How the New York Times reported the 1957 flu epidemic that killed up to 116,000.

Historial Perspective
How the New York Times reported the 1957 flu epidemic that killed up to 116,000.

Posted May 27, 2020, 1:15 PM UTC

359147
[deleted]•

[deleted]

181
ANGR1ST•

nobody who wasn't alive then even knows about that shit.

Even people that were alive don't remember it.

90
[deleted]•

[deleted]

85
ANGR1ST•

I really wish we had the context of how many people die on a regular basis. Somewhere between 2.5 and 3.0 million people die in the US every year. That's on the order of 7 thousand a day, every day.

100k dead Americans from a virus is bad, but it's not "commit economic and sociological suicide" bad.

68
AstralDragon1979•

Equally important is that the average age of the deaths is around or over the average age of mortality, so deaths attributed to COVID will lead to a reduction in deaths attributed to other causes. Half the people who died were in nursing homes, where the average life expectancy of a person in a nursing home is normally about 5 months. A wave of COVID deaths now should mean a trough in other reported deaths among the nursing home cohort over the next few months.

25
sense_seeker•

I enjoy takes on perspective because it forces thought and calls on logic.

I'll add to this initial perspective. How many people know that 360,000 people are born on Earth every single day? 54,000,000 entered the world so far in 2020.

On the other end of the spectrum we have death: Worldwide: 23,793,150Deaths this year. 114,142 Deaths yesterday. (1,500 of those deaths attributed to Covid-19) 32,880,963 Net population growth this year.

This raises the question as to where powerful intentions truly lie.

3
Waadap•

Im confused a bit here. Why are people acting like we are stopping at 100k? In a way, it invalidates a lot of the good info that shows up in this subreddit.

-5†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

14
SettleDownAlready•

My mom remembers both of those pandemics. She told how sick she, my sister and brother were in 1968.

8
ANGR1ST•

My mom didn't. I should ask my dad if he remembers.

3
SettleDownAlready•

You might have to ask around but I was able to find some family that did remember.

3
wutinthehail•

My mom was a nurse in 1968. I asked her if she remembered that pandemic and she said, "I really should but I don't".

4
Capt_Roger_Murdock•

Are adults so stupid and easily mislead they can't put things into proper historical context?

What's bizarre to me is that it seems like it should be so easy to break the spell. Ok, the media succeeded in whipping you up into a panicked frenzy because you're so historically illiterate and statistically innumerate that you have zero sense of proportion. Fine. But it seems like all it should take to snap you out of it is one person giving you that context, which takes all of around 10 seconds, e.g.,:

"You realize 116,000 Americans died to a flu pandemic in '57 and an additional 110,000 died to another one in '68? And that our population back then was significantly smaller? You realize that the median age of these '100,000 COVID-19 deaths' is literally around 80 years old, and that 90% had at least one known, significant comorbidity? And that all-cause mortality in the US is about 2.8 million deaths every single year?"

Poof. That's it. Or at least it should be. What the fuck is wrong with people?

47
[deleted]•

[removed]

16
mendelevium34MOD•

Thanks for you submission.

Our focus on this sub is examining the empirical basis for lockdowns. We don't welcome partisan posts.

3
AineofTheWoods•

It's a type of brainwashing. I was under it myself at first, jumping away from people on my walks, super scared etc. Luckily I never became obnoxious shaming people online, I never understood people doing that. Anyway, one day someone said 'if the media didn't exist, we wouldn't actually know the virus existed' and something clicked in my mind.' I realised my fear was because of the media. I stopped reading it and within a day or two I started to think 'hang on a minute.' It was a rapid change from there to a confirmed and total skeptic. I keep waiting for other people around me to go on the same journey but a lot still seem under the media brainwashing. Not all of them though, which has been reassuring to find out. I do think there are a huge amount of silent skeptics out there wondering what on earth is going on.

9
sense_seeker•

Thank you for your thoughts. This gives me hope.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
PensiveAfrican•

JP Sears, a comedian was talking about COVID and he basically said that people ignore more correct information that shows that they don't need to be as scared as they are because they already made up their minds when they were most afraid.

