r/finance•
howdytest

I am an Independent Trader, AMAA.

I only have two requests. First, if you want to hate, leave. Second, no personal questions. I have no desire to lose my anonymity.

Being independent means I don't belong to a prop shop or any commercial business. I trade equity, futures, FX, and options for my own account. My trading style is best referred to as swing trading.

I believe anyone and everyone is capable of learning to trade. Just like anything else, you have to put the time and effort in to be successful.

AMAA.

Posted Feb 2, 2011, 9:38 PM UTC

44147
Godspiral•

You made a post previously that was basically an AMA. Your trading strategy can be simplified with "love the momentum".

Do you have any criticism for more academic based buying/selling based on value?

4
howdytestOP•

I do love that momentum.

If you mean academic as in automated or quantitative trading, I can't really criticize something I have little knowledge of. With that said, I would like to understand it better. I've read Mandelbrot's stock market book, but really couldn't take any of his ideas further.

If you mean academic as in fundamental investing, my only criticism would be of the entire "buy and hold" philosophy. I don't know where buy and hold actually came from, but I've read it was from mutual fund managers who failed in timing the market. Granted, this is unfair, but if analysts paid to look at a single company can't accurately determine earnings, how can an individual do any better?

However, I do have family members and friends who have found success with value investing.

Also, Will O'Neil, who is very much a momentum trader, is the guy who developed CAN SLIM, a value approach to momo trading.

3
Godspiral•

I don't know where buy and hold actually came from, but I've read it was from mutual fund managers who failed in timing the market.

buy and hold is financial industry advice to clients so that they just sit down shut up and give them money.

I was in fact referring to value investing. What do you think of buying something because you don't think it will go down rather than thinking it will go up? CANSLIM is definite momentum based, and not really value-based even if it has principles that would make it pretty hard for a stock to go down if the conditions maintain themselves.

2
howdytestOP•

I can't even think in terms of value investing.

Would I buy something because I think it wouldn't go down? No. If a stock isn't moving, I sell. When the same stock starts to move again, I'll buy it back. What's the point of having a chunk of cash sitting there when you're given opportunities every day to make money.

Talking with value investor friends, they try to ask me what I think of XYZ. They'll talk to me about future earnings, earning potential, management, etc. Even with all the details, "value" is a subjective thing. NFLX is a constant source of "it's worth more" and "it's worth dog shit". With all the numbers being equally available, with analysts paid to watch the company, no one can make a decision.

By using momentum to trade and ignoring fundamentals, I allow all those hard decisions (like value) to be handled by the market. In essence, I view the market as supply and demand. Not, P=D*((1+g)/(k-g)).

2
Godspiral•

If there is a large move after earnings, do you pile in at open? or is that something you avoid?

1
[deleted]•

Am I off here? I thought "buy and hold" meant to buy something and hold it for a few years while it went up in value.

Do you think it's a bad idea to invest in strong and dedicated CEOs?

0
Nefarious-Gordon Gekko•
  • What is your educational background?

  • How old are you?

  • Is this your only job?

  • What are your average annual returns?

  • How did you get into what you currently do?

  • How did you get started with what you currently do?

2
howdytestOP•

I have a degree in Finance. I've been doing this full-time since graduating college, something like 11-12 years. See my response to dunnyvan for how I got started.

I average 20-30% in normal years. With the tech bubble, housing bubble, and commodity bubble (and their respective crashes), there have been years where I've more than doubled my account.

5
[deleted]•

Do you think there's a day-trading bubble?

0
howdytestOP•

As in more people day trading? No, but if there was, would it matter?

1
CovertRaider•

If the "bubble" existed, I'd short it in milliseconds.

0
RanlierAnalyst - Corporate Finance•

More traders mean more liquidity, which means larger share lots can be traded without taking hits on your fills.

0
[deleted]•

lol what?

0
dunnyvan•

What online tools do you use?

Did you start trading in college, if so, how serious about it were you (I am a sophomore and want to open an online account and siphon some of my work money into it to begin trading)?

When you started off how did you do your research and how good of a background did you have in finance?

