CPUSA, PCUSA, PSL etc. - what's all that?

As an young European communist, I find it to be somewhat confusing how many Communist (or Socialist) Parties exist in the USA that all claim to be Marxist-Leninist but yet must somehow differ from each other. (Not that there'd be much less here in Germany, though.) For that reason I'd be very thankful for a brief overview of all those self-proclaimed ML parties of the USA and maybe reasons why you prefer one over the other (or to be forwarded to a post where the same issue has already been discussed if that's the case).

Thank you in advance!

Posted Sep 2, 2020, 5:33 PM UTC

3924
[deleted]•

CPUSA, PCUSA, PSL

The CPUSA is an older party that used to be the largest communist party in the US, and important historically, but the leadership has become defunct or at least more liberal.

The PSL is a split from the Trotskyist WWP. They aren't explicitely Marxist-Leninist, but they're a syncretic party that falls more in line with Marxist-Leninists when it comes to their defense of "actually existing socialism."

The PCUSA is a newer party, and the only one with an explicitely Marxist-Leninist label.

I prefer the PSL, because they're active in large anti-war coalitions and anti-war or anti-imperialism is what I think is most important. The PCUSA is probably fine too. I don't think any of the parties in the US are large or influential enough to justify too much antagonism between the three.

43
ProudMLMarxist-Leninist•

PCUSA is not small, we're growing quickly with a lot of members throughout the country and 19 clubs, a few of which growing very large.

33
[deleted]•

Good to hear!

19
withthatfugazishit•

I’d like to add that while the PSL as a whole isn’t explicitly ML, almost all of the local chapters are.

0
WZFosterPCUSA•

I keep hearing this, but why if the majority of PSL members are Marxist-Leninists, the party not enshrine Marxism-Leninism into its party program? And I think the answer is related to why PSL was formed and who leads it now. Specifically, Gloria La Riva has explicitly said that PSL is not “Stalinist,” instead promoting the term “revolutionary marxist.” Which is reflected in the current party program of PSL. I sincerely hope that PSL adopts Marxism-Leninism since mostly everyone in the party is said to be a Marxist-Leninist.

9
TheShweeb•

There are certainly a lot of Marxist-Leninist parties in the USA these days, for all sorts of quirky historical reasons. I’ll try and summarize each of the most significant ones, to the best of my own knowledge.

-CPUSA: Communist Party USA (legally “The Communist Party of the United States of America”, but the shortened name is always the one that is used, including elsewhere in official documents). Founded in 1919, and has a long and storied history of organizing during its heyday of the 1920s-1950s, which makes it attractive to many. They came the closest of all these parties to being mainstream, having somewhere around 100,000 members at their height (and they claim to still have 5,000 or so, which isn’t nothing), but they were decimated in the 1950s by a number of factors, most notably mass suppression by business and government - Congress passed a law which attempted to ban them (didn’t hold up in court) and launched legal action against many of its members, who were also systematically driven out of the major trade unions and fired em masse from jobs in major industries - but also by events in the international movement, like the Sino-Soviet split and Kruschev’s speeches against Stalin. Thanks to their long heritage, they still maintain their historical ties to other communist parties, including the five ruling parties, and this is reflected in their online news publication People’s World, which frequently releases dispatches and announcement from other parties around the world. For quite a few decades, especially the past two, they have been criticized from both within and without the US for having overly liberal policies and goals; though they don’t officially run or endorse candidates, they often publish items which are very obviously sympathetic towards the Democratic Party and the AFL-CIO, and they no longer have any kind of vetting process, which they’ve claimed is due to their desire to form a “mass party”. There is also a common meme in ML circles that the party is an FBI front group, essentially a honeypot to catch radicals; though this was basically true once (thousands of members in the 1950s were found to be FBI informants), there is not a lot of direct evidence that it still is. If nothing else, it’s notable as the one and only communist party in the US to have a member in any elected position- Waseyah Whitebird, a Chippewa man in Ashland, Wisconsin, was elected to the small town’s city council in 2019 and remains in office.

