r/livesound•
kelcema

No Stupid Questions Thread - Week of 2020-09-21 - 2020-09-27

The only stupid question is the one left unasked!

Do you have a basic question you want answered? Let us help! Remember that r/livesound is for PA/sound systems/streaming -- we may not be able to be as helpful with questions about, say, home theatre systems. Keep in mind that the more information about your setup (amps, speakers, mixer, microphones) you can provide, the quicker we'll be able to help you!

Posted Sep 21, 2020, 4:08 PM UTC

880
MidnightWombatPro - Theater•

Which macbook pro do I buy today for a show computer?

Smaart, Qlab, Reaper, Protools, WWB, Vantage, various system control etc.

I've been looking at the 15" mid-2017 version since it doesn't seem worth the money going any newer but will this hamper me beyond requiring a butt load of dongles at all times.

I want to go for something older so I can at least plug a flash drive in but I want it to last for a bit.

I currently have a 2015 13" that is starting to have some hardware issues and I want to keep a computer capable of running 32 bit software so I'd like to keep it on it's current OS version of 10.11 but I'm starting to run into some apps that can only be run on 10.13 or newer.

Should I just abandon my old software and update my 10.11 machine?

4
Press_Play_•

Disclaimer : I don't own a macbook. Used to own one. Switched over to windows 4 months ago.
If your 2015 Macbook is starting to have some issues, is it worth rationalizing that the 2017 Macbook might not see past 2022 or 2023? Maybe that doesn't matter to you. Inevitably, Apple will update their OS to the point where manufacturers have to release 64bit software versions. There are 32 bit 'sandboxes' but they are just that. Limitations apply.

I'd say, if you do get a new mac, try to find a way of installing 10.11 if it means that much to you.

2
the-real-compucatEE student by day, engineer by night•

What hardware issues are you running into? Consider having your 2015 repaired.

1

How do professional audio theatre guys manage the obvious bleed and comb filtering from forehead or ear mounted omnis when production does not allow for in-ears? Stage get quite loud and comb filtering becomes quite apparent, even if mixed line to line. Any tips?

3
dcgrp•

What is the stage getting loud with? Pit orchestra sounds? Are the actors getting foldback of their own voices?

3

I was more thinking of backing tracks through foldbacks. But indeed, orchestra sounds could be a problem too. Their own voices may happen too, for instance when outdoor and where free field makes hearing themselves difficult

2
soph0nax•

Onstage foldback is a tricky thing in every musical - there are no real rules for how you do it, just best practices.

Generally in musical theater we don't pump vocals through the onstage monitors. If you're in a position where you have to throw vocals in there, limit it to the person or people who are demanding it, and then to just the scene they feel it's needed. From there look at monitor placements -- maybe they are singing a duet centerstage and foldback in the wings isn't great, I'd see how to bury a speaker in a set piece centerstage, get something flown overhead (yeah, doesn't work outdoors), something built into the deck underneath the actors, or something downstage center pointed upstage. Anything to get speakers as close to the actors as possible so you aren't blasting from a far distance. Start small, work bigger as the show demands.

As far as music goes -- don't send the full orchestra mix to the onstage monitors. Send just what's needed, some drums for tempo and some piano for pitch, and from there send at a low level. Start small, work up.

While probably not the most feasible thing at the moment, in normal circumstances (and also assuming the mixer isn't the sound designer) I'd advise hopping onto the stage while the scene is being rehearsed in show conditions and moving around to make sure you can hear what the actors are hearing - making yourself seen and looking active to their plight goes a long way in making friends and getting mutual understanding of the problems at hand. Another tip I've found is that a lot of the time when actors say they can't hear something in the monitors that you know is there is that it's just being covered up by something else in the mix and they can't just key into what they want immediately - foldback is just as much about taking unnecessary things out as putting useful things in, or unburying them.

8

That is SUPER useful, thank you so much!

So, guessing from your comment, if I were to decide to use cardioid mics for forehead, that's a bad idea? Because surely the closer to the source, and the most rejection, to easier it is to accommodate singers' needs. What do you think?

2
dcgrp•

I'm not a pro, but my guess is that actors wearing omni lavs just need to learn to live in a quieter stage environment. I'm sure having louder foldback makes them feel more confident when their singing/acting, but you have expect anything loud is going to get into those lavs.

5
leskanekuni•

I saw a video where the Hamilton mixer explained that he only has an actor's mic open when that actor is speaking a line. He does incredible tapdancing on the board to do that. I think this was the video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60OpF3DCVls

2
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

That's u/kmccoy!