Thanks man, hopefully I can do what you do!

2
howdytestOP•

I use finviz.com when ThinkorSwim's platform is being slow.

I got interested in trading when I was in high school. Back then, I think I read every book on trading/investing that I could. Perhaps the one benefit I had was when my family saw I took an interest, they would ask me what stock I liked and why. My rather wealthy uncle who has success as an investor would tell me what he was watching and we would talk. Yet, just like a kid, nothing really held my attention and I would bounce between ideas and strategies. It wasn't until I gained a bit more maturity and understanding did things start to make sense. By the time I graduated college, I had a decent account.

When I started, I did my research the old fashioned way. With the internet, you can do research the same way I do now: through your broker or on finviz.com. You don't need to pay for expensive proprietary tools to make good returns.

I really didn't have much of a background in finance when I first started, it's just something I stumbled onto. Though, later, I did get a degree in Finance, but I don't think that had much to do with my success. I got the degree because I liked the stock market. We spent very little time actually talking about the market, though.

Definitely open that account. The sooner you start doing, the more you'll learn. After you learn the basics, the only thing holding you back is yourself. I'm not saying it's a matter of will either. Rather, your own psychological issues will cause you to fail. If you have other questions or need someone to bounce ideas off of, I should be around.

4
pitbul13•

I like the fact that you mentioned ''your own psychological issues will cause you to fail'' How many times I let emotions take control and ended up with losses.. Until I learned to control myself, that is.

So true!

4
dunnyvan•

What do you mean? Just not being able to let go of a stock and take your losses on it? I just watched Wall Street for my humanities class and all I read your post in Gekkos voice.

0
pitbul13•

Kind of. Good example: I saw a stock go from $.85 to $.98 in one day on huge volume. I rationalised, telling myself the price would correct. I had an order for $.91 I think. Next day it went up to about $1.50. I was furious... I had missed the boat.

So now I was on a mission not to miss the next one. Bought the next stock that seemed to have good momentum, and a few of my screening criteria. I bought at $1.40, with minimul Due Dilligence.. Couple months later, the company went bankrupt. That's one example.

Another example is listening to tips. Never buy on tips. ALWAYS do your DD. And yes, ALWAYS cut your losses. Easy to say, not easy to do..

Goodluck

2
abid8740•

Did you opt in for a paid finviz account? Is it worth it?

0
howdytestOP•

No, I use ThinkorSwim more than finviz. ToS doesn't always have speedy servers though.

1
abid8740•

Gah, I have been hearing so much about think or swim...sadly they are in Canada but they merged with Waterhouse and now aren't accepting new accounts till they "transition everything over". Can you get all the live data with a paper account?

0
soviel•

About that account, what is the minimum I should start with?

0
jzwinck•

From another reply by the OP:

Put aside a few grand a month and trade with that. Make it an amount you're comfortable losing, an amount that won't risk you or family's health, until you gain confidence with your system.

1
soviel•

Thanks, I had not read the whole AMA.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
howdytestOP•

Small? Sure, I suppose. Quick? Probably not unless you went FX.

You could probably do OK putting 1-2k in one stock and letting the stock run.

Whatever you do, just keep to your stops and don't let commissions bleed you dry.

1
roundhouse27•

What's your edge?

How do you estimate alpha?

How do you back test your strategies and ideas?

1
howdytestOP•

The first time I heard "edge" was in a forum a few years ago. I definitely don't remember reading anything pre-2000 about "edge". It comes off as something someone used to sell a book and/or trading course. When I was first asked that, the person told me it means "how are you better than the market".

Well, I'm not better than the market. No one is. I do my best with what the market has given me. What makes me better than other traders? Patience and discipline. My setups are defined by price and volume, but waiting for the setups and having the discipline to execute my strategies is the entire game.

I don't care about alpha.

I don't backtest. The last time I had to test a new idea was when I first got into options and I paper traded options for a few months. My trading strategy isn't far from Livermore's who operated in the 20's or Darvas who operated in the 50's. Human behavior will always stay the same.

