I am an Independent Trader, AMAA.
I only have two requests. First, if you want to hate, leave. Second, no personal questions. I have no desire to lose my anonymity.
Being independent means I don't belong to a prop shop or any commercial business. I trade equity, futures, FX, and options for my own account. My trading style is best referred to as swing trading.
I believe anyone and everyone is capable of learning to trade. Just like anything else, you have to put the time and effort in to be successful.
AMAA.
Posted Feb 2, 2011, 9:38 PM UTC
You made a post previously that was basically an AMA. Your trading strategy can be simplified with "love the momentum".
Do you have any criticism for more academic based buying/selling based on value?
I do love that momentum.
If you mean academic as in automated or quantitative trading, I can't really criticize something I have little knowledge of. With that said, I would like to understand it better. I've read Mandelbrot's stock market book, but really couldn't take any of his ideas further.
If you mean academic as in fundamental investing, my only criticism would be of the entire "buy and hold" philosophy. I don't know where buy and hold actually came from, but I've read it was from mutual fund managers who failed in timing the market. Granted, this is unfair, but if analysts paid to look at a single company can't accurately determine earnings, how can an individual do any better?
However, I do have family members and friends who have found success with value investing.
Also, Will O'Neil, who is very much a momentum trader, is the guy who developed CAN SLIM, a value approach to momo trading.
buy and hold is financial industry advice to clients so that they just sit down shut up and give them money.
I was in fact referring to value investing. What do you think of buying something because you don't think it will go down rather than thinking it will go up? CANSLIM is definite momentum based, and not really value-based even if it has principles that would make it pretty hard for a stock to go down if the conditions maintain themselves.
I can't even think in terms of value investing.
Would I buy something because I think it wouldn't go down? No. If a stock isn't moving, I sell. When the same stock starts to move again, I'll buy it back. What's the point of having a chunk of cash sitting there when you're given opportunities every day to make money.
Talking with value investor friends, they try to ask me what I think of XYZ. They'll talk to me about future earnings, earning potential, management, etc. Even with all the details, "value" is a subjective thing. NFLX is a constant source of "it's worth more" and "it's worth dog shit". With all the numbers being equally available, with analysts paid to watch the company, no one can make a decision.
By using momentum to trade and ignoring fundamentals, I allow all those hard decisions (like value) to be handled by the market. In essence, I view the market as supply and demand. Not, P=D*((1+g)/(k-g)).
If there is a large move after earnings, do you pile in at open? or is that something you avoid?
Am I off here? I thought "buy and hold" meant to buy something and hold it for a few years while it went up in value.
Do you think it's a bad idea to invest in strong and dedicated CEOs?