3

I saw this before asking the question, and I don't remember it solving the problem of having multiple mics open at once during: duos, ensembles, etc.

Still a very impressive performance!

1
kmccoyTheatrical touring•

It varies by the specifics of the situation. In a duet you might need to choose one mic or the other, or maybe they'll be far enough apart to let both mics be open. Ensemble singing can be made to work by choosing a few mics, or maybe doing some work on the EQ of the chorus to thin out their mics while still allowing the leads to come through. Lots of options. I'd also second all of what sophonax said about foldback -- keeping the stage foldback as quiet as possible while still giving performers what they need to hear is extremely beneficial to allowing the mixer to get as much good sound as possible out of the vocal mics.

4

That's very helpful, thank you so much to take the time to answer.

Hope you're doing well during the pandemic, I am not US based but if it's as bad for our industry that in the UK, then let's brace ourselves...

2
tang1947•

Saw that too. That dude is on top of things.

1
DJMekanikalPro Theater Audio BUF/ROC NY/HHI•

I think I understand what you're asking, but I'm gonna speak in general terms, from what I do, and my experience.

- From my experience, unless you have two cast members singing into each other's faces, comb filtering from one microphone mounted on the head or ear isn't something that really occurs in musical theater. The exception to this is maybe if you're folding back the cast mics into the monitors, and for some shows that's required, but I've never needed to send the cast mics into the monitors unless there's an offstage choir part (think "I Am My Own Best Friend" from Chicago). The singers are offstage, well out of the path of any foldback going to the stage, and singers onstage shouldn't be getting any signal that would cause comb filtering.

- If you have a loud show that requires a high foldback level onstage and IEMs aren't possible, utilizing an omni boom-style microphone (DPA 4066, Countryman H6, etc.) can help maximize the ratio of your primary sound source (cast members' mouth) to reflections that could cause comb filtering. This is also aided through good line-by-line mixing.

As for tips to mitigate this:

- Do as much as you can, through speaker selection and/or placement, to minimize the amount of bleed from your main PA to the stage.

- Properly tune and time-align your system.

- Only send the bare minimum that your cast needs to keep time and pitch to the foldback speakers (I usually do kick, drum overheads, snare, piano, bass, and MAYBE a second keys feed if they have a melody line).

- Choose microphones, whenever possible and required, that picks up as much of the primary source as possible.

- Don't have your foldback onstage so loud that it spills out into the house and interacts with your Main PA. This can also be a source of comb filtering.

- Place your foldback speakers in such a way that they won't interact with your main PA, but will allow you to get the volume you need for sufficient stage coverage.

2
Corrigan42•

Not OP but that was as amazing answer thank you for sharing your knowledge! If you were mixing line-by-line with foldback, would you use post-fader sends to the monitors?

1
DJMekanikalPro Theater Audio BUF/ROC NY/HHI•

Yes, and usually with a gain reduction so as not to overwhelm the cast onstage. Then again, cast mics through foldback is my last-resort tactic. Same goes for foldback for offstage singing booths or for band IEMs.

2
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

I suppose my question is what kind of shows are we talking about? Corporate? Theatre?

2

Musical theatre specifically :)

2
KarsReygent•

I’m setting up a Dante network and have a brand new MacBook Pro that everything to can but is unable to see anyone else in Dante controller. I don’t know where to start trying to get it to see the three other devices (GLD 80, Rednet AM2 (which is its own mess), and live-streaming Pc) The network settings all appeared to be correct when I was looking at everything yesterday and the network is DHCP until I get the open addresses for static from the network people.

3
BaconComposterPro RF and TV A2•

Can you ping the other devices?

2
fantompwer•

you need to make sure you are in the same subnet, and that you don't have firewalls turned on. If you have no discovery, it could be a firewall issue.

2
KarsReygent•

So I am able to see the macbook pro on other computers using dante controller. I can confirm that they are all using the same subnet (cidr of 24 on a class b network) I think the issue is a is issue on the macbook and not a network issue. I won't be able to confirm that until I fix all the other issues I ran into though.

1
Vote4flipflop•

Can I use a DBX 286s to remove background noise and plug directly into my DSLR camera?

2
fantompwer•

It has a gate. Watch some youtube video to understand how an audio gate works. Background noise can be many things. If it is HVAC noise during an interview, a gate won't work. If it is hi-hat noise between snare drum hits, a gate will work.