EDIT: Opps, Darvas was in the 50's. O'Neil was in the 80's.

3
[deleted]•

Amen.

1
the_cat_kittles•

fascinating... I hear about edge all the time in sports betting :)

0
[deleted]•

What proportion of "independent traders" are actually bad traders that just haven't gone broke yet?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
howdytestOP•

I don't really use "indicators". I'm more a price and volume guy. Even in the moving averages department, I only keep the 10, 50, and 200 sma on the chart.

1
Nokade•

How long did it take you to become consistently profitable?

1
howdytestOP•

2-3 years of doing.

0
ImperfectlyInformed•

When I hear swing trading, I hear a few months of holding. Yet you say that you don't look at fundamentals at all. How is that possible?

I swing trade. I can't imagine swing trading without looking at the fundamentals. Sometimes stocks which are fundamentally fine drop in a way that doesn't make sense, and you buy them until the price corrects. I can give a couple examples: I bought CCGY at around $0.40 and sold around $0.75 since I could see that it was generating positive cashlow and it was about to triple its revenue. The negative earnings it was showing were actually from changes in values in warrants and not operations. I also own LRAD, which tanked in September even after it reported a decent quarter of finally achieving positive cashflow and has a very strong balance sheet. After it reported, predictably, a profitable quarter, it shot it up from $0.75 to $3. I almost bought AFSI - again, strong fundamentals (low P-E, strong growth).

Without fundamentals, there's no way to distinguish these stocks from, say, REDF, a clear short which rallied from $4 to $10 and is now down to around $7, and HHWW, the most obvious short in a while.

EDIT: I guess I can see what you're doing, it's just that it sounds too short-term for me to call it swing trading - I'm guessing you just look for volume and the breakout, take your position, and then set your price target and stop loss and get out. So for REDF above, you might have gotten in around $5-6 and sold around $8 or something to call it good. I guess my main question then is whether you primarily set price targets, or do you let your profits run and then rely on a stop loss.

1
howdytestOP•

Talking with value investor friends, they try to ask me what I think of XYZ. They'll talk to me about future earnings, earning potential, management, etc. Even with all the details, "value" is a subjective thing. NFLX is a constant source of "it's worth more" and "it's worth dog shit". With all the numbers being equally available, with analysts paid to watch the company, no one can make a decision.

By using momentum to trade and ignoring fundamentals, I allow all those hard decisions (like value) to be handled by the market. In essence, I view the market as supply and demand. Not, P=D*((1+g)/(k-g)).

As long as the stock goes in my direction, I don't care how bad their sheets may look. If the stock goes down, I'm out. I'll hold a stock for as long as it performs and dump it the minute it doesn't.

If I was concerned about fundies, I might have missed the NFLX trade: 61 to 200 in 1 year. I don't know if the fundies were shit the entire time, but I know recently people have been talking about it being overvalued, yet it still goes up.

I look at price and volume, that's it.

1
ImperfectlyInformed•

Looking at NFLX - how tight are your stops? If you hit the 61 to 200 run, then clearly they are loose enough that you don't sell when, say, NFLX drops from about 124 in June of 2010 to below 99 in July of 2010 (a 21% drop).

Also, there are a lot of gaps to the upside on NFLX, but these could just as well be gaps to the downside if NFLX reported slower growth. Had any bad experiences with gaps?

0
howdytestOP•

I sold out on 6/21 and bought back in on 8/10. I'm not going to hold it as it falls.

0
danny_•

Good answer

-1
howdytestOP•

I don't typically hold into earnings just for that reason.

Other news does tend to be a mess though. Recently it was AAPL and Jobs' going to the hospital. I gave back a good chunk of profits there.

0
[deleted]•

What would you say is your average holding period for a position? How much time do you devote to trading and research per day? Do you formulate strict and unbreakable rules for entering and exiting positions, or is a lot of it based on what the context and your gut tell you?

1
howdytestOP•

I have no idea what my average holding time is. A day or two if things don't work. A month or longer if it acts right. Whatever makes money, right?

