CMV: Mankind is good for the environment.
[removed]
Posted Jul 24, 2020, 12:09 AM UTC
[removed]
Posted Jul 24, 2020, 12:09 AM UTC
I'm pretty sure most people care about the environment because the nature is a means for us to survive and derive enjoyment.
People care about the pandas dying out because pandas are cute and bring us enjoyment.
People care about the bugs dying out because it could dramatically affect the food chain, and hurt humanity in the long run.
Humanity is bad for nature because humanity brings dramatic change to the ecosystem (GMOs, climate change, antibiotic resistance), which makes it inherently unstable. This instability is bad because it destabilizes things that are important to humans such as food.
humans need the environment in order to survive therefore humanity is bad for the environment
That's incoherent.
...That's not what I wrote, I'm saying that humanity is bad for the environment, which is bad for us.
I'm saying that humanity is bad for the environment,
How so?
Climate change and population are causing great reductions in populations and species are going extinct. GMOs reduce genetic diversity which makes them more susceptible to viruses...
The fact that humanity is causing dramatic change to the environment is not up for debate.
I don't know man... If you held me at gunpoint but told me that you'll resurrect me (eventually) I'd still ask you not to pull the trigger, but that's only my opinion I guess. The same way, I'll won't buy a Lambo today because I might win the lottery in a distant future. You probably won't start doing massive amont of cocaine today because you may or may not be able to transfer your consciousness someday...
In just 500 million years, the Sun will heat up and photosynthesis will become impossible on Earth. Unless a species exists with the power and desire to prevent this End.
So, let's say this is true. It sounds like your view is based on the idea that humans can and will be able to stop this.
What if they can't / don't?
Also, the massive amount of pollution, habitat loss, global warming, garbage produced, and the destabilization of ecosystems has been terrible for the environment. Even if you only value nature as a means to human ends, these things are directly harming people as well (e.g. higher rates of asthma / death, crop failure due to temperatures increasing, wars happening due to droughts, people being displaced).
I think the trouble with this statement is with the term "environment". It's too broad.
It's a little bit like saying Columbus coming sailing across the ocean in 1492 is good for America. Sure... maybe Columbus was good in the sense that European contact brought technology and other things to the Americas... but at the same time Columbus brought a lot of bad things and millions of people died.
I think the analogy extends to the "environment". Humans might be great for squirrels (who are doing fabulously in the urban/suburban environment), but we're terrible for polar bears.
More specificity is required before it's possible to say much.
Also, if you told me that you were going to genocide my entire race/species yet resurrect a few descendants a million years in the future, I would still probably hate you because that doesn't change the fact that a genocide occurred.
It's a little bit like saying Columbus coming sailing across the ocean in 1492 is good for America. Sure... maybe Columbus was good in the sense that European contact brought technology and other things to the Americas... but at the same time Columbus brought a lot of bad things and millions of people died.
It would be bad for the natives Americans to be isolated from the world. So Columbus actually did good to them by opening up their world and consciousness.
Mankind is good for every single species on Earth that has ever existed, because without mankind, every species will go extinct.
What do you mean “will go extinct?” If you’re talking about humans stopping the expansion of the sun, then you need to say how humans will survive that long as a species and also how they will stop the sun. Hypotheticals get us nowhere
What do you mean “will go extinct?”
I explained this in the post: in 500 million years, all life on earth will die because the Sun will heat up. Unless mankind is around.
Please read what I write before replying so I don't have to say it twice.
No I have read it, I just think that this assumption is simplistic at best. You cannot know that humans will be around when that happens.
So I guess what I’m asking is: how can you justify operating under this assumption
Edit: also way to not respond to the rest of the question.
There are a great deal of hypothetical situations in your view. The idea that humans will be alive in 500 million years is flawed in itself. But rather than argue hypotheticals that take place millions of years in the past or future, let’s talk about what is happening on Earth right now.
The amount of animal species being pushed to (and over) the brink of extinction by humans is a clear display for the case that we historically destroy the ecosystems that they inhabit. That is not to say that we do it intentionally, but we do damage environments.
Climate change is another example of damage on an even larger scale.
What is your definition of good for the environment? I'm assuming from what you have written it's being able to co exist with and encourage the greatest diversity of species.
https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/1/5/e1400253.full
There is no reason to believe with what we know that we will be able to delay the extinction of all life on earth as the sun changes. Or that we would even attempt to - might be a lot easier to just up and relocate elsewhere after all.
Even if mankind were able to delay the extinction of all life on earth that means distant future mankind isn't bad for the environment, not that present mankind isn't bad for the environment.
