
SurLEau
u/SurLEau

In a linguistics course on formal semantics I encountered the claim that the proper subset relation was not antisymmetric while the non-proper subset relation was. I didn't believe that. I asked ChatGPT which agreed that the proper subset relation is not antisymmetric. Who is right?
My reasoning: A relation R is antisymmetric iff (if (aRb and bRa) then a=b).
Let A and B be any sets, then A⊂B and B⊂A can never be true because ⊂ is irreflexive and therefore the conditional "if (A⊂B and B⊂A) then A=B" holds aways true (ex falso quodlibet).
Or via contradiction: Let A and B be sets so that A⊂B and B⊂A and A≠B. The conditions themselves are contradictory because A⊂B and B⊂A can never be true o
In the city centre there are, like, a trizillion shops with almost the exact same cheap souvenirs to buy (the same postcards, magnets, cups, lewd t-shirts as so on). They must all have the same supplier. But how does that work?
Who is the supplier? Why do they all buy their stuff there? How does this whole infrastructure work, economically speaking? I tried to look it up but I didn't find anything interesting about it, so I'd be glad if anyone could point me to an article or something to learn more about the economic site of this.
I'm wondering if you could ever say something like
(Al) que vi ayer, al/el hombre, lo he vuelto a ver hoy.
instead of
El hombre al que vi ayer, lo he vuelto a ver hoy.
That is, put the relative clause at the beginning of the sentence, directly follow by its head noun, instead of the other way around. Is that (or anything similiar) possible in Spanish?
Why is "I don't have" "У меня нет" and not "У меня не" or "не У меня" or something like that? Why is it "нет" instead of "не"? And are there other constructions where "нет" is used as negation particle?
Þere is a poll on tumblr to decide which is þe best letter (or symbol) of any Latin-based alphabet. It's þe final poll and it's a real head-to-head race between Þ and &. So þis might be þe opportunity for all of you to make þorn win and bring it back to life!
Hey everyone, so me and a friend started to translate the famous Communist Manifesto (of which we couldn't find a publicly available Latin version) to Latin, just for fun. We both don't have any previous experience in composing Latin prose or translating into Latin, so we'd be very happy if some of you could comment on what we've got so far. I'll give you the English version below but note that we've actually translated from German. Here we go:
Manifesto of the Communist Party
Declaratio factionis communisticae
A spectre is haunting Europe — the spectre of communism.
Phantasma in europa circat - phantasma communismi.
*All the powers of old Europe have entered into a holy allian
So, I've started to read Thomas Hobbes' "Leviathan" recently and right in the Introduction I stumbled over an odd sentence. I am acquainted with the archaic conjugation of "to do" and its forms "Thou doest" and "he/she/it doth" - at least I thought so. So I was not taken by surprise when Hobbes used those archaic verbs. But then I read the following sentence:
"...whosoever looketh into himself, and considereth what he doth, when he does think, opine, reason, hope, feare, &c, ..." where he uses both forms right after another which made me wonder whether there is a difference between the both or how else this is to be explained?
I'm not sure if this is the right subreddit for my question
I'm an 18-year-old native German speaker who wants to improve their English and French. I would say I'm almost fluent in English and an intermediary French speaker. Both written and spoken exchange is fine to me - so we can just write e-mails or actually chat, maybe play video games or talk about all sorts of stuff. I'm open to lots of things. :)
Hi, I'm currently about to unsubscribe from a rather bourgeois political journal so now I'm looking for a Marxist journal to subscribe to instead. I'm looking for magazines in English, French or German.
I'm specifically interested in periodicals that discuss the current application of Marxist(-Leninist) theory, particularly in the West, that engage in Marxist study of history or analyze global economic developments from a Marxist perspective. (Or in other words: journals that engage in the subjects of politics, history or global economics from a Marxist point of view.)
Furthermore, since I'm from Germany, it'd be preferable if the journal was available in a digital format or shipped to the
As an young European communist, I find it to be somewhat confusing how many Communist (or Socialist) Parties exist in the USA that all claim to be Marxist-Leninist but yet must somehow differ from each other. (Not that there'd be much less here in Germany, though.) For that reason I'd be very thankful for a brief overview of all those self-proclaimed ML parties of the USA and maybe reasons why you prefer one over the other (or to be forwarded to a post where the same issue has already been discussed if that's the case).
Thank you in advance!
You've reached the end of this feed.
