Nether84•

It's bound to happen eventually, it's no secret that Canadians are well indebted.

99
Jswarez•

Canadians are the most indebted people on the planet.

Few politicans like talking about that. It would mean they need to do something about housing prices.

38
Nether84•

Housing prices aren't the only reason Canadians are indebted, people live well above their means in many ways.

59
TacoRockapella•

That’s very true. Especially in the suburbs. Every house has a driveway full of cars.

17
deeperest•

I live in Mississauga (family of 5 with one minivan, just to frugalbrag) and there's a house my wife and I walk by every couple of days that holds our neighbourhood record. 7 cars, for a semi-detached. None of them beaters. The $ sitting in the driveway should exceed the value of the house (except, you know, GTA) and it boggles my mind.

The very fact that we often see all 7 IN the driveway surely means they don't need them all, right?

16

Care to explain how my bicycle, $500 apartment and regular plain chicken and rice are above my 24 year old means? 😂 doesn’t matter. I shouldn’t be in a position where I’ll never own a home just because some fuck in Toronto wants to drive a Porsche. Ignoring the problem is ignoring the problem, period.

7†
Nether84•

Angry much?

Self pity isn't a redeeming quality.

Obviously not all Canadians live above their means but many do.

Anyway don't blame others success for your situation

-3†
[deleted]•

Either Canadians are inherently/genetically predisposed to spending more or there is some context to why Canadians are so indebted.

It's easy to say "lol just stop taking debt". It's tougher to say "a history of cheap money, massive short run appreciation, and a government bailout just an arms reach away".

6
peecefreek•

Exactly. If people wouldn't buy at the top of their budget they would have some wiggle room. Once they realize that house ownership is more expensive than just a mortgage payment they often have started to keep up with the Jones' as well.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-140
[deleted]•

[removed]

188
IHCTD9•

Are tons of Canadians stupid with money?

Just look at all those downvotes...!

Guess I’ll keep my financial situation to myself :D

12
12stepsodawater•

The answer is yes. If you are doing well financially it's best to keep it to yourself.

My close friends are all in the same boat so we can talk amongst ourselves. I was directly asked by a neighbor about our mortgage and answered truthfully. Big mistake. Just pretend you're broke like everyone else.

13
peetak•

I don't get why people are so interested in stranger's finances. My parents live in a very nice house in a very nice neighborhood. Every driveway is filled with Teslas, BMWs, Mercedes etc, except my parents' driveway. They have one early 2000s Toyota Camry, in decent condition. Their neighbors straight up asked them how they can afford their house with such an old car in the driveway and if my parents won the lottery 🤦🏻‍♂️

6
IHCTD9•

Oh, I know! BIL asked what I thought our retirement income will be - I never should have told him. Now, “I’m all about the money...”

Canucks hate success stories.

4
Th3_Eleventy3•

The downvotes don’t matter, I was in debt, but worked on it and steadily looked for ways to cut the credit card spending and not accumulate any more.

-2†
Neat_Onion•

Peanuts.

3†
Nether84•

I've got a mortgage but about $300,000 of equity at current market levels, so definitely not concerned.

1†
PlanteraWine•

What is the equity? With a bunch of bankruptcies real estate could go down.

1
Nether84•

Well it's worth about $500 and my mortgage is less than $200, I highly doubt the market drops that much.

4
CanuckYou2•

Why does it matter if real estate goes down if you are not selling? And if you are selling and buying in the same market you will still be helped by real estate dropping since you will pay much lower transaction costs.

2
ead20•

Downvoted because people in debt want to believe everyone is also in debt and feel better when everyone is in the same situation.

-2†
Th3_Eleventy3•

Yes downvoted......sad Arms. BUT I AM FREE!!!!!
Happy dance 😃

4†
downtofinance•

Lol what's with all the downvotes? I thought this is PFC Triumphant Thursday worthy.

-2†
Th3_Eleventy3•

Crabs in a bucket.

