Where to go after Strahd?

HELP / REQUEST

CoS is the best adventure I have every been apart of. From maps, to NPCs, to story; it is all beautiful.

Are any other modules as well done? I am looking for a game after my group finishes CoS but all the other mods I have looked into seem to fall short. Also it doesn’t need to be a continuation, they can make new characters for a new adventure.

Thank you.

Edit: I should have included what I have looked into and my thoughts:

Waterdeep (all 3): Overall a great city. The mad mage dungeon maps are less than. The story options are interesting and this is my current too pick.

Avernus is a hard pass, again the maps in hell are much lower quality. The map of Avernus itself is awesome but half of the locations aren’t in the mod and worst off is that vehicular combat is not fleshed out very well. I am okay with theater of the mind but I feel there was a real miss with the vehicles.

Icedale: hopefully? Once we know more.

Dragon Queen: I haven’t read the mod but started it as a player and the DM disliked it so much we switched.

Saltmarsh and Ravnica: are more world building than fleshed out adventures.

Ebberon: Is cool but I am playing it currently so I can’t run it too.

Bonus points if the map are as awesome as CoS.

Posted Sep 9, 2020, 1:42 PM UTC · edited

122121
Chance5e•

Rime of the Frostmaiden is the new horror-themed adventure coming out this year. It looks pretty cool and it’s an official publication so the quality should match Curse of Strahd pretty well.

Edit: It comes on September 15th, so, like, next week.

78
LeftOutToDryOP•

Looks interesting, I hope it is as good, we will know soon.

16
Task_wizard•

I had no idea it was going to be horror themed. Interesting.

12
Chance5e•

We’ll see. They say it’s “dark terror,” but that could mean a lot of things.

10
Bradshaw79•

Chris Perkins said he took a lot of inspiration from John Carpenter’s Thing. So...it should be in an isolation horror type setting and theme. I’m stoked for it.

7
Yoman987•

Tomb of Annihilation has a pretty active community and the module has a lot in it as well.

Suggestions from me - remove the perma-death and the timer/deadline, so that they can explore more of Chult, as well as expanding on areas with modules from the Adventurer's League, DM's Guild, Yawning Portal and, hell, even Princes of the Apocalypse could fit with a bit of tweaking.

47
LeftOutToDryOP•

Never looked at this one, I will check it out. Thank you so much .

11
okawei•

Tomb of Annihilation is great for parties that enjoy dungeon crawls and war-gaming but is definitely lacking from a role-playing perspective IMO. There's just not enough towns or villages to really build up NPCs apart from a couple

12
LeftOutToDryOP•

Are there good side quests or puzzles?

6
okawei•

Oh yeah, tons of puzzles and side quests. Just not a ton of interesting NPCs compared to CoS in my opinion.

7
strangetoaster•

I haven't run ToA, but it's next on my list. The maps are by the same artist (Mike Schley) who did the CoS maps.

6
LeftOutToDryOP•

The maps are so good.

6
Rampasta•

If you are running it straight, keep in mind itvwas designed as a hexcrawl, ie. big sandbox. You may need to strap on some rails to keep players focused. So much is going on.

3
Yoman987•

Just want to bump you a resource link, but there's a subreddit for ToA resources as well.

https://www.dnd-compendium.com/dm-resources/adventure-guides/tomb-of-annihilation

3
LeftOutToDryOP•

Awesome, thank you!

1
Solarat1701•

Maybe have a starting deadline to get them into the world but then cut them loose? Like in Fallout how you need to get the water chip in 150 days but after that there’s no time limit

4
HaroldOfTheStorm•

Here to second Yawning Portal. Not as a standalone but a good source for filler arc or dungeon drop

3
1sinfutureking•

I've never played in a printed DnD module that held up to CoS without significant modifications by the GM; however, If you're interested in a different system, there are some all-time great campaigns to consider.

