How responsible are people for picking up on social cues?
Okay, so I've recently been downvoted to oblivion for an opinion I held and I thought it was a totally reasonable, rational opinion. As the reasonable and rational community that I know TwoX is I come to you to shed some light. I think that feeling uncomfortable with the unwanted, unsolicited attention of strange men is something that many women have delt with on a number of occasions. Obviously, it seriously sucks, in most cases for all parties involved. My opinion on the matter was that in these instances women need to express their disinterest directly, particularly in cases where the guy has been intrusive over a span of time. I suggested that it was the responsibility of women in this position to tell the guys they aren't interested straight up. People responded very, very poorly to this idea and it was linked to victim blaming, which I found to be quite offensive because I consider myself a good person. As far as I could tell, people were saying that simply giving off vibes, and having a certain demeanor and tone should have been sufficient evidence to a man that his advances weren't welcome. I thought this was nonsense. We have the ability of language for a reason. Certainly not all of the responsibility for these awful situations should fall on the guy just because he was too dumb to pick up on the series of hints you've been sending out, right? I mean can you really blame someone for not understanding what you haven't told them? Is this actually victim blaming? P.S I can't figure out how to do separate paragraphs, so sorry for the block of writing.
Posted May 23, 2011, 7:08 AM UTC
If I'm already feeling unsafe when a man is trying to flirt with me or find out more about me, I try to escape the situation rather than being confrontational.
If you say something "mean" to them, like "please leave me alone", how can you tell how they're going to react? They could have a violent reaction. It isn't a tactful thing to say.
A lot of people lose their social norms when they've had too much to drink, so you're right. They could get physically confrontational. The primary goal is for you to stay safe and do what you feel is necessary to do that.
Good point. I think I overlooked the role of alcohol in these situations.
This exactly. Many women -- including myself -- try to avoid voicing a straightforward rejection because we are unsure whether or not the rejected party will escalate in the face of outright rejection. There are so many stories of people -- men and women -- getting downright ugly and threatening when they're told, "No."
And, frankly, if you're over the age of 20 and don't have Asperger's, expecting the world to give you black & white verbal answers all the time is a rather naive/childish attitude. Yeah, it'd be easier, but that's not how society generally works. Human interaction isn't like computer code. Human interaction is filled with subtlety (e.g. tone of voice, body language), and refusing to make the effort to learn how to read said nuance is your problem.
I do it all the time. I haven't been attacked once. You're going to have to learn how to stand up for yourself and stop being so afraid of men, ESPECIALLY if you are around other people. You are not going to get attacked if you are at a bar or out in public where there are other people around.
While I agree that is unlikely that the you are going to get attacked in public, it only takes one time for someone to totally lose their confidence in this sort of situation. I think you've been lucky, but make sure you don't discount the experience of those who haven't been.
They haven't tried, though. They've said they have always been too afraid. If they had said something and then been attacked, I'd understand the fear; but they haven't.
Thank you. It takes courage to say a clear "no" when you are in a frightening situation, and I've had that answer disrespected in the past.
Luckily flirting is not usually threatening and is flattering, but I've been in two situations where I was afraid. Both times involved the significantly older man following me and looking for me throughout the day when I had tried to remove myself from the situation. One of those men tried to get me to narrow down where exactly I lived. In retrospect I should have told the event security about that address-seeking guy. The non-address-seeking guy found me at the same event a year later and sat next to me.