1
MarginallyUseful•

It’s really not that, it’s that it’s bragging about something no one asked about.

2
Krazy2020•

Dunno why you're being down voted.. lots of people live outside their means.

Great work

-5†
RedditSucksss1•

Clearly bragging super hard.

56
Th3_Eleventy3•

This road has been hard, I learned early about bad debt. But I worked hard for the last 5 years, cut all spending and here I am today.

6
Krazy2020•

Nice!

It's hard for me but I'm getting better, slippery line to walk between Mizer and extravagant. Covid helped me see how much I was spending on eating out.

I know people who deferred their mortgage to buy luxuries with no savings who make great money which is crazy to me!

2
Opal-Escence•

Cool, a privileged or old person. It’s not necessarily an accomplishment.

-14
IHCTD9•

Yes young regular dudes are all screwed.

No chance unless you have a trust fund or old...

Except for all the young working stiffs I know who are doing just fine apparently.

7
VipKyle•

26 here: live on my own, own my vihicle, saving $4k a month, high scool education..

6
Peng-WinOntario•

I swear we've gotten this article 3 times in the last 3 months.

I don't think it'll happen unless there's a strong second wave which results in another 2 month of full quarantine.

51
_dodged•

Well, it seems that's exactly where we're heading. BC just set another daily record, Ontario is trending upward, Alberta is following right along. School just started, flu season is about to start which will complicate things a whole lot more...

Things are not getting better.

36
DragynfyreBritish Columbia•

Hospitalization rate is extremely low though with this wave of cases.

49 hospitalizations and only 10 in the ICU in BC with 1461 active cases

https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/a6f23959a8b14bfa989e3cda29297ded

37
12stepsodawater•

Everyone forgets this was the original purpose of the lockdown. There could be 10 million "cases" but if nobody is in the hospital or dying its irrelevant.

21
DrOctopusMD•

Hospitalization is low because young people are less likely to need hospitalization. But if enough people get it, that low percentage can turn into a raw high number.

10
MrTacoTuesday35•

I mean, you need to wait a few weeks. It’s mostly young people who have it.

I can see this taking out my entire office for one - we’ve people of all ages sitting in an office without masks on right now. All it’ll take is one young person to get the whole office, and bingo bango - hospitalizations are up.

9
DragynfyreBritish Columbia•

It been over month since we started having this spike in BC. We had around 750 active cases with 20-ish people hospitalized in mid August and now it’s roughly double the active cases and double the hospitalizations

7
Neat_Onion•

Mostly because the infections are isolated in younger people? If it spreads, older people are bound to end up in the ICU.

4
DragynfyreBritish Columbia•

So many of the hospitalizations and deaths in the first wave were from long term care homes. I think we just need to lock those down better and not lock down the rest of society so much

24
9871234567654322•

Schools going to be brutal either way. If one kid tests positive for covid, all their classmates and teachers isolate for 14 days. So If one kid in my class is positive that's a minimum of 60 kids and 2 teachers in isolation for two weeks. That's bad for sure, but the other side of it is that any symptoms require 10 days of isolation or a negative test and no more symptoms. If a kid gets the sniffles they are out until they have a negative result and no more symptoms. It doesn't even matter if there is confirmed covid, it's still going to be hell on parents and schools. Tbh as an asthmatic teacher, I'm glad the policies exist, but it is not going to make for a reasonable flu season.

4
vinsoni•

Obviously this kind of plan is flawed. Why not teach them online for the year?

-1
CharacterHuge•

Because a great many parents have to go back and keeping kids isolated for a year is bad for their mental health and development. The benefits of homeschooling in a pandemic do not outweigh the other costs, or at least that's what's being said

3
Own_Nectarine7433•

Intersting COVID cases are on a decline in USA and on a rise in Canada, "how the turn tables?". Either that, or Trump just reduced testing.

1
TheCryptoDaddy•

We have 0 deaths dude. There is always going to be cases. Worry about the only important stat, deaths and hospitalizations. Stop the fear porn. Sweden proved we can get thru this without lock downs.

