r/starcraft•
ProZero

So I made a program... but I don' think I should finish it...

I play StarCraft 2 and I'm not very good (Forever bronze :( ).

During the heat of battle I always forget steps and I fall behind.

So I started writing a program that would give me a sound when:

  • Larvae has popped off hatchery (hotkey 5 > s > v; start countdown)
  • Tumor has reached maximum spread. (c > start countdown)

But I don't think I should finish this tool because it may be considered cheating. What do you think screddit?

Screenshot of program: Zerg Aware

btw im new to reddit Hello!

FINAL EDIT

The project has been cancelled as Blizzard has added "an alert has been added when the Spawn Larvae buff expires." Effectively making the program redundant.

Posted Mar 9, 2011, 12:34 AM UTC · edited

1477
[deleted]•

Yes, this would be cheating.

15
fuzzyevil•

Gonna agree with this guy here. It doesn't seem like much, but it is definitely something that's boosting your game using an external program. In other words, against the rules.

8
renaldthefox•

I'm not sure I agree. At a even moderately high level of play (like mid diamond) payers wont need these notifications. At a lower level some players might find them useful, but it isn't playing the game for you, or giving you information that you wouldn't have already. If a zerg player beat me using this mod it would be because it helped him make fewer mistakes that I did. Which is really my fault anyway. I couldn't possibly consider this cheating.

1
[deleted]•

Where's the line then? Am I allowed to create a program that notifies me whenever a dropship emerges from the fog? Can I write a program that shows me where observers are? Both those things are information that I can notice myself, but I could get something to help me with.

0
recursive•

That's different because it requires extracting information from starcraft to operate. This does not.

3
[deleted]•

Doesn't change anything, you're hooking up the program to react to what happens in the game. It's the same thing as looking at someone else's FPstream.

0
failburt•

Yeah this is cheating, but it's not hooking into the game and reading its memory so it's not going to get you banned from b.net. You could prefer people not use it on the ladder, but that's unenforceable.

It's just an external timer. There was that timer website you could run on a second monitor. It would change its entire background color every 25 seconds to remind you for inject. This is the same thing but a little more advanced.

1
NolariTeam Grubby•

How do you feel about people that live stream while laddering, and at the same time chat on Skype with friends that watch the stream? I feel that's an equal amount of cheating or non-cheating.

1
[deleted]•

I don't know why you would bring something like that up, but if they're helping him of course that's cheating.

1
NolariTeam Grubby•

Well quite a few live streamers do something like that, so they're all cheaters then.

0
[deleted]•

i heard the ptr now has alerts for when injections finish/chronoboost has enough energy/mules are available. i might be wrong though. just letting you know it might not be too useful in the future :P

10
risosZerg•

Can someone confirm this?

2
cHiNaHoP•
8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
NiceTryGai•

I'd love to see you finish this program, even if you made it available with the disclaimer that it's intended to be used as a training program in single player mode. That's where I'd use it, myself. To develop the habit and pattern...

8
hun13•

i agree, it would actually make an excelent training program

2
ProZeroOP•

I agree as well

1
oOOoOphidianZeNEX•

Not much different from just having an alarm in the first place, but much more convenient. I don't think it's cheating really, but not entirely necessary either, especially given that the new patch will give alerts for macro mechanics if it's implemented.

5
moarzorsZerg•

after months of training myself to inject on time they make it so anybody can do it T_T

2
IVIAuricGama Bears•

Creep tumor alerts would be useful though.

1
Tamer_•

I think that sort of utility seems to be in a gray area, but really is not. First, you can't prevent anyone from using it in online play and many players would consider this to be an unfair advantage (that's for the "appears to be")

BUT, there were tools being used that added a clock on top of SC2 before that was integrated by Blizzard. This is the kind of stuff that should be inside the game, but until it is, people will consider them unfair.

I myself have used (and actually have been - AFAIK - the first person to publicize a way to use) custom hotkeys for SC2, back during the beta. The general opinion was saying this was either illegal or would never be accepted in tournament play. I'm fairly certain that when Dustin Browder said in interview that "advanced users could use tools to edit text files" he was referring directly to the method I was supporting.

My point is, doing it will bring light to what the community wants and maybe get Blizzard to support that - if your tool becomes popular. As long as it does not change in any way the game works or any of its files (and I understand you're not), you should not break the EULA.