Masks of Nyarlathotep for Call of Cthulhu - kind of the granddaddy of them all - a world-spanning eldritch adventure of investigation and fighting off horrors from beyond the world

The Great Pendragon Campaign for Pendragon - it's a generational campaign following King Arthur's court

The Dracula Dossier for Night's Black Agents (although a Dracula campaign after a Dracula analogue might a bit much) - what if Bram Stoker's Dracula was real: not a novel, but an after-action report by British intelligence attempting to recruit the big man himself

Darkening of Mirkwood for The One Ring - how you see Mirkwood go from the cleaned up place it was following The Hobbit to a dark and dreary place, inhabited by the shadow, in the fifty years between The Hobbit and LotR - it's a thirty-year campaign that is absolutely wonderful

Warhammer Fantasy roleplay: The Enemy Within - I know very little about it, but it's reputed to be great

25
TitanGoat•

Masks of Nyarlathotep is a step beyond every other campaign in my opinion. So many clues, characters and events that tie together in a strong plot, but still leaves room for changing things to fit your group. It is hard to run though and you and your players need to be organised from start to finish.

The Enemy within is great as well, it starts off extremely strong, with a strong plot. The adventures are fun to go through both as a player and as a gm. The problem with the enemy within is that the last 2 chapters fails to live up to the rest, but that might be fixed with the new version for WFRP 4th edition.

11
LeftOutToDryOP•

Thank you so much! I will invest the time to review these. They sound awesome, personally the Pendragon one is where I will start. That sounds like so much fun.

2
1sinfutureking•

I've only played/read Masks, Dracula, and Darkening, so the others I only know by reputation.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I have played warhammer RPG before which was less than but the rest I haven’t looked into before. Kind of excited to try a King Author RPG. I had never really thought about that world but it could be pretty awesome, it executed well.

1
doorknobopener•

Interesting to see Masks of Nyarlathotep get a recommendation. I've been listening to the How We Roll podcast's actual play of that adventure, and I cant say that I've been all too impressed by it. That could be because the keeper for the adventure isnt that great. It sucks really because the keeper has run a few adventures he's written on the podcast (and helped create Masks of Nyarlathotep), but he is just not that fun to listen to. He's also not the usual/original keeper of the podcast, and seemed to only show up to give the original keeper a chance to play characters.

2
Sarik704•

Tomb of Annihilation is lots of fun and so is Waterdeep. But, let me offer a tantalizing 3rd option. The Oracle Of War.

It's an Adventure League campaign. It has base building, a weird western aesthic. And decent support from Wayfinder's Guide to Eberron and Exploring Eberron. All of this is over on DMS Guild.

The plot surround a town of salvagers whose job is to collect valuable artifacts, scrap, and information about the mournlands.

As far as I know the adventure is completely self contained and has nothing to do with the Official WOTC book Eberron, Rising From The Last War. After Strahd my group needed a change of tone going from the dark and tragic themes of Strahd to the pulp noir western feeling of Eberron has been fantastic!

17
LeftOutToDryOP•

That sounds awesome. I will check that out, thank you.

When your group changed did you create new characters or continue on?

1
Neocarbunkle•

I ended up doing a homebrew campaign after CoS because nothing else from WotC seemed up to the same level of quality.

12
LeftOutToDryOP•

I feel like that is where I am at too.

6
brandcolt•

What was the story you did afterwards?

2
Neocarbunkle•

It is very loosely based off of the rod of seven parts 2nd edition campaign. After Strahd died Barovia was teleported back to it's original plane. This is a new land for the players even though it isn't too different from the forgotten realms in the sense it is more of a typical fantasy setting. The parts of the rod were drawn to this new land from the realm where order and chaos battled because of Barovia suddenly popping into existence. After stumbling across the first piece they are tasked with finding the others.

I want to have the lich from the amber temple return as an owner of one of the pieces and for Strahd to come back as a demon, but I haven't worked them in yet.

It's going so so. I miss having the structure of a set of an official campaign though.

1
MeekTheShy•

Curse of strahd 2

Mecha Strahd.

10
LeftOutToDryOP•

Blinskey stepping up the toy game here.

10
MeekTheShy•

Lol!

Still waiting for the campaign to drop!

I'm sure somebody will come out with a homebrew for it one day tho.

2
Epoh9•

I plan on running CoS a second time one day and because one of my OG players will be in it I'm gonna update it with all of the changes my players made during the campaign. We'll see how Lady Fiona handles Vallaki, how Ismark rebuilt Barovia (it got wrecked by two of the Bonegrinder hags), and how the combination of the druids and werewolf tribes went (OG player's PC multispeced from Cleric into Druid and united the two tribes at the end of the campaign).

3
DidThis2Downvote•

I had an idea to run a sequel CoS with Strahd having become trapped in a Gulthias tree that grew through the castle and the heart and maybe was sentient. I hadn't planned much beyond the basic idea of Gulthias tree traps Strahd.