-11†
DrOctopusMD•

Sweden’s death rate was more than double that of Canada. And even there, things were not operating as normal.

13
TheCryptoDaddy•

At some point we have to just get back to normal and let nature do its thing. The mental health issues we are going to face from the mental aspects of the virus and being locked up are going to far outweigh the 86 year old gramas that die 6 months sooner than they had hoped.

-6
RadiumGaga•

It's called a tsunami because it takes a while to unfold and its impact isn't immediately apparent. We're still uncovering the full economic impact of COVID-19. We're way too impatient, arrogant, and stupid to understand this so that's why we get comments like this. 2021 is going to be a dark, difficult year with business & personal bankruptcies and we'll start to see foreclosures on sub-prime mortgages and people losing their homes.

These are the good times. We've had good summer weather, patios were open, and we could BBQ outside and hang out with friends but winter will bring a quick end to all of that. The prevailing sentiment is likely to be much darker then.

32
flushotmonkey•

It's in no ones interest to let this happen.

The money will keep flowing to avoid exactly what you're talking about. Obviously injecting all of that money into the economy will have other consequences, we'll see what those are over the next decade.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TheMonkeyMafiaOntario•

Except this time the data is coming from StatsCan instead of MNP... Sure there's an interview with a trustee & TD, but it's the data source that's different this time around...

6

I'm more concerned about people who received CERB while they were working and then when the tax man comes around they'll be hooped.

0
Own_Nectarine7433•

I dont feel too sympathetic to people scamming the system. If you make more than 1k/month and are taking CERB, you scammed the system and deserve to get fines and pay it back.

2
seesoon•

Way too many Canadians spend a lot more then they should and they spend it on useless things. My wife and I are lucky, we have no kids and an annual household income of around 215k and we own a home. Yet we have friends with half the household income, kids and rent who spend more on stupid shit like ordering food, going out to eat, buying clothes everytime they see a sale etc then we do.

As smart and educated the Canadian population is, many of them are dumbasses when it comes to managing personal finances. It's actually shocking and scary!

34
Sporadica•

You're downvoted but you're making sense. People spend money on dumb shit then turn around and complain they don't have money. Then you tell them to make their own coffee instead of starbucks and they say "but I want my treats in life" and "i deserve it".

I've given up talking to these people on that front but one I did apply tough love "stop buying starbucks for fuck sakes, you make $12 an hour for 30hrs a week". She got educated, made her own coffee, ate out once a year, became "boring" by not going out at all for anything.

Cutting starbucks alone she was able to catch up on credit cards. After that all her cuts she invested and her investments have paid for her tuition. She's more ahead than had she just saved it alone.

Now she is about to be a nurse who can afford that F U I'm getting my daily starbucks lifestyle.

When you make so little you're going into debt to cover living expenses WHILE you're spending on frivolous things then no, you don't "deserve it", you need to earn it. I've seen people who are that, making minimum payments but spending all their extra disposable income on dumb shit.

Some people never learn and scary enough our economy is built on it!

25
[deleted]•

[deleted]

14
JohnyZoom•

ate out once a year

Mmmh... That's extreme

11
Sporadica•

Depends how much you value your goal. The furthers extreme I went was once a month because I valued reducing debt and investing more than going out. It helped that my roomate/friend/coworker got on the same program and was more chill eating at home. I did spend more on dominoes back then though.

2

But...I don't even know her!

0
GuzzlinGuinnessOntario•

It’s not a rule for every single one , but a bunch of the companies that are relied on to generate the investments people champion , are dependent on people spending like this to generate their profits .