-SWP: Socialist Workers’ Party. Minor to the point of irrelevance these days, but historically important, so let’s discuss it. Founded in 1934 by Trotskyists who were expelled from CPUSA, it was a founding member of the Fourth International, and probably its most significant member party and the most significant Trotskyist party in general, but it broke from Trotskyism in the 1980s to become Marxist-Leninist, following its support for the Sandinista revolution as well as the Cuban government. Its leader is a fellow named Jack Barnes, who has been in charge since 1972 (yes, that long!), and orchestrated the split from Trotskyism as well as the “turn to industry” policy, which mandated that SWP members had to be active in trade unions and manufacturing jobs. While neither of these policies were devoid of potential, they nevertheless decimated the party’s membership by quite a bit, and it remains tiny now.

-WWP: Worker’s World Party. Founded in 1958 by one Sam Marcy, who split from the SWP over disagreements regarding the Chinese and Cuban revolutions (he supported them, they didn’t), bringing him back to the ML side but not, for whatever reason, back to CPUSA itself. Thanks to its origins, its structure and party line are something of a unique blend of Trotskyist and ML elements. It’s probably best known for its publication of Worker’s World newspaper, which has been dutifully issued every week in pretty decent circulation numbers for 60+ years. Has recently fallen into some controversy regarding the national organization’s handling of racial issues & a prominent sexual assault accusation, which led to the Detroit and Philadelphia chapters disaffiliating from it.

-PSL: Party for Socialism and Liberation. Founded in 2004, from a split with WWP; neither party has actually explained the reasons for the split, but evidence seems to suggest it was over disagreements regarding the proper method of opposition to the Bush administration and the Iraq War. Founders and leaders of the ANSWER Coalition, a protest organization that was very active in the Iraq War years. Not terribly relevant after than until after 2016 election, where it received a pretty huge jump in membership, comparable to the DSA’s rise on the social-democratic side; the exact reason why they, of all these various parties, were the ones to earn this boost is beyond me. They still maintain the old Marxist-Leninist practice of membership candidacy, which requires an applicant to go through a lengthy process before they are approved as an actual official member. They still share numerous policies and structural similarities to WWP, which has led to members of the two parties being nicknamed “Marcyites” (after Sam Marcy), usually as an epithet. The two parties also frequently organize together, as well as with SWP on occasion, so I can only imagine they remain separate parties for reasons of pride and/or convenience.

-PCUSA: Party of Communists, USA. Founded in 2015, which would make it the most recently-founded US communist party. To be perfectly honest, I know little about them- I’ve never seen any signs of them at protests or organizing in any way, only occasional mentions of them on Twitter as well as in this subreddit, where (as you can already see from other comments) they seem to have a pretty fanatical following. They appear to have been founded not through a split, but by newly minted activists who were uninterested in joining any revisionist parties in the first place.

-RCPUSA: Revolutionary Communist Party, USA. Nominally speaking, the country’s resident Maoist/Marxist-Leninist-Maoist party, though their ideology is, in practice, based around the writings of their chairman Bob Avakian, who they nickname “BA” and refer to his politics as “New Synthesis”. They are often derided as a Scientology-esque personality cult based around Avakian, in an apparent imitation of the crudest stereotypes about Mao-era China. They’re also notorious for their numerous front groups, who are a common site at protests in the US and rather shadily avoid admitting their obvious ties to RCPUSA; the most recent and significant is “Refuse Fascism”, which was founded after Trump’s election and has made the news every so often.

-APL: American Party of Labor. An anti-revisionist/“Hoxhaist” party founded in 2008, who follow the model of the Albanian Party of Labor in the era of Enver Hoxha, and friendly with many other anti-revisionist parties who most heavily emphasize Marxism-Leninism in their policies. They don’t seem to be terribly active outside of New Jersey.