6
sense_seeker•

This sums up my frustration in a nutshell. Thank you!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HohlraumHe3•

Some of them don't want to admit they were wrong. Others were misled by politicians that CANNOT admit they were wrong since they'd be blamed for deaths, deaths they're trying to blame on the other party. Others still were misled by the media and I think a significant number just kind of got in a herd on social media and can't ever think of leaving.

1
JackLocke366•

Trump baited into the partisanship and Democrats took the bait. The history is that's few Dems said Trump wasn't doing a good enough job protecting the US, to which Trump stated their assessment was a hoax as they were doing things, and this snowballed into Republicans not wearing masks and Democrats supporting legislating monopolies for Walmart. It seems like a risky move now, but my sense is that when it gets to be November, the hysteria side will be greatly disadvantaged in the election.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

52
Izz2011•

Obamagate I believe is related to Obama setting up the initial surveillance on Trump which led to years of Russiagate nonsense. So it makes sense he really wants to push that. It's not like the mainstream media will ever report objectively on Russiagate though so it's kind of moot.

22
friendly_capybara•

Obamagate is not a thing

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
friendly_capybara•

You should look into it

It's not a thing.

This is low effort even by Trump standards: he didn't even come up with a conspiracy theory this time. He just said "Look into it! It's totally a real thing!"... much like you're doing

0
The_Gurl_Among_You•

Republicans are now like the fun dad who'll let you go the beach while Democrats are the shrew mom who wants you to stay inside forever

Good analogy

3
HohlraumHe3•

Obamagate needs to be fully investigated. It is not cool for a sitting president to spy on a political opponent or attempt to sabotage the incoming administration with lies and a weaponized bureaucracy.

It needs to be investigated and people need to go to jail. Otherwise, Trump can do it too.

1
pfthrowaway21315•

It’s also worth mentioning that it probably would kill more today, as people are living longer.

Half of the people who die from COVID in nursing homes, that were probably hanging on by a thread, wouldn’t be alive in 1968.

18
[deleted]•

Very good point. Or, they wouldn’t be in nursing homes, as they were not as predominant then.

5
sense_seeker•

It's an absolutely HUGE point that is lost on too many. Healthcare has evolved to increase the lifespan of many who would otherwise perish. It's ironic that the today, lockdown has caused the healthcare industry itself to be severely crippled, if not dismantled.

3
Capt_Roger_Murdock•

It looks like the United States’ 65+ population was around 9.8% in 1970 versus around 16% today. I can’t easily find data for back then that gives greater breakdown than that, but I’d guess increase in number of 80+ year olds may be even more striking. Also worth considering that there was much less obesity back then. Those prior pandemics not only killed more Americans in population-adjusted terms than COVID-19 will, they killed more from a population that was significantly younger and healthier.

4
KhmerMcKhmerFace•

I think having hit Italy first more or less outside China was really bad luck. Their media is notoriously sensationalist, famous for rushing nonsense to print. Shit, they invented the term “paparazzi.”

Had it hit hard in say Norway or Sweden first, they probably would have stressed in their reporting something like “although this is mirroring an extremely bad flu season, over 70% of deaths are people in nursing homes already sick with other issues, and the average COVID death involves elders already older than our average life span.”

I guess Sweden went their way because of these facts. It would have been great if it hit Sweden first because Sweden is literally 98% “leftist.” The most Conservative party in Sweden is very far left of say, mainstream US Democrats. Yes, there are right wing parties but they are too small to even worth mentioning.

So you would have had a chance at least of it not becoming a political issue in the USA.

Ah, who am I kidding. The left would have been for lockdown no matter what. Free checks is pretty popular with Democratic leadership.

I’m curious how Europeans will react when they realize they were manipulated by USA media to generate panic solely to give Democrats a chance against Trump by destroying the greatest economy the world has ever seen.

11
bitfairytale17•

This is the key takeaway. All of this.

3
TrickyNote•

I lived through the 68 flu epidemic and didn’t know about it until I recently started reading about it. I do recall getting the live small pox and polio vaccines, and I also remember chicken pox and measles parties. It was all just normal.

