Dark Phoenix was far closer to its source material than people give it credit and many people are misperceiving it

I recently reread the entire Dark Phoenix saga(all 38 issues) and the only major difference is that they changed the Hellfire Club to those random aliens(they were the Hellfire Club in an earlier version of the script). Otherwise it followed the beats of the original storyline.

Here is a brief comparison:

Comic:

-Jean gets cosmic power in space.

-Jean develops wild and less under control personality.

-Jean accidentally “kills” X-Men and is at her lowest.

-Hellfire Club takes advantage of Jean being at her lowest and manipulates her.

-Jean gets tricked into thinking her allies are her enemies.

-X-Men get captured and have power disabling collars placed on them.

-Jean turns on the people manipulating her.

-X-Men are freed and fight the Hellfire Club.

-Authorities try to arrest the X-Men.

-Jean gives her manipulator the power he wanted and it’s too much for them.

-Jean goes Phoenix and flies into space and eats a star.

Movie:

-Jean gets cosmic power in space.

-Jean develops wild and less under control personality.

-Jean accidentally kills a X-Man and is at her lowest.

-Aliens takes advantage of Jean being at her lowest and manipulates her.

-Jean gets tricked into thinking her allies are her enemies.

-X-Men get captured and have power disabling collars placed on them.

-Jean turns on the people manipulating her.

-Authorities try to arrest the X-Men.

-X-Men are freed and fight the aliens.

-Jean gives her manipulator the power she wanted and it’s too much for her.

-Jean goes Phoenix and flies into space to eat a star in a sequel that won’t happen.

It was structured like the events that set-up her transformation into the Dark Phoenix.

For a more in-depth comparison:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d8qFJ7Frbm8

I keep seeing people say they rushed to make Jean the Dark Phoenix when that isn’t really true. She became the Dark Phoenix at the very end of the movie. The movie is like the Joker movie where it is all about the slow transformation of the character.

Posted Mar 30, 2020, 4:04 PM UTC · edited

1116
Natewest1987•

That’s nice and all but the movie was garbage and I’m not a dc person and I couldn’t hack trying to slog through the entire joker ( so dark, damn ), but those two movies are nothing alike. One is masterful cinema, the other, see above.

The fact is that they did rush the movie, they had to. Do I think they rushed to make her Phoenix ? Idk, wanna talk about how she already was Phoenix-fied by the end of apocalypse and then somehow that was ignored?

The issues that I’ve observed people take up with the movie have had little to do with the plot points you mentioned. I think it’s well known there was an alternate original draft of the script Since it’s been talked about in the press. Most “fans” that you encounter on Reddit or where ever, were never going to accept mystique as the leader of the xmen, and I love Jennifer Lawrence, but people were tired of seeing her in that role and unfortunately used her as a scape goat for all the other problems with the movie. Like the fact that it sucked lol

4
CosmogenusOP•

Idk, wanna talk about how she already was Phoenix-fied by the end of apocalypse and then somehow that was ignored?

“Jean absorbs those solar flares and then hurls them back out into space,” explains director Simon Kinberg of the sequence shown in the above exclusive concept art.

“That’s what triggers, awakens, creates this Phoenix force and voice inside her. What appears to the world to be another heroic victory by the X-Men in saving stranded people in space we realize is the the thing that begins the unraveling of Jean and the unraveling of secrets Charles told her.”

https://ew.com/movies/2017/12/07/dark-phoenix-x-men-jean-grey-space/?__twitter_impression=true

I think it’s well known there was an alternate original draft of the script Since it’s been talked about in the press.

It isn’t really well known. Some people stay clam it’s nothing like the comic.

1
CosmogenusOP•

but those two movies are nothing alike

Both of them do deal with the idea of childhood trauma.

1
BrunchIsAMust•

Good points but the movie was still horrible.

3
subism•

This!

I keep seeing people defend the film by talking about Kinberg having to change it, or how Claremont was involved, or proclaiming it’s “accuracy.”

None of these things change the fact it is just bad.

1
CosmogenusOP•

None of these things change the fact it is just bad.

How is that a “fact”?

1
subism•

Of course this is a subjective opinion, but it's a figure of speech. It's impossible to prove a movie is objectively bad. But, the greater market / populous has determined it's a stinker, and I firmly agree. No one cares how "close to the source material" it is if the product they consumed at the end of the day was not something they enjoyed.

If you enjoyed it, good for you. But you shouldn't need to convince anyone else of it's merit for that to be true to you.

1
CosmogenusOP•

I mean no offense but...what is your point?

When did I say that people like this film? No where. I was simply addressing a criticism among fans that was objectively false. So you’re just making a strawman.

But while we are own the subject.

But, the greater market / populous has determined it's a stinker, and I firmly agree.

That is mainly because it was mismarketed and people thought it was suppose to be some epic grant finale with Jean as final boss.

1
1966CJ•

I give it the movie a C+ meaning it was okay but you are absolutely right.

3
MasterofSciFi•

As a film it's still not good

2
CosmogenusOP•

How do you think it stands as a film?

1
MasterofSciFi•

I think it’s clunky, it starts out great but it quickly gets boring, the aliens are boring and cliche villains which makes you less invested in the story, I hate how it handles Xavier

3
CosmogenusOP•

I see, though I think how they handled Xavier somewhat made sense with what was established in the previous film.

2
ChrisRobbins15•

your not wrong.there is valin debate on how franchise was handled post days of future past when kinberg was given control but claiming it isn' like the comics is wrong.

1
dudenoidea•

Okay, we get it but it is bullshit Robbins17chris and I am damn proud the X-Men get to be in the MCU.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ChrisRobbins15•

yeah x-men get ot los emutant allegary all serneas and darkness and get to be if hollywood ever is up and running comedic avengers supporting characters.

besides seeing new mutants possable as long as it doesn't premiere on hulu or disney + sinc ei will never sign up for eather one x-men is gone for me.just like marvel having killed all good about x-men in comics will do similar to films jus tlike they butched psider-man.i barely tolered fox erassing all non first class films with end of days of future past i sure as hell wouldn't tolerte whatever feige would do to them.but with viris ciris it's moot point.

0
PAWG-fest•

Less than 1 percent of movie goers read comics. It doesn't matter. The film sucks.

1
CosmogenusOP•

What is your point exactly?

1