5
benzet•

Klotsche Center, $15 Locker... this is my mission

3
ProZeroOP•

lol my locker!

1
[deleted]•

Sup UWM

1
ProZeroOP•

Hey! Do you know anything about the r/uwmilwaukee meetup?

Also, I just posted my beer pong table design Check it out!

1
[deleted]•

That's sweet. I used to live on the east side so I just knew the Klotsche Center, not there anymore though

1
WalriLord•

Yea if its not built into the game itself than its not different then a timer and isnt cheating at all

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
w0Ot•

omg can you upload your wallpaper for me please :D

and i would like to see you finish this tool i would like to try this out as i play zerg.

2
ProZeroOP•

Here Deviantart is your wallpaper friend ;)

3
w0Ot•

Thank You :)

1
ProZeroOP•

np

1
keshi•

You could simply have an alarm that beeps once every 20 seconds....Even if things get out of sync, having an alarm beep will bring your mind back around to what you should be doing.

Much like how people used to tie string around their fingers.

2
AvelestarZerg•

That's a good idea...I'll have to try and find a timer that I can set for every 40 seconds. Especially if it can have a reset function, that I can just push and it will start again, so I don't have to fiddle around or waste time syncing the timer with the injects again.

1
ProZeroOP•

That is a good suggestion

1
jaydee81•

I find it amusing with what kind of explanations people come up for why this would not be a cheat. I'm sure the EULA mentions something about external tools/scripts... can't be arsed to check though, have fun cheaters.

2
exoplasm•

I tried a similar idea 7 months ago and my conclusion was that it does not actually help.

Was fun to make, though.

Edit: It's currently hosted on google code

2
cyklaTeam 8•

I tried a similar idea 7 months ago and my conclusion was that it does not actually help.

I can see that it might not be helpful in terms of learning. To me it feels a bit weird listening for a sound rather than going through your controls groups continuously (5,6 in my in case). To me it's part of muscle memory now and I can inject pretty darn well I think.

I think that while relying on hearing a sound for inejcting may be very helpful for people in the lower leagues, but I don't think it'll be even close as beneficial long term.

1
ProZeroOP•

Was fun to make, though.

Yes!

1
KabukiJakeProtoss•

As long as it doesn't actually interfere with the game itself, Blizzard doesn't consider this kind of thing cheating.

Obviously it's not tournament legal, but it would be fine otherwise.

1
ProZeroOP•

lol bronze tournament. No the app runs adjacent to the game, like a trainer. It looks for a specific key sequence.

1
Tamer_•

Can we specify the key sequence? (sorry, I haven't try it yet, and don't plan to today either)

1
ProZeroOP•

Basically it looks for a sequence of keys:

Currently it is set to my hotkey setup so larvae inject would be 5 + V (Cooldown counter runs)

or pressing "C" (tumors) runs another cooldown counter.

1
Tamer_•

Right...could you change it so that we could specify the sequence it is looking for?

1
Tamer_•

Can we specify the key sequence? (sorry, I haven't try it yet, and don't plan to today either)

1
rakantaeTerran•

Automated Mule Tracking System Online in 5...4...3...2...1...

1
ProZeroOP•

I've been worked by so many mass marines that I don't support this, sorry :)

3
Kardaron•

isnt this being implemented in patch 1.3 though?

1
ProZeroOP•

src?

1
NapsteR897Protoss•

Dude just dot it, its a training program, its like saying that playing while listening to music is cheating caause helps u focuse and its a 3rd program or having a coach looking over you and saying "LARVA!!" or "CREEP" is cheating... i mean u really doing this guys?? for the love of god Mr. Bitter tells their students to use a thing that makes a sound every 30 seconds so they remember to spawn larva.... QQ MOAR

1
Yoonjin90•

I recommend people using it however in tournaments im pretty sure they will not allow it.

1
theshadow990•

Good idea great work too bad blizzard is going to ban you.

1
foxdaleRandom•

sweet!

1
skyrideRandom•

How does it work? Like, what are you using to keep check on the timings for injects/tumors? I wouldn't have thought taking the input directly from keyboard input would be a great idea (there's more than one function for the "V" key) and hooking directly into the game itself would get marked by AC as cheating.

1
NolariTeam Grubby•

Cooldown time: 25

That seems odd. At "Faster" speed, the conversion factor between game time and real time is 29/40 = 0.725, so I would expect to see 29.

1
ProZeroOP•

oh I just read somewhere it is 25.

1