8
seesoon•

The Starbucks point is so true. I remember when I got my first job in Toronto after my undergrad, I was making around $55k (was still living at home with my folks) so my expense were minimal, I use to make 2 trips to Starbucks daily, at least have one heavy duty drinking/dinner night with friends per week. But after about the first 4 months, I remember sitting down and just going through how much did I make in the first 4 month, how much did I save, spend etc and I had a HOLY FUCK "come to Jesus moment"! I remember doing the math and it was something like 2 trips to Starbuck were costing me almost half an hour of work if I broke my salary down into hourly. So I worked for 8 hours to make money but would spend 30 Mins of the money I made on just coffee. Forget even the impact of necessary costs like transit etc.

I swear since that day almost 10 years ago and despite the fact that I personally make 6 figures now, I still have never bought a coffee or lunch outside at work(I became boring lol), unless I'm meeting a client or having a work lunch/coffee that I could expense!

Best decision ever and if someone ever calls me boring, I say, if being boring means you have a awesome stock portfolio, an investment property, you own your home and have no bad debt (I still have mortgages on my home and investment property but those are good debts on appreciating assets). I'm glad I'm boring!

2†
MiG35ToW•

You are straddling the extremes. It is not typical.

6
Sporadica•

measuring your money in time really puts it into perspective and has helped me judge future purchasing decisions.

4
Jerkstore911•

The problem is that for the last decade your friends behaviour has been rewarded. Never so much as the last few months, in fact. There have been no consequences to indebtedness and overspending.

9
WhereBeCharlee•

Yeh, no one gets taught anything. I actually find it quite enthralling to learn about finance - but it means I have to research it on my own time. I can see why so many people are lost.

2†
FeistyLakeBass•

This assumes that there is not a pile of more government money. Want to make bets on that?

23
[deleted]•

[removed]

-40
FeistyLakeBass•

Neither. I believe the government will spend a ton more money. There is no policy preference in my comment. It is not what I would do in their situation. It is just what I think they will do.

16
tuxedo_moon•

This kind of news has been posted for probably 5 years now. And because of the pandemic, we think it's going to happen but it's not.

There's actual proof. The govt and the BoC have done everything to extend/delay wholesale bankruptcies, especially during this pandemic. So I'm not saying it'll never happen but every level of govt is doing everything they can to kick the can down the road.

The BoC is embarking on real QE for the first time in its entire history. Look at the US, Japan and EU. They've been doing QE for over 3 decades. Did anyone of them go under? No.

The worst case is Japan with massive deflation and 0 growth. Yet if you visit Japan today, it's one of the most developed countries in the world.

Countries aren't run the same way as a family household (though they should).

The goal of doing this is not the expected end result (financial implosion) but for enough people in those bankruptcy situation to realize they need to get out of it. All the govt, BoC and banks are doing is provide the time for people to adjust course.

Not saying QE is bad nor good but as long as it's necessary the BoC will do everything and CAN do everything to prevent wholesale bankruptcies.

Sure there's still going to be bankruptcies but it's not going to matter in the big picture of things.

15
JustWannaGrilll•

though they should

No serious economist working today would argue this point. The operations of a country that prints its own currency, exists indefinitely with no lifespan, and sets its own economic and monetary policy could not be more different from a family budget.

Not to be a dick about it, but I think that this comparison actually does a lot of damage to how people understand economics and federal economic policy.

10
Ottawann•

Japan also doesn’t/didn’t have the same personal debt levels we have, it’s a bit different

6
denzelcurrypowder•

What a headline! Also breaking news, a tsunami of COVID-19 bankruptcies could not be coming.

14
warning_globe•

I have heard this before about the oil crash.. and yeah there were some bankruptcies but not everyone went under like the way it was characterized

12
ohhhhhokkkkk•

Can someone explain this debt to disposable income ratio? Is it the same as debt to income?

If I have a monthly income of $10k gross and debt payments including mortgage are $3k per month. My ratio would be 30%? Or do I use my net income? What expenses are considered?

The 158% Canadian average seems ridiculously high either way but I’m trying to figure out how bad it is.

9
parmstar•

The 158% includes mortgage debt so it's actually pretty fine.