2
CocoonMaN•

Castle ravenloft.

8
LeftOutToDryOP•

I don’t know that mod, do you have a link? Thank you.

5
CocoonMaN•

🤔

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I assumed you meant a not CoS mod, like a sequel or something.

6
CocoonMaN•

Was just being an idiot. You asked where to go after strahd

7
Heretek007•

Okay, I know it's not super popular... but have you checked out Princes of the Apocalypse? It seems to have a somewhat mixed reception, but I genuinely loved running it. It takes place in a localized, very explorable area (The Dessarin Valley/Hills), has a very colorful cast-- not the least of which are four main villains, each of whom have their own personality and methodology. (This is where some reading between the lines is needed-- you can really bring PotA to life by getting into character for the Prophets and realizing there is a lot the book implies, but leaves up to interpretation on the DM's part.)

It leaves a lot up to player agency, allowing them to tackle the villains in whatever order they choose, or however feels natural to them as things unfold. >!But there is also a very clear outline for how the other's plans progress as time passes, turning the adventure into a race against time to stop them as things continue to escalate further and further.!<

It has dragons. It has dungeons >!connecting together into a bigger megadungeon to delve, once you find how they're joined together.!< It has a variety of enemies, ranging from humanoids and elementals to fiends and undead.

And it wasn't terribly difficult for me to pick it apart and drop it into my home game's setting! I even changed the finale slightly, >!adding an extra level of the dungeon set deep in the Underdark beneath the dungeon, where my true villain, a beholder, has been orchestrating everything under the mantle of the "Elder Elemental Eye".!<

I could go on, but I think I've gushed enough to get across just how much fun we had with it. Don't let people's mixed reception discourage you from giving it a look-- heck, I've seen posts about people who have made Tyranny of Dragons an awesome time!

7
LeftOutToDryOP•

I will definitely check it out, I had passed it over due to seeing so many negatives about it but your gushing means there is value in checking it out. I appreciate it.

Also; love the true villain. Sounds like a fun time.

4
Heretek007•

Oh, it was great. I set up one of the four villains as one of the PC's childhood friends, and then turned it into "they were driven to madness and evil... are you all badass enough to save her?"

It turned out absolutely amazing. I'll refrain from patting myself on the back too much and just say, there was enough to work with there that I felt confident in my ability to pull it off well.

If you want to do some lore-diving, Elemental Evil has some very deep roots in the history of D&D as well, which I really liked sinking my teeth into as the DM.

3
BreakfastGrenade•

I was hugely impressed by Storm King's Thunder. The map and world info in chapter three is supergood, and the plot allows plenty of player choices without much chance of wandering away from the story.

6
LeftOutToDryOP•

And giants are always fun. I will take a look, thank you.

1
Sclasclemski•

I am currently running this and love the story though I am filling out with some DMs guild adventures. It has been a lot of fun so far

1
BreakfastGrenade•

It is really good. I think they've done a fantastic job with the published adventures, but CoS and STK are a cut above IMHO.

1
ArrBeeNayr•

You could just run more Ravenloft?

"Night of the Walking Dead" is a great intro to more of the setting.

6
LeftOutToDryOP•

That is actually a pretty cool idea. Kill Strahd and have them still locked in. I like it.

3
ArrBeeNayr•

If you want to take your adventures in the Ravenloft campaign setting further, I would highly recommend that you read the Ravenloft Boxed Set. Barovia is just one of the Domains of Dread; There are many more waiting for a party's trepidatious arrival.

5
LeftOutToDryOP•

That looks awesome, buying it now. Thank you.

2
Bart_Thievescant•

I am a HUGE fan of The Red Hand of Doom. It's an older 3.5 module, but it holds up well and translating it to 5e is not very difficult.

5
LeftOutToDryOP•

I have never heard of that one. I will check it out, thank you for sharing.

1
HdeviantS•

Waterdeep is seen as good if you like social interactions. Avernus is good and since it is set in the hells it is reasonable to upscale encounters to continue with your current party.

3
LeftOutToDryOP•

Waterdeep is higher on my list, as that city looks very interesting. The mad mage dungeon is very disappointing, graphically.

Avernus is a hard pass, again the maps in hell are much lower quality. The map of Avernus itself is awesome but half of the locations aren’t in the mod and worst off is that vehicular combat is not fleshed out very well. I am okay with theater of the mind but I feel there was a real miss with the vehicles.

