Population-level COVID-19 mortality risk for non-elderly individuals overall and for non-elderly individuals without underlying diseases in pandemic epicenters
medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.05.200543...Posted May 13, 2020, 6:43 AM UTC
Posted May 13, 2020, 6:43 AM UTC
It appears that your article has already been submitted [Rule 5]. Exceptions will be considered for posts that add significant context or new content that was absent from the previous post.
If you believe we made a mistake, please please message the moderators. Thanks for keeping r/COVID19 informative!
Reminder: This post contains a preprint that has not been peer-reviewed.
Readers should be aware that preprints have not been finalized by authors, may contain errors, and report info that has not yet been accepted or endorsed in any way by the scientific or medical community.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
This paper was posted on April 8th, before NY, on which it’s based, exploded.
“Data were available for Belgium, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland, as well as Louisiana, Michigan, Washington states and New York City ....”
All of which hadn’t peaked by that time.
My comment still holds.
Risk and fatality estimations are undervalued until all cases of a given population are closed.
We saw the same underestimation on the Diamond Princess, where after the study was published a number of patients died throwing the figures off.
[deleted]
Actually, it was on the 7th accordingly to the same source.
However, due to how Covid-19 works, fatality data is completely unreliable up to 20 days following infection, and some as late as 35 days. Which is my problem.
I don't know. This data correlates and the conclusions correlate with almost everywhere on the planet that has a large number of covid19 cases.
So what is the point of denying it? Or at least, where can we find a place where this data is significantly (not at the margins) refuted?
The South Korean study which is one of the few retrospectives.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.14.20036178v2
You simply can’t do these studies in real time. You actually need time for all the cases to get closed.
[deleted]
Is it?
It still shows lower values than South Korea. The plus of using NY is that you can calculate the minimum possible values for different heard immunity values and asymptomatic ratio.
The only other reliable source is exactly South Korea.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.14.20036178v2
It’s a crap when really does’t fit your world.
[deleted]
Median age differs by 1.5 years, South Korea being the older.
On the other hand, there were no fatalities in South Korea of people younger than 39, which was certainly not the case on NYS.
This paper does not go into other risks from the virus, including lung damage, nervous system damage, and younger people being hospitalizedand overwhelming hospitals - which ironically would cause older people to get even less care. Dangerous paper when viewed out of context. This paper leads folks like Rand Paul to tell Fauci "He is not the end-all", as he takes everything out of context.
Please don't politicize things. Explain why the paper needs to mention those risks and why not including them refutes the paper. I'd sincerely like to hear it.
It doesn't refute the paper, but the paper fails to provide the context required for the non-scientist to understand the caveats of their obvious "take-home" message - which could (and will be) be read by non-scientists that it is safe to go out, not wear a mask, and not social distance.
Scientists have a moral obligation to place their research in appropriate context, particulalrly in a period like this where their research will be read, and used, by a wider audience.
I would love to hear why you think ethics are irrelevant to science. Ever read anything on the psychology of science, and scientists? It shouldbe taught in every PhD program....
given that it's a paper analysing mortality risk why do you expect it to include other risks?
what evidence do you have of "lung damage, nervous system damage" etc?
Do you read this sub? I would ecommend you do before commenting. See above for ethical concerns about this paper. See this for lung damage, etc.
https://health.clevelandclinic.org/heres-the-damage-coronavirus-covid-19-can-do-to-your-lungs/
Blood clots: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01403-8
Nervous system: https://www.boldsky.com/health/wellness/coronavirus-can-damage-patients-central-nervous-system-132728.html
As you're complaining that the study doesn't include the risks young people have from these things I was hoping for some evidence that there are risks specifically to young people, not general sets of complications
Read the blood clot, lung damage papers - they affect anyone - and the blood clot complication was specifically first identified in younger people. I am not going to do your research for you, particularly if you are simply going to attack and not read the papers anyway.
I have serious qualms about estimating the absolute risk during a growing pandemic. The number of deaths in NYC has grown by an order of magnitude since this paper came out, so the estimate for NYC should be ~4,000 miles driven per day by now. This will continue to increase, so what is the utility in estimating absolute risk now, other than to mislead? Would we say that Covid-19 is harmless in Vietnam because 0 per million people have died?