2
kennyisthebest•

tl;dr: where can i find a dynamic lavalier microphone with a 3.5mm jack for less than $100?

hi everyone, looking to solve an audio quality issue i have.

i have a mask https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07J4DVZ6B and i want to mic myself up from within.

i'll be using this speaker or something similar: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07SJ4XFTT

two examples of when i'd use this are (1) simply walking down the street and (2) snowboarding.

given this, i think a dynamic lavalier mic with a 3.5mm plug fulfills my need.

i've tried condenser lavs, but i think being inside the mask causes distortion. for this reason, i think i need a dynamic mic. the audio from the microphone that came with that speaker was good and is all i need. unfortunately that mic broke. i imagine that microphone was a dynamic one - it seems many similar headset mics are.

as for lavalier, the form factor is compatible with fitting inside the mask.

and, that speaker and similar ones accept 3.5mm jacks.

am i off-base in any of my assumptions? is a dynamic lavalier mic with 3.5mm plug something i can find? because i've struggled thus far...

ideally, i'd spend < $25; however, for the sake of this conversation, let's say < $100

thanks in advance for any help!

2
fantompwer•

Being inside your mask isn't what is causing distortion. Distortion is caused by overloading the input with too loud singing/talking. A dynamic mic is probably the right device.

​

Pyle Pro or other cheap companies may be in your price range. Sweetwater or Fullcompass may have options Amazon doesn't.

2
dcgrp•

So, my school districts auditoriums got upgraded with new lighting and l'acoustics a series sound system with ks21 subs. Yay! But they specified 4 belt packs of 2.4 Ghz clear com intercom. Am I right to be a bit disappointed from a reliability perspective on the 2.4 Ghz intercom?

For reference our biggest intercom use is for plays and musicals. We'd likely need to buy 2 more packs of this clear com just to use it for shows. Our previous system was a wired Telex system.

2
AudioThrowAway9999•

Freespeak 2 at 2.4 ghz is very reliable. I would still prefer 1.9 ghz if possible because you can get more beltpacks per antenna at 1.9ghz.

6
rwbreck•

I believe the Freespeak that I have used on corporate shows was the 1.9 variant, but it was rock solid, even with more packs per transceiver than the documentation recommended. I was pretty impressed with it. My guess is that the smart folks at ClearCom are well aware of the potential limitations of 2.4Ghz and have engineered some intelligent ways of navigating a crowded spectrum- just be sure to follow best practices with transceiver placement and I would be surprised if you found it unusable.

3
VinceLennonPro | LA•

This is correct. While 2.4ghz is generally frowned upon for critical use, ClearCom has engineered this system to be robust in the crowded RF environment. Here's a white paper they have released describing the technology:

https://static1.squarespace.com/static/53062f8de4b09e63a23ce552/t/5a723723ec212ded19b0ad16/1517434659917/FSII_24_RF+Perfomance+White+Paper+_v1.3.docx

6
rwbreck•

This is great info, thanks for substantiating my very general hunch!

2
The_Fowl_Play•

What's your preferred wire gauge for custom extension cords?

2
kelcemaOP•

Custom or not. 12ga for standard 120V/20A cabling. For 30A/220V or 208V, I try to stick to 8/4 or 8/5 SOOW to help protect against voltage loss. For 50A/1Ø cable, although code says 6/4 is only good for up to 45A, just about everyone uses it for 50A cabling. As for single conductor, we went with #2-- it's good for 190A/leg and since we don't do big lighting rigs, we've not run out of amperage with it.

7
D-townP-town•

Just to add, 12ga for cables up to 50'. For cables approaching 100' I'd go up to 10ga. Again to minimize voltage losses over distance.

6
The_Fowl_Play•

Great stuff!

2
Press_Play_•

The gauge that will give me the best results I need on the other end at a fair cost. I use a calculator to determine the best wire gauge. It has fields for Voltage, current, power factor, length, type of conductor, insulation type etc.

1
The_Fowl_Play•

Interesting. Is it a website or a spreadsheet? I’d love to take a look!

1
Press_Play_•

It's an app I have on my phone called electrical calculations by Ettore Gallina.

1
parksandcrepes•

Some SoundVision q's

Is there any way to find the standard deviation of SPLs for a given frequency?

Also is there any way of analysing the sound pollution of an L'Acoustics rig in soundvision the way you can with d&b noisecalc?

Also if I want to see an accurate mapping I reduce the dB per band setting, but if I do that then the range of SPLs gets really small. Is there any way of seeing an accurate mapping for a wide range?

Also is there any way to use the source alignment tool for the full system including subs? I see i can align them separately but would like to know how I would align the subs to the mains.

If I set the listening height to be roughly 1.7m, it draws a box which then hides the sub mapping because its higher, are you not supposed to do it this way? Or do I just take the mapping floor level?

Quite a few questions but hopefully I can get some answers.