2
quattro4ever•

If you're interested in Waterdeep: Dragon Heist, I highly recommend using The Alexandrian Remix.

I'm DMing it right now and there is so much flexibility depending on what the players enjoy.

3
LeftOutToDryOP•

Looks interesting, thank you. I will read it over .

1
Bakaza95•

I haven't tried it yet but I've always liked Out of the Abyss plot.

3
notthebeastmaster•

I almost recommended it, but the maps are TERRIBLE.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I will take a look, thank you.

1
notthebeastmaster•

Tomb of Annihilation. Huge setting, deadly dungeons, great reviews, and the maps are by Mike Schley, who did CoS.

3
LeftOutToDryOP•

You are the third to recommend that, I will defiantly check it out. Thank you.

2
gulelin•

I hear you man. I love curse of Strahd so much that I decided to write a homebrew Raven loft add-on to take my party into immediately after. I tied it in to the Curse of Strahd story.

The gist is that the dark powers made a deal with the players when they were in there Amber Temple: they revealed that Strahd would just come back even if he was killed, but offered a permanent repreive for Barovia if the players would bring them the soul of a necromancer in the neighborhing domain.

My players have no idea why they must do this and that's the fun part. It's designed around the necromancer's lair which is like a dungeons and dragons escape room of sorts. Once they go in it is very difficult to leave. The necromancer has figured out how to manifest the mists himself and he has used it to build a huge strong hold that is a hodgepodge of locations taken from other worlds.

3
LeftOutToDryOP•

That sounds awesome. My party hasn’t gotten to the amber temple yet, but are aware of the lore around it.
I have also been waiting for one to die to use the dark gods to offer to bring them back, so that could work too.

2
Intortusturris•

Tomb of annihilation is as good as curse of strahd I'd say.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I will check that one out. Thank you.

2
modsme•

The system neutral setting, Dark of Hot Springs Island, was my favorite adventure book after CoS. It is a hexcrawl set on a tropical island filled with ruins of a hedonistic race of elves. I am quite fond of the factions currently roaming the island. This post explains how to run it in 5e.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

Did you continue on or start with dress characters?

2
modsme•

I have not run it yet. I have only read through it. I imagine if you were to use the bestiaries in the post, you would probably have to start with new characters. It would also not be too difficult to simply upscale the enemies to allow your players to continue their current characters.

I should mention that this adventure contains some mature themes. Nudity, slavery, and drug use come to mind.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

Thank you for the heads up. I think new characters are perfectly fine, just curious.

2
Stormcrow12•

ToA is an amazing adventure. But I think new Icewind Dale will be the new king.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

ToA has been brought up a lot, I had written it off but need to re-look at it. Thank you.

1
eddieswiss•

I hate to promo my own stuff, but I wrote an adventure and I'm selling it for like $5 on DM's Guild. If you DM me, I can send you a free copy. Takes place in Ravenloft still but in another domain known as the Sea of Sorrows.

It's a cool starting point if you wanna turn your post-CoS game into a Ravenloft campaign. I wrote it specifically as a fun stepping off point after Curse of Strahd.

https://www.dmsguild.com/product/325115/Ravenloft-Sorrow-on-the-Sea

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I appreciate the offer but I am 100% okay with buying it. Thank you for sharing.

Does it keep the fog up or is the land expanded at all?

1
eddieswiss•

It is only the one domain unfortunately and as for the mists and fog that’s entirely up to you! It’s not the whole of Ravenloft included just another domain called the Sea of Sorrows. There’s a really great free wiki out there that offers up oodles of information on Ravenloft as a whole as well if you’re interested.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I will check it out, thank you.

1
eddieswiss•
2
Mojake•

Try looking at 3rd party published stuff man, WotC have a few good adventures but none hold up to CoS. ToA, OotA and SKT are good. If none of those take your fancy, jump on DriveThruRPG and find something new :)

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

I have been looking at DMG a lot, I will check there too. Thank you.

2
Mojake•

I find DriveThru has way more personally. I'm looking at starting Legacy's Wake soon. Much different tone but looks great.

2
LeftOutToDryOP•

DMG I have been using to add more content to Strahd, which has worked out really well so far but never though of DriveThru.

1
Mojake•

Yeah DMG is great for additional stuff, Drive is better for modules or 'megacampaigns' can't remember what they refer to them as

2