(Canada) how does the quarantine act not violate UN Human Rights

I read the quarantine act and the United human rights on detention and imprisonment.

The quarantine act is the statutory law by which persons are taken into “detention” and have certain rights - basically for a review every 7 days.

Yet, the fact you can be taken to a detention facility with or without warrant and without due process of law nor opportunity to face criminal charges in court seem to be against human rights.

Further the quarantine act identifies a person can be imprisoned for 6 months on summaryor 3 years on indictment.

Question : if persons can be put into a detention facility without due process of law, how is this not kidnapping and illegal confinement? Never mind any government breach of constitutional authority - deprivation of liberty.

If this should be posted somewhere else, please let me know.

Posted Jul 23, 2020, 4:15 AM UTC

155
GArmas-CardonaInternational Law & Human Rights•

First, there is a human right to liberty, but that right is not absolute (in fact, no right is absolute with the possible exception of the right to life). If you look at Article 12 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the right that discusses freedom of movement, you'll see that paragraph 3 points an important exception to this right:

  1. The above-mentioned rights shall not be subject to any restrictions except those which are provided by law, are necessary to protect national security, public order (ordre public), public health or morals or the rights and freedoms of others, and are consistent with the other rights recognized in the present Covenant.

In terms of quarantine & COVID-19, if the quarantine law is considered necessary to protect public health, then it would fall within this exception.

However, I do agree with you that forced quarantine is a severe infringement on one's human rights (an infringement, not necessarily a violation). This severe infringement must have a proportionally significant benefit to comply with human rights obligations. The general test is whether there is a "less restrictive alternative" available. For most people, self-isolation at home is a less restrictive alternative that is just as effective. Human rights advocates have been pushing for forced quarantine to only be used when self-isolation is not a possibility.

25
LeaveTheMatrix•

Human rights advocates have been pushing for forced quarantine to only be used when self-isolation is not a possibility.

I do not like the idea of forced quarantining, however with the number of "wearing masks violates my rights" and "the virus is a hoax" people out there, it scares me how many people would be running around infecting people if quarantine was not being enforced in high infection rate areas.

I think that the "less restrictive alternative" is wearing a mask, but in the rare times I go out in public it amazes me how many people are wearing masks incorrectly.

Even at stores where the employees are being made to wear them, half of them are only covering the mouth and not the nose.

Have even seen this with nurses/doctors at the local VA hospital.

Needless to say, I have never been so glad that living a hermit lifestyle is something I have already been doing so I rarely have to go out in public.

EDIT: When I or my g/f do go out somewhere, we wear n95 masks.

4
powder_gwnOP•

so there is a long conversation for another sub about the efficacy of masks. N95 protect you breathing in a specific size particle and not micro droplets, which are present with covid. Dont get me started on cloth/sock masks.

​

My wife and i wear masks when we are in a store.

​

I firmly believe that people have the right to protect their civil rights. As a generalization, i believe people are good and will do good for the community. The issue i have is that the government has chose to subvert the legal procedure to establish law and are using proclamations and exec orders to violate and exceed their constitutional and statutory authority.

1
powder_gwnOP•

Thank you for your response. This helps me understand the context of the UN human rights. It seems like there is a thin line between infringement and violation.

3
GArmas-CardonaInternational Law & Human Rights•

You're welcome. In short, an infringement is a violation unless the infringement can be justified. Paragraph 3 provides that justification regarding the right to liberty and movement.

10