Example: make $500K per year but have a $1M mortgage = 200%. Yet, nobody would really call that an issue for that earner.

13
ohhhhhokkkkk•

Got it. Makes sense and actually doesnt make that ratio sound that bad at all.

2
CanuckYou2•

ohhhhh, okkkkk

1
[deleted]•

Except it isn't fine. It's among the highest debt ratio in the world. Remember, you are looking at an average amount and a lot of Canadians have way more debt than this.

0
parmstar•

No, it's fine. The Debt Servicing Ratio is more important, and it's basically unchanged over the last 30 years.

Any stat that talks about debt to income that does not include interest rates as a factor is idiotic.

2
rskene•

Unemployment rate is ~10%, up from 5%. That delta is virtually guaranteed to result in bankruptcies and would have already but for all the government assistance.

And the true unemployment rate is likely much higher. Many companies have maintained staff through CEWS that very well could be on the chopping block when that program stops.

So it's really up to government to decide ... keep the taps open to support demand and rapid return of jobs ... or don't.

7
SleazyGreasyCola•

​

Exactly. A lot of bankruptcies were avoided with CEWS. Hard to go bankrupt when government is covering most of your labour cost. The scary thing is 10% unemployment WITH CEWS. unprecedented times though, the gov seems determined to avoid as much pain as possible so it will either be bankruptcies or devaluing the cdn dollar when it all ends. Could go either way right now

3
BestFill•

It's still cheaper to lay someone off than to have their wages subsidized slightly.

2
rskene•

Nope. I have heard of companies that have HIRED people in order to collect cews.

2
BestFill•

That makes zero sense. They only subsidize up to 75%. So those companies hired employees to take a 25% wage loss?

1
SleazyGreasyCola•

Depends on the position and time/cost to train a new employee who fits with the culture of the job but overall I agree.

1
TacoRockapella•

I’m swimming in debt. 30k in credit card debt. Plus my brother stole my inheritance and put me 40k in debt to the CRA because of the way he “handled” the family estate.

6

☹️

2
Behacad•

This conjecture is getting old! People also said the housing market was going to hit rock bottom in June. I'm 100% sure we don't know shit and I'll keep saying it

4
trackofalljadesOntario•

I’m not sure we need the conditional on that headline, nor am I sure we need another one of these articles...but yeah we all better brace for this and the impact it’s gonna have on everyone.

2
r-013•

I spent $3k just on alcohol and fine dine this week.

1
cheesechokerOntario•

Thank you for your service

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
CanuckYou2•

It is confusing that one line just says income (which would imply gross) and one line says disposable income (which would imply net).

As for the definition, disposable income is everything you have after taxes (often called net income, but people also confuse net as take home pay which may have been reduced for non-tax spending/saving like insurance or retirement contributions).

The term for money that you can spend or save as you choose, after paying for necessities, is 'discretionary' income.

1
ANormalSoftwareDev•

I never understood how people keep talking/posting about the great bust that is going happen then post an article that seems informative on the notion. Reading the article it makes some points about how we have a high the debt to income ratio is but has no citation on past studies that triggers the bust.

I used to always think that a bust was coming (honestly it could happen) but it's so hard to understand how these busts happen. I get the feeling even in the utmost terrible state we get in all organizations are willing to hurt savers in the name of keeping the system running. Just look at the BOC, federal + provincial governments, and what banks are doing. They are just trying to defer + encourage debt until we have a miracle(vaccine) to keep the system running. I only think our system will only crumble when we incite civil wars because of the wealth disparity which would cause the social devaluation of our currency to go down causing investors to panic(pretty much the BOC at this point with all their buying).

I think so much of money in today's age is played on with emotion that it's hard to justify how things are valued correctly anymore. Just look at the big technology companies and how their stocks have risen up ridiculously.

1
JoeBlack23•

Every slow news day CBC recycles their standard "Canadians are in too much in debt" story, comes up every other week.

1

Buy a gun to protect your family and shit.

-1