3
friendly_capybara•

Are adults so stupid and easily mislead they can't put things into proper historical context?

year of our lord Trump 2020?

You just answered your own question?

1
OffMyMedzz•

I asked my parents about the 68 flu, they don't remember it. They would've been 12-13 at the time.

1
dat529OP•

Compared to today's breathless coverage this article is clearly from another era. If we compare the deaths from 1957 based on population, it would be the equivalent of roughly 230,000 people dying today from the epidemic. Notice the language: "Most Cases Are Mild, " "no cause for alarm," they even mention that, "the assumption, therefore, was that several hundred and possibly several thousand others had Asian flu."

Link to the article: https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1957/10/03/84768604.html?pageNumber=1

163
[deleted]•

[deleted]

36
SweatingSoy•

Democrats have perverse incentives as well (media is an arm of the Democrat party). Very big ones. We won't be hearing a lick about covid after November. Then everyone will just pretend like this giant cluster fuck never happened. Mark my words.

20
Graham_M_Goodman•

When people stop talking about Covid19 I will eat cake. Mark my words.

7
The_Gurl_Among_YouOhio, USA•

...Is it too soon to say anything?

1
IAMAHobbitAMA•

Well, here we are. Lets see if this pans out lol.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
The_Gurl_Among_You•

RemindMe! November 5, 2020

Hopefully the bot works this time

1
ASemesterAbroad•

RemindMe! November 5, 2020

I'm also interested in seeing how much better we are in Nov.

2
RemindMeBot•

I will be messaging you in 5 months on 2020-11-05 00:00:00 UTC to remind you of this link

5 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)


^(Info)^(Custom)^(Your Reminders)^(Feedback)
1
[deleted]•

Unfortunately for my mental health the bot worked perfectly. This really sucks.

1
WasabiEyemask•

media is an arm of the Democrat party

That would be a conspiracy theory no?

We won't be hearing a lick about covid after November

You really think the entire world is all in one a big conspiracy to be mean to Donald Trump?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mymultivac•

Current Covid-19 media coverage is akin to the shark attack news that dominates media every 10 years or so, except now we have social media to help power it.

Covid-19 is unseeable, uncontrollable, and results in an agonizing death ... just like shark attacks:

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animal-emotions/201711/shark-attacks-myths-misunderstandings-and-human-fear

73
jugglerted•

Ahh imagine "Jaws" with social media!

2
WasabiEyemask•

Except the death rate and rate of being permanently disabled is much higher with covid19.

Source: My grandmother and mom died of covid19 here in Connecticut.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1

When everyone over 50 would actually remember the Spanish Flu, not to mention 3 major wars and the peak of polio...

61

It's kind of what de Tocqueville talked about when he pointed out that the more equal we become, the more any remaining inequality bugs us.

It seems that the safer we become, the more intolerable any remaining risks become to people.

42
Duckbilledplatypi•

In addition, we're raised in a culture of fear - God, authority, illness, safety, strangers, strange places, etc. Fear everything lest it lead to death. Because the ultimate fear? Well, that's death.

12
[deleted]•

I love that we can casually drop a 'Tocqueville' and trust the reader will know who it is.

10
bagelbabey•

Upvoted for Tocqueville

2
Engine-earz•

This needs more upvote

2
ed8907•

Most cases are mild

It feels like deja vu

51
UrFreakinOutMannn•

Deja flu

48
[deleted]•

This is extremely eye-opening since it's coming from literally the same newspaper that ran an entire frontpage on a disease that killed less people (not even accounting for total population differences). Really shows to what extent the increasingly sensationalist media has warped our view of reality, and how much our society's view and attitude towards death has shifted. Nice find, OP.

50
[deleted]•

[deleted]

48
negmate•

The pandemic isn't even on his Wikipedia.

1
Capt_Roger_Murdock•

killed up to 116,000

The population-adjusted equivalent of around 212,000 today. No front-page "incalculable loss" article with 1,000 randomly-selected names of people who died from the flu (or were murdered in their cars)?

