were let in after. Turning down the thermo sensor swiftly caused the methane to boil in the pipes.

This result agrees with previous testing in that the methane started eventually boiling when the ethanol loop couldn't drop the sour gas much under -90C. The counterflow really needs to be going well to protect the methane if you don't have ethanol.

As for the thermo regulator route... The ethanol is helping start things up and you might replace it with hydrogen reasonably, but replacing the methane would probably be a different story because the methane is performing a lot of cooling. The issue isn't that you can't do it with thermo regulators, but how much you're doing. I calculated that I'm drawing off 216.5kDTU/s in the condensing chamber. This means that you're performing the work of 7 thermo regulators. That's not bad in and of itself, but you need to also factor in that the gas pipes carry far less mass that the liquid pipes. You could compensate for this by making the hydrogen much colder, but you might still need to use more than one line.

There's probably a build there and I'd love to see it, but I don't know if it's necessarily "far simpler". For my part, I'll be focusing on liquid cooling loops for my builds because I prefer the benefits in compactness and increased thermal mass.

On the up side, the power hit is likely to only be a bit more than double power for the cooling alone in the setup I'm using or about an extra 700W. Since the pumps themselves consume about 504W, this is very little.

EDIT: what I mean by "the power hit" is that my cooling setup is calculated to draw 630W considering aquatuners and turbines while a thermo regulator setup would draw 1337W for an extra 700W. I figure this isn't that much more because all the pumps in this already draw 504W.

4
not_old_redditor•

Interesting. Why not use a bunch of high SHC tempshift plates to keep temperatures in the cooler steady and resistant to shock?

I guess what I meant by much simpler hydrogen is that everyone knows how to make hydrogen easily, and you don't have to worry about state changes, shocks, multiple coolants, priming the system, etc.

1
psirrowOP•

I tried that a little with ice temp shift plates, but it didn't seem to help much. It also created a priming problem in that the temp shift plates needed to be cooled too. Setting those problems aside, I also try to avoid temp shift plates touching insulating material.

The big thing that thermal inertia does is give the system time to pause and recover before things get out of hand. If that's the goal, steel and diamond work well enough. I don't think I can raise thermal inertia enough to get past the priming phase except for maybe one thing...

Early on, I played around with using water in the counterflow heat exchanger instead of metal. This seemed to work well but ended up taking forever to get things going. However, if you use water for all but the top and bottom segments and freeze the entire counterflow with hydrogen to around -100C, that could do the trick. This would take a long time though.

That's a fair point about how hard the methane is to deal with. It's great once everything is set up, but getting everything set up can be a bit touch and go. It gets especially difficult if you want to try self priming. This is why I mentioned preparing various parts with hydrogen. It should be a relatively simple matter to run in the cooling necessary to basically sidestep all risk related to using methane. This gets you the best of both worlds.

As for getting methane in the first place, I have a handful of ideas about that which I'll get into later.

3
Iwasfrozentodaay•

Cool builds dude!

2
Gamers_Handbook•

Excellently done again! I too found startup to be terribly tricky. The best I got was by going with as little heat conducting things as possible. That means less to pre chill, and less time for exposed methane to get beat on by heat spikes. Of course the down side is it can't process as much gas once it's stable. I liked your approach to precooling, basically doing it under vacuum and building each piece after the previous ones were chilled. I too found it extremely helpful with start-up (and just life of the build in general) to shut off gas if things got out of hand.

Do you think the build would benefit any by having the ethanol loop segregated off in its own room? The sour gas is already in pipes, so it would be easy to transfer the temps in another heat exchanger (although it may be a bigger room than it is now)

2
psirrowOP•

The condensing room is designed off of my older CO2 condenser which used an open top to just suck CO2 out of the air. In the current steady state, ethanol seems to cool the sour gas by about 12 degrees in that small space to be within 1.5 degrees of the coldest ethanol input (that is to less than -101C). On startup, the ethanol could generally keep the sour gas colder than -89C as a maximum.

There is certainly some upward propagation of chill from the methane cooling loop, but this doesn't seem to be notable in any way. If such a propagation were notable, I would expect the ethanol loop to be colder at some point which is not observed.

Since I've already experimented with previous builds that used two coolant condensing chambers, I feel comfortable with them and it was the first place I went when I realized that I wanted to insert an ethanol loop (I had a pure methane cooler early on which couldn't process the predicted volume. Hindsight indicates that the counterflow wasn't long enough, but the ethanol loop drastically simplifies startup anyway). It's possible that the ethanol loop could be segregated as you mentioned, but the current system seems quite compact and I don't see that there's enough room to improve cooling to make the change.

2
Gamers_Handbook•

Wow that's excellent news then!

1
Valendr0s•

Why would you delete the heat? Why not use the heat in the boiler?

Just seems like you have a part that wants heat, and a part that wants cold. Deleting heat seems wasteful.

1
psirrowOP•

This is perfectly viable with thermium aquatuners, but the goal for the moment is to get things going without those.

I view the state of sour gas boilers as being sort of like petroleum boilers before a few months back. Once folks like Francis John started showing off builds that just ran in a volcano, there was an explosion of people building petroleum boilers. Some folks even say that they never use the refinery building to make petroleum. But the bigger point is that petroleum boilers were something only something for a select few until, suddenly, they were something that everyone could have.

I figure that part of the change was both a reduction in complexity and a demonstration without space materials. These builds are to start the ball rolling by eliminating space materials. With that, complexity can be reduced with iteration. I haven't gotten to it yet, but there goal is to make sure the system is capable of being run on heat sources like a volcano. I figure that, if we can hit all of these goals (I'm trying to inspire others too with this), sour gas boiling can be made more accessible.

6
AngryTarasivna•

SAVE please!)

1
psirrowOP•

Sorry, but the build was assembled in my testing map which I would rather not share around. It's mostly full of junk. This is why I try to share sufficient details to replicate the builds I do. If you have any problems with replication, let me know and I'll try to work with you about it.

2
Gamers_Handbook•

Write ups stand up over time, saves not so much.

1