-FRSO: Freedom Road Socialist Organization. Formed in the 1980s, it’s one of the few existing remnants (alongside RCPUSA) of the New Communist Movement, a movement in the 1970s which saw a huge flurry of new communist parties being founded in the United States, which were mostly based around the Black Panthers’ model and were puny in membership, influence, and longevity; as the NCM era wound down, its remaining members founded FRSO to try and keep the flame alive. Never terribly significant, its most notable theoretical contribution is its name, explicitly designating itself a socialist organization rather than a party, reasoning that a party must develop a mass base of supporters before it is worthy of the name, which neither they nor anyone else have yet done; a philosophy not without merit. Confusingly, the organization suffered a split in 1999, but both sides kept the same name, insisting the other side was illegitimate for 20 whole years, until one side finally gave up the ghost and changed its name to “Liberation Road” last year.

23
tyazhelaya•

PCUSA split from CPUSA, as most others did at some point. I was told that in the 80s after CPUSA supported Perestroika and Glasnost, the anti-revisionist membership had enough and left. They went on to form a non party organization called US Friends of the Soviet People which eventually became PCUSA in 2015. The founding members of PCUSA were part of the CPUSA throughout the 60s and onward.

I am in PCUSA, an honest opinion: it's really new. I joined right at the beginning of COVID, it's not advisable to meet up and we have gained at least hundred members since then. I still went to protests in Portland with one member and others in the area drove to CHAZ. There isn't really any top down organization right now. Your club is responsible for your organizing.

5
ProudMLMarxist-Leninist•

Just to clarify, CPUSA purged them, they didn't split. Also USFSP wasn't what turned into PCUSA, National Council of Communists USA (NCCUSA) is what turned into PCUSA. USFSP is simply a sister org.

6
crincuvox•

To clarify, CPUSA never supported glasnost or perestroika. When Gorbachev introduced his policies, the CPUSA cut relationships with the USSR and stopped receiving funds.

A number of prominent members tried to advocate for dropping Leninism as the CPUSA's guiding ideology of Marxism-Leninism, after the dissolutionof the Soviet Union. The movement failed, and these party members split off to form the Committees of Correspondence.

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
ProudMLMarxist-Leninist•

Just to add additional info in regards to the PCUSA.

Clubs are responsible for attendance to protests and we urge them to act autonomously within their region or in assistance of another club. We don't document all involvement however what we do get we share on our subreddit or on our Facebook/twitter pages. That said we don't often get pictures/videos of members themselves for security reasons, but this is also purely up to the members consent to be filmed or not. Our clubs have been very active to local protests in their areas. For more info on clubs presence in specific states you can find that here: https://partyofcommunistsusa.org/districts-clubs/

As for organizing, since we are new, and this can be said with pretty much all ML parties, 80% of organizational work is internal, meanwhile clubs deal with local organizing, and national leadership just act centrally over to make sure everything goes ok.

We have high presence on reddit considering a lot of our comrades are very active here, along with Facebook.

4
AngelicAlice•

CPUSA are revisionists and liberals who support Biden and don't even properly teach Lenin in their party educationals (they exclude all talk of revolution) And while PSL is slightly better they still don't claim to be Marxist lenininists and imo are closer to Trotskyites PCUSA is the only Marxist-Leninist party in the United states and I'd highly recommend checking out their constitution and points of unity (the only one of the three to have them avaliable publicly) on their website https://partyofcommunistsusa.org/ for more information

18
[deleted]•

PSL literally describes themselves as a Marxist-Leninist organization.

0†
AngelicAlice•

Literally nowhere on the about us section of their website do they describe themselves as Marxist or Leninists.

9
[deleted]•

When I had my first interview with PSL, the outreach member said, "We are a Marxist-Leninist, revolutionary communist party."