TIA

2
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

I would recommend reaching out to the L'Acoustics applications team directly, they have several people on staff whose job it is to help with these types of things:

https://www.l-acoustics.com/en/contacts-pages/sales-application/

5
In0chi•

I'm looking for a rack-mountable device that has 16 XLR inputs on one side and a single plug to connect to a stage box/multicore on the other side. Any hints on what exactly I should search for or do you know a product that has this? Does this even exist? Reason is we'd like to not have to plug in and out 16 XLR cables before and after every gig to save time.

2
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

Just to understand, you're looking to go from 16 xlr to a stage box? So just analog copper?

So essentially a patch? The easiest would be a custom plate you build yourself with 16 xlr to whatever you want. Otherwise look to a pre/built to order option from whirlwind or someone like that.

3
In0chi•

That’s right. We’re looking for a rack-mountable counterpart to something like this. So basically we’d like to have a fully connected “stage box” inside our rack that we can “extend” using a Multipin cable. Any ideas?

2
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

Got it. Yea, it will likely need to be a custom or homebuilt solution. You can buy the rack plates and connectors and wire it up your self. That'd be the cheapest solution if you have the time.

Otherwise look into a built-to-order solution from the likes of Whirlwind or Rapcohorizon.

3
In0chi•

Alright thank you!

2
Humhead•

If you want to build something yourself from scratch, these guys pretty much sell all the parts. Really good prices and quality products. I have a custom snake loom for an I/O device that is very well made.

​

https://www.redco.com

3
kipkessmenPro - USA•

Places like CBIcables.com make this, even if not expressly the exact thing you want, as they tend to make things built to order (so you could choose which type of disconnect, XLR spacing, Colors, etc). Alternatively they have a shuttle system utilizing Shielded CAT5 similar to the CAT Rack.

2
In0chi•

Thanks, this sounds like a great solution but not like on that's currently in our budget. I thought there might be some simple solution off-the-shelve, but it seems this is not the case. Thanks anyway, much appreciated!

1
tang1947•

Whirlwind

1
FragrantErmine•

I remember seeing videos of a symphonic orchestra playing, and most of them had some type of in-ear device that had a thin bar across the ear. Can anyone tell me what those are?

2
fantompwer•

Post a picture, that would be the most helpful.

1
FragrantErmine•

https://imgur.com/a/YnAbuDX

The guy on the right. Best picture I could find from memory.

I realize now that it might some kind of microphone array to pick up the sound of the adjacent musicians.

1
fantompwer•

It's a cheap in-ear monitor. If you notice that the other musician has a different one, it means that they are supplying their own IEMs, which they should.

2
macknifica•

Does anyone know what I can put on metal podium to decrease reflections back into a lav mic.

2
fantompwer•

2" of insulation.

In all seriousness, it seems like you need to move the mic closer to the person's mouth, ask them to talk louder (good luck) and use a unidirectional microphone.

3
macknifica•

Never thought about using insulation. We do have a cardioid lapel mic. They refuse to use a countrymen or anything like that. The normal pastor is 6'5 so when he is at the podium it's not that big of a problem. It's when the associate ministers speak who are all around 5'5 to 5'10 when it becomes an issue.

I will have to get some insulation and and possibly cover it with cloth to make it neat. They will have to still place bibles and other items on the podium.

1
ElMariachi1211•

I am looking at a pair of passive speakers that use a single NL8 connector on the back of the cabinet. What would the wiring have to look like in order to power it using 3 separate amps running into a patch panel, terminating in a single NL8 cable? I’m terribly stumped on how to go about this.

2
VinceLennonPro | LA•

The speaker documentation, and/or often a label on the speaker itself, will specify what wire pairs in the NL8 are used for what channels.

3
jholowtaekjho•

How long can directional antennas last? I work with some Shure shark fins that are 5 years old, giving some pops and hissing on my wireless mics. Should I get someone to inspect the set-up, repair them, or just outright replace them?

2
VinceLennonPro | LA•

An active shark fin should have no reason to fail for decades, unless they are being regularly subjected to mechanical stress, vibrations, heat, or other abuse. Have you absolutely eliminated the possibility of RF interference being the cause of your pops and hissing?

5
tonkapolllo•

Unless you are physically treating them like garbage they should last at least a decade or two. Pops and hiss sound more like RF interference or bad shielding on a cable than a bad antenna.

5
Ambercapuchin•

With a midas m32 or yamaha tf, using their DANTE holes. If i plug in a proco or neutrik dante/xlr hole that dante control can see, configure, route and use, will midas or yamaha see+play nice with that hole? Dante rout [email protected]>[email protected] device...

