Property division/co-habitation agreement/child

How would a situation like this play out? Currently my GF and I both own our own separate homes. We've been together 10 years. Her home is fully paid off and is worth $270,000. My home is worth $440,000 and I owe $220,000 on the mortgage. So she's got around $50,000 more property equity than I do.

My GF has done well for herself. She has a high paying career (same salary as me), her house is paid off, has a good pension, and is close to maxing out her TFSA and RRSPs. I want nothing from her, I just want to protect what I've worked hard for up to this point in my life, in the event of a separation. Plus my home has some money in it from a small inheritance I received when my Grandpa passed away.

Now let's say we decide to move into my home (because it's bigger), have a kid and she sells her home. How can I protect the $200,000 equity I have in my home in the event of a separation? We want to keep what we have now separate, but anything after having the child would be combined property equity and split in the event of a separation. She wants to ensure she can buy another property in the event we separate.

Basically I want to ensure I don't lose my $200,000 equity in my current home in the event of a separation. I don't think it'd be fair that I have to split that equity, yet she keeps the full $270,000 from the sale of her home.

Hope this makes sense. Please ask any questions if I missed anything. Thank you in advance.

Posted Sep 21, 2020, 2:31 AM UTC

316
fake-name-here1•

There are very set out common law rules for this. Maybe talk to a family lawyer to find out for sure, but as I said, this is not new territory, so googling family law in Canada for this kind of thing should get you some good info to start from.

From what I remember, If you are common law, whatever you pay into the home is what you will get out of it. If she sold her home, and paid off your mortgage, you would both get back whatever percent you had put into it at the time. From there I would divide the bills, she gets some in her name, you get others that balance out to make it 50/50 to keep it simple for later.

Once you have a kid, I’m not sure the rules. I think it would probably be something like marriage, where whoever stays home is counted as a full time job, and they would “earn” half the wage of the other person. Then alimony and child support may play a role. I am very unsure of the part with the kid though, but that’s where a lawyer will help you.

If you do end up getting married I believe everything resets to 50/50 u less you have a prenup.

I also feel like you should also be able to do a cohabital prenup.

Edit: just went back and reread your post... it’s none of my business but if she sells her home and won’t settle your mortgage while moving in and having a kid... that doesn’t quite sound like a good deal.

Edit 2: damn, drinking whiskey and skimming posts doesn’t pay... inheritance is also considered differently. I want to say it’s exempt from the “what you put in is what you get out”, in that inheritance is always yours.

Long story short, keep It wrapped up until you talk to a lawyer I think.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Trinity0519OP•

What you're saying does make sense and is logical. My concern is that somehow I could lose my half share of the house...losing over $200,000 of my life savings would be devastating.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Trinity0519OP•

She seems less concerned about protecting her assets as I am. Likely because her parents were divorced so she lived through it once. My parents are still together so it's more scary and an unknown for me.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
rockford853okg•

A woman rscently got spousal support in Ontario even though they had no children together and never cohabitated together. These are strange days. A lawyer is required to write up an agreement. Having her buy half the house is a good idea. Take that cash and specify its out of reach in the agreement. Even then as mentioned judges do what they want anyway.

3
Trinity0519OP•

What do you man by: "Take that cash and specify it's out of reach in the agreement"?

1
rockford853okg•

Just a thought. Nal, but perhaps setting that cash in a separate account and specifying it in the agreement may help keep it safe. When the excrement meets the impeller, its all about documents. Having a cohabitation agreement and no mingling of big assets will help. Theoretically.

1
Trinity0519OP•

But if she buys half the house, as you suggest, that just pays off my current mortgage. So there's no cash to put into a separate account.

1
RayCharlesBoyle•

Look at a cohabitation agreement. You two can legally ensure that that what you own is still what you own in the event of a of separation or death. Also FYI if you two live together, you are considered common law after a year. Just get the agreement in place before you move, it'll ensure you both are protected.

Also depending on where you live, inheritances are not involved in marital assets in the event of a breakdown provided you never comingle the asset. Meaning never hold those funds in a joint account or joint property.

2
Trinity0519OP•

Doesn't it get more complicated when a child is involved? Currently she owns her home and I own mine. But she might sell hers to move in with me.

1
RayCharlesBoyle•

Well the the moment a child is born you become common law. The home becomes the marital home and the value of the home from that point on is half hers should she decide to pursue her share in the event if a separation. I'm not sure how much water the cohabitation agreement will hold if a kid is involved even if you aren't married. A judge could give her a portion of the equity especially if she's contributing financially to the maintenance, upkeep, and or mortgage.

I would discuss this with the lawyer you meet to get the cohabitation agreement drawn up. Where you live will impact this as each province/territory has its own rules.

2
Trinity0519OP•

So even if I own 100% of the home, once there's a child she automatically owns half the home?

1
RayCharlesBoyle•

Well that's where a lawyer would be able to help you more. As where you live (e.g BC or Ont) will impact this. Some provinces have stronger protections, others don't. Without knowing your province/territory of residence it'll be hard to say. Just know that having a kid changes things. Like if you lived in QC and signed a cohabitation agreement. Kid is born and 10 years later you separate. Well if the cohabitation agreement leaves one person destitute, QC law will prevent that.

3
IHCTD9•

Maybe both of you sell everything before moving in together.

Then start over as one unit, buy a new house and go 50/50 from there.

2
SurviveYourAdults•

lawwwwwwwyer

1