r/rock•
TheMaxChance

During the inception of his experimental era, and as rock was experiencing it’s own progressions; Miles Davis once told an Interviewer “I could put together the greatest rock ‘n’ roll band you ever heard”. Two years later he made this masterpiece. Thoughts from rock fans??

Posted Apr 1, 2020, 5:24 AM UTC

68
Farrell-Mars•

It’s a beautiful number, but apart from its having guitars in it, I don’t think this fits even a fairly wide definition of rock. It’s jazz of a very high order IMO and yes, Miles was a genius. Can we know who plays on it besides the trumpeter?

2
TheMaxChanceOP•

Jack DeJohnette- Drums John McLaughlin- Electric guitar Dave Holland- Bass Chick Corea- Electric Piano That’s a pretty heavy lineup !! In order for it to fit, what are we comparing it to ?? I’m not saying your right or wrong I’m just asking. I feel like at this time there’s no clear definition of what rock was.

2
Farrell-Mars•

I feel like the one rnr essential is a consistent back beat. Even bands that really stretch it—the Dead for instance—always comes back to the beat. An exception might be Frank Zappa, but he openly acknowledged his jazz proclivities. This is jazz in that regard.

1
TheMaxChanceOP•

Okay thanks for the feedback.

1
Kabirdix•

Well, this is from his fusion period, right? So relevant for the rock influence. Not like PURE rock by any stretch, whatever that would be, but enough so (I would’ve thought). Great stuff by the way!

1
TheMaxChanceOP•

Yea I completely agree with you my friend. I personally think it could be considered rock because he was pushing new boundaries. If there was a wall that separated rock from jazz Miles basically bulldozed it. That’s why he’s such a legend, he made people actually think about the concept of “genres” by pushing their boundaries, just like you alluded to with his influence.

2
Hanni74bal•

this is awesome!

thnx

1
TheMaxChanceOP•

Isn’t it amazing !

1