Mankind if it exists in 500 Million years (and with the capability of interfering with the end of life on earth) it would probably be so unrecognizable to us as mankind today that it would effectively be another species.
What is your definition of good for the environment? I'm assuming from what you have written it's being able to co exist with and encourage the greatest diversity of species.
I explained: assume animals are rational and capable of answering moral questions. Consider how much an animal is willing to give up for us. If I knew my species was going to go extinct, then I would give up anything to have a species capable of preventing the extinction, or reversing the extinction. Even if that species came with high risk of causing the extinction ahead of time.
Despite the efforts of some we as a species are responsible for the 6th great extinction event.
So was the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs. That asteroid did a good thing. Extinction events have no inherent badness.
There is no reason to believe with what we know that we will be able to delay the extinction of all life on earth as the sun changes. Or that we would even attempt to - might be a lot easier to just up and relocate elsewhere after all.
We will 100% not just be capable, but also willing. We already conserve species. What will we be capable of in 100 years, let alone 500 million.
- Even if mankind were able to delay the extinction of all life on earth that means distant future mankind isn't bad for the environment, not that present mankind isn't bad for the environment.
Are children not good for society just because they spend the first 10 years being evil?
Mankind if it exists in 500 Million years and with the capability of interfering with the end of life on earth would probably be so unrecognizable to us as mankind today that it would effectively another species.
Children are unrecognizable compared to their adult forms.
I explained: assume animals are rational and capable of answering moral questions. Consider how much an animal is willing to give up for us. If I knew my species was going to go extinct, then I would give up anything to have a species capable of preventing the extinction, or reversing the extinction. Even if that species came with high risk of causing the extinction ahead of time.
I don't see the usefulness of looking at trying to intuit this from the point of view of a rational and moral animal when that is not the situation that we are in. I could speculate after all that cats would want to watch the world burn ;)
I'm not trying to be combative here, if we can't agree on a definition of "what is good for the environment" then I have no chance in changing your view.
So was the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs. That asteroid did a good thing. Extinction events have no inherent badness.
This is natural evil vs moral evil though right?
We will 100% not just be capable, but also willing. We already conserve species. What will we be capable of in 100 years, let alone 500 million.
How can we begin to speculate on the morality or motivations of humanity in 500 Million years, look how much it's changed over the last 1000, 100 and even 10 years.
Perhaps we will have transcended to a higher plane of existence, become a technological rather than a biological species, wiped ourselves and the planet out.
We can wildly speculate all day long because there is not nearly enough data to know what mankind will become. We can observe however that our our technology has advanced in an exponential fashion.
Are children not good for society just because they spend the first 10 years being evil?
Some are, some are not, and sadly some never get the opportunity to be either. If I were to follow the life of any one person they could. a) start evil and remain evil b) start evil and become good. c) start evil then die before the opportunity to ever become good.
Why are we assuming that case B would be our trajectory as a species.
Children are unrecognizable compared to their adult forms.
That is a whole other conversation :)
Sorry, u/PolyphenolOverdose – your submission has been removed for breaking Rule B:
You must personally hold the view and demonstrate that you are open to it changing. A post cannot be on behalf of others, playing devil's advocate, as any entity other than yourself, or 'soapboxing'. See the wiki page for more information.
If you would like to appeal, you must first read the list of soapboxing indicators and common mistakes in appeal, review our appeals process here, then [message the moderators by clicking this link](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fchangemyview&subject=Rule+B+Appeal+PolyphenolOverdose&message=PolyphenolOverdose+would+like+to+appeal+the+removal+of+[his/her+post](https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/hwrc4h/-/\)+because...) within one week of this notice being posted. Please note that multiple violations will lead to a ban, as explained in our moderation standards.
Manking isn't good for envirtoment, nor it's bad. We are part of enviroment and part of things that make it change. Enviromental changes aren't bad because we will kill the earth, they are bad because we will cause enviroment to become uninhabitable to us.
We inhabit outer space. How bad do you think global warming is going to be lol?
Finding a way to shield from cosmic radiation, solution for living in different gravity, source of food to be used in outer space, a way to fuel our stations/colonies - all for enough people to safely reproduce. There is little chance that we will be able to accomplish it before enviromental changes start bothering us.
Pile up rubble to shield space stations and minimize time spent outside of it. Wear a radiation badge.
https://www.artificial-gravity.com/sw/SpinCalc/
Spin.
Plants.
Hydrogen, uranium, sunlight. What else?
We already have them solved. We are currently in the implementation stage.
The implementation is the actual problem...
A small number of people live in space temporarily, but we can't reproduce. A fetus won't develop right