omulandreiBrainBlocks Designer•

As a former Product Designer for BrainBlocks, I would love to continue to help and put myself at service for the community. Hit me up and we’ll make things happen ✌️love y’all

60
Joohansson:n3:Community Manager•

We are looking for devoted devs to help making this the best Nano wallet on the planet. https://github.com/Nault/Nault/

If you are interested, join us in the TNC discord!

46
QwahziFreeNanoFaucet.com•

RIP, thank you for the great service over the years! I used y'all for most of my Nano trades, and you were my top recommendation for new merchants looking to accept Nano

Best of luck to you and your future endeavors!

46
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
AndyBlockLettuceNano User•

BB was an important service in the early onboarding of merchants into the Nano ecosystem and really helped to push real use cases early, helping to form the identity of Nano as a genuine payment protocol.

Thank you to all at BB for all of the time and effort invested in the project over the years, and for the graceful nature of the planned closure. All the best!

33
redditor2836•

Not sure if this ever will be disclosed, but would be helpful to know the reason for sunset (personal thing or business model didn't worked out or just lost any hope in nano in general, etc.) Thanks for your contribution anyway!

32
vkanucyc•

it's a protest of the changed increase work generation requirement, even though it's still way too low, at least until the node can actually handle a large amount of requests.

4
redditor2836•

Thank you.

1
SeveralIfrepnode.org•

How do you know that? See my other comment...

1
vkanucyc•

I don't, but the timing seems to indicate this, I am sure there are other reasons as well.

I agree with your other comment, it needs to be more expensive for people to stall the network, which they can still do with dumping pre-computed blocks.

1

Ty (the brainblocks dev) agrees with me that a small fee would be more effective in spam prevention than POW.

If you're a payment processor, it's already difficult to find a viable path to profitability. This becomes impossible if they have to pay for the POW for all of their user's millions of transactions.

3
throwawayxooox•

Ty has been very vocal about not agreeing with the PoW increase, so I'd say this is in fact one of the reasons, if not the reason.

1
pwlkSomeNano.com•

I use BrainBlocks as payment processor for my WordPress Paywall and I was going to offer Nano payments on a soon to open woocommerce shop. Bummed it is going away, but thankful for good and useful products over the years. Best of luck to the BranBlocks team!

30
guil5566Nano User•

F

29
otherwisemilk•

F

14
JoeyjoejoeFS•

Are there any alternatives to for accepting nano payments online for a web store out ATM?

23
AndyBlockLettuceNano User•

Despite BB announcing the planned closure of the service, there are a growing number of payment-processors available for Nano.

Coingate offers Nano payments across a range of plugins (including Woocommerce) as well as a custom API, with direct settlement into fiat for merchants looking to limit exposure to volatility.

NowPayments offers a similar service as Coingate, across several plugins and an API

Coinify, too have an API for Nano payments and fiat settlements.

In addition to these 'larger' services, multiple community projects are offering similar functionality to BrainBlocks, so the ecosystem should be well equipped to pivot where necessary.

39
JoeyjoejoeFS•

Amazing, thanks for the reply and links!

10
kilrizzyNaNote :n1: LearnNano :n1: CoinEmbed•

Thanks Andy 😘

7
thelamer12345•

I am not going to pretend this is an actual replacement for Brainblocks because it is not , but I made a non custodial checkout system https://www.nanocheckout.com/ . There are many core logic things that are at play here to keep it free and low maintenance including no relation to real world currencies and the messaging bus being tied into Google accounts. Also our wallet is currently the only one that supports this, and due to the very low server side footprint it is not a direct integration into others, so no way to know if this will ever be available on any other wallets.

21
JoeyjoejoeFS•

Still pretty cool, I wish I had a bit more time to work on something with this. Feels like there is a big gap in the market now with BB gone but not much real word usage just yet for nano. Curious if and when that gap will be filled.

10
2D3S3RTMyNano.Ninja•

Check out https://github.com/accept-nano/accept-nano for webshop payments

17
JoeyjoejoeFS•

Nice, though need a nano node running, I know that someone had a nano node with an api is that still around or not anymore?

8
shamo42•

For devs who want a simple api to receive instant confirmations I recommend the excellent nanos.cc websocket api which is free atm:

https://api.nanos.cc/socket/

​

Check out this project if you want to want to implement a solution for your own node:

https://www.reddit.com/r/nanocurrency/comments/glxfja/introducing_buildoff_project_nano_rpc_proxy_a/

13
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
IAmMiguelChanelnanomart.cc•

I wish there was a way the Nano community could keep the BrainBlocks "Pay with NANO" button running - it is an essential service that makes projects like mine possible.

23
JoeyjoejoeFS•

Yeah its a big blow to have that gone it was a great service and really easy to implement.

15
elderadooy•

for eli5

what was their business model? i mean how they made revenue ?

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

24
elderadooy•

thanks for replying. but that dont seem right. lets assume that adoption was happening. how to generate income. is it by fees. plus whats hard for a site to service like BB locally? id it the node and wallet management? im just curious

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
elderadooy•

providing a service or a product.

what were the service or the product BB were providing ? if you say payment gateway, they were free

1
dontlikecomputersNano User•

Ad revenue possibly?

