Daovua F&F: Warped blade. Fix or Return?

Question

So I finally sprung for a Daovua Bunka from CKTG. I'm newish to sharpening my knives, so I thought it would be a good knife to futz around with while I practiced. I was aware of the rep of these knives, but still decided to roll-the-dice and order one.

For the most part, the grind and edge were as bad as people say, but that doesn't actually bother me as I'm going to be using it for sharpening practice anyways. What I'm not happy with is the steel's overall condition. To begin with, it looks like it's coming out of the handle in a way which it's not plumb or straight. On top of that, the blade is warped (bowed?) significantly. In that pic, you can see that it curves out to the left side of the blade a bit. Here, you can see the spine actually curves out and comes back. This speed square helps accentuate it..

I guess my question is should this be an immediate return? It seems like there is a litany of issues going on and, while I don't mind learning how to fix these things, is it even possible to fix this?

edit: taking pictures of knives with a phone is so goddamned hard with a phone. any of you who do this regularly are really some kind of wizards.

e2: for the next person that comes along this during a search, here's some of the f&f problems 1, 2, and a choil shot

Posted Apr 16, 2020, 4:49 PM UTC · edited

419

Here we go again....

My advice is to return it. If purchased from CKTG, I wouldn’t give them my money again, either.

11
PewpasaurusOP•

I've noticed an increasing amount of anti-CTGK sentiment going around. Is this solely because of them hiding negative reviews or is there more to it?

2

That is the reason for my opinion, yes. They did it to me. I thought it was shady, and I won’t give them my money again.

Others feel he doesn’t do a good job of making sure he’s buying the best knives the makers offer, since handmade knives have a lot of variability. Prices in the US are higher than japan, and customers expect the dealers to filter out the lower quality ones, especially since you can’t hold these knives when buying online.

Still others don’t like that one of his hobbies seems to be putting fancy handles on cheaper knives, and selling them for a much higher margin.

For all these reasons, I have personally decided not to give him my money.

For instance, I’ve never heard anyone say they bought anything but a great knife from Jon Broida at Japanese Knife Imports. He enjoys a sterling reputation in the community.

8
PewpasaurusOP•

Still others don’t like that one of his hobbies seems to be putting fancy handles on cheaper knives, and selling them for a much higher margin.

That's funny. I think these Daovua's have the same problem. Steel aside, I think their rep would be a lot better if they put more effort into QC rather than churching up the handles.

In regards to CTKG in general, I've always appreciated the information and videos that they've had on the knife pages, but I can understand the disdain if those other claims have creedence.

I also love Jon and his content, I'm just not in the price bracket for most of his knives right now.

2
IJayceYou•

Yes CKTG has a pretty good range of knives and their prices are usually alright except the "fancy" handled ones. The problem is their quality control as you can see. Dao Vua is already problematic, so not necessarily a good idea to buy from them. Also their shady shit with ratings and some lack of professionality. I read one case where a customer was not satisfied with their product and their customer service in that regard and complained about it, not really in a nice manner but not calling names bad. Mark Richmond (Owner) then had the audacity to call him out with his real name and posting a screenshot of the trakking with all the personal info in it.

2
slickmambamade in solingen•

I’m not sure about increasing, but I’d say the knife community as a whole has a light-moderate disdain for cktg, except their own forum of course Reasons vary from personality, uncurated products, misleading info, “customs/one of a kinds”, shady reviews, other business practices, etc

3
slickmambamade in solingen•

Return it dude you knew about all the issues and still bought one?

You can straighten it out, but the steel will still be shit

10
Spipet•

Dont buy a shit knife to learn how to sharpen on. Better to learn on something decent

4
PewpasaurusOP•

I also have a Fujiwara Kanefusa nakiri, I just thought it would be interesting to check out a different geometry & steel combo.

1
pootzillait's knife to meet you•

Some helpful, non-degrading advice: return it. If you're still interested in the knife, exchange it instead. At least it's a relatively affordable knife and you didn't drop $300 for this to happen. The daovua knives are obviously budget blades that are pretty cool and interesting, not $200+ works of art.

Personally, I would exchange it. Worst case scenario, the next one is messed up. You return it for a full refund and move on to a different knife to practice on.

3
Taramonia"Never go full bolster."•

F

3
HALBowmaninstagram.com/willisonknives | discord hero•

F

5
DifferentPeanut•

F

4
Skalla_Resco"I know what sharp is"•

F

3
marine775patron saint of r/chefknifememes•

That choil shot looks like a rusty nail.

Return that bad boy.

2
francois_du_nord•

I picked up a super inexpensive Tosa bunka from Bernal Cutlery about a month ago for the same reasons (practice). It too had a bit of a bend, the F&F of the handle was terrible, and it was in serious need of stone work. I've been working on it off an on for some time, and it actually has come around and I'm pretty happy with it.

The bend wasn't too difficult to get out, about the same as yours and about the same place, except to the right instead of the left. I actually bent it straight with just hand pressure.

But I'd send it back. Hopefully you'll get a much better example.

1
harrypiplum•

I too have the Tosa bunka because I wanted a project knife, but it came in a way more bent shape than I expected. I haven't figured out the best safest way to bend the blade back in shape. What's your experience? Should I just be persistent with the hand pressure?

My instincts say a rubber mallet, my experience says just pry it with my fucking hands.

1
francois_du_nord•

I just put my fingers on the concave portions, positioned my thumbs at the apex of the curve on the convex side, and applied pressure. TBH, my bend might have been 3-4 mm, so nothing super substantial.

I've seen some suggestions to use heat and a dowel rod, thankfully mine didn't require that much work. But it has made me wonder, did this actually get hardened, or was the Bernal copy a big story??

1
DifferentPeanut•

it's not worth your time. return it.

1