45
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
Full_Progress•

Wow that’s all I have to say...

35
Max_Thunder•

So different from the news nowadays, where the focus would have been on the 5 kids that developed Kawasaki syndrome and how doctors have been observing a very worrisome 400% increase in the typical number of cases for this disease.

31
Damianawenchbeast•

Hey I'm curious about this kawasaki thing, just how prevalent is it? People around me are starting to talk about it like it's spreading like wildfire.

9
verticalquandry•

257 healthy kids die from the flu a year. freak out when were above that

12
Max_Thunder•

To be honest I'm not sure.

There was this paper https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.10.20097394v1 where they mention getting 17 kids with it in Paris over 11 days when the average for 2018-2019 was 1 every 14 days. All had a positive clinical outcome. The correlation with covid-19 is unclear but over 80% of the kids tested positive for it. It seems to affect people with African ancestry more.

My take is that it's serious and happening more often, but that it's still very rare.

Here they say that a press release from the American Heart Association (AHA) aimed to reassure parents of how uncommon the condition is but noted that as "some children are becoming very ill extremely quickly, children with these symptoms should be swiftly evaluated and cared for in hospitals with pediatric cardiac intensive care units, as needed."

6

As a soon to be historian (I'm doing my PhD), all the ahistorical comparisons to the Spanish Flu piss me off when things like this exist. You don't need to be a trained researcher to do a google search and find this. There might have been cause for concern back in March, but right now, today, there is no excuse for continued panic.

26
35739578345353•

Snopes even says it was the returning troops that made the second wave worse, not so much a lack of social distancing.

2
[deleted]•

This is a really creative idea. I’m gonna see how many different articles from 57 and 68 I can find

20
freelancemomma•

Fascinating to read. The equanimity and lack of alarmism jump out.

17
[deleted]•

Imagine that. Honest fact based reporting. No opinions no fear mongering no sensationalist headlines. Just facts and a quote from the Commisioner of Health. Just reporting the news. What a novel concept. Too bad you have to go back 50 years to find it.

17
hotsauce126•

This is what happens when there's no social media or 24 hour news stations to spread hysteria and virtue signaling

16
[deleted]•

PhIlIp BeNjAmIn Is A gRaNnY kIlLeR!

15
[deleted]•

Was that over one flu season? And were lockdowns imposed? You can’t argue with people because they’ll claim that without a lockdown, we would have lost millions!

13
HoldTheCorona•

They did not lock down during 57 or 68 pandemics. In fact, in 69 Woodstock occurred with that pandemic still going on.

But Lockdown was not imposed in Japan either for the current pandemic and they only had like 850 death out of 30 million people. I have heard multiple people say that with or without lockdown, the numbers are looking to be about the same in the long run with non locked down places faring even better in some cases

13
NotJustYet73•

But in 1957 they weren't looking for an excuse to destabilize the entire society. Today they're desperately scrambling, reaching for anything that might sound halfway plausible to the people. They're fed up with maintaining the illusion of a free society and that's why they're pushing the "new normal" so insistently. "When is this going to end? Who knows!" They want us to accept that freedom of movement is a thing of the past.

12
[deleted]•

Ok genuine question though, how long did that pandemic last?

Like I do think there is an overreaction but if its that number over a year for example its not really comparable.

5

About a year. But we are comparing two widely different worlds. In 1957 there was no mass travel, cold war, large areas of the world effectively isolated. The same virus would spread much faster today and potentially have the same amount of deaths in a smaller period.

You could also say that a pandemic that lasts longer is harder to deal with than one burns itself out in a matter of months.

13
[deleted]•

Yeah I guess. I honestly dont have enough knowledge to know how comparavle the diseases are.

2
OrneryStruggle•

Over a flu season, obviously.

1
KWEL1TY•

Asian flu? 😡😡😡

3
Duckbilledplatypi•

How did NYT report on Spanish flu (which, by all accounts, is substantially worse than covid 19)? I've heard it wasn't even front page news - nevermind the ONLY news

2