1

It was never going to be possible for them to be profitable given the current state of Nano. They were paying for the POW for all of the transactions of their users. An 8x increase in those operating costs becomes untenable. If they started charging a fee to cover their POW costs, then Nano is no longer feeless, and the community would cease to use their service.

1
throwawayxooox•

I think the community would still use the service honestly. BB is the best solution out there, people should expect to have to pay for it. Or even a subscription model or something would have worked. Charge users a yearly or monthly or even a once-off fee to unlock the service. There's lots of ways to make money, it's a shame they aren't trying those before shutting down. I'm sure a lot of people who were using BB would much rather pay right now than find another solution.

1
[deleted]•

This is a bad thing and a good thing.

This is probably why:

https://medium.com/@schenkty/why-nano-should-not-increase-proof-of-work-f933da5b1932

Colin and the team should take these points seriously and address them. The best technology does not always win, the best implementation of customer experience often does.

The good thing is that the community can take this forward and try to address the issues. The best nano Payment gateway should be owned by the community.

13
SeveralIfrepnode.org•

Not really, a payment processor can optimize and only get a 4x increase in difficulty (because it knows that the first block will be a receive etc). In addition to this, people have found improvements on how PoW is computed on GPUs, basically increasing the speed with around 4x, which balances out the difficulty increase for them.

14
__heimdall•

Its unfortunate if GPU computing is required at all for a service like this. I like the PoW concept to help prevent individuals from spamming the network, but it doesn't scale for services that have thousands or eventually millions of legitimate users wanting to send transactions.

3
SeveralIfrepnode.org•

The cost of a PoW is still very low (I personally think it's too low). My view is that the cost of one PoW should at least "cover" the costs of all nodes processing and storing that transaction.

7
__heimdall•

I'll trust you there for now. I've been interested in building a nano service to help push the community forward but haven't had a chance to start modelling my operating costs and scalability yet.

Having to even consider PoW calculations for say a service is tough though. Say I wanted to make Venmo for nano, its a blind spot for scalability if I have to account for PoW on every transaction and that level of PoW required could change in the future. A 2x or 5x increase of the work required could cripple profitability unless there's some way to offload that work to user devices or pass the PoW cost on to them as it is increased.

Edit: let me clarify a little here. I don't like the idea of passing PoW cost on to the users of a service. But that's only one of 2 ways I can think of that would allow for a business model that scales profitably. If a business has to cover PoW calculation costs for every transaction they could end up in a position where that cost eats up any profit and every transaction processed loses the service money.

3
Cockatiel•

Can't say I'm surprised

10
Velomo_•

This doesn’t include Vola right? Is it standalone from BrainBlocks?

9
appdev980OPBrainBlocks Dev•

Correct. Vola is separate

15
Velomo_•

Cool. Hope to see some awesome things!

7
kilrizzyNaNote :n1: LearnNano :n1: CoinEmbed•

BrainBlocks has been a great tool for a lot of my apps. Sad to see them go.

Now who's going to be the hero that brings it back?

9
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
fatal_music•

Does Daniel Brain have any ongoing involvement in Nano-related app development? As a Paypal engineer, he was a major reason why I invested in NANO and this news is a monumental disappointment to me.

7
WishYouWereHeir•

Why would you invest in a cryptocurrency just because a paypal employee creates a weekend project

16
c0wt00nDon't store funds on an exchange•

That's more thought than about 60% of the cryptoverse puts in

14
dontlikecomputersNano User•

don't stress too much about this, I remember how exciting it was to have a paypal engineer make brainblocks..... the reason it was exciting was that it worked!!, not because it was a Paypal guy!! There will be better services in the future, we all know just a little of what Nano is capable of!

8
kilrizzyNaNote :n1: LearnNano :n1: CoinEmbed•

this 💯

4
appdev980OPBrainBlocks Dev•

No, He isn’t actively involved.

5
BasicCustomer•

brainblocks holding rights for the domain nano.me

so they will delegate this to the devs, appia or sell it for the highest bidder

4
appdev980OPBrainBlocks Dev•

I currently own the domain, it is available to the highest bidder.

5
kilrizzyNaNote :n1: LearnNano :n1: CoinEmbed•

$1

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
omulandreiBrainBlocks Designer•

$500

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
madsudaca•

$500 + 1raw

3
madsudaca•

This is very sad to hear. Best of lucks in you next endeavors!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
appdev980OPBrainBlocks Dev•

Vola is separate

7
fatalglory•

In case anyone had in mind to try their hand at offering a similar service, I was wondering if you'd be prepared to comment on how much traffic BrainBlocks' payment processor was receiving?

P.S. thank you so much for providing this service for so long!

3
dontlikecomputersNano User•

Shame as you have provided great service, thanks for the good times.

2
ureindanger•

Sorry to hear that :( Quite a hit for NANO ecosystem IMO.

2