Today I spent more time answering questions than I did trading or at least it seems like it. I wake up 6:30 EST to run scans, set alerts, and trade futures. The rest of my day is responding to those alerts and trading futures until 1 or 2pm. This week has kept me pretty busy with the market, but on slow days I'll do whatever I want. I use to keep a Dwarf Fortress game on my second monitor.

I keep to my rules. The moment you break your rules is the moment you open yourself up to a significant loss.

The only time I use "my gut" is in trading futures. With futures, I'll watch the 5m, 1 hr, and daily to trade. I think equities have pretty shitty personalities on the daily level so my gut isn't required.

1
holdmybeer•

How many eggs? How many baskets?

1
howdytestOP•

Fuck baskets, I'm juggling.

-2
twenty4two•

You've obviously had a huge history in finance, but are there any parts that you've found to be most beneficial to your current success?

i.e. Which things (finance undergrad, lots of books, full-time focus on practice account, etc) would you have someone focus on, who wanted to similarly be an independent trader?

1
howdytestOP•

Even if you work with 1 share, do it. Doing is the only way you learn.

1
unidentifiable•

You mentioned that you're a momentum trader in the style of O'neill et al.

I'm very new to investing (23 years old) and am increasingly looking at momentum trading as something that makes sense to me.

Two questions:

First, if I read O'neill/Livermore/Darvas, what knowledge would I still lack? As in, what key piece of information have you learned that isn't in the books?

Second, Do you work with cycles & trends? I've been carefully watching various cycle investors that seem to be able to call movements with a good deal of consistency (eg, Copper season runs from month X to month Y). Are these people simply familiar with momentum on a broad scale or is this something different entirely.

Thanks.

1
howdytestOP•

You won't be able to read the books than instantly trade successfully. Watch the markets and put some trades in and eventually you'll learn.

With momentum, I'll capture most of any trend up or down. So no, I don't consciously watch for cycles.

2
unidentifiable•

Sorry, maybe I wasn't clear.

I understand that I won't be an amazing trader after having simply read a bunch of texts. Wisdom is gained through experience as well. I was wondering if you'd be willing to impart some of your wisdom upon a newbie investor. If it's all trade secrets, then no pressure :)

1
howdytestOP•

I understood heh. I don't have any trade secrets. I've explained a few times how exactly I trade. I've even posted charts and explanations.

At the same time, I believe everything you need to trade successfully is in those 3 books. However, some of the points might be lost on newer traders due to their lack of experience. Even worse, you may think you understand, but miss the subtly or true meaning of what the author has said.

So like I said, the most important thing is to watch and trade the markets, even if it's 1 share at a time. At some point, you'll stop trying to trade like somebody else and realize that you trade like yourself. Once you have that confidence, it becomes much easier to trade and to "feel out" the markets.

1
unidentifiable•

Thanks for the help, and for speedy replies!

1
Fighterdoken•

How long had you been trading before you were comfortable doing it without the support of a job?

About how much would you say you were trading with at that time?

I assume you had some savings to fall back on as well but was it more than what you were trading with?

I understand the numbers depend on lifestyle and location, I'm just looking for a ballpark figure.

1
howdytestOP•

I never a had a "job", thankfully. My parents had put a (small) amount of savings (~10k) away for me at a young age for my retirement. In college, I used the entirety of that money to trade. By the time I graduated, I turned that small sum into 100k.

At the same time, I tried to find a real job. I applied to some of the big banks and tried to get into wall street somehow, but I was never the "perfect student" that got their attention. Even the interviews I networked into were jokes.

I realized that even if I made scraps, I'd rather spend 90 hours a week looking at stocks than 40 hours pushing paper. With that mindframe, I moved in with my parents after graduation and traded from home for a year or two. My profits from the tech bubble gave me the confidence to move out and start my life.

The only "fall back" I had, even after I moved out for a while, were my parents. They were very supportive and I'm not sure if I would have succeeded if it wasn't for that. They didn't give me money, but it sure was nice to know that I wouldn't be homeless if shit hit the fan.

If you're looking to get into full-time trading, I'd suggest trading on the side before anything else. Build your confidence first then up the risk.