2†
withthatfugazishit•

They said that to me also, I don’t get how people are disagreeing with something you experienced lmao

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
friendlypslbot•

CPUSA was the dominant communist party from its formation until the collapse of Soviet Union. At its peak it had half a million card carrying members and hundreds of thousands of sympathizers. The CPUSA always had a bit of a revisionist streak but this only became an issue under Earl Browder- a sort of progenitor of what we could later call Euro-communism he allowed revolutionary moments to pass and opted for a more peaceful cooperation with the capitalist forces in America.

Still the CPUSA was only rivalled by trotskyist organizations at that time and was the largest and most dedicated Marxist-Leninist party with the Socialist Workers Party and the Socialist Party both following behind as smaller orginizations.

Eventually a split occurred in the Socialist Workers Party and from it came the Workers World Party and a key figure of it was Sam Marcy. While it was never huge a great deal of American Parties can be considered Marcyite in the sense that they agree with his stances which were that though he was more sympathetic to Trotsky there is a global class war waging and that we must defend the Soviet Union and existing socialist regimes. Its pretty revisionist but its important to understand where the PSL came from.

In 2004 the PSL split from the WWP who at this time was a leading orginization in the ANSWER coalition. They split over structural differences and the PSL came to not just lead the ANSWER coalition but is looking like it will come to supplant the CPUSA. It's currently the fastest growing party and possibly larger than the CPUSA though revolutionary parties don't really disclose their membership numbers for good reason. It still has some Marcyite holdovers but the party teaches a thoroughly Marxist-Leninist candidacy program and is structured with democratic centralism. I have to disclose my biases here but I am a member, I have nothing but respect for other Marxist Leninists in the US though and I wont smear any of them as they are putting out good work.

The PCUSA is expressly Marxist Leninist but are really only about 1000 or so members, I can see it growing faster in the current crisis but it makes more sense to mention the Freedom Road Socialist Organization at this point.

7
pearl_actually•

PSL seems fairly large on this subreddit. I've not worked with them, but the impression I get is their politics are focused mainly on anti-imperialism.

I've had great experiences with Socialist Alternative (or International Socialist Alternative for you). As a party there is a focus on democratic centralism and advancing members' political development. We have a sitting city councilmember in Seattle, Kshama Sawant, who fought for a $15/hr minimum wage, and who is active in the BLM protests.

4
friendlypslbot•

Hello I'm a PSL member but I have tons of respect for the SA

As someone who might be closer to the situation I have to ask, how serious are the efforts to recall Sawant from city council? Is it something that Seattle leftists can shrug off or are they actually gaining support?

3
crincuvox•

CPUSA member here. I can't speak for the other parties but I can provide some information for CPUSA.

The CPUSA was the leading Marxist-Leninist vanguard party for most of the 20th century, and was closely affiliated with the Soviet Union. At one point, a secret CPUSA member was even elected into the US Senate. After the dissolution of the USSR, the CPUSA suffered a few major splits and was set back considerably.

Right now, the CPUSA is often criticized for revisionism because it is not confrontational against Democrats. Although the CPUSA never endorses non-communist candidates, it does focus most of its efforts on attacking Republicans and the far-right. Internally, many CPUSA members are highly critical of Democrats and there is a push to adopt a more staunchly leftward policy platform, but that continues to be an ongoing debate.

From my understanding, CPUSA remains the largest Marxist-Leninist organization in the United States. It is also the only Marxist-Leninist party with an elected official in power, although its influence in politics is still very low compared to some other third parties.

3
bw147•

Don't quote me on this but the PSL might be larger

3
Waltrude83•

I spent some time in the CPUSA and all the comrades in the local club were explicitly ML (they were also older and many were “red diaper babies”). The situation of the CPUSA is a bit different than the other organizations because of its former ties to the USSR. After McCarthyism effectively broke the organization in the 60s, it couldn’t openly advocate for overthrowing the government and I imagine that’s still true today. I’m considering applying for membership in PSL, but I’m looking for jobs and I’m not sure if I’ll end up in a place with a chapter, so I don’t want to commit to anything just yet.

1