Ofc no "head amp" control, but does midas or yamaha ingest, process, control and spew an off brand hole if dante tells it to?

2
rwbreck•

As far as audio goes, Dante is Dante, so yes, anything that supports Dante can talk to anything else that supports Dante over an IP network- no matter the brand. You are correct in observing that remote control data for things such as head amps are seldom if ever supported across devices from different manufacturers. EDIT: unless a manufacturer specifically designs support for that other product into their product, eg Yamaha consoles controlling devices from Shure or RND. That support is not inherent to Dante; Yamaha had to build it into their console firmware.

3
WhoIsTheSenate•

Today during practice I had a cd going out , so I pulled the fader down to fade it out. Problem was, the music was still playing from other outputs. I thought the whole point of the fader was to control the volume from that channel everywhere. Is this assumption wrong? Does the fader only alter the volume going to the house? I was using a behringer x32

2
kelcemaOP•

Sounds like you get to learn about mixes/outputs being "pre-fader" versus "post-fader" level. :)

When a monitor mix, for example, is "post-fader," when you bring the fader down, it controls the levels sent to the mixes as well. Hence, the name "POST-fader." The send to that mix is generally on or off, as opposed to a variable level.

But, if that monitor mix is PRE-fader, then the monitor mix is being picked from that channel before the impact of the fader. The fader position won't change the level(s) in the monitor mix, and generally that mix level is variable. The fact that you heard music playing through other outputs when you pulled the fader down makes me think that those outputs are being pulled "pre-fader," and you'll want to change that.

10
hnathan628•

Why are shotgun mics not commonly used in live sound?

​

Also, would it be practical to use a stereo mic, like a m/s mic, on a x32?

1
greylokiI make things louder•

They 'sort of' are, but not in places that you'd see them. A lot of engineers seem to enjoy using them as spaced pairs for audience ambience, whether for artist IEM feeds or multitrack recordings. I've occasionally seen people use them for choirs as well, more often outdoors than indoors, weirdly. I personally don't get on with them, the combination of side and rear lobes mean that no matter how you position the mic, it's probably 'pointed' at something you don't want to come through it.

I don't think the X32 has a mid/side decoder specifically, so you would have to burn three channels for your stereo mic setup, however M/S is my favourite mic technique and I use it whereever I possibly can, moreso on livestreams than live-to-audience, as the 'side' mic is once again usually pointed at the PA and sidefills. If it's any other stereo mic, you can certainly parameter link two adjacent inputs to have it function as a single stereo channel, and this can be very convenient.

4
hnathan628•

So on the x32 would I need to use some sort of additional processor?

1
greylokiI make things louder•

For stereo mics, no. For mid/side, also no - duplicate the side channel and invert the polarity of the channel you want to be the rear side of the side mic, then add in the mid to suit. Just needs three channels.

5
EviltechieBroadcast Engineer•

Depends on what part of live sound you're doing. They are the staple mic in broadcast.

3
hnathan628•

I am working on a musical where the pit is in a separate room and I am trying figure out the best way to mic them. Then I was watching some NPR tiny desk and I saw how powerful a m/s mic and shotgun mics are for music.

1
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Mid side is almost always an arrangement of two mics, not a type of mic. Like X/Y, A/B, ORTF.

5
hnathan628•

Correct - I was getting confused with a mic like MKH 418-MS (technically it is two mics inside on housing)

2
soundwithdesignTheatre-Designer/Mixer•

I use them frequently on straight plays when not using body mics.

2
hnathan628•

How well do they work vs something like a pcc?

1
soundwithdesignTheatre-Designer/Mixer•

Depends how you're using PCCs. If I'm in a standard proscenium theatre I'd probably use body mics. Smaller black boxes I'll actually use a combination of shotguns and PCCs mounted upside down and hung in the air. That works out really well.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
poweralleyssuck•

we have some 16 ohm loud speakers here are the specs. LF rated power: 500 w rms LF program power: 1000w HF rated power : 120 w rms HF program power: 240 w Max spl (1m) 132 dB Impedance LF 16 ohm/ HF 16 ohm The amps that are powering the line array are some lab gruppen clones that this guy sold to us long time ago. the amp is the problem that’s powering two of the boxes. The problem is the sound is coming out muffled after measurement everything after 3k declines.I want to use another amp to power those speakers currently one speaker box is daisy chained into another box. I only have a crown xs1200 I’m not sure if it be enough to power those two speakers or if any damage would occur I’ve found some answers online but it’s beyond my knowledge to apply it to my use. I’m always all about trial and error but don’t want to risk anything right now

1