3
[deleted]•

So in four years, you accomplished a 1000% ROI. What were you picks and what did were your average gains?

You also said you the tech bubble started you off. I understand the during that time, there was no pattern day trading rule. Do you think that was an advantaged had you started trading today?

Nonetheless, good stuff.

1
howdytestOP•

I'm going to guess my picks were tech related...

My holding period isn't insanely long. I don't buy something then make it my baby like "investors" do. So I don't have any reason to remember a particular stock from 10+ years ago.

I don't think the pattern day trading rule was/is/could be a benefit/hurdle. If you're looking to hold for a week/month/whatever, then the only time you'd "day trade" is to close a position that you started during the day, but went against you by the end of the day.

Even if you were worried about that, aren't you allowed 3 "day trades" per week? Isn't the limit only 25k? The day trading rules shouldn't be a huge deal.

2
Nokade•

How do you find your trades? Do you use a scanner (e.g looking for 52 week high/lows) or do you use the same list of stocks every day, or play stocks in the news etc?

1
Fighterdoken•

I'd also like to know the general idea behind this. He mentioned at one point that he clears out his list every so often and starts off on a clean slate again but surely there must be some repeats that make the cut several times.

0
drudru•

hi - what is your typical day like?

1
howdytestOP•

Wake up at 6:30ish to run scans and set alerts. After that, I just manage my positions and trade. My day ends anywhere from 1-5pm.

2
omegaclick•

What is the one stock you kick yourself for selling because you missed the "giant" move? If you don't have one, how the hell do you hold em when they jump 300% in a couple months?

1
howdytestOP•

It's impossible to catch every move. I look for the best performing sectors and best performing stocks within those sectors. That means that there are plenty of stocks that make good moves that are simply off my radar or that I simply don't trade.

At the same time, it's not worthwhile to hold onto regrets. If you're constantly reminding yourself that you missed a 300% move, you'll always be afraid of missing out. One way or another, that emotion is going to cause losses.

I actually got stopped out of a copper trade (holding for hours, not days) this morning for a 3% loss. Not huge, but it made me hesitate getting back in under the same conditions an hour later. Since then, copper has gone in my direction, but I don't have any contracts. That 3% loss made me miss out on a 10-15% gain. It's a good reminder of what emotions can do to your trading.

Stocks move slowly. The game isn't "300% in a few months", but to simply catch the trend. You look at the leaders and anywhere from 10% to 30% is possible in the last month. Add in leverage and you have good returns.

Back to your question: how do I hold onto the stocks for the big winners? For the most part, I don't. Over the course of months, I'll be in and out of a stock depending on how it's acting. When the stock is forming a base, typically I'll be out. I'll re-enter when it breaks out of the pattern and sell when another basing pattern emerges. This is so my money stays efficient should a stock base for a month or two. For example, CAT based for a month before really breaking out. Other stocks have more of a "wave" than a "pyramid" and I'll ride out of the ups and downs. A good example of this is GE since the beginning of December.

2
[deleted]•

Is your trading primarily focused on technical analysis? Do you incorporate financial news (data), and investment ideas/theories as well?

1
drudru•

cool, thx - that is just like a day job... albeit one that pays more

1
rangermike7•

I have read all of the same books as you and basically implement the same strategy with William O'Neil as my idol and How to Make Money in Stocks as my investing bible. I have two questions:

  1. Do you ever use weekly charts like O'Neil prefers or do you stick to daily charts? Thoughts on intraday charts?

  2. Have you ever read "Trade Like an O’Neil Disciple: How We Made 18,000% in the Stock Market" by Gil Morales and Chris Kacher and if so what are your thoughts? I've read it and found it extremely helpful.

Thanks for your time and input.

1
howdytestOP•

I'll look at a weekly chart on occasion, but my entire routine is based on the daily charts. Especially with stocks making fresh 52-week highs, a weekly chart isn't going to tell you much more than a daily chart. I find that weeklys are useful for confirming trend changes, though.

I haven't read "Trade Like an O'Neil Disciple", but I'll add it to my list. I'm not a huge O'Neil follower. CANSLIM is nice, but I don't believe in fundamentals. After all, we had fundamental guys rationalizing the tech bubble, the housing bubble, and the commodity bubble. Especially in 2009, how many fundamental people were saying "dead cat bounce"? I'm not 100% certain, but I think stock prices went up before earnings did in 2009.

I think CANSLIM is a good way to find the next AAPL (or whatever), but I'm fairly confident I'll pick up the stock eventually too. Once it makes that first large breakout, it's on my list. So even if you catch that first breakout with CANSLIM, it's only a drop in the bucket of a real winner.

2
agnt007•

hey howdytest, i had another question. what is the minimal amount of knowledge someone would need to do what you are doing right now? Is there some way to get a crash course and still reap the benefits you are enjoying or is the only the long road of learning&trial error? thanks.

1
howdytestOP•

That's a tough question. The real difference between a newbie and someone who has 5-10 years under their belt is being able to maximize profits while minimizing losses.

In a trending market, which is where I trade, anyone can make some money. Since December, you could have made 30-50% just by having money in some popular stocks (BAC comes to mind). Look at the market this week though, would you have been able to get out before you lost a chunk of your gains? At the same time, that 50% doesn't look so good compared to someone using 2:1 or 4:1 leverage on stocks that move 15-50%+/month. That's the difference between a new trader's blind luck and an experienced trader's skill.

I think what makes good traders is the ability to control emotion. That doesn't come from knowledge, but from experience. Maybe a rare few can claim they've never struggled against emotion, but everyone I know, including myself, has an ongoing battle against one emotion or another.

I could sit you down and show you everything that I do. Yet, once the uptrend in the market hits a snag (like this week), you'd probably shit your pants. However, if you traded through the snag and survived, you'll be able to handle the next one (flash crash excluded). So regardless of what you know, I would have to say that experiencing different market behaviors is the key to success.

It all comes down to doing = learning but learning != doing. Even if you fumble about making peanuts, eventually you'll figure something out that propels you to the next stage of success.

3
onlypoints•

Late to the game, I know, but what future markets do you trade?

1
howdytestOP•

ES, CL, SI, GC.

2
onlypoints•

Thanks for the response, I've been doing quite well the last few years, and am looking into trading full time, so I hope you will have time to answer a few more questions.

Lately I've been focused on CL and SI as well, with some ZS when worthwhile. You mentioned equity trading as well, do you still do much? I got away from it because the 1256 contracts are much better tax wise. Unless perhaps, you make the Mark to Market election, If you don't mind me asking how do you declare you gains, self employment or just as capital gains?

What percent of your capital/trades/time do you dedicate to forex/futures vs. equity? I'm guessing maybe it helps to smooth out the equity curve? What upside do you see in equities over the leveraged products?

Thanks.

1
howdytestOP•

I let my tax guys handle my tax situation. The short answer is self employment, though.

How much I spend in futures vs. equities is a tough question. If I'm light in equities, I'll get a little heavier in the futures. I suppose on a day-to-day basis, futures help smooth my equity curve, but futures contribute a good portion of my overall profits too.

What upside do you see in equities over the leveraged products?

It's partly personal, partly practical. I think I understand the behavior of equities better. It's also easier for me to have 10 equity positions than try to get a full position in ES.

2
onlypoints•

Thanks, I appreciate the answers.

1
wreckingcruVP - Private Equity•

Is it possible to trade moderately successfully "on-the-side" while holding a regular day job? Any strategy suggestions for those who want to be able to trade but rather not put all their work-eggs in one basket?

I'm thinking something along the lines of being able to research in off-hours and put in trades (and monitor them) during some down-time during market hours?

0
howdytestOP•

If I had to "trade on the side", I would use MOC, LOC (on close), MOO, LOO (on open) orders with stops depending on your thoughts. Might also have my stops lower than they are now. It's definitely doable though.

You don't have to trade with your entire 401k. Put aside a few grand a month and trade with that. Make it an amount you're comfortable losing, an amount that won't risk you or family's health